r/asoiaf • • 8h ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) Weekly Q and A

3 Upvotes

Welcome to the Weekly Q & A! Feel free to ask any questions you may have about the world of ASOIAF. No need to be bashful. Book and show questions are welcome; please say in your question if you would prefer to focus on the BOOKS, the SHOW, or BOTH. And if you think you've got an answer to someone's question, feel free to lend them a hand!

Looking for Weekly Q&A posts from the past? Browse our Weekly Q&A archive! (currently no longer being archived, but this link will remain)


r/asoiaf • • 2d ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) Moonboy's Motley Monday

6 Upvotes

As you may know, we have a policy against silly posts/memes/etc. Moonboy's Motley Monday is the grand exception: bring me your memes, your puns, your blatant shitposts.

This is still r/asoiaf, so do keep it as civil as possible.

If you have any clever ideas for weekly themes, shoot them to the modmail!

Looking for Moonboy's Motley Monday posts from the past? Browse our Moonboy's Motley Monday archive! (our old archive is here)


r/asoiaf • • 1h ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) What's the most shocking thing GRRM can do in Winds?

40 Upvotes

Let's not beat a dead Tyrek and say "finish it". I think he said he wouldn't be adding any new POVs, but words are wind etc. and mayhaps a singular chapter is the exception

  1. Ned POV chapter: In a similar way to how the Reek chapter was done, imagine you turn the page and see that the chapter is titled "The Lone Wolf" or something similar. As you're reading you realize this is taking place in a dream or a memory, the character feels lost and confused trying to make sense of things and you immediately think it's Bran, Rickon, or Jon. The imagery gets closer and closer to all the mysteries that surround Lyanna, new pieces of prophecy begin to reveal themselves and by the last page you're hit with the reveal you've been with Ned the entire time somewhere inside the collective consciousness of the Old Gods
  2. Other POV chapter: I think this one would have to be a short chapter as to not reveal too much, but seeing what the world of men full of kings, wargs, and dragon riders from their perspective would recontextualize the impending destruction that threatens Westeros. To them they might see Targaryens as our children of the forest, the way we think of Others might be how they think of dragons
  3. A Song of Ice and Fire: The show makes this one less shocking because of its significance to not have come from GRRM himself, but despite that I think he could do a lot here. If he thinks the story can still benefit from some kind of time skip this would be an "easy" way to do it. The story as we know it is in the past and being retold by someone in the future, either in the form of a dream or written account. Old Nan and her stories are mentioned frequently for a reason which might be relevant if the story is heading towards a cyclical kind of thing

r/asoiaf • • 3h ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) Defending Catelyn shouldn’t lead you to downplaying how she abused Jon Snow (even if it wasn’t physical abuse)

39 Upvotes

Before I get into my point, I wanna make one thing clear, I’m not one of those avid Catelyn haters cuz I’m a Jon Snow fan. She’s one of my favourite characters cuz she’s such a complex character and a mother tormented by the losses of her children and husband throughout a war her son is leading.

I’m well aware that many fans tend to favour 2 extremes regarding opinions about Catelyn, either she’s an evil stepmother straight atta a Disney movie or she’s an innocent saint who can do no wrong. However, this is ASOIAF, she has virtues and flaws like any other character which many, who favour the former, tend to ignore. I’m well aware of that.

But I feel like many who go to defend Catelyn or like her character fall into the latter category when it comes to Jon Snow. I’m not saying you can’t like characters who do bad things, hell go ahead this is ASOIAF, but you’re really not required to justify it.

Catelyn did abuse Jon, it wasn’t physical abuse, but she did abuse him by making a 14 year old KID feel unwanted in a home. Did he have it better than most bastards? Ya course, but that doesn’t mean things were perfect saying things like “he would’ve had it worse elsewhere” is still justifying abuse.

Was Catelyn a victim of the patriarchy and forced to accept her husband’s affair child? Yes definitely, hell i feel bad for her cuz I doubt anyone asked her permission for her betrothal. But that still doesn’t give her the right to take out her anger on a KID instead of her husband.

George himself didn’t see it as abuse cuz his idea of it not being abuse is cuz it wasn’t physical. However, Jon’s own writing confirms it as a form of abuse cuz he was terrified of Catelyn, in one of the lines when he goes to bran’s room he says something like “once that sight would’ve sent him running” and in another line in one of the books he remembers Catelyn’s cold look when thinking about him having winterfell (not sure of this one but it did happen, maybe different context)

I love George’s writing but maybe it’s cuz he’s from another era he doesn’t see that as abuse but it was, that’s not an opinion, it’s a fact.

What I’m trying to say, overall, is that it’s perfectly fine to like Catelyn, to love her character, to love her complexity but you don’t have to justify her every action. A character with flaws can only become more likeable to you if you let them have those flaws

And maybe it’s cuz the concept of having a bad step-parent or feeling unwanted hits home for many that they tend to be the only ones to feel annoyed whenever someone justifies similar treatment.

Again, I want to repeat. Liking a character? Good. Justifying their actions? Not good. Catelyn and Jon are both amazing and well-written characters with their own flaws and virtues. Of course it’s a work of fiction at the end of the day and set in a different time period with its own rules but as a reader, we can’t help but see it through a modern lens at times when it addresses issues common in our time and the medieval era (even if it’s a fantasy one lol).

Edit: Ya Ned deserves more blame, he sent a kid to a glorified penal colony despite him just being a sad drunk 14 year old when he suggested it. Naturally, Catelyn was more than happy to send a 14 year old she hates away but Ned knew the truth. He could’ve sent Jon to howland reed at least, he would’ve been safe there.

Edit 2: This fandom is hell-bent on justifying abuse lmao, is it really that hard to accept ur favs’ flaws instead of dismissing or downplaying it to feel better about urself for liking them? Catelyn did abuse Jon, that’s not an opinion, it’s a fact that too many don’t want to accept.


r/asoiaf • • 4h ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers EXTENDED) Are there any tinfoil theories you choose to believe despite little evidence?

39 Upvotes

For me:

  1. Brandon the Shipwright made it to Asshai.
  2. The Drowned God is actually just the deep one/squisher/merling equivalent to the greenseers, and saved Davos after the Blackwater.
  3. Night’s King was turned into the Black Gate after his fall.

r/asoiaf • • 8h ago

MAIN [Spoilers Main] Can I read book 1 only?

28 Upvotes

There's this course on MIT open course that teaches fantasy writing. The person in charge recommends reading three books before beginning the course, those being a game of thrones, the lord of the rings and the entire Harry Potter series. I read LOTR and the entire Harry Potter series so I'm a bit surprised that only book 1 of game of thrones is a prerequisite.

I don't want to commit to a whole series but I have got some stories of my own to write. So will I be fine with just book 1? I don't mind spoilers, I frequently watch GoT theories.


r/asoiaf • • 2h ago

PUBLISHED [Spoilers Published] Losing your castle in Westeros also means losing something we rarely think about: your address

7 Upvotes

Something occurred to me while thinking about how ravens work in the books.

Westeros has an incredibly efficient communication system, provided you're an important person who stays in one place.

A maester can send a message across enormous distances. Lords can coordinate marriages, wars, inheritances, and political schemes without ever leaving their castles.

But ravens are generally trained to fly to particular locations. They're not going to find Robb Stark just because somebody writes "Robb Stark, somewhere in the Westerlands" on a piece of parchment.

And I think that has some interesting consequences for the story.

Consider what happens when Winterfell is taken and burned.

The Starks don't just lose their ancestral seat. They lose the place where messages for House Stark would ordinarily arrive, be received by a trusted household, and get passed along to the appropriate people.

Anyone trying to contact a surviving Stark now has to figure out where that person is, who might be able to reach them, and whether the message will pass through friendly hands.

Even a lord commanding an army has this problem to some degree. He can carry ravens trained to return to particular castles, but receiving replies while constantly moving is a different matter.

Which makes the distinction between powerful people with established households and powerful people who are displaced much more significant than I initially realized.

It's also worth thinking about the people who control the system.

A maester isn't just a scholar or physician. He's effectively responsible for maintaining one of the most important lines of communication available to a noble household.

If the lord dies, the castle changes hands, or the maester's loyalty becomes questionable, the people depending on that communication network have a serious problem.

I'm not suggesting there's some grand maester conspiracy here. It's just a practical vulnerability built into how the system works.

And it's particularly interesting in a series where so many characters spend years traveling, hiding, fighting, or trying to find people whose whereabouts are uncertain.

Brienne's search for Sansa, for example, would be a fundamentally different undertaking if ordinary people could reliably send messages directly to individuals rather than locations.

Obviously messengers, merchants, and travelers can carry information too. Ravens aren't the only option.

But it makes me wonder how much political power in Westeros depends on something as mundane as having a permanent, functioning household where people know they can reach you.

A castle isn't just somewhere a lord lives. It's also where the rest of the realm knows how to find him.

I'm curious whether there are examples in the books where a character's inability to receive information is as consequential as the information itself.


r/asoiaf • • 2h ago

EXTENDED When the Onion Knight WON'T Return (spoilers extended)

7 Upvotes

Most fans would agree that Davos will return from Skagos. Whether he'll return with Rickon with Skagosi & unicorns might be up for debate. Of course there is the question of when they return. I have seen the idea that they'll return during the Battle of Ice, turning the tide against the Boltons/Freys. While a cool idea I don't think it'll happen. I just don't see GRRM not having a chapter take place entirely on Skagos & given how he has said that the Battles of Ice/Fire will open Winds that rules out a last-minute calvary save from the Skagosi or the prodigal return of Rickon. So, should Davos return with Rickon & unicorn riding Skagosi it likely won't be during the Battle of Ice.


r/asoiaf • • 21h ago

MAIN (Spoiler‘s Main) Genna Lannister marriage Spoiler

Post image
142 Upvotes

I know Tytos was pretty weak minded and always tried to be a people’s pleasure but HOW did Walder Frey managed to convince the Tytos to marry off his ONLY daughter to one of his sons ?!?! Like, I don’t even think the guy was even the heir of the Twins at the time.

This is always baffled me. The fact that Genna was promised to one of Walder’s sons when she herself was a child is even weirder to me, (not because of the age because pre marriage betrothals at a young age were obviously normal back then) because I don’t think there was an urgency from Tytos side to have her get married to one of Walder’s sons. Especially because I think it was stated that a lot of Westermen nobles were obviously pissed as they intended Genna to marry one of their sons.

Other than that, which known male character could she have married if it wasn’t for the one she eventually ended up with ?


r/asoiaf • • 16h ago

MAIN [Spoiler Main] The characters from ASOIAF meet their TV counterparts. Who would be the best of friends, and who would be the worst of enemies?

57 Upvotes

r/asoiaf • • 54m ago

EXTENDED What is the worst thing your favorite character has done ? ( spoilers extended ) Spoiler

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/asoiaf • • 13h ago

MAIN [Spoilers Main] Is there a reason people think the battle for the Iron Throne will happen after the Long Night?

24 Upvotes

I see a number of people saying this and is there any reason for it besides the fact that that was the order in the show?

The reason this doesn't make sense is that I think the entire point is that the Iron Throne and the grand political intrigue and all that is a distraction. It's meant to be ironic how everyone in Westeros cares so much about who sits on a chair and not the real threat of a literal apocalypse. The way I see it the REAL conflict of the story was always the Long Night and the fight against the Others. So I think spending probably half a book about who sits on a chair after saving the world feels kinda anticlimactic and again it doesn't fit. I mean this is a fantasy series after all

I don't know this maybe because the show's execution of this was so bad I want it to happen the other way around but still I think it'd feel a bit odd for everyone to defeat the Others thers and then they go "Okay time to go fight Young Griff" or whoever


r/asoiaf • • 21h ago

MAIN In generations with large numbers of Targs running around, do younger kids get any inheritance? (Spoilers main)

45 Upvotes

since there’s a distinct lack of in between titles for lower ranked Royals. I know there’s Summerhall but that’s just one castle and it’s largely a family vacation house, but for example, where would Egg live and what would he get if all his uncles, cousins, brothers all lived to a ripe old age? would he just be a guest forever at his uncle, cousins or brothers house?? or his wife’s male relative’s house?


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

EXTENDED [Spoilers Extended] How's Rickon going to end up?

53 Upvotes

Attention: If any of you so much as whisper the zig-zag stuff, I'm gonna lose it!

He's literally the "last man standing" of House Stark. It would be pretty shitty of GRRM to keep that traumatized little boy around only to whack him in the most unceremonious manner. Call it wishful thinking, but I would be absolutely shattered if Rickon doesn't make it. All the honor of Ned Stark can't mean that his line doesn't survive by the male line.

Rickon has to be the vengeful, ruthless Stark King of old. He has been chased away from his home, his parents are murdered, his eldest brother is murdered, his other brother has been crippled, and his sisters have been subjected to countless hardships and trauma same as him! Any ending that doesn't have Sansa ruling as Rickon's regent and Rickon growing up a bold and fierce warrior that will rule as the King of Winter doesn't have any merit in my opinion.


r/asoiaf • • 23h ago

EXTENDED [Spoilers Extended] What characters that died in game of thrones that you think would’ve survived the whole series and vice-versa?

24 Upvotes

“One thing I can say,  in general enough terms that I will not be spoiling anything:  not all of the characters who survived until the end of GAME OF THRONES will survive until the end of A SONG OF ICE & FIRE, and not all of the characters who died on GAME OF THRONES will die in A SONG OF ICE & FIRE.” That’s from George’s winter garden post a few years back, so who do you think fits the bill?


r/asoiaf • • 6h ago

MAIN (Spoiler main ) I’ve read the game of thrones and dunk and egg novels, don’t wanna read Targaryen books right now anything else to read ?

1 Upvotes

r/asoiaf • • 22h ago

MAIN [Spoilers Main] What was Dorne's revenge plan?

12 Upvotes

There is a definite answer to this: Dorne had no revenge plan or preparations whatsoever. They simply waited for the pieces to fall into place.

While reading the Dorne POVs, especially with Doran Martell, it is implied that he has a reason to remain patient and that he is actually planning some grand revenge scheme. However, if we look at the overall flow of the story, that does not really seem to be the case.

We know Oberyn arranged a betrothal pact between Viserys and Arianne, meaning they planned to place Viserys on the throne. The problem is that while Viserys and his sister spent years living as fugitives across the Free Cities, the Martells did absolutely nothing. They never truly prepared the man they considered a claimant for kingship. As a result, Viserys became another madman like his father. Even if Dorne had raised its banners for him, it would have been difficult for him to gain support. Joffrey being similarly cruel balanced the scales somewhat, but the lords of Westeros would still prefer the madman they know over the madman they do not.

The other problem is the Dothraki issue. By marrying Daenerys to Khal Drogo, they hoped to secure a Dothraki alliance. I do not know whether the Martells were involved in this plan, but even if they were, it was foolish at best. Bringing a Dothraki army to Westeros would turn the Targaryens into a symbol of hatred in the eyes of both the nobility and the common people. Yes, wars are cruel, but the looting and slavery practiced by the Dothraki make even the Lannister armies look merciful. More than half of the houses considering support for the Targaryens would immediately turn against them.

Then there is the possibility of fAegon. Perhaps Dorne knew from the very beginning that Elia’s son was alive (!), and their true investment was always in him? But that does not seem to be the case either. We know Arianne went to Storm’s End specifically to meet fAegon and confirm whether he was truly her relative. In addition, Doran Martell sent his own son to Daenerys to arrange a marriage alliance and promised her the crown of Westeros. If he already knew about fAegon’s existence, would he really have made such a move?

Looking at everything that happened, it feels as though there was never truly a long-term plan behind Dorne’s wait for revenge. Doran Martell seems to act entirely according to circumstance and prefers waiting for the pieces to fall into place on their own. Otherwise, he would have taken advantage of the War of the Five Kings to strike back at the Lannisters. If the Starks had defeated the Lannisters and executed Tywin, then it would have been the North, not Dorne, that avenged Elia Martell. That would have been deeply humiliating for Dorne. Yet they still sat in the corner and waited. What exactly were they waiting for, and for whom? They had no hidden claimant prepared in secret, Viserys was dead, they seemed unaware of fAegon’s existence, and Daenerys had rejected their alliance proposals.


r/asoiaf • • 21h ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) Your thoughts about young griffin? Spoiler

Post image
11 Upvotes

I'm reading ADWD right now, and this is what I think about him.

He's really Aegon Targeryan, and the heir to the iron throne, here's why:

1° Varys' schemes are for stability, He's the opposite of little finger, who works with chaos. I think varys knew how bad of a king Robert would be, and tried to save Aegon to raise him as a perfect and easy manipulated king for his plots.

2° Connington was loyal to the throne, so we would raise aegon in secret.

3° the golden company would support and protect a true targaryan king because they would like to return to westereos.

4° a puppet king of varys would be great for Morpatis, who hidden Aegon from viserys because he feared that viserys would try to take aegon for himself or consider him as a threat to his own claim. I also belive that Morpatis made the marriage between Daenerys and Drogo because he thought that the Dothraki would kill them both due to the difficult life, and them, make the path clear to Aegon.

5° I don't think Young Griffin is a blackyfire, neither a normal valyran boy, because if any information leaked, the claim to the throne would be weakened, so, civil war

7° for varys, a puppet and legitimate targaryan king would be better for the realm than a bunch of crazy lannisters


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago Bravo

EXTENDED Player Number Two: Kevan Lannister (Spoilers Extended)

43 Upvotes

Background

One thing I love about the ASOIAF is the shades of gray of the character's morality. Almost every single adult and even most the of children make some morally questionable decisions at times. One of those characters is Kevan Lannister ("They will burn, my lord") who exists mostly in Tywin's shadow. In this post I thought it would be interesting to explore that older brother/younger brother relationship dynamic here a bit.

Introduction to Kevan

We meet Kevan in AGoT, as Tyrion arrives for the Battle on the Green Fork to the Lannister camp:

Ser Kevan Lannister, his father's only surviving brother, was sharing a flagon of ale with Lord Tywin when Tyrion entered the common room. His uncle was portly and balding, with a close-cropped yellow beard that followed the line of his massive jaw. -AGOT, Tyrion VII

and a few chapters later we get Kevan's infamous line:

"Let them," Lord Tywin said. "Unleash Ser Gregor and send him before us with his reavers. Send forth Vargo Hoat and his freeriders as well, and Ser Amory Lorch. Each is to have three hundred horse. Tell them I want to see the riverlands afire from the Gods Eye to the Red Fork."
"They will burn, my lord," Ser Kevan said, rising. "I shall give the commands." He bowed and made for the door. -AGoT, Tyrion IX

Tywin's Vanguard in War Councils

Kevan tends to speak Tywin's thoughts in meetings:

Ser Kevan leaned forward. "We had a thought to put you and your wildlings in the vanguard when we come to battle."
Ser Kevan seldom "had a thought" that Lord Tywin had not had first.  -AGOT, Tyrion VIII

and:

"We have no lack of foes," said Ser Kevan Lannister. "If the Eyrie can be kept out of the war, all to the good. I am of a mind to see what Lord Petyr can accomplish."
Ser Kevan was his brother's vanguard in council, Tyrion knew from long experience; he never had a thought that Lord Tywin had not had first. It has all been settled beforehand, he concluded, and this discussion's no more than show. -ASOS, Tyrion III

The Other Siblings

While Kevan is Tywin's "player two", his other siblings seemed to have went their own way:

Yet despite these accomplishments, Tywin Lannister was little loved. His rivals charged that he was humorless, unforgiving, unbending, proud, and cruel. His lords bannermen respected him and followed him loyally in war and peace, but none could truly be named his friends. Tywin despised his father, the weak-willed, fat, and ineffectual Lord Tytos Lannister, and his relations with his brothers Tygett and Gerion were notoriously stormy. He showed more regard for his brother Kevan, a close confidant and constant companion since childhood, and his sister Genna, but yet even in those cases, Tywin Lannister appeared more dutiful than affectionate. -TWOIAF, The Targaryen Kings: Aerys II

and:

It has been hard for Kevan, living all his life in Tywin's shadow. It was hard for all my brothers. That shadow Tywin cast was long and black, and each of them had to struggle to find a little sun. Tygett tried to be his own man, but he could never match your father, and that just made him angrier as the years went by. Gerion made japes. Better to mock the game than to play and lose. But Kevan saw how things stood early on, so he made himself a place by your father's side." -AFFC, Jaime V

Tertiary Lannister posts:

Tywin's Right Hand

Even with Tywin's "love" more about duty than affection (as mentioned above), Kevan seems to have been able to be relied on:

But I would have thought you on your way to Darry by now, to take up your lordship." Her father had made Lancel a lord after the Battle of the Blackwater, as a sop to his brother Kevan. -AFFC, Cersei II

and:

“I hold no lands, that is true. But I have certain incomes, and chests of coin set aside. My own father forgot none of his children when he died, and Tywin knew how to reward good service. I feed two hundred knights and can double that number if need be. There are freeriders who will follow my banner, and I have the gold to hire sellswords. You would be wise not to take me lightly, Your Grace … and wiser still not to make of me a foe.” -AFFC, Cersei II

and:

"Why does a man with one pot of gold need another? Men are greedy. Tywin should have granted Riverrun to Kevan and Darry to Emm. I would have told him so if he had troubled to ask me, but when did your father ever consult with anyone but Kevan?" She sighed deeply. "I do not blame Kevan for wanting the safer seat for his own boy, mind you. I know him too well." -AFFC, Jaime V

and:

"Ser Kevan refused the office."
"So he said. He did not say why. There was much he did not say. Would not say." Lady Genna made a face. "Kevan always did what was asked of him. It is not like him to turn away from any duty. Something is awry here, I can smell it.".

Sharing Death

It is well discussed how Varys not only things Kevan as a good man:

This pains me, my lord. You do not deserve to die alone on such a cold dark night. There are many like you, good men in service to bad causes … 

and also how Kevan/Tywin die the same way:

"I thought the crossbow fitting. You shared so much with Lord Tywin, why not that? 

but another part of the Epilogue sticks out and that is when Kevan is dying, Tywin is one of the people he tries to cry out for:

Kevan Lannister tried to cry out … to his guards, his wife, his brother … but the words would not come. Blood dribbled from his mouth. He shuddered violently. -ADWD, Epilogue

Other Kevan Posts

TLDR: A post with no real point other than some quotes regarding Kevan being Tywin's little brother and how that dynamic factored into the series.


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

EXTENDED [Spoilers Extended] What's the deal with Lady Barbery Dustin?

81 Upvotes

So, I know what most of you are gonna say, Grand Northern Conspiracy. But, there are still others in this sub who keep mentioning Lady Dustin's hatred for the Starks along with the Boltons as the two principal Northern Houses that are against the Starks.

Now let's try to understand, the only beef you have with the Starks is that it's former lord who was a war hero, liberated Westeros from the tyranny of the mad king, and ruled justly for 17 years before being murdered under the obvious falsehood of treason, - didn't bring back your martyred husband's bones and buried him honorably in the Red Mountains of Dorne, and only returned his magnificent horse. Also, that his elder brother took your maidenhead (consensually), and didn't marry you.

On the other hand, the ill-begotten bastard seed of your dead sister's husband murdered your beloved nephew (that you clearly share blood with) to steal his inheritance, and then committed countless atrocities against the North by marrying a respected old widow at sword point, locked her in a tower and left her to eat her fingers, not to mention the countless other girls and women he raped, hunted in the woods, flayed, tortured, etc. If this wasn't enough, his father murdered your rightful king who brought glory to the North by defeating the hated Lannister forces in every battle he fought, when that king was coming back North to liberate his people from the iron-born invasion.

And Lady Dustin keeps a grudge against the Starks, instead of the Boltons? I know some of you will say that it's been made clear that she hates Ramsay, but c'mon, she ought to be nuts to even think about supporting the Boltons, right? So, she has to be actively plotting against the Boltons, and people on this sub shouldn't even consider that she is genuinely supportive of them.


r/asoiaf • • 19h ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) ASOIAF characters - if they can glimpse the future… will they make a different choice?

0 Upvotes

Let’s see if a character is about to make a decision and then suddenly they get to see how their decision played out including its consequences, positive or negative.

So which character in A Song of Ice and Fire will try to make a different decision and who will stay the same? And they can only see the consequence of their original choice.

So none of these characters would make a different choice if they saw the consequences of their actions?

Examples:

Go with Eddard Stark. If he saw what his choices from telling Cersei Lannister that he know what he know? Would he make a different choice? Likely. I don’t think he’ll tell the king because he doesn’t want innocent children to be hurt (and I mean Tommen and Myrcella) except maybe Joffrey.

What about Catelyn if she got a vision of what gonna happens if she take Tyrion? Does she go through with it but be smarter OR does she just quietly let him go?

And let go backward to the past? Lyanna and Rhaegar? If they could see the consequence of their actions? Would they back down or find a smarter way to be together? What if the timeline their on is the only one where dragons returned OR the world is saved from the upcoming white threat? Do they stick with their original road or forge a different path?

What about Rhaenrya? If she knew the fates that awaits her sons on their diplomatic mission? Woudl they make a different choice?


r/asoiaf • • 10h ago

MAIN [Spoilers MAIN] History, ASOIAF and why its beautiful that we will never get TWOW

0 Upvotes

Okay, hear me out.

One of my favorite features of ASOIAF is the historical inspiration. The history loosely being based on the war of the roses, the history of westeros is basically english history, red wedding is inspired by scottish history, Jon Snow is kind of Julius Caesar, Valyria might be rome and so on.

I always thought that gave the story a lot of texture and an actual backbone. But as I started studying history I noticed a lot of aspects that I havent notices before.

  • Especially that what we are reading feels like historical sources.

    • Our interpretation of what is happening is dependet on the characters perspectives. If we want to fully understand the plot, we need to take into account who that person is, where they came from, what their interest are and so on.
    • Fire and blood is literally narrated by a historian. Haven't read it myself, but I always think its kind of funny when people try to explain away inconsistencies, when the reason might simply be Gyldayn did a mistake (which, if inteded by george, is a genius move).
    • Many events are only known to us through second-hand accounts, so their is always the possibility of unreliable sources.
    • (This also would also partially explain, why AKOTSK feels so different, because it breaks that mould)
  • The fantasy elements work great with this too. History is full of "fantasy", i.e. events and persons that are simply mystical, stuff like the conversion of constantine the great (or stannis), the dancing plague, tons of stories about saints and their miracles, the success of figures like Joan d'Arc. Was there a higher power involved? Is it the work of imaginative historians? Facts and fiction cannot really be seperated anymore.
  • The asoiaf community adds a whole other layer.

    • We try to use this "history" to anticipate what is going to happen in the future.
    • discussions on this subreddit are sometimes eerily similar to r/UKmonarchs.
    • r/HOTDBlacks and r/HOTDGreens feels like listening to a turk and and a greek talking about history.
    • There are even discussions around alternative history. "What if XY survived?" "What if YX did do sth else?"

Anyway, I think this gives the world of ASOIAF a realistic quality I havent seen in other places. And it made me think about the unfinished ending and how there is a certain beauty to it.

As much as we look into the past, we will not find the answers we want to have. The past, as well as the future lay in the dark. There will never be a clear answer to what really transpired at Summerhall. We will/might never know if the Starks will rise again. In the end, the past and the future is unknowable. And that is essentially what we all have to deal with in real life. We have to accept the uncertainty of tomorrow and that yesterday is already disappearing into the mist.

But whatever, this might just be cope 2.0.


r/asoiaf • • 2d ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) Something I've never considered about the Seastar's dark magic

106 Upvotes

Have you ever noticed how young Shiera is when Egg says she baths in virgin blood to keep her youthful beauty? When Egg and Dunk have that conversation, she's somewhere between 26-32 years old. That's like season 3 Emilia Clarke young..

Small detail i know but for some reason, I always thought those rumors would have atleast began when Shiera was around 40 (or older). But most hot and rich people are still gonna look young before they're even 30. Especially if they avoid having kids and live the luxurious lifestyle of nobility.


r/asoiaf • • 2d ago

MAIN (Spoiler’s Main) Siege of Storm’s End

103 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about something that’s both remarkable and, honestly, incredibly heartbreaking. The fact that Renly didn’t just survive the year-long siege of Storm’s End as a CHILD (!), but that Stannis was probably the main reason he made it through in the first place. Starving and barely hanging on for dear life, Stannis most likely gave his little brother whatever scraps of food they managed to get their hands on before eating anything himself.

What the two of them went through together makes it so much more understandable why, despite everything that happened between them, they still looked back somewhat nostalgically on the good times they shared. It makes their story all the more tragic.

And I don’t care how you look at it, I understand the traditions surrounding the line of succession and all that, but Robert should have simply given Storm’s End to Stannis. Renly should either have stayed with Stannis in the Stormlands or, if anything, gone to live with Robert in King’s Landing. The guy only ever cared for throwing lavish feasts anyway. He could’ve done that in King’s Landing with Robert.