This is my first post on Reddit, and I could really use some help from the community on how to handle this situation. Any advice or guidance would be greatly appreciated.
Amazon sold me a defective $1,112 computer. A week later, I still cannot obtain a replacement or initiate a refund.
I purchased a Beelink SER8 for my home office. The computer developed an abnormal jet-engine-like cooling-fan sound almost immediately (4 hours).
Amazon customer service explicitly offered me a full refund without requiring a return. I accepted.
That decision was reversed.
Amazon subsequently created a free replacement order, marked my original order as “Replacement complete” and “No need to send the item back,” then cancelled the replacement.
Now my Amazon account says the return has already been processed, preventing me from initiating another return or refund.
After nearly a week of correspondence with Amazon.ca Executive Customer Relations, I'm being told to return the computer and potentially wait up to 30 days for processing, yet I still haven't received the promised prepaid return label. They keep issuing decisions without providing any practical way to carry them out. Every time I follow up, a different representative responds, politely asking for another 24–48 hours to review the same case.
What makes this particularly frustrating is that I could have selected another listing sold by Amazon Canada, where a replacement would have been straightforward. Instead, I unknowingly purchased an Amazon US-sold item through the same Amazon.ca app, paid in Canadian dollars, and had it delivered to my Canadian address. Even customer-service representatives initially offered solutions before discovering the Amazon US seller limitation and reversing them.
I had no idea that purchasing an Amazon US-sold item through Amazon.ca could result in such a different customer-service experience.
I have screenshots documenting the promises, cancelled replacement and contradictory order statuses.
Has anyone experienced something similar with Amazon.ca or Amazon US? How did you get it resolved? I'd genuinely appreciate any suggestions.