r/ancientrome • • Jul 11 '26

“Sources only” post flair

40 Upvotes

We’ve made a new flair that we encourage users to make use of. Comments on posts that are tagged with “Sources only” must include a source in their comments. This is to help keep our discussion informative and accurate. It is not mandatory to use but we encourage anyone with a question about Roman history to please use it.

Discussed on this post

https://www.reddit.com/r/ancientrome/s/9K69OHDawM


r/ancientrome • • Jul 12 '24

New rule: No posts about modern politics or culture wars

486 Upvotes

[edit] many thanks for the insight of u/SirKorgor which has resulted in a refinement of the wording of the rule. ("21st Century politics or culture wars").


Ive noticed recently a bit of an uptick of posts wanting to talk about this and that these posts tend to be downvoted, indicating people are less keen on them.

I feel like the sub is a place where we do not have to deal with modern culture, in the context that we do actually have to deal with it just about everywhere else.

For people that like those sort of discussions there are other subs that offer opportunities.

If you feel this is an egregious misstep feel free to air your concerns below. I wont promise to change anything but at least you will have had a chance to vent :)


r/ancientrome • • 10h ago

Further evidence of the Romans’ advanced supra-regional mapping — Discrete distances between the known camps in Germania Magna in the last phase prior to Tiberius' withdrawal following Augustus’ death

Post image
41 Upvotes

This map shows all known Roman camps east of the Rhine from the final phase of the occupation prior to the defeat in 9 CE and the final withdrawal in 16 CE.

The Roman transport hub at Vervins (Verbinum) and the camp on the Kops Plateau in Nijmegen (Noviomagus Batavorum) also date from this phase.

In Bonn (Bonna), also on the left bank of the Rhine, a detachment of exploratores is thought to have been stationed during the Augustan period, before a legionary camp was later established there following the consolidation of the Rhine frontier.

As it fits within the chronological context, the battlefield at Kalkriese ("Teutoburg forest") is also included.

---

Anyone who would like to contribute to this fascinating topic is very welcome here:

https://forum.archaeologie.online/t/neue-belege-fuer-fortgeschrittene-roemische-vermessungstechniken-um-die-zeitenwende/17785/56?u=geognost


r/ancientrome • • 21h ago

The “Marius” and “Sulla” Busts: Two Roman Rivals, or Perhaps the Same Man?

Thumbnail
gallery
183 Upvotes

I've been looking closely at two Roman portrait busts traditionally associated with Gaius Marius and Lucius Cornelius Sulla, and I find their identification - and especially their striking resemblance - fascinating.

The so-called Marius bust, now in the Munich Glyptothek, is traditionally identified as Gaius Marius. However, this identification is not universally accepted. There are also other portrait busts attributed to Marius, and their facial features look noticeably different from those of the Munich bust. This raises an important question: how reliable are these traditional identifications in the first place? There have also been alternative proposals, including Filippo Coarelli's suggestion that the Munich bust could represent Lucius Cornelius Scipio Asiaticus.

The other bust, commonly referred to as Sulla, is equally controversial. In his 2003 study Bildnisse des Lucius Cornelius Sulla Felix, archaeologist Volker Michael Strocka challenges this identification. Among his arguments are the hairstyle, the absence of the characteristic receding temples associated with Sulla's proposed portrait type, and stylistic considerations. He also points out that the head cannot be securely connected to other known replicas.

But here's what really caught my attention: the two faces look remarkably alike.

Could this resemblance be more than coincidence?

One possibility is that both busts represent the same individual at different stages of life. Another possibility is that they really do depict two different people - perhaps Marius and Sulla - whose facial features happened to be similar.

And even if both sculptures represent Sulla, their differences would not necessarily rule that out. They could have been created by different sculptors, working in different artistic traditions, with different interpretations of the same person's appearance. Roman portraiture was not always about producing identical, standardized representations.

Of course, facial resemblance alone cannot establish an identification. We would need to consider archaeological context, provenance, chronology, stylistic features, and comparisons with other securely identified portraits.

There is also an important distinction between the different sculptures historically called “Sulla”: the so-called Sulla Barberini, now in Copenhagen, and the separate bust in Munich that Strocka rejects as a portrait of Sulla. These should not be confused.

I'd like to hear some thoughts:

  1. Do you find the traditional identification of the Munich bust as Marius convincing, especially considering the other portraits attributed to him?
  2. Is the resemblance between the two busts significant, or am I seeing something that isn't really there?
  3. Could both portraits conceivably represent the same historical figure at different ages?
  4. If both are portraits of Sulla, could their differences simply reflect two different sculptors and artistic interpretations?
  5. What do you think is the strongest evidence for identifying either bust?

I'm particularly interested in opinions based on Roman portraiture, archaeology, and art history - not just visual resemblance.


r/ancientrome • • 8h ago

The Ghosts of Vergil: Lost Epics of the 600s

11 Upvotes

I published my latest essay about late antiquity today. Here are some snippets:

From the Introduction

There are four places in that century where you might expect a secular epic poem in Latin to be written: France, Italy, England, and Spain. But, apparently, no such poem survives. In this essay, I want to explore each country separately, because on a first perusal, it seems unlikely that any single one of these regions produced a secular epic poem in this century, but, if you take them together, I think it’s probable that at least one of them did.

From the France section

According to the scholar Hildegar of Meaux, who lived in the 800s, the Merovingians did produce a poem of the kind I’m seeking: The Farolied. ... I’ve versified the surviving lines in English. They go like this:

This song is of Clothar, the King of the Franks,
Who battled the fierce Saxon race.
How grievously would it have gone for their envoys,
If Faro had not shown them grace!
For envoys of Saxony, passing through France,
When Faro was noble of rank,
By heaven’s assistance departed the city,
Unharmed by the king of the Franks.

From the Italy section

Italy’s Lombard and Byzantine leaders also commissioned some poetry. One example is...a poem written for display on the sepulcher of a Byzantine general named Drocton. That poem will be discussed shortly and given in full.

From the England section

One might wonder if a suitable poem was written in England and was just lost, but sadly, unlike in France and Italy, we have a definitive reason to infer that, in England, there are no lost ones of the right kind. Here’s why.

From the Spain section

Count Bulgar of Septimania was a secular figure who once wrote to a bishop about a financial dispute and used a Vergilian simile to demand restitution: “Just as a debtor might cast aside all human shame, and, out of sheer impudence, attack his lender with arrogant objections, while the timid lender, who has truth on his side, overlooks what the false accuser ought to blush deeply for saying, even so there remains to…King Gundemar…no small claim, for you must repay a great sum of money.” (Letters to a Frankish Bishop – Epistola 3)

Here is the full text, I hope you enjoy it!

https://venatoverba.xyz/2026/11/19/the-ghosts-of-vergil.html


r/ancientrome • • 17h ago

Did Emperor Augustus allow criticism, disagrement or making fun of him in public during his rule?

50 Upvotes

r/ancientrome • • 1d ago

Colosseum of Rome

Post image
631 Upvotes

r/ancientrome • • 21h ago

If Crassus never went to Parthia then would the civil war between Caesar and Pompey still have happened?

42 Upvotes

Hi if Crassus never went to Parthia then would the civil war between Caesar and Pompey still have happened?


r/ancientrome • • 1d ago

Did "bad" emperors like Commodus, Nero or Elagabalus actually hurt the empire in ways other than causing political instability?

38 Upvotes

They all failed to be accepted by the elites or the military, which caused them to be assassinated, which is obviously bad for the empire.

But were they actually bad rulers in the sense that they impoverished their subjects, lost territory, damaged the economy, weakened the military or caused long-term structural damage?

From all the "Roman emperors ranked" posts and videos in which these 3 all get trashed, I would have expected them to have done something like these things. But it seems like Elagabal's biggest crime for example was just breaking Roman cultural norms. And Commodus biggest crime was that he made the senate hate him.

Which is definitely not smart, but not something we would judge modern rulers by.


r/ancientrome • • 1d ago

Roman mosaic depicting the Triumph of Neptune surrounded by various Nereids riding marine monsters & Sirens in the Bardo Museum

Post image
209 Upvotes

Me in front of a huge Roman mosaic depicting the Triumph of Neptune surrounded by various Nereids riding marine monsters and Sirens. It dates to the late 2nd century AD, was found in Sousse and is on display in the Bardo Museum in Tunis, Tunisia.


r/ancientrome • • 2d ago

Historians' opinion needed..

Thumbnail
gallery
367 Upvotes
  1. HBO has done a wonderful job on "Rome" of course, we got to love the show not only for presenting such an exciting period, but also for the attention to detail.

My question however concerns the central figure himself, in particular - Caesar's armour. Was Caesar's armour presented well in terms of being period-correct, and close to something a general of his period would use? In terms of fabric, style etc? We mainly see him in his leather lorica musculata.

  1. Can we theorize what a general like him would have worn in terms of clothes and armour? We can keep in mind this information about him:

  2. He was vain - proud of his mythical divine Alba Longa descendance and him being a capable individual in general. Personal pride would often affect what you wear

  3. He valued and enjoyed luxury. No surprise if he sought finest of the finest

  4. Was conscious about his appearance - to the point of manually plucking out individual hair on his body. He would probably would like to appear a certain way in his armour (heoric/muscular/lean etc)

  5. He played a perfect Roman of senatorial birth. Would often question societal norms, but undeniably saw himself as a Roman general within the Roman system, followed the army norms

  6. Superb horse-rider. In general valued speed and maneuverability above all

  7. He could dress effeminately as a young man, and went as far as promoting it to his peers

  8. Fought in the front lines if the situation required it

  9. Did not drown in Nile, while presumably fully armoured, and reportedly swam one-handed holding his CDBG papers above his head to not let them get wet. So what the hell was he wearing? What armour can be so light?


r/ancientrome • • 2d ago

Possibly Innaccurate La República hubiera mantenido viva a Roma?

Post image
78 Upvotes

La República romana hubiera alargado la vida de la civilización romana o la hubiera acortado?

Debate


r/ancientrome • • 2d ago

Quien fue peor para Roma ?

Thumbnail
gallery
34 Upvotes

Atila conocido como el Azote de Dios o Aníbal Barca, el hombre que cruzó los Alpes y atacó a Roma en su corazón.

Que enemigo de estos dos fue peor para Roma ?


r/ancientrome • • 2d ago

Vespasian was born 17th November 9AD.

Post image
167 Upvotes

Emperor 69-79AD. He was considered a good emperor and reformed the financial system under his rule. The campaign in Judea was successful. He was succeeded by his natural son Titus the first natural born son to succeed as emperor.


r/ancientrome • • 2d ago

Were there other 'Agrippas'?

115 Upvotes

Agrippa is known to be extremely competent and loyal. Never tried to go for the throne. Just a ride or die dude. Anyone else that fits that mold?


r/ancientrome • • 2d ago

How did the Eastern Roman Empire react to the fall of the West?

59 Upvotes

The fall of the Western Roman Empire was a monumental event in European history, but how did the people living in the Byzantine Empire feel about it? Did the mourn the fall of Rome? Were they scared? Or were they apathetic? I do know they occupied parts of what used to be the Western Empire for a time, including Rome itself, so some saw it as an opportuinity to gain land.


r/ancientrome • • 2d ago

What are the best illustrated history books about Rome?

5 Upvotes

I'm searching for colorful illustrated history books about ancient Rome. I don't mean just images of Roman art but 2D or 3D images made to explain history. It can be anything from roman cities, military, daily life etc. The more illustrations the better. Anyone have some good recommendations?


r/ancientrome • • 3d ago

New Roman Scotland Exhibition

Thumbnail
gallery
367 Upvotes

I went to see the new Roman Scotland - Life At The Edge Of Empire exhibition at the National Museum of Scotland in Edinburgh today. A fantastic collection of artifacts, mostly found in Scotland that tells the story of how Caledonia fit (and didn't fit) into the Empire. It's on until 18th April 2027.


r/ancientrome • • 2d ago

Trying to figure out what to read next, help!

9 Upvotes

I’m between SPQR, Storm Before the Storm, or Caesar: Life of a Colossus.

Also, if you have others, please recommend them! I’m sort of new to the world of Roman History.


r/ancientrome • • 3d ago

Do we know of any Latin profanities that would most likely used in such situations?

Post image
247 Upvotes

r/ancientrome • • 1d ago

Why did the Romans do Vercingetorix so dirty?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ancientrome • • 3d ago

A section of a Roman mosaic depicting the hours from the Archaeological Museum of Thessaloniki in Thessaloniki, Greece

Thumbnail
gallery
134 Upvotes

A section of a Roman mosaic "from the floor of a triklinion of a house found at the junction of Egnatia and Antigonidon streets. It probably depicts the Hours (one has been destroyed). The depiction of personifications relating to the cycle of time in the mosaics of wealthy houses was related to the prosperity of its owners and the abundance of their goods.

The placement of this mosaic at the guests' point of entry to the triklinion enhances the symbolism.

250-300 A.D." Per the Archaeological Museum of Thessaloniki in Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece where this is on display.


r/ancientrome • • 3d ago

Polyphemus, The Ten Maidens

Thumbnail
gallery
133 Upvotes

Villa Romana del Casale

Edit: maidens got cut off so only 8 maidens


r/ancientrome • • 2d ago

Roman Empire; Octavian

0 Upvotes

Hi...u got any recommendations? I'm looking for a movie that is historically accurate about the battle of Actium (Augustus and Marcus) Cleopatra, Agrippa and idk


r/ancientrome • • 4d ago

Was Octavian/Augustus as brutal and cold as I’ve seen him portrayed in historical fiction?

Post image
701 Upvotes

HBO’s Rome, Shakespeare and any books I’ve read about Cicero tend to portray Octavian as either a monster or a sociopath but what do we actually know about his personality?