r/WritingPrompts • u/MajorParadox Mod | DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) • Aug 22 '20
Off Topic [OT] SatChat: What makes a good hero in your eyes? What about a good villain? (New here? Introduce yourself!)
SatChat! SatChat! Party Time! Excellent!
Welcome to the weekly post for introductions, self-promotions, and general discussion! This is a place to meet other users, share your achievements, and talk about whatever's on your mind.
Suggested Topic
What makes a good hero in your eyes? What about a good villain?
Also, which do you find more interesting: the hero or the villain?
(This is a repeat topic. Suggest new topics below!)
More to Talk About
- New here? Introduce yourself! See the sticky comment for suggested intro questions
- What are you doing to keep busy while self-isolating or in quarantine? Click here for some resources
- Have something to promote? (Books, subreddits, podcasts, etc.)
- Suggest us topics for future SatChats!
Avoid outright spam (don't just share, chat) and not for sharing full stories
News
Fifth Friday Challenges! | Summer Challenge! | r/WPCritiques has launched! | Apply to be a Mod | Discord Server (Weekly campfires every Wednesdays at 6pm CST!)
9
u/withervoice Aug 22 '20
Don't much care for heroes or villains as a specific term. To me, a "hero" is a label put on a character to tell me how to feel about them, which I tend to reject, and "villain" is the same. Rather, I want to be shown a character that has things they want, need, fear, dream of, respect. A person. Then if they take risks and make an effort to help others and avoid harming people, that's pretty much a hero, right? A villain is someone who works towards a goal that's destructive or disruptive to people, or uses methods that are.
That said, heroes can be anything and it can work. Villains are harder to make work, because if they're too awful you don't want to know about them, you just want them to die and be gone. I tend to get annoyed with two types of villains. The ones that are just pure "I want to do evulz", like kick-the-puppy impractical evil stuff. The other is the super-idealistic villain who may kill, steal and trample over people, but just in order to save the world. They tend to get annoying.
The most important thing is for the author not to tell me how to feel about someone. Show what they do, the consequences, perhaps how they feel about that, and then let me decide if they're a monster or okay.
7
u/Thetallerestpaul r/TallerestTales Aug 22 '20
Hi, SatChat. I'm Paul, I have dabbled in replying to prompts for a couple of years, but I've recently upped my practising after a story I wrote got people reading, and I'm now on part 28 of it. Its the longest thing I've ever written and its teaching me a lot. I have never plotted before and I enjoy just allowing a story to happen. Sometimes it goes well and sometimes not, but I usually enjoy figuring it out.
Because of that lack of planning my 'heroes' and 'villains' are frequently not the who I expected them to be. I start writing a hero, and a bit of dialogue is unsympathetic and a few lines later I find that I'm turning them more negative. The fact I don't know to start with if they are good or not makes a lot of my characters pretty grey.
I really like writing here. I have always loved stories, in whatever form, and its allowed me to anonymously have people read what I write. I'm not ready to tell anyone in the real world that I make up stories for fun. The encouragement I got here, and on the sub I set up to keep my stories have meant a lot to me.
I type at about 30 WPM, but I'm trying to learn touch typing, to speed up how quickly I can get ideas down in my free time.
Thanks for the chance to say hi!
6
u/mobaisle_writing /r/The_Crossroads Aug 22 '20
To me, good heroes should tend toward pro-social methods for their aims, whereas villains should tend toward selfish or antisocial ones. Both should be in some way relatable or understandable for the audience. I tend away from black and white morality in my writing so that's about as much as I distinguish between them.
5
u/NystromWrites r/nystorm_writes Aug 22 '20
Ooooh. Hmm. That is an excellent question.
Slightly off to the side of that topic- do you think any of your heroes, in the absence of a villain- would have become the villain?
Consider Harry Potter- he was ambitious, not above cutting corners for the sake of personal progress and prestige (re: Half-blood prince) as well as comfortable doing violence to achieve his goals. If it hadn't been for the case study in 'being evil' by you-know-who, he may have been more like his father, who was a bully, a show-off...and he may have been worse, on top of that. With all of the attention, deference, money at his disposal- maybe he would have developed a more anti-social attitude? A "I'm superior to others" attitude...maybe he would rationalize it because of his pure blood? Maybe, in his later years in Hogwarts, he would have begun to seek power for power's own sake, to maintain the leg up he had always had on his peers...and found himself in the restricted section at the library, reading a little reference to something called a Horcrux.
I think heroes often display signs that would have made them villains, if they hadn't been using those indicators to fight evil. I think heroes are only different from villains because most people agree that "the ends justify the means"
4
u/Archipelagoisland Aug 22 '20
I’m nothing of note, but I’v written a little here and there. A good hero is one with complicated convictions that allow them to consistently do what we as the audience would consider moral while still allowing for the occasional questionable act. Like Aang in avatar the last air bender, Luke Skywalker in StarWars, Steven from Steven Universe, Ironman from the marvel movies. Like they’re all “good” guys but sometimes they go to far, their personality lets them be a bit pompous, they have insecurities that prevent them from making logical decisions etc. but above all else, I like to see change and growth. This can be in villains too, show how they fell that far and how fast. The best characters are those that start off indifferent and are pushed into adopting morals for better or worse. Take Captain Nemo from 20,000 Leagues under the Sea for example, the mad lad just wants to chill in his submarine and explore. But he slowly goes mad and the events through that book lead him to..... that ending. Or take Danny Archer from the film blood Diamond, the guys literally a diamond smuggler profiteering off the Sierra Leonian civil war. He starts off selling guns to a terrorist group but at the end the events as well as the choices he had to make led him to..... that films ending. But in both cases, these fictional characters could have gone either way.
4
u/nightshademilkshake Aug 22 '20
Hey! I'm a nobody who writes stuff now and again, and recently started sharing.
A good hero (imo) is a character that propels us to a certain line of thinking. Whether that takes on a heroes journey, or lets us see their world through their eyes, they genuinely believe that what they do improves their world. (Mumen Rider, One Punch)
A good villain then, should make us question that premise. Is the hero really doing the best thing? Or even a good thing? (J. Jonah Jameson, Spiderman) They don't need to have a plan or idea, but the best ones do. The villain should be just as complex as the hero, even if we dont get to see most of it.
These are different from protaganist and antagonist.
The protagonist is simply the character we as readers get to follow and sympathise with. Whether they are good, bad, ugly or otherwise isn't the point. (Artemis Fowl -Book Series)
The antagonist is the foil for the protagonist. The one who makes goals difficult, creates problems, and/or gets in the way.
A hero could be both the protagonist and antagonist of the story. A villain could be the same. These are simply titles given to characters that help us explain their story.
(I tried to come up with examples, but my brain is fried for today.) Havva good one Y'all!
3
u/moinatx Aug 22 '20
For me a great hero has a pressing need and internal flaw that makes pursuing that need difficult. I like it when the antagonist is something of a shadow, maybe even not a villain but someone who simply has conflicting goals. My favorite heroes engage in interpersonal dialog with other characters that sounds natural and includes humor, social commentary, and pop culture. I like a hero with either really profound or ironic internal dialog. I like a hero who presses on toward their goal in fits and spurts, taking distracted breaks in a hidey hole, sipping a beer and send their sidekicks to do a hero's job, preferably either better than the hero or creating chaos for the hero. I prefer present tense, non-omniscient points of view although retrospective can be effective in some cases. Nonlinear storytelling is great as long as the reader can follow it.
Introducing me - Moinatx
3
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20
To me, a good hero is somebody who is able to captivate you. The same applies to a good villain as well. Both a good hero and a good villain have ideals, goals, and a good sense of intrigue that gets you to engage with them. Both also have a flaw that makes them grounded, and prevents them from becoming too perfect. The difference between these two is that the hero is able to know what that flaw is and work to mitigate it, or at the very least is able to prevent it from warping who they are, whereas a villain is someone who’s been pushed into becoming a villain.
This is mind, not every hero is a protagonist, and not every villain is an antagonist. A good hero can easily serve as a good antagonist, and vice versa. To me at least, that’s what makes for a good hero and villain.
Hey, there! My name is David Revill and I’m from Virginia. I’ve been on Reddit for like a week and a half, but I started going on this subreddit two days ago. I’ve been an amateur writer for about a couple of years now, primarily because I have a lot of fun concepts for stories and such. I primarily use Google Docs to write, and I can type at about 14 words per minute.
2
u/vestegaard Aug 22 '20
I like villains that are a good mix of charismatic and terrifying. However, the pitfall of that is potentially making your villain more interesting than your hero. A villain exists to be defeated. Making your villain too likeable, will make your hero feel like a hall monitor handing out detentions.
What I find effective in heroes is a sense of humour. You can see it in comics and kids cartoons. It creates an underdog relatability and makes them more likeable.
2
u/JohnGarrigan Aug 22 '20
So, both of these are A. generalizations, as with all human defined things there are exceptions and B. talking not about general character strengths, but only things needed for a hero/villain.
A hero needs to be rooted for. Not charismatic, there are heroes who are disliked in their own universe, awkward, loners, and generally uncool. The reader, however, needs to form an emotional connection with a hero. They need to actively want them to succeed. The hero doesn't necessarily have to succeed, or be a good person (though the worse of a person they are the harder it is to root for them), they just need to be liked by the reader.
The villain does not have to be disliked. The villain has to be a threat. Be it through force, political power, being a sneaky/clever/manipulative bastard, or other means, they must be able to realistically be a force to be reckoned with. The reader should want to fight them, but also not want to fight them because they aren't sure they would win. If given to much power it can seem farcical, but too little and they are a pushover. An ineffective villain falls flat.
Again, there are exceptions to both of these, and there is more to it (they also have to be effective characters in general), but this is specifically about those labels.
2
u/TheLettre7 Aug 23 '20
Good is subjective.
that said a hero would be someone relatable that tugs on the emotions. It would have you root for them, knowing in some sense, that what they are doing is 'right'. the what the opposite of that is a villain, who is doing 'wrong' from the perspective of said hero.
A villain would embody the same likeness as a hero, but would be booed or looked down on because they are not the hero. therefore they should lose because they have the label of villain, of evil doer. even though from their perspective they are 'right', whether they truly are or not.
Work and Ward are good examples of this, loved reading them.
it's not all black and white, there are difference. sometimes rooting for the Villain is better subjectively, than rooting for the Hero.
2
u/AslandusTheLaster r/AslandusTheLaster Aug 23 '20
It kind of depends, particularly on what roles they play in the story. The protagonist should always to be at least somewhat sympathetic because the audience is going to want to empathize with them. If you've got a "hero" as the protagonist, then they need to be charismatic and capable. If the "hero" is not the protagonist (ie, in a fantasy or superhero story where "hero" can be a sort of job or role instead of story designation), then you've got room to make them more morally dubious or incompetent.
Villains are a bit more complicated. In the role of protagonist, they should be still sympathetic, but that can be a bit tricky with them still ostensibly being the villain of the story. I usually resolve it either by having them be technically a villain, in the same sense as the non-protagonist hero, or just making their situation such that the reader can accept them slicing a man's jugular. If they're not the protagonist, the whole sympathetic thing is completely optional, but they should still be fun. After all, if the villain is boring, the story's bound to be boring too.
2
u/Kirkiosity Aug 23 '20
I'd say a hero in terms of a story it's anyone with a goal to improve on their reality or their perception of the reality and will go to hell and back to get the job done. The villain is anyone who is an obstacle to that.
If you're talking about real terms it's pretty subjective.
By the way Hi. I'm new to this thread. Trying to improve my writing skills. Hoping this might be my job one day.
2
u/BurningEmbyr Aug 23 '20
Hey! I'm burningEmbyr (or bE), and I'm new (to SatChat, at least)! I've been on Reddit for just over 2 years, now, and I've been actively writing on r/WritingPrompts for at least two thirds of that. Motivation? That particular feeling of dissonance that happens around 3am in the morning. That's a good motivation. Also making my friends laugh/cry with the comedic/sad pieces I can write. I usually just write right here in the Reddit comment box (and I once lost an entire monologue to my browser crashing, so that was fun) (and it almost happened again while writing this).
Anyway, on to the question!
I think the best villains are the ones that are clear, coherent, brilliant, and absolutely focused. They have a purpose, a goal, and will do absolutely anything to achieve it. Villains like that are interesting, because you can begin to understand why they are doing what they are. Their reasoning is mostly sound. They seem normal, almost human. And forcing people (and heroes) to reconcile that with their actions is so interesting!
A sense of honor also helps to humanize them, and make them more enjoyable. Like, be evil and all, but at least be evil in a classy way.
For heroes, I think not being motivated by a grand scheme of right and wrong is a great thing. One story I wrote involved someone breaking in to a place, inflicting a horrible punishment on a being that objectively deserved it, and leaving. They didn't do it because of all the harm the being had caused to everyone else, but because the being had killed their lover. And to me, that's a more compelling motivation for the hero than the bland "they did a bad thing to people I don't know and for that they must be brought to justice!" This hero's motivation was personal, their revenge was personal, and the resolution was personal. That, to me at least, is very interesting and allows for more character development, and a greater amount of focus on your hero.
2
u/keizee Aug 23 '20
So, I picked up Re: zero novels a few months ago, and the author made some very interesting characters.
The antagonists/villains: a love obsessed lunatic, the witch that sees everything logically and cannot comprehend emotions, they are all written pretty well. Some of them are not very believable at first sight, until the protagonist/side characters etc displays behaviour that is close but not as extreme as them.
The protagonist itself also has potential to become a villain, with the author's non-canon alternative universes stemming from the wrong choices. Thanks to his cheat power, I could believe that he could achieve that much. What happens if he didn't swallow his pride to call for help? The stress, pain and spite from the events later completely unhinges him and he would eventually destroy the country. What happens if he isn't patient enough to fix the rift between him and his companions? He would've ran off, and with the always mistrustful mindset, become a mafia boss who would kill thousands.
2
u/crazypinkwigthethird Aug 27 '20
To, me a good villain is one who does bad things but not for no reason. Maybe they had a bad past.
2
u/phormix Sep 03 '20
Strong villains are the ones that are believable, and even understandable, but broken in some way. The muahaha sociopath doesn't really work very well anymore. In movies and sometimes books, sometimes they have a few choice lines that may have you nodding your head thinking "yeah, I get that."
I thought that Incredibles actually did this really well the "buddy." He's brilliant and actually wanted to be a Hero but - due to being immature - couldn't stand the rejection from his idol. There were great lines such as "when everybody is Super, nobody will be," in which he implies that he'll elevate the common man - kinda a noble idea actually - buuuut in the next breath he's lost it again and gone dark side.
Another good trait had been the "chaotic" villain. It's not easy to do right by Dark Knight's Joker, and the killer in Seven are good examples where you feel like you're starting to track on them and then BAM they hit a 90° turn. The trick the seems to be making it something that would be unnatural for a normal person but fitting in the villains character without being them be entirely gonzo all the time.
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 22 '20
Tell us about yourself!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.