r/Debris • u/sanctuary_moon • Mar 16 '21
Debris - S01E03 Solar Winds - Episode Discussion
| Episode | Title | Directed by | Written by | Airdate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.03 | Solar Winds | Rebecca Rodriguez | J.H. Wyman | March 15th, 2021 10/9c |
Episode synopsis: When Bryan and Finola investigate a mysterious, otherworldly square that has appeared in a field, they come to understand new revelations about our planet. Maddox meets with an old contact.
Past Episode Discussions
Reminders
No piracy. Link requests and links to unauthorized distribution such as torrents/streaming sites will be removed.
Use spoiler mark up for any unique information about unaired episodes: >!Between these "brackets" resides a spoiler!< results in Between these "brackets" resides a spoiler
16
Upvotes
14
u/mtm4440 Mar 16 '21
Clearly the passage of time in the dimension is Jeremy Bearimy.
13
u/usagizero Mar 16 '21
I'd like to pretend i'd be smart enough to not mess with the weird thing if i saw one, but i know i'd poke it with a stick.
13
u/therisingalleria Mar 16 '21
man, those poor people trapped there for decades.
13
u/gatemansgc Mar 16 '21
well that looks like fun, throwing the chair through one debris and having it come out another. like a portal gun!
12
u/edspillane Mar 16 '21
Wonder if Brian still likes peeps. If no, he’s a clone
12
u/three18ti Mar 16 '21
Why did Jones have to pull the girl out, but everyone else just reappeared?
Also, what's going to happen to these people from the 70s who just appeared in 2021? Seems like a whole show unto itself...
11
u/mtm4440 Mar 16 '21
Debris is using the "Dark" soundtrack. Blowing out my speakers.
11
u/gatemansgc Mar 16 '21
oh dang some of them have been trapped in nowhere for decades
9
u/robotlasagna Mar 16 '21
It’s exactly like Fringe! But without the talented storytelling.
8
u/mtm4440 Mar 16 '21
They're in different pocket dimensions.
8
u/gatemansgc Mar 16 '21
there's 10 minutes left in the episode so they'll figure it out pretty fast
8
u/mtm4440 Mar 16 '21
Just realized Debris is going to compete with Manifest for the sci-fi timeslot.
7
u/usagizero Mar 16 '21
So, random thought. Do you think we will ever see what the ship looked like when they spotted it?
7
u/mtm4440 Mar 16 '21
These creepy shadows are reminding me of an Are You Afraid of the Dark episode.
7
u/CidLeigh Mar 16 '21
It must be where the Missing 411 people go.
7
u/mtm4440 Mar 16 '21
I love the stories but I'm not falling in love with the characters like I did with Fringe. They need more substance.
7
u/gatemansgc Mar 16 '21
that music made me thought it was a sound effect that they were hearing.
7
u/usagizero Mar 16 '21
Neat! I had a thought that the ship traveled through different dimensions.
7
u/SG14ever Mar 16 '21
I really liked the Dad and Daughter - the Dad going through a roller coaster of emotions - a mixture of resignation, hope, stoicism and love...
7
u/SG14ever Mar 16 '21
"If we're not willing to use this technology on these people, then we're not worthy to have it..."
Agree or disagree?
6
u/usagizero Mar 16 '21
Oh no! It's Zod trapped in the Phantom Zone! ;)
6
u/pgm_01 Mar 16 '21
I like this, it reminds me of the Twilight Zone episode Little Girl Lost.
6
u/gatemansgc Mar 16 '21
and all those other people still trapped in there? what about them?
EDIT: nevermind!
6
u/usagizero Mar 16 '21
She's got kind of freaky eyes.
6
u/gatemansgc Mar 16 '21
BODY SWAP
6
u/usagizero Mar 16 '21
That was neat. Still episode 2 was my favorite so far, but i love body horror.
6
u/Nervous-Energy-4623 Mar 17 '21
Do you know what makes this show stand out from the pack, the characters have a lot of emotional depth. It makes them feel more grounded and real. It's a good change of pace for these formulaic shows and helps hold my attention.
The amount of civilians that know about the debris, ha good luck keeping that a secret from now on.
6
u/EllaMinnowPea1 Mar 17 '21
She can see you! Why can't you wave? Let her know you can hear her. Get a whiteboard out or something. For God's sake, make a gesture at least 🙄
6
u/PaladinGodfather1931 Mar 20 '21
I feel like this sub was only created to shit on this show. We get it, you could write a better sci-fi show. So go do that and let us enjoy this
11
u/gatemansgc Mar 16 '21
and this is why i try to upvote everyone, to encourage people to comment. when people comment continuously others may be able to read stuff they missed in the comments.
11
u/JakeFromSkateFarm Mar 16 '21 edited Mar 16 '21
Three episodes in and this has just been painful to watch.
It feels like the creators/writers are just directly stealing from The X-Files and Fringe without really understanding how the elements they’re using worked in those other shows.
For example, family drama as part of the larger conspiracy. In The X-Files, it’s the shock of learning how complicit Fox’s dad was in not only Samantha’s abduction, but also in the greater conspiracy and cover-up and his work with the Cigarette Smoking Man.
In Fringe, it’s the repairing of the father/son relationship plus learning that Walter accidentally triggered the events that led to not only the “pattern” affecting both universes, but also the truth about Peter.
So far, the focus in Debris just seems to be on emoting and trauma. Which would be bad enough, but the acting and writing are equally terrible. It’s all so overwrought and ham-handed, and it’s always so high stakes. Episode 2’s Victim of the Week and their relationship drama, Episode 3’s Vee-Dubs and his daughter.
It’s like every episode and plot point has to be about the most extreme emotion of loss and trauma and family. It just gets tiring and very quickly feels formulaic and also a bit manipulative.
It similarly feels like they’re Mary Sue’ing the main characters. Male Protagonist wants to be both the nerdy Fox type who knows / believes in weird things (episode 3, when he casually asks about the Bermuda Triangle like he believes in it and assumes everyone else does, or when he mentions “Native American legends”), but they also want him seen as this badass loner warrior soldier w/ trauma (which of course itself is an almost toxic cliche of a male character - the emotionally repressed warrior).
This show has been so disappointing and frustrating to watch that I’m at the point where I’m getting irrationally upset at seeing them constantly wearing their ear-pieces at all time. Like I’m already picturing the season 3 or 5 sex scenes between the two where they’re still wearing the damn things.
Another thing I'm reminded of is a comment/remark I remember reading once back in the 90s near the end of The X-Files. It essentially was about how The X-Files was ultimately a body horror show about the fear of losing control and autonomy over one's body - ie via alien abductions and experimentation, mutation, death by creepy and almost paranormal serial killers, etc. It really feels like the "theme" of Debris is going to be about trauma and regret and emotional repression, which...is fine...but it feels like a topic or theme that's really easy to over-act and over-write for and it feels like this show is doing exactly that so far. The main characters are trying too hard, written too hard, and acted too hard. The victims of the week are similarly overwrought.
Related to that, the debris tech seems interesting, but it seems more to be a "science-y" vessel for basically doing shows on ghosts and demons than on aliens or future science/tech. The 'ghost theme' fitting in perfect with this whole obsession on loss and regret and trauma.
Also:
The “tension” sound effects they’re using to try and build drama (ex going into the commercial break after Male Protagonist informs Female Protagonist that her dad was right about the access portals in Michigan and their current location) reminds me a lot of how Fringe would do the same thing. To the point that it almost feels like they’re just directly ripping off Fringe.
The “I’ve met agents like you that work by your own rules” scene was so gd cringe. Or was until "there's still magic in the world" scene came along and obliterated it with even more cringe.
The “native Americans talk about” legends bit was so desperately attempting to be Fox Mulder -also, this isn’t the 90s, why not mention the specific nations or tribes and their legends rather than just yet again lumping them all into one generic group and legend?
Also, is it just me, or is “situational awareness” spy craft undermined when the secret phone you get at the deli is directly removed from the deli bag right outside the deli and you suspiciously look everywhere while using the phone and getting into the car you walked directly to after the deli? Also how is he surprised that his own agency is tracking the guy he met with?
5
u/gatemansgc Mar 16 '21
not as much reddit activity on this episode
5
u/mtm4440 Mar 16 '21
Those sound effects felt out of place.
5
u/gatemansgc Mar 16 '21
maybe when the square is there the times are synced?
5
u/gatemansgc Mar 16 '21
they must have used that teleporting stuff.
5
u/SG14ever Mar 16 '21
Has the show said if the debris was public knowledge? Won't this new situation be the toughest (so far) to explain to the time warped/stasis people and their family friends?
5
u/dmnwl Mar 16 '21
Really enjoyed this episode. It’s getting better as it goes. Once the characters/mythology and such get more fleshed out I think we’ll have a real gem. Unless all the negativity causes NBC to pull the plug which would be unfortunate.
9
u/therisingalleria Mar 16 '21
just tell her Bryan 😭
8
u/pgm_01 Mar 16 '21
That was a good episode.
4
u/therisingalleria Mar 16 '21
Let's gooo
4
u/usagizero Mar 16 '21
good rule to live by, lol
4
u/SirWobblyOfSausage Mar 17 '21
My partner and myself are really hooked on this show. It's nicely filling that void Fringe and X-Files left long ago.
Would be pretty awesome if we find Walter roaming in some pocket universe <3
6
u/therisingalleria Mar 16 '21
Finola spitting out facts.
3
u/gatemansgc Mar 16 '21
love these kaiju flonase commercials!
3
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '21
That quick "yesss" to Byrans "where do they keep coming from?" Was a bit sketchy. And then she just leaves.
3
u/Supereurobeat Mar 17 '21
Another NBC Sci fi show at 9pm on Monday that will dissapoint and frustrate. Anyone remember Earth 2?
5
u/SomeRandomJoe81 Mar 16 '21
Decent enough concept but the characters are bland and uninteresting. Be nice if they had a bit of development and every episode wasn’t so monotonous in tone and action. Needs a more human element injected into the show.
I’m just going to finish my Fringe rewatch and call it a day.
4
u/DarkRoastJames Mar 16 '21
The science fiction aspect of this show is horrible.
They need a way to communicate with the trapped people and can't, so the male main character just MacGyvers up a way instantly? Is he a world class engineer? Throughout the episode they keep talking about how they need to find the debris, then towards the end Bryan is like "let's try this thing we tried in Michigan" and they instantly find it - uh....why didn't they try that already?
"The transmission is stronger when she's more emotional" what. Literally zero explanation for that and it's such a strange conclusion to jump to. Dad just happens to have a map of spatial anomalies. Moving the main debris thing around lets you see into the rectangle at different angles, but then everyone is rescued at the same time despite being in different phases / places / dimensions.
I don't need rock solid full scientific explanations for everything but the leaps of logic and lack of any effort is trying - it's just "the power of emotions" and a bunch of hand-waving. Stuff just happens whenever it's required to move the plot along without even a hint of coherency.
3
u/neo101b Mar 17 '21
The part that bugged me was the time dilations part, where the young girls said it felt like time was slow inside the bubble.
That's not how it works, time is relative and so time would feel normal within the time dilation field compared to outside. So 1 min inside = 1 year outside. You wouldn't be able to notice.
The series has a good premise, sadly it not executing it that well.
2
u/Prudent_Relief Mar 17 '21
I am officially departing, since this show will be cancelled.
2
u/mickeyflinn Mar 16 '21
Annnnd I am out.
I have given this mess three hours of my life. It gets no more.
1
u/ECrispy Mar 17 '21
This is the dumbest show I've seen written by and for idiots. Every episode is dumb pretend SciFi with 90% of the show about emotional nonsense, her dad etc.
1
u/JohnnyMojo Mar 17 '21
This show is just too full of cheesy emotional cliches. As a huge sci-fi fan, this completely ruins it for me. This show really did have potential but it's ruined by network TV cliches.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
12
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
11
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '21 edited Mar 16 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
10
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
7
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
10
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '21
[removed] — view removed comment