r/anime • u/IndependentMacaroon • Aug 23 '20
Watch This! [WT!] SoreMachi (Soredemo Machi wa Mawatteiru) - a true slice-of-life series
I joined the recent rewatch for this a while ago, but never got around to spelling out my thoughts on it. So here they are in form of a short review/recommendation.
A cross-section of an entire place
Slice-of-life series tend to focus on a small tight-knit group of characters of similar ages and backgrounds (usually girls), focusing on their interactions among themselves and/or their journey through their current stage of life (usually high school). SoreMachi, however, is a bit different. It's neither a lengthwise cut through the story of any one character or group - in fact, both the manga's chapters and the anime's episodes are deliberately not in chronological order, and there are no story arcs or plotlines longer than a single episode - nor a collection of samples revolving around a particular gimmick, but a cross-section of the people and places of its setting (a small seaside town and its shopping district) and the various kinds of connections among them, friendly and somewhat less so. Yes, the most prominent characters are still high school girls, but also in the spotlight are siblings, parents, teachers, employers and other business owners, a policeman, and later on even a little surprisingly appropriate-feeling supernatural/sci-fi material - the best comparison I can make is Jojo part 4, which I also enjoyed very much, but without the battles or villains.
Well-rounded characters outside the "moe" paradigm
Except for one character who only gets some hints of depth in the material the anime covers, the main members of the cast are a well-rounded combination of amusing to endearing and sometimes troublesome quirks and genuine love for their own passions and the small, beautiful world around them. The best example is the clumsy, none-too-smart, somewhat lazy, carefree yet stubborn lead, Hotori Arashiyama, who makes some serious efforts to bring more customers to her workplace, a newly maid-themed café owned and operated by an old widow, help out her younger siblings even if they sometimes annoy her, and has a surprising aptitude for out-of-the-box mystery solving while remaining hopelessly inept at mathematics, much to the chagrin of her painfully straight-laced math teacher, who is in the opposite situation. Also, in contrast to the modern "precious moe marshmallow" craze, everyone actually looks, behaves, and sounds like (mostly) normal people of their age - some characters are even deliberately ugly or odd-sounding.
The variety and little joys of everyday life
As the show goes on, we witness many kinds of more and less comedic situations; learning proper etiquette as a maid café employee, unconventional yet surprisingly good musical performances (have you ever wondered about the sound of a band consisting of an accordion, a violin, an electric bass, and a drum set?), conversations going to strange places and topics without getting inappropriate or boring (if you think talking about vending machines and drying clothes can't hold your attention for ten minutes, think again), awkward date setups, table tennis matches, fruitless tutoring sessions, beach days that don't quite work out, little mysteries whether natural or supernatural, and even just enjoying strolling around town whether at day or night, with friends, the dog, or alone. I won't spoil the finale, but it does get quite emotional as well. To sum it up, this really is a slice-of-life show in the most literal sense - many different mundane things happening to different people day-to-day, while, as the title says, the town just keeps on moving.
Shaft quality, with a few caveats
Shaft clearly put a lot of effort and some of their trademark quirks into this show's animation, resulting in a very smooth experience with no noticeable flaws, except maybe for some rare awkwardly fanservicey moments. The whimsical soundtrack is also a real joy to listen to even outside the show. As for the few issues: It has a bit of an awkward start, so really do make sure to watch until episode 3 or so before passing judgement; some of the humor can feel a bit too random or over-the-top; due to the structure there inherently can't be much in the way of character or relationship development besides exploring their current status and their chemistry with others more deeply; and of course, it's only twelve episodes and there will never be any more, so it's "read the manga" for anyone who actually got interested. For me, it's enough to give it an 8/10, and I'd encourage you to give it a try if you are in any way interested in a less conventional take on slice-of-life... or if you just have a general "soredemo" obsession (you know who you are).
The series is only available for legal streaming in North America, on HiDive and VRV. The manga can be read with a Crunchyroll subscription.
7
u/melvinlee88 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ryan_Melvin15 Aug 23 '20 edited Aug 23 '20
Fellow rewatch holder of Soremachi here, and to anyone interested, here's the MAL link for Soremachi and to people who have watched the show and actually liked it, hope you read the manga and here's a neat fan Twitter account.
Wow wow wow u/IndependentMacaroon making a WT! for Soremachi? I remember you weren't feeling too hot on the show after the first few episodes and I thought you dropped it. Glad that you actually continued and liked it. I welcome you to the WT! catalog for Soremachi, now there are two of us!
True slice of life really is the perfect way to describe this wonderful series. A brilliant WT! written out, touching on all the great points of the series, especially the fact where the show cuts the stereotypical "moe marshmallow" characters that is basically everywhere in SOL shows now.
To anyone who bother reading this, give this show a chance (more than 3 eps i guess, but it was a strong start for me). It is sitting at only 47k members with half of them on their Plan to Watch and the other half having completed the show. It's a show that definitely brings something fresh to the SOL genre with its focus on characters and brilliant mix with surrealism and mystery at the same time.
It is a show that well and truly shines alone as a hidden gem among Shaft's more majestic works and it has its own wonderful story to tell and when the curtains finally fall on episode 12, you'll be wanting to revisit the wonderful world of Soremachi yet again as the town continues to move.
Edit: Also they recently released some Soremachi music on Spotify recently with the wonderful ED and insert song from episode 8 ! Here's the link. Maido!
2
u/DrJWilson x5https://anilist.co/user/drjwilson Sep 07 '20
Hello, and thanks for writing a wonderful WT! Typically one of the admins of the Watch This! project will leave constructive feedback, but recently they're busy so it falls to me! Yoroshiku onegaishimasu~
You piqued my interest with the opening paragraph, and the whole post was an easy read. If I had any criticism, I would say that I don't think I have a really good grasp on SoreMachi as a show despite reading this. Is there still a main cast? Is there a main cast but more emphasis is placed on side characters than normal? Are there actual musical performances?
In my experience, most Slice of Life are "a cross-section of the people and places of its setting", so I had trouble placing exactly what made this show stand out to you, especially then with the fact that apparently supernatural elements appear later in the show. You sort of get into it later when you mention that it makes things such as vending machine conversations and other mundane things compelling, but I would've liked a little more description. Maybe talking about how exactly you think it makes these things interesting, or the feeling it gives off? I imagine it sounds like it could invoke the feeling of just hanging out with a group of friends quite well. Lastly, I really liked the character section as many slice of life tend to be more character focused, but I would've preferred seeing some of the variety I could expect to encounter rather than just reading about a single character. You also have a pretty egregious run-on sentence in that paragraph that can be a little confusing to read.
All in all, I've seen some clips of SoreMachi before, but this post does certainly make me more interested. I hope my feedback was at least a little useful and I look forward to seeing more from you in the future.
Guide to making a successful Watch This!
4
u/Yri4lf12 Aug 23 '20
The MC is buffed by Maka Album feel Soul Eater and produced by by Shaft. It's not nearly as trippy as Monogatari but you can see pre Madoka Shaft style.
7
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Aug 23 '20
Yes I do.
3
u/MiLiLeFa Aug 23 '20
That song is absolutely hilarious. Shaft had a talent for using really good music in their shows from Tsukiyomi to Koufuku. A good OST and proper use of it is one of those things which instantly and massively improve an anime.
2
u/stefandy31 Aug 24 '20
great anime, also manga is really good too. i hope they will do season 2 although its almost impossible.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '20
[removed] — view removed comment