r/anime • u/DrJWilson x5https://anilist.co/user/drjwilson • Aug 01 '20
Announcement Announcing the Next Essay, Review, and Video Contest!
SUBMISSIONS ARE CLOSED!!!
THANKS TO EVERYONE WHO SUBMITTED!!!
Hello!
We've had a number of writing contests on the subreddit, with the first occurring over 3 years ago! I wonder who won that one?... Oh well, I can't remember. What I do remember is that it was a great time and brought with it some great reads—from Gochiusa's secret alternate WWII setting revealed, to meaningful contemplation and illumination of the shows we enjoy.
Years later, /u/BanjotheBear so graciously kickstarted another writing contest, upping the ante by allowing reviews and videos in addition to traditional essays. As a result we received over double the amount of submissions as the first time, no doubt in search of one of the many prizes.
So, since people like participating and people like reading/watching entries, why not have another one?! That's what I said! We'll keep the details similar to the past 750k subscriber contest.
Written Essays Category
These encompass anything from single scene breakdowns to thematic analysis of an entire creator's work. Here are your guidelines for submission:
Your submission must in the form of a written essay. Your essay is not limited to any particular topic, so long as the subject of your analysis is anime-specific. It must be between 1000 and 3000 words. Your work must be original. It must be written and submitted within the given time frame of three months (deadline: Nov 1st, 2020).
While creative writing is not allowed, such as fanfiction or original narratives, we encourage you to be creative in your comparisons or analyses. As always, ensure that grammar, spelling, and other fundamental writing concepts are to the best of your ability!
Written Reviews Category
Reviewing any given series is often less about what is "objectively" true, but rather allowing others a look at your own perspective. While analysis essays tend to zero in on a single idea, reviews have the burden of having to cover the totality of a work, taking into account the pieces yes, but also how they all work together as a whole. The guidelines are similar to the written essays:
Your submission must be in the form of a written review. It is not limited to any particular show, and it may even be about a group of shows. It must be between 1000 and 3000 words. Your work must be original. It must be written and submitted within the given time frame of three months (deadline: Nov 1st, 2020).
Other than being a review of anime, everything else is up to you! You can do the standard 5 point "Story, Characters, Visuals..." structure, or do something completely different... be creative!
Videos Category
You might be wondering, "why include videos?" Well, although they aren't exactly the same as written pieces, they certainly share a lot of DNA. Some are literally just narrated essays, with the benefit of being able to show you exactly what they're talking about when they're talking about it. However, videos can be much more than that. The ability to have presentation, creative editing, and showmanship open up the category to embrace a lot of content that at the end of the day, is just plain entertaining. Here are your guidelines:
Your submission must be in the form of a video. Your video is not limited to any particular topic so long as it meets the sub's rules on anime specificity. Unfortunately we are not taking AMVs at this time. It must be between 5 and 12 minutes long (excluding intros and outros). Your video will be evaluated on multiple levels, including: content of your argument/message, audiovisual presentation, and overall structure. It must be created, published, and submitted within the given time frame of three months (deadline: Nov 1st, 2020).
The video category is the most broad, allowing for typical analysis/review, but also a number of other styles of video as well.
Submission Details
A lot of this is covered in the individual categories, but will be restated here for emphasis. Your submission must be in the form of a reddit post to /r/anime between now and the deadline of November 1st, 2020. You may link to any external website, and, for the purpose of the contest, we will waive the self-promotion rule/limits for exactly one entry that you make. Please make it clear this will be your contest entry either through the title of the post or through a comment reply to your post. Flair your post as "Writing" or "Video" accordingly. All spoilers must be properly tagged according to our spoiler policy.
Link your submission as a reply to the stickied comment below in this thread. If you do not your submission will not be counted.
Whether you submit an essay, review, or video, it must have been created expressly for the purpose of this contest. You may not reuse your own content that was made before the announcement of this contest—self-plagiarism is plagiarism!
Written essays and reviews must be within 1000 and 3000 words long, and videos must be within 5 and 12 minutes long.
You may enter into any/all of the categories you would like, but no more than once. Meaning, you may submit any combination of essay, review, or video, but no more than one of each. Submissions are final, you may not change your submission once it gets linked in the comments below. Be sure of your choice!
Judging
After all the submissions are in, they will be reviewed by our panel of judges! As with last time, you may recognize the familiar names of Writing Club members, who will take over the monumental task of reading and evaluating each written work. They are:
And who better to judge the video category than video creators themselves! They are:
and
Shaybs already does a weekly series called Anitube Digest, where he goes over the best (and not so best) anime videos of the week, so it was a no-brainer to have his already sharpened mind help judge videos for us! As for Kamimashita, some say they're shrouded in mystery, only coming out of the woodwork to host the /r/anime Awards livestream for us year after year.
Prizes!
Of course, what's a contest without baitincentive! The winners of each category will receive the following:
- A custom flair (see my username for an example)
- Their winning entry displayed as the sidebar image, much like WT! of the month and Thursday discussions
- Reddit platinum
However, we know you're not here for something the last Kaguya thread got 30 of. In addition to the above, First Place winners will also receive $100 RightStuf giftcards. And if you don't win, we'd like to award the effort anyway. Second and Third Place will receive $50 and $25 giftcards respectively. Please thank the moderator team for generously funding over $525 in prizes!!!
That's all folks! The contest begins immediately and continues until November 1st, 2020. Remember to link the reddit threads for your submissions in the stickied comment directly below in order to be counted.
If you have any questions regarding the format, rules, or what-have-you, please either comment within this thread, contact the moderators, or /u/DrJWilson directly.
We hope that this event will be fun and generate oodles of great content for months to come.
Happy writing!
•
u/DrJWilson x5https://anilist.co/user/drjwilson Aug 01 '20 edited Nov 02 '20
Link thereddit threadof your submission as a reply to this comment! Anything not linked here will not be in consideration.EDIT: Although it should be obvious, mark whether your submission is an Essay, Review, or Video to make it easier to check at a glance.Submissions are closed! Thanks to everyone who submitted and we'll get grading done as soon as possible!
22
u/AnokataX Aug 01 '20
Nice, I liked reading a bunch of the essays last time and looking forward to it again.
7
u/RX-Nota-II :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotANota Aug 01 '20
Ayy I've been waiting for this. /u/taiboss WT and now this, damn classic /r/anime really is making a comeback.
One question: do links count in the wordcount?
4
u/cesfactor Aug 01 '20
Seems very intriguing! I'll try to give it a go :3
Just one question to clarify: when you say "analysis of an entire creator's work", creator does not necessarily mean director, right? Because the topics I'm thinking of right now lean more towards background artists and character designers. Hopefully they're fair play...?
4
u/Fools_Requiem https://myanimelist.net/profile/FoolsRequiem Aug 02 '20
I take it that posts made earlier in the year don't count?
2
u/engalleons https://myanimelist.net/profile/engalleons Aug 01 '20
What methods would you recommend for confirming best Reddit formatting and confirming word counts (which can get a bit wonky in Word, etc. after adding links and images and such) before setting it loose in the subreddit proper? Is a quick post to and deletion from our profile, rather than a subreddit, be the best option?
2
u/engalleons https://myanimelist.net/profile/engalleons Aug 01 '20
I'd suggest making the limits completely hard - if you want to make the limit 12 minutes, make it 12 minutes. Phrasing it the way it is here, in my view, leaves things open to possible disputes down the road between those who interpret the limit conservatively vs liberally. 2 minutes is 20% more content, after all.
2
u/Nick_BOI Aug 11 '20
I have a couple questions, one is about the topics that are allowed
The post says that it must be anime specific, but does that mean just the anime adaptations or things related to the series in general.
If say for instance, I wanted to write an essay about how good an anime is as an adaptation-which would require referencing the source materal, would that be allowed?
I assume that writing a topic on just the source material would be not allowed, but would using the source materal as a point of comparison be okay at all, or would all discussion be limited to what has been animated?
Likewise, would comparisons to other media be disallowed, even if the topic itself is regarding an anime?
I was thinking of doing a compare contrast of the Clannad anime to the VN source material, and comparing how well the anime had done as an adaptation-but in order to do that I would need to be able to discuss what was cut from the source material. Would a topic like that be okay?
My second question is regarding the word limit. It says 1000-3000 words, but is 3000 words a hard cap? I am asking because in some classes I have taken the upper limit is more of a recomendation where the lower one is a requirement, so I was wondering if the same principle would apply here. Put simply, is over 3000 words immidiate disqualification, or would it be on a case by case basis like say, if it was bearly over it at all?
Those are my questions, thank you for your time :3.
2
u/wali_tahir Aug 25 '20
If I post an essay about an ongoing anime, or such, which would mean dynamic of it could change, which could render my analysis worthless. Would my essay be evaluated, at the time of submission? Or with the new changes in place? :c
Sorry my question structure is extremely bad XD
2
u/Kuiper :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kuiper Sep 05 '20
I've been working on a video for this, and I'm nearly at the point of being to upload it. However, I wanted to check on one thing before posting it, since checking back on this thread, it seems like the video guidelines have been slightly updated since the thread was originally posted. Previously, I recall the original post being something like, "Suggested video length is 5-10 minutes, but it's okay if it goes a few minutes over," or something like that. Now, it looks like the post has been updated to just say between 5-12 minutes, and I'm wondering if this is supposed to be a hard limit.
So, here's my situation: I've just finished a video essay that's close to 12 minutes, but I'd also like to add a short 5-second spoiler warning to the start of the video, plus an "outro" credits sequence with music and sources used, and then an "end card" like I've seen other Youtube channels do (where the last 20 seconds of the video are just background music with a still image with a channel link/subscribe button placed in the middle of the screen). Also, given the amount of time spent working on this thing, I'd really like to record a short self-promo for the ending outro/credits just to say "By the way, if you liked this video, I usually do written content, check the description for a link to where you can read it," and that combined with everything else would surely take me over the limit. I'd rather not have to go back and trim content from the actual video essay just to squeeze in an end card and a self-promo at the end.
Is it okay for the video file to be longer as long as the actual "video essay" is 12 minutes? I realize that the rule is probably there to prevent extra work for the judges who have to watch every video, but I'm totally fine to let the judges just evaluate my "entry" just based on the first 12 minutes of the video, since everything else is just extraneous and not actually part of the "video essay" submission.
13
u/babydave371 :Ej:myanimelist.net/profile/babydave371 Aug 01 '20
As the current Intercontinental Essay Competition Championship Belt holder I shall be making my return!
Last time I had a flash of inspiration with my Voltes V essay and now I must go on a spiritual quest in order to replicate such inspiration!
5
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Aug 01 '20
If I do one per month...
5
u/krasnovian https://anilist.co/user/krasnovian Aug 03 '20
hmmm, Wilson is judging essays and Kamimashita is judging videos. It's good you don't have any overlap between the panels of judges.
4
u/Suavacious :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Suavacious Aug 01 '20
Hope I get to see my boy Jack Finch in this.
1
u/porpoiseoflife https://myanimelist.net/profile/OffColfax Aug 01 '20
I have been commanded by a minor deity of this subreddit to submit this for the essay contest: https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/i1vl8l/a_rant_watch_the_damn_anime
I was kinda hoping that I was short on the word count so I could get away with letting it slide. Alas, I was just over the low limit.
1
u/Grawe15 Aug 02 '20
So if I were to write a review it must be of an anime and not that of a manga right?
1
u/SingularCheese https://anilist.co/user/lonelyCheese Aug 02 '20
How exactly does the spoiler policy apply to video content?
1
u/Redd_Hood Aug 02 '20
Can we still post analysis videos that aren't part of this contest?
1
u/parallax_kimchi Aug 03 '20
I have an essay saved as a PDF I'd like to post. I did it for a University course so won't be submitting it for competition as the rules say not to submit previously-created essays. Would still like to share though so was wondering the best way to do so?
1
u/DjRone :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DjRone Aug 04 '20
Has anyone done anything on the topic of Meruem from Hunter x Hunter? Im asking so I do not cover something that has been done before.
1
u/lazy_eye_of_sauron Aug 07 '20
I have an idea for an essay, but I want to do something a little different. If I provided a word count in the post, could I submit it as an image or pdf instead of just a standard text post?
1
u/Villeneuve_ Aug 07 '20
This contest has me intrigued! Thank you for hosting it!
I just wanted to confirm, when we're talking about anime here, we're counting both shows/series and movies, and not just the former, right?
1
u/Anime-Ramblin-Boiz Aug 14 '20
What are the criteria of judgement for an essay and for a video? This is all the motivation I need to finish my essay/video script on why Fate/Zero is NOT a greek tragedy. So, I deeply appreciate you all putting forward this contest. But, as someone who is relatively new to this community, I would love to have some clarity around how academic vs. reflective vs. literary the essay should be. Many thanks. 🧡
1
u/krasnovian https://anilist.co/user/krasnovian Aug 30 '20
May I include works cited and references that do not count toward my word limit?
1
u/Itou_Kaiji Sep 10 '20
Quick question. On the contest linked as to show how the entries will be judged, it mentions quotes as an example of evidence as well as say that evidence does not count towards the word limit. Does that ruling still stand?
Just to be sure, i'd be using a few quotes to better shape and back up my essay and they might push it slightly over the hard limit.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '20
I don't believe I should be since it just falls under my own production decisions, but will I be penalised for pitch-shifting my voice? In recent years I've been pretty deliberate about not mixing my private and public handles, and so the chance (no matter how miniscule) that I'd be recognised deters me from submitting a bit. It's not like my public persona is even popular or active by any stretch of the word, but I just like having that distinction drawn between them, and this time around I was interested in putting it under the amhpanther branding in order to put some production assets I've been sitting on to proper use.
Upon submission (which isn't quite ready yet btw I'm just asking beforehand), and assuming this flies, if you'd need me to then privately PM a relevant judge my public channel just for an extra assurance that I'm not using the changed pitch to secretly enter twice then I obviously have no qualms with doing so. I know you may think "if you have no intention of abusing it then why even ask", but in the video I believe it's immediately obvious that it's pitch-shifted (though not so roughly that it becomes jarring imo), and therefore feel the need to come forward and check the ruling first.
1
u/collapsedblock6 myanimelist.net/profile/collapsedblock Oct 04 '20
Hoho am I late for this but please answer me a little doubt /u/DrJWilson. Would it affect the judgement of a review essay if I direct it to what I witness with my eyes instead of tangible data?
To explain, I'm planning to review an anime but also how its impact and how it is perceived by the community, but this is pretty much reduced to what I have seen with my eyes in this subreddit and one could say that is inherently biased. So while I do plan to properly review the anime in question, I do wonder how it would sound to put things such as "I talked to this friend of mine talk about it" or "I remember some random dude years ago say this thing" in a serious essay.
3
u/WaterDarkE Aug 01 '20
This sounds fun! Bookmarked for now
3
u/melvinlee88 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ryan_Melvin15 Aug 04 '20
After basically devoting my month to writing a WT! for Soremachi, selling Soremachi to people for the rewatch, actually holding a rewatch itself and even now doing so on Twitter, I guess I'll do a review for Soremachi to top the whole experience of!
2
u/Itou_Kaiji Aug 01 '20
YES!!! This is always real fun and great. Thanks to all the involved for not only hosting and judging it all, but also funding prizes. Your passion really helps keep the sub alive and well.
2
u/Totalenlo https://anilist.co/user/Lenlo Aug 01 '20
Damn only 3k word max? Guess ill actually have to write somethin instead of just submitting Antarctica.
2
u/The_Draigg Aug 01 '20
I think I’ll toss my hat into the ring for this. God knows that I have a lot to say about various mecha series.
2
u/Vaynonym :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Vaynonym Aug 02 '20
Exciting! I hope I'll manage to write something again
2
u/Groenboys https://myanimelist.net/profile/Groenboys Aug 02 '20
The last time I joined the review contest I reviewed Sakura Trick and people didn't really like my review. So hopefully this year I can make it up from my last review and make something people will like!
2
u/Zelosis Aug 05 '20
This is awesome, good luck to everyone participating!
2
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '20
I’ll try and give it a shot ig
2
u/Raszero :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/raszero Aug 15 '20
Well, I had an idea for my first anime video essay thing then saw this...I'll take that as destiny calling
2
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '20
That's like a whole season of Gundam on Blu-Ray!
1
u/Biscuits7 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Biscuits7 Aug 05 '20
This looks interesting! I might give it a shot since I've been trying my hand with videos lately
1
u/prapokiii Aug 07 '20
Ok
1
u/ComicDoctor :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/yojimbokame Aug 07 '20
This looks interesting. I'm all in for making a video essay!
1
u/AccomplishedMedal3 Aug 07 '20
Where to submit the essay?
1
u/AMightyDwarf Aug 15 '20 edited Aug 15 '20
Sound's interesting, it's been a while (probably 10 years) since I wrote something akin to an essay so I'm tempted to see if I can still pull something out my arse.
A couple of questions, I'm guessing that a deep dive into a specific character is allowed, right? I'm tempted to do an analysis of Shouko Nishimiya from the perspective of a deaf person or I might throw the net a bit wider and have a look at how disability is represented in anime as a whole.
Edit, was also going to ask if this has been done before... I'll be needing as much time as possible for proof reading it seems.
Also, can a written essay use links to still frames or even gifs? I'm guessing no as it defeats the point of a written analysis but I thought I'd check.
Cheers.
1
u/Therefore_I_Must_Cry Oct 30 '20
Due date is November 1st, 2020. But in what time zone?
0
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment