r/IAmA • u/Steve_Alpert_Ghibli • Jun 23 '20
Director / Crew I am Steve Alpert, former Senior Vice President at Studio Ghibli. I helped bring Princess Mononoke, Spirited Away and other Ghibli films to the international stage. I traveled with, accepted awards on behalf of, and worked closely with Hayao Miyazaki for about 15 years. AMA
I am Steve Alpert, former Senior Vice President at Studio Ghibli. I helped bring Princess Mononoke, Spirited Away and other Ghibli films to the international stage. I traveled with, accepted awards on behalf of, and worked closely with Hayao Miyazaki for about 15 years.
I also voiced the character, Castorp in the Japanese version of The Wind Rises.
In addition, I was yelled at by Harvey Weinstein and was present for the infamous "NO CUT(https://kotaku.com/the-time-studio-ghibli-stood-up-to-harvey-weinstein-wit-1823223914)" story, was privileged to help record the voices of some of the world’s most talented actors in the foreign language versions of Ghibli’s films, and learned how it feels to be a foreigner in a Japanese company.
My new book, ‘Sharing a House with the Never-Ending Man: 15 Years at Studio Ghibli’ details this and more. It’s out now from Stone Bridge Press.
You can pick up a copy here: https://www.stonebridge.com/catalog-2020/Sharing-a-House-with-the-Never-Ending-Man.
I'll be here from 1pm - 3pm EST answering questions. EDIT: This is fun, I'll stick around for a while longer. Still answering questions, thanks!
Proof: https://twitter.com/StoneBridgePub/status/1275468377654472704
EDIT:
Hey everyone, thanks for all the questions. Really. Sorry I couldn't answer them all.
Some of the questions posted here can be answered in my new memoir. Please pick up a copy if you're interested. Thanks!
1.8k
u/Sprachspielerin Jun 23 '20
How does Joe Hisaishi always make the perfect soundtrack for each Ghibli film? What does the studio tell him?
569
u/Morazan51 Jun 23 '20
Was there any difficulties in terms of work culture in being a foreigner in Japan?
348
u/okletssee Jun 23 '20
Are there any stories about how any Ghibli films affected the Studio employees or fans that you found especially impactful?
726
u/Tyraels_Might Jun 23 '20
In your mind, What did Studio Ghibli do differently? Were you proud to work there and why?
599
u/creich1 Jun 23 '20
Fav studio Ghibli movie?
185
u/Goose-Bone Jun 23 '20
Thank you for the AMA, I have two questions!
137
u/Carefully_random Jun 23 '20
If you could have dinner with a character from one of the Ghibli films, who would you choose and why?
496
u/The-Mandalorian Jun 23 '20
Can you shed some light on the fallout between Ghibli and Disney? I was someone hoping to see Ghibli on Disney+ considering the decades long relationship with the studio but Disney stopped being a distributor of the films in favor it Gkids it seems.
456
u/wray_nerely Jun 23 '20
Since you say you were a foreigner working at Studio Ghibli, how did you come to your position there? Did you apply or were you recruited? What drove you to pursue the position and what did your role there entail?
298
u/MikiMice Jun 23 '20
What's one of the biggest challenges in adapting a Ghibli film for an American/western audience?
288
u/roadtrip-ne Jun 23 '20
This might be more a comment than a question, but many everyday people just have no idea these films exist. When I suggest Totoro to a parent or give them a dvd as a gift/ the kids become instant Ghibli fans.
Do you think the deals with HBO will expand the audience? Disney had been distributing them for awhile and they remain under the radar.
79
u/necropolis- Jun 23 '20
Thank you for your work! In a studio renowned for beautiful imagery, is there a particular scene that you particularly like, or is impactful to you?
417
u/princesskinomoto Jun 23 '20
How do you evaluate the works of contemporary directors like Makoto Shinkai ?
77
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '20
How do you pronounce Ghibli? A friend and I have been debating for a long time.
402
u/CaffeinatedLiquid Jun 23 '20
Is Mr. Miyazaki as heartwarming as his movies?
137
u/jp_taylor Jun 23 '20
Ghibli's next movie going CG is an interesting move. Do you see Ghibli pursuing more CG works down the road, or will we continue to see traditional works after Aya and the Witch?
54
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '20 edited Jun 24 '20
Steve,
Thank you for your hard work to make these films the masterpieces they are. They are a special part of some of my favorite memories with my family.
What is your favorite memory from your 15-year journey with Mr. Miyazaki himself?
62
u/Kolkaata Jun 23 '20
I've been reading your book for the past few days now, and it has been a real pleasure. Thank you for writing it.
Do you know what film Mr. Miyazaki considers to be his finest work? Or is there perhaps a film of his that he's not particularly fond of?
61
u/gtwilliamswashu Jun 23 '20
Besides Ghibli, who is making compelling films in Japan in the same spirit as you and Ghibli?
47
u/Nihhrt Jun 23 '20
I can understand some localization to maybe help western audiences understand the content, but a lot of the dubs and subsequently dubtitles (subtitles that use the heavily localized dub) completely butcher what the characters are saying.
Is this a conscious decision to localize so much or is it that the translation department does not get paid enough/have enough talent or something else?
35
u/JTurner82 Jun 23 '20 edited Jun 23 '20
Apparently according to your book, Miyazaki "vetoed" Hisaishi's new score for Castle in the Sky. However, this seems to contradict an interview that Joe Hisaishi made in Keyboard in 1999. In his words Miyazaki was apparently pleased with the rescore. (See link for proof). Are you sure about your claim? http://www.nausicaa.net/wiki/Laputa:Castle_in_the_Sky(Rescoring)
43
u/brosbe4gnomes Jun 23 '20
Hi Mr. Alpert! Have you ever helped or thought about helping to bring other genres to the international stage, such as Arabian themes?
I have a team that’s trying to get our film 🎞 done and into the mainstream.
Do you also have any advice for how we can get in touch with studios on average to seek help? Any advice and tips from someone so deep in the industry would be incredibly helpful, and we’d be very grateful for it.
Thank you for doing the AMA!
20
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '20
Did you have to learn to speak Japanese?
229
u/lazdo Jun 23 '20
why was Christian Bale, a Welsh-born actor cast alongside other British actors, picked to play Howl, a character with a Welsh accent in the original novel, not asked by the voice/localization director to use his native accent when recording Howl's lines? :(
Signed, a generation of Howl's Moving Castle fans! (if Ghibli ever has any inkling towards making sequels of any of their movies... we have several ideas.)
10
u/Josquius Jun 23 '20
Love Ghibli films and spent several years working in Japan myself, albeit not in such awesome jobs.
I've noticed ghibli is often very western influenced. Did people ever come to you with weird questions about stuff in the west? Making use of having a real foreigner around for designing any details?
27
u/Xaicandy Jun 23 '20
Is it true about the samurai sword sent to Harvey Weinstein? To reiterate no cuts to princess mononoke. I believe it is but I'd like confirm it.
Also thank you for all your hard work.
7
u/totorobree Jun 23 '20
started reading your book this morning... few chapters in already. Such an intriguing story so far. I had a question in regards to Miyazaki’s not visiting the United States anymore due to much of our political stances. Do you think he would ever return here? Did he ever speak with you about his time in America? (the only time I remember him visiting was in 2009 for comic con) Same thing with Joe Hisaishi. Would love to see his orchestra live one day.
Thank you so much for taking questions, and i was wondering if you’d sign my book? Or if you’re planning on having a book tour where I can meet and have it signed? Thank you so much again, Bree
6
u/Mystic8ball Jun 23 '20
Recently Ghibli have announced their first fully CG animated film, what do you think that means for the studio moving forward? If I recall Miyazaki was very strict with wanting to keep Ghibli primarily 2D with only a little CG here and there to enhance the 2D elements.
4
u/panda07 Jun 24 '20
Is the story about Miyazaki sending the katana bearing the words "no cuts" true?
4
u/MCofPort Jun 23 '20
It's amazing to speak to someone who has worked with the legendary Miyazaki and someone who is deeply rooted with making some of the greatest films of this century. How was the audition process for American voice actors for Studio Ghibli films? I'm surprised Phil Hartman played Jiji, and Suzanne Pleshette, a veteran actress of American TV and film, agreed to be Yubaba, one of the roles that are part of her legacy. Were they offered these roles, did Miyazaki have to approve and did he even suggest which American or English actors voice these characters? Alot of questions but thank you and long live Studio Ghibli!
2
u/Atlascrow7 Jun 23 '20
Which movie was the hardest to make ?
2
u/JTurner82 Jun 23 '20
Other question: can you tell us a bit more about your involvement in the recording of the character voices for the dubs?
2
u/mattdelarosiere Jun 23 '20 edited Jun 23 '20
I admit I’m surprised to see a senior member of studio Ghibli in this subreddit, but in a good way. I’m 16 and fascinated by the work you have helped bring, I do think I am too late to the party but I’m the off chance you see this, thank you!
I do wonder though, what do you plan for the future with many masters retiring or leaving the studio? Also, how close to fruition is Miyazaki’s swan song?
2
u/Spilfw Jun 23 '20
Do you like Totoro?
2
u/Leogrissther Jun 24 '20
What's your favorite movie?
2
u/Roar_Im_A_Nice_Bear Jun 24 '20
Hello Mr. Alpert, I don't really have a question but I just wanted to say thank you to you and the Studio Ghibli. I have seen almost all your movies and they are all amazing. But two years ago or so, I watched Spirited Away for the first time since my childhood and it truly brought tears to my eyes.
I first saw that movie when I was a child and I barely remembered it. When I saw it again, I realized that it has been way more influential on me than I could ever imagine. I think this movie played a very important part in defining what I consider beautiful, what makes my heart beat, what makes me going. Everything about this movie screams masterpiece. The story is amazing, the animation is wonderful, but the most amazing part for me is the ambiance, the feeling of that movie. For two hours, you are transported to another universe. I was not a grown man but a little child again, afraid of seeing my parents turned into pigs or to lose my voice.
I will never thank you enough for bringing this movie to my life. From the bottom of my heart, many thanks.
I need to finish with a question, so can you please accept my thanks?
2
u/Xzenergy Jun 23 '20
Hi, thanks for doing this!
Can you give any advice on someone trying to get their ideas animated, but without having animation skills themselves?
Thank you!
2
u/TellMeAboutGaming Jun 23 '20
When would you say western audiences really started to take interest in Japanese media? I remember as a kid growing up in the early 2000s all I watched were things like Digimon, Pokemon, Medabots etc.... But I feel today as it's slowed down. Would you say interest has increased, or decreased over the years? Sorry I know this is a weird question and I suck at explaining it haha
2
u/AaronThePrime Jun 24 '20
So where you the guy that chose not to put any studio ghibli films on any streaming services?
1
u/FierceAlchemist Jun 23 '20
Miyazaki and Takahata both have reputations for being stern perfectionists in their work. Do you have any stories about that or counter examples of them being softer & fun?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '20
when is the next Ghibli movie coming out ?
1
u/lilcondor Jun 23 '20
I just wanna say thank you for your work as these movies have impacted me deeply since childhood. I know this is probably a Ghibli centered AMA but I’d love to know what your favorite non animated film is? Or if your favorite film happens to be animated I’d love to hear that as well
1
u/Inferno792 Jun 23 '20
Which of the Studio Ghibli movies do you think is the best, or your favorite, and which one did you love working most on?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '20
Is there any possibility that Hayao Miyazaki may have some unreleased materials, or working on a new story?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '20
Did they really FedEx a katana to Harvey Weinstein?
1
u/SushiBroski Jun 23 '20
Who are some of your favorite actors that you worked with, while working at Studio Ghibli?
1
u/uncontinued74 Jun 23 '20
What is it like to work in the anime movie industry?
1
u/Pickzelated Jun 23 '20
Why do the Japanese and dubbed versions have different soundtracks? For instance I believe Laputa has nearly an extra 30 minutes of soundtrack added for the dub release. Is this common practice in distributing anime films internationally and if so, why?
1
u/conspiracy1994 Jun 23 '20
My partner is a massive fan and it would mean the world to me if you could tell me what your favourite shape is so I can let her know? TIA
1
u/b0k3h1nata Jun 23 '20
Hi, thank you for having an AMA, I really enjoy Studio Ghibli’s movies. As for my questions; as a foreigner how did you come to work with Studio Ghibli and did working with Hayao Miyazaki on such beautifully created movies change you in any way?
1
u/IOSL Jun 23 '20
How does it feel to be amazing?
1
u/Coolmikefromcanada Jun 23 '20
i've heard rumors that a bunch of studio ghibli films would be coming to Canadian Netflix soon, can you confirm?
1
u/phil035 Jun 23 '20
What's your favorite recipe to cook at home?
1
u/xynnax Jun 23 '20
I'm a huge fan of Studio Ghibli. I love every single movie you guys made. Thank you for creating masterpieces that will inspire millions!!
In your opinion, which movie do you think will largely impact the youth today?
What's the best thing about working in Studio Ghibli?
Which film do you relate to the most?
What was the hardest challenge in making the movies?
Where do you get the inspiration for every film?
Which film is your personal favourite?
What is the biggest life lesson you got while working in SG?
And lastly,
Which film did you have a deep connection with?
Sorry for the long questions, I appreciate you, Hayao Miyazaki, and all the people from Studio Ghibli for making impactful and moving films. Thank you!
1
u/OneAndOnlyJackSchitt Jun 23 '20
Any chance you're in a position where you could talk them into a remake of the Never Ending Story?
Please don't get me wrong. I watched this recently and it's great, but it to me feels like a story better told by Studio Ghibli, with the London Philharmonic covering the soundtrack from the 80s film.
1
u/MaskedManta Jun 23 '20
I've long been fascinated with the character of Castorp- both in his thematic depth he adds to the Wind Rises (allusions to the Magic Mountain, etc.) but the fact that he was an interpolation of you, a longtime Ghibli employee! Was his appearance based off of yours?
Also, how was the voice acting experience? I imagine that being "on mic" is much different than directing vocal performances! Did you get to act opposite of Hideaki Anno? Thank you so much!
1
u/andymorphic Jun 23 '20
Is there a resistance to developing some of the titles even further? Many would make fantastic series. Or even sequels.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '20
What is your favorite movie? Doesn't have to be Ghibli, and if it is, your favorite non-Ghibli film as well.
Love the work.
1
u/SendSend Jun 23 '20
As a foreigner, how hard was it to climb your way up top to becoming SVP compared to a non foreigner?
1
u/Alphy-fa Jun 23 '20
What are your favourite western films?
1
u/Bypeteryt Jun 23 '20
First of all let me thank you for doing this Q&A and second, for me soundtracks play an incredibly important role in movies so
Which is your favourite Ghibli movie soundtrack?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '20
How to make a great quality project, without huge funding or popularity? Maybe have a story how studio Ghibli made its progress?
1
u/Kubera10 Jun 23 '20
Out of all the films made which one was your favorite, and why?
Thanks for helping make such amazing films!
1
u/Mourne84 Jun 23 '20
What are your plans for the future?. I am so happy to see you here on reddit, me and my family are huge fans of miyazaki. Also what are your thoughts on the new movie that is coming up next? I heard it will differ a lot graphically.
1
u/Dangerdude40 Jun 23 '20
What advice do you have to anyone who aspires to do professional animation?
1
u/patronizingperv Jun 23 '20
Any relation to Herb?
1
u/OttoDocOck08 Jun 23 '20
What kind of excuses were people making to stop you or at least trying to convince you not to bring theses films over to the west?
1
u/Thea108 Jun 23 '20
What do you think about the decision to move away from hand drawn animation to CGI for the latest film?
1
u/IrrelevantPuppy Jun 23 '20
If you had a westerner friend who thinks they don’t like anime or that it is all the same and you wanted to introduce them to Ghibli, which movie would you show them?
1
u/JayPemberton Jun 23 '20
There are so many things I want to ask and not sound trite or contrived, but, in your opinion, is there a possibility that one of films from said studio could be successfully turned into a live action and still capture the magic? A la Alita Battle Angel?
1
u/moviebuff77 Jun 23 '20
What was the moment when you realised you wanted to pursue film as a career?
1
u/Hisnibbs Jun 23 '20
Did you work with Dave Freedman?
1
u/FeilVei2 Jun 23 '20
Unfortunately, I haven't gotten around to watching most of Studio Ghibli's work, since I want to get my hands on 4K versions of them. The one film I have watched is Spirited Away, which is an odd film from my childhood. The scene where the parents are pigs all of a sudden creeps me out the most. My question is; what do you think Studio Ghibli's films mean to different age groups; children contra teens/adults? Is there a deliberate attempt at making certain elements stand out more to a certain demographic?
Not afraid of spoilers :)
1
u/SirDragix Jun 23 '20
Do you love Italy? Which are the best place that inspired you?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '20
Why does Miyazaki love formless black blobs so much?
P.S. Studio Ghibli rules!
1
u/ilovemodok Jun 23 '20
Any chance we’ll get Ghibli films on Netflix in Japan one day or is it a distribution thing?
1
u/moashforbridgefour Jun 23 '20
How can I convince my adult friends who don't watch cartoons or anime to watch Studio Ghibli?
1
u/Rexlove Jun 23 '20
Totoro: Bear or Cat?
1
u/BusyFerret Jun 23 '20
Has studio Ghibli ever gotten in touch with Dave Bull (Woodblock print maker)? IIRC He wanted to speak with the studio to do a collab but could never get a hold of anyone working there.