r/civilengineering • u/Own_Conversation3083 • 3h ago
Career I would get a good gov job ASAP if I’m under 35
I've been through 2 PE acquisitions and both companies went to shit afterward. Healthcare got worse, benefits got cut, bonuses were mediocre, and pay was ok at best. I don't think it's just my two companies either. The whole private side is racing to the bottom on fees, and the people doing the work are the ones who take the hit.
Yes pay is better on the private side no one’s contesting that. But if you’re not an owner or in a leadership role that gap has been narrowing in the past half decade (or at least it has in my area). Theres virtually no pay gap for entry-mid level people and if there is it’s maybe ~10% which is quickly eroded away after you factor in benefits (WHICH ARE DRAMATICALLY BETTER).
Let’s talk about my biggest concern which is AI. I'm not saying engineers get replaced overnight or that nobody needs a PE stamp. My concern is how firms make money. Most of them sell hours, and a big chunk of those hours are junior and mid level people doing markups, calcs, drafting, QC, report writing, and plan review responses. That's exactly the work AI is getting good at, and it's improving fast. We're not in 2023 anymore.
You don't need 100% automation for this to hurt. If a firm can do the same project with two fewer people, someone is going to do it, and Private Equity owned firms will be first because their whole job is squeezing margin. Clients will also start expecting lower fees once they know the work takes less time. Less headcount, lower fees, same race to the bottom, just faster. The entry and mid level folks will feel it first, and that's who I'd be most worried for.
Government is set up very differently. Procurement is slow, civil service rules make layoffs hard, and agencies are cautious about adopting new tools. They'll use AI eventually, but I'd expect it to help clear backlogs and onshore more work, not gut the staff. At least in my area the agencies already run pretty lean theres really not that much to “gut” and the PEs drive the entire operation I can’t see reductions in force that target PEs at government agencies. Nothing is 100% safe, but that's about as insulated as it gets in this field.
The catch is that these slots are limited and the hiring process is tedious (it took me 4 months to get hired and im told that’s normal/fast). It isn't very competitive right now, but I can easily see that changing. If everyone figures this out at the same time, getting in could be nearly impossible for anyone who isn't already inside.
Just my 2 cents, call me an idiot if you want to but this is my cynical take on the industry and what I think the best move is for younger engineers.