r/HFY • u/someguynamedted The Chronicler • Jun 20 '21
MOD CONTENT THEFT ALERT
FOR IMMEDIATE ACTION: It has come to the mod team's attention that there are multiple YouTube accounts uploading HFY Original Content and potentially plagiarizing it as their own work, or at least reproducing it on their channel without permission.
If you are one of the authors who have been affected, check to see if your story has been stolen. From there, you may contact the Youtube channel to have it removed if you wish, or report the Youtube channel and file a DMCA notice.
If you are not an author who has been affected, please do not harass these youtubers. We do not want the author's voices to be drowned out, or to be accused of brigading.
Some channels in question:
- https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCrFijJLLeBT3JDh4iNX7P7g
- https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC0PR1_kRre2rRu7SjeXsF3A
Another one! Added June 22,2021
- https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCIk0_IcQXZ7OqRbRVIccuFw
As a reminder to everyone, reproducing someone else's work in any medium without their permission is plagiarism, and is not only a bannable offence but may also be illegal.
•
u/nelsyv Patron of AI Waifus Jun 20 '21
A Public Service Announcement and FAQ for the uninformed persons brigading this thread:
The fact that it is posted in a public place does not mean that the author has relinquished their rights to the content. Unless they have explicitly stated otherwise, they reserve ALL rights to their content by default, other than those they have (non-exclusively) licensed to Reddit. This means that you are free to read their content here, link to it, but you can not take it and do something with it, any more than you could (legally) do with a blockbuster Disney movie or a professionally published paperback.
This is doubly wrong. In the first place, there are many authors in this community who make money on their writing here, so someone infringing on their copyright is a threat to their income. I'm personally aware of several that don't just do this as a side-hustle, but they stake their entire livelihood on it: it is their full-time job. In their case, it could literally be a threat to their life.
Secondly and perhaps more importantly, even if the author wasn't making money from their writing and never did, it doesn't matter. Their writing is their writing, belonging to them, and unless they explicitly grant permission to someone to reproduce it elsewhere (which, FYI, is a right that most authors here would be happy to grant if asked), nobody has the right to reproduce that work. Both as a matter of copyright law, and as a matter of ethics--they worked hard on that, and they ought to be able to control when and where their work is used if they choose to enforce their rights.
Most of these narration channels are simply taking the text as-is and reading it verbatim. There's not a mote of transformative work involved, nothing new is added to the underlying ideas of the story. In a fanfiction, the writer is at least putting a new spin on existing characters or settings--though even in that case, copyright law is still not squarely in their favor.
Public Domain is a very specific legal status which does not apply to nearly any of the stories on this sub. A work only enters the public domain when the copyright expires (thanks to The Mouse, for newly published work this is effectively never), or when the author explicitly and intentionally severs their rights to the IP and releases the work into the public domain. A work isn't "public domain" just because someone put it out for public viewing.
One of our community members wrote up a great explanation about this here that is better than what I'd come up with on my own, so I'll allow him to explain it. To summarize, for those who don't click through: no, it's not fair use. Copyright fully applies here.
If a person does not enforce their rights when they find out that their copyright has been infringed, it can undermine their legal standing to challenge infrigement later on, should they come across a new infringement they want to prosecute, or even just change their mind about the original perpetrator for whatever reason. With that in mind, it is simply prudent, good sense to clearly enforce their copyright as soon as they can. If an author doesn't mind other people taking their work and doing whatever they want with it, then they should state that, and publish it under a license such as Creative Commons (like SCP does) or MIT (like much open-source software does).
Special thanks to u/sswanlake, u/Glitchkey, and u/AiSagOrSol3-43912 for their informative comments on this post and elsewhere; several of the answers I provided in this comment were strongly inspired by them.
29
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '21
Good thing my writing isn't good or frequent enough to be stolen
199
u/ShneekeyTheLost Jun 20 '21
There was one channel which approached me and asked if he could narrate, to which I gave permission. I was properly and appropriately credited in his video. So that sort of thing I'm fine with.
However, neither of these channels are that fellow. Also, these channels appear to be using extremely popular series such as Billy Bob, Space Trucker and Jenkinsverse. And at least the first linked channel apparently has a Patreon as well that should probably be looked into.
None of my (very few) stories were stolen by either of these channels, so I won't muddle the waters further by hoisting a pitchfork. Perhaps the authors of the infringed works (which are still archived here) could be informed so they may take whatever action they deem fit?
57
u/Lugbor Human Jun 20 '21
Is there a list of channels that are doing narrations with permission from the authors? It’d be a lot easier to report the problem channels if we had a list to compare to.
192
u/ReadByDragonfire Jun 20 '21
Copyright infringement; it's only plagiarism if you pass it off as your own.
Plus, you can be held civilly liable for copyright infringement. Plagiarism is more an academic/ethics issue, not punishable by law (considering it's apparently possible for people to plagiarize themselves, that would be an interesting trial).
50
u/Spartawolf Alien Scum Jun 20 '21
I'm a narrator that asks permission from the authors here. I have publicly denounced the 'Tales of Humanity' channel after their 'apology video' encouraged their fans to target one of the affected authors. I have nothing but respect for my fellow narrators that ask permission and am happy the HFY genre is becoming more well known and popular due to this.
24
u/Nightstone42 Jun 20 '21
DAMN the first one is partly what led me to this subreddit i thought they had permission
23
u/fletch262 AI Jun 20 '21 edited Jun 20 '21
I’m pretty sure NFY is searching for permission for his work as of a long time ago his channel is not currently active though
17
u/PlsHlpMyFriend Jun 20 '21
The channel A Good Bean approached me about my story and has been given permission, so they're all good. Just putting that out there.
32
u/Firebird2771 Jun 20 '21
If they're monetizing your work you should be able to take that from them just like the music industry does otherwise if they are giving you credit I don't think that is really a bad thing because it's getting your content to a wider audience.
But they really should have gotten your permission.
11
u/eddieddi Xeno Jun 20 '21
The worst thing? They changed the names, gave no screen text or refrences. its just a single link in the description. And I know people ignore that.
58
u/Archaic_1 Alien Scum Jun 20 '21
It's not just a harmless use, these channels are monetized and are cashing in on the work of others. Hammer them into oblivion and get these channels taken down. Every dollar they make stealing from our authors is a potential dollar an HFY author won't be able to make in the future if they decide to monetize their own work.
32
u/Thebiscuitdoe Jun 20 '21 edited Jun 20 '21
BTW, please contact the channel before sending a DMCA. It's the nice thing to do and will result in less headache for both party's involved 99% of the time.
Keep in mind that DMCA is a Legal document and that you could get in legal trouble for misusing it, even if accidentally. "I thought I was in the right and using it correctly" or "I thought that was copyright infringement" is not a good legal defense. You may even want to contact a lawyer before submitting one.
16
u/goss_bractor Jun 20 '21
I would care less than I do about this if these were properly narrated, but they are just some monotone american accent which totally does no favours to the written content.
4
u/Quarian013 Jun 20 '21
Damn, I liked TOH, time to leave I guess, though their channel is being deleted so whatever
5
u/Abnegazher Xeno Jun 20 '21
The only one that I watch is the SpartanWolf guy.
Mostly because he is the only one which the voice is annoying.
And he always put the link of the original in the description.
0
u/charis345 Jun 20 '21
I wonder if that fall under fair use ? The narration does add a transformative aspect
-20
u/conser01 Jun 20 '21
I don't think there's too much to worry about.
-27
u/ThatFadedAsian Jun 20 '21 edited Jun 21 '21
----Edit---- 6/21/2021
Sigh, Reddit is so harsh. I finally decide to comment and my account is already negative Karmaed. But whatever I'll stand by it.
I'm not only coming at this from a legal perspective. You're right I admit it that the law is on your side. But, the course of action you're choosing to take is detrimental to yourselves. What I'm saying is get out of your own way.
There's reddit scroller text-to-speech channels with 250,000 views per video, this community has 188k members and 2k active readers. Imagine if every redditer went super serious IP Copyright, on every funny joke or writing prompt they did in any popular post they ever made.
You think Wendy's would be like "Oh don't meme Wendy, she's our Intellectual Property."
---My Original Post--- 6/20/2021
These are just story reader YouTube channels. None of them claim any ownership or authorship over the works. There's readers for all sorts of communities such as the SCP or CreepyPasta readers, etc. No one assumes the reader is the author. If anything they're bringing awareness and new fans to this genre and fiction universe. I discovered this fictional universe from one of those YouTubers. All of them generally post links to the original source for viewers to read along. I'm sure you guys gain tons of views, upvotes, and new fans from channels like these.
Just from my perspective as a fan of CreepyPastas and the SCP universe. The open nature by which the stories are shared is the major metric by which these types of communities and authors gain notoriety and expand their fan base.
The SCP community wouldn't be nearly as large as they are today, nor have the same support and fan base if they were taking this approach.
-24
u/Faolan26 Jun 20 '21
Yah I doubt sending takedown requests will get you anywhere. There are dozens of channels that do nothing but read coments and posts, without asking permission and not linking to origonals that have hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
For instance, sir reddit, best posts and coments, reddit jar, and radio tts, but radio atleast links the post the coments came from.
Tldr, don't post stuff on public forums that you don't want reposted.
-13
u/cornbadger Jun 20 '21
TBF, the only reason that I know that this subculture exists is because of youtube. So, ya know.
-28
u/cyotee Jun 20 '21
Noting which authors are upset to make sure to never support them in the future. Those types of channels are good I found the genre. You posted for free, you have no hope of monetization here. You could have done your own recordings. Instead you'd prefer to shut down a method to enjoy your work.
Oh well, plenty of other authors out there. Hope you never achieve anything.
-12
u/UnQuacker Jun 20 '21
I mean, Tales of humanity always links the source
-96
u/DR-Fluffy Human Jun 20 '21
This site is for retards to post poor fanfiction, and yes I'm one of them. If you care that much about someone "plagiarizing" the work you post on reddit off all places, than maybe you should reevaluate your life.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment