I've been looking closely at two Roman portrait busts traditionally associated with Gaius Marius and Lucius Cornelius Sulla, and I find their identification - and especially their striking resemblance - fascinating.
The so-called Marius bust, now in the Munich Glyptothek, is traditionally identified as Gaius Marius. However, this identification is not universally accepted. There are also other portrait busts attributed to Marius, and their facial features look noticeably different from those of the Munich bust. This raises an important question: how reliable are these traditional identifications in the first place? There have also been alternative proposals, including Filippo Coarelli's suggestion that the Munich bust could represent Lucius Cornelius Scipio Asiaticus.
The other bust, commonly referred to as Sulla, is equally controversial. In his 2003 study Bildnisse des Lucius Cornelius Sulla Felix, archaeologist Volker Michael Strocka challenges this identification. Among his arguments are the hairstyle, the absence of the characteristic receding temples associated with Sulla's proposed portrait type, and stylistic considerations. He also points out that the head cannot be securely connected to other known replicas.
But here's what really caught my attention: the two faces look remarkably alike.
Could this resemblance be more than coincidence?
One possibility is that both busts represent the same individual at different stages of life. Another possibility is that they really do depict two different people - perhaps Marius and Sulla - whose facial features happened to be similar.
And even if both sculptures represent Sulla, their differences would not necessarily rule that out. They could have been created by different sculptors, working in different artistic traditions, with different interpretations of the same person's appearance. Roman portraiture was not always about producing identical, standardized representations.
Of course, facial resemblance alone cannot establish an identification. We would need to consider archaeological context, provenance, chronology, stylistic features, and comparisons with other securely identified portraits.
There is also an important distinction between the different sculptures historically called “Sulla”: the so-called Sulla Barberini, now in Copenhagen, and the separate bust in Munich that Strocka rejects as a portrait of Sulla. These should not be confused.
I'd like to hear some thoughts:
- Do you find the traditional identification of the Munich bust as Marius convincing, especially considering the other portraits attributed to him?
- Is the resemblance between the two busts significant, or am I seeing something that isn't really there?
- Could both portraits conceivably represent the same historical figure at different ages?
- If both are portraits of Sulla, could their differences simply reflect two different sculptors and artistic interpretations?
- What do you think is the strongest evidence for identifying either bust?
I'm particularly interested in opinions based on Roman portraiture, archaeology, and art history - not just visual resemblance.