r/DogFood • • May 01 '26

Wall of Shame Addition: The Farmers Dog

269 Upvotes

Congrats to The Farmers Dog who has earned a spot on our Wall of Shame because their employees DM users of this sub to share marketing information in order to get around both a ban and our rule against brand representatives posting here.

Interfering with conversations here through DMs after they have been explicitly informed that their marketing content is not allowed is gross.

How do we know?: Users have shared DM content with us, and the account in question identifies themselves as an employee in multiple places.

Enjoy your addition, TFD!


r/DogFood • • May 01 '26

Debunking the DM you're getting

94 Upvotes

Hello! Many users receive a DM after posting from someone absolutely obsessed with this sub.

That user shares some pretty pernicious (and frankly, a little funny) myths about dog food, cites zero sources, and presents information that is contrary to all available scientific evidence. Let’s talk about it!:

The claim: r/dogfood exists only to promote Nestle, Mars Corp, and Colgate-Palmolive brands. 

The reality: Absolutely not. We exist to science backed information and recommend brands that meet the highest standards in the areas identified by WSAVA, which is precisely the same thing that the vast majority of the veterinary community does (hence why we are able to provide hundreds of veterinary citations in our wiki). If additional brands meets those high standards at some point, we will be thrilled to add them to our recommendations.

This claim also misunderstands the relationship of brands to parent companies. For example, Royal Canin meets the highest standards according to the veterinary community, but other Mars brands, like Nutro, do not, and are not recommended widely by the sub or by vets. We do not recommend parent companies as a whole at all, and one shouldn't assume all Mars, Nestle etc. brands meet the same high standards because they don't.

The claim: All of their recipes are mostly made of corn byproduct (cob, stalk, husk, etc) that has virtually no other use in the market.

The reality: There are literally hundreds of diets available within WSAVA-compliant brands. None of them are “mostly corn by-product” and not nearly all of them use corn at all. This is a wild exaggeration that is not based in evidence.

This user is also using the term “byproduct” to create fearmongering. What they mean is corn gluten meal, which is really only used in some products and is considered a corn co-product. This is a protein-dense ingredient that results from removing the starch, bran, and germ from the corn. That makes it more digestible, less starchy, and has an excellent amino acid profile, which are compounds necessary for dog’s (and everyone else’s) health.

The claim: It used to be an expense for [pet food companies] to dispose of until they figured out they could put it in dog food. 

The reality: If we’re being very generous, this user appears to be making the very silly claim that corn is used in pet food because Nestle and Mars have leftovers from using high fructose corn syrup in their human candy products.

First, corn has been used in these products since well before Purina and Royal Canin were bought by Nestle and Mars and were part of their supply chains before that.

Second, the component parts of corn and corn gluten meal used in pet food are not cast offs of corn syrup refinement. There is no functional way this claim can be true, it is completely made up. 

The implicit claim: This is a horrible product

The reality: Wrong. There’s no debate about this among experts: corn, when used correctly, is a super digestible (upwards of 95%) source of critical nutrients and amino acids like linoleic acid, lysine, tryptophan, and many more.  When used in concert with other ingredients, it is an excellent ingredient to create balanced, safe food. 

And of course, this ignores the fact that lots of science-backed foods use other sources of grain in addition to or instead of corn: barley, wheat, rice, oats, sorghum etc. that all have similar nutrient profiles and good digestibility. 

The claim: It didn’t matter to them that illness rates skyrocketed simultaneously

The reality: This is literally untrue. Dog lifespans have doubled in the past forty years, and diet and healthcare are both a big part of that.

And!: more people than ever are treating dogs like they are family. Do you know what happens when dogs live longer and people go to the vet more often? They uncover diseases that might not have been diagnosed or treat-able in the past, or the dog wouldn’t have even lived long enough to develop. 

For example, not that many people in 1950 were getting their dogs anesthetic dentals; now, we can prevent organ failures with regular dental care. But the number of dogs diagnosed with dental disease have gone up as a result of the availability of this care. 

There is zero evidence that the use of corn in dog food is even correlated to “illness rates” much less any kind of causation. Many things contribute to pet disease, including dogs living longer, breeding practices, environment and more. 

The myth: These corn byproducts are also used as absorbents for chemical spills.

The reality: Corn-based absorbents exist, and they are not the same product that goes into pet food. This is literally made up. Just because they both have “corn” in the name doesn’t mean they are the same thing. 

The claim: corn is so damaging to their systems, along with wheat and soy products.

The reality: No they aren’t. There isn’t one single study that indicates this. And that’s why this user doesn’t send you any. 

The claim:  These “foods” are cooked at very high temperatures

The reality: Wrong. Kibble (just a food without the scare quotes) is typically cooked a few times times at a max of 400 degrees Fahrenheit. If you sear a steak and finish it in the oven, you’re cooking at higher temps than kibble is cooked at.

The claim: FULL of glyphosate

The reality: Wrong. “Even the most contaminated feed they studied had thousands of times less glyphosate than levels that were shown to have no adverse effects on dogs in the U.S. EPA’s Draft Risk Assessment for glyphosate.” There is zero evidence in existence indicating health risks to dogs from consumption of glyphosate in commercial diets. Zero. 

The claim: kibble sit on shelves for up to 24 months. The implicit claim is that this is obviously a sign of poor quality, which is simply fear mongering. 

The reality: Dry dog food tends to have a shelf life of a maximum of 18 months, and only 4-6 weeks max once the bag is opened. It can last up to 18 months in a sealed bag because it doesn’t have that much moisture that would allow bacteria to grow. The same is true of a lot of healthy human food including properly stored root vegetables, grains, and beans and lentils. 

The claim: They’re also sprayed with “palatants” because dogs wouldn’t eat it if they weren’t tricked into believing it’s meat. 

The reality: Kibble is often coated with light amounts of fat for palateability much the same way we add olive oil to the bottom of a pan before cooking something. It tastes better. Weird language about “tricking” dogs into “believing” it’s meat is just fear-mongering. Do you add salt or dressing to your food to make it tastier? Are you being tricked when that happens? Of course not, that’s just silly.

The claim: They cause hot spots, shedding, chewing at the feet/fritos smell, and much worse problems later.

The reality: Wrong. In literature reviews, literally zero cases of corn allergies were identified. Hot spots, chewing, and an overgrowth of yeast are almost always immune responses to environmental issues or a true food allergy (most commonly to meat proteins and it doesn’t matter if it’s raw, cooked, fresh, or kibble-based to cause that reaction. If your dog is allergic to beef, that is equally true of raw beef and beef in kibble or canned food). There is zero evidence in existence that kibble causes any of this. 

The claim: Their high cost isn’t a reflection of their quality, it’s a manipulative way of improving consumer perception. It gives people confidence that it is quality.

The reality: This is just funny coming from someone advocating harmful and expensive raw diets. Something like, for example, Purina One is priced at $1.50/lb. What raw meat can you reliably source for your dog at that price? Not even counting the extras that need to go into a raw diet to make it balanced like supplement powders. Raw and fresh diets are universally more expensive than a science-backed budget kibble. It’s not even close. Are the high prices of raw food diets manipulative also?

The claim: Raw diets are completely safe and healthy for dogs and cats and are the best nutrition available.

The reality: Stunningly wrong. There is overwhelming evidence that these diets are not safe, and there is no body of evidence demonstrating superior nutrition to commercial kibble and canned diets at all. Cats have recently died from bird flu from eating freeze dried raw products, and we know dogs can contract bird flu as well. Dogs can become paralyzed from campylobacter in raw chicken. E.coli can make dogs and their humans very sick Many peer review studies have demonstrated that raw pet food diets spread antibiotic resistant illness, putting pets and humans in danger. 

The claim: DCM is not a “valid” concern

The reality: The entire veterinary community disagrees and there is ample peer reviewed evidence suggesting otherwise. For example, how are dogs who get nutrition-related DCM able to get better (even be cured) when switched from an implicated to a science-backed diet, when dogs with genetic DCM never improve regardless of diet, if diet isn’t contributing? 

The claim: Your dog will require almost no maintenance and be healthier if you keep corn, wheat and soy away from him

The reality: Literally no evidence supports this. Imagine making the claim that avoiding corn, wheat and soy avoids ALL health problems. That’s just irresponsible.

The claim: I have no requests or gains to make from this, I just love dogs and want to inform others.

The reality: This user gets something from it because they’ve been spamming this DM to users on this sub for months. They want to put “Science” in scare quotes because they know they can’t provide real experts or studies to back up what they’re saying.

But because knowledgeable users can’t “refute” them by providing factual information when they DM random people, this user gets to FEEL right and righteous. That’s what they’re getting.

And to the user who sends these: Sending crazy unsolicited DMs waving around a hate boner for corn is deeply odd behavior and it makes you look silly.

A general warning to anyone: Misinformation in pet health and pet food is widespread and growing.  This user tellingly doesn’t provide any kind of evidence, but when you encounter similar claims, you also have to be critical of other “sources” that contradict veterinary consensus when making weird claims like this too.

A great rule of thumb: check to see if the source backing sketchy claims like these has anything bad to say about normal approved vaccine schedules. The anti-science ones always do.


r/DogFood • • 3h ago

2 yo mixed breed dog am I missing any protein dog food when your dog has apparently eaten EVERY animal already?

1 Upvotes

Vet mentioned a novel protein trial as one possible next step for my dog, but I am realizing he has eaten chicken, beef, turkey, salmon AND duck at some point.

I don’t understand why this little pup (who’s basically a remix of different dogs) acts like he’s royalty. He won’t eat what I offer him; he only eats what he chooses, and he’s quite picky. On top of that, he gets bored with his food after just three days! The vet mentioned something about protein supplements, but I don’t know much about that. Have any of you dealt with a similar situation? If so, how did you resolve or manage it?


r/DogFood • • 8h ago

7-8 year old pitty mix with food issues

1 Upvotes

I have a pitty mix who of course has all the allergies. She is on Purina Pro Plan SSS salmon Adult. She was doing well for the most part (she's always had loose stools and anal gland issues). She started to get acid reflux a bit and had a full week of diarrhea.

Vet suggested a lower fat food and feeding smaller more frequent meals. Finding a lower fat food without chicken is a nightmare. But I tried her on Hills Science Diet Perfect Digestion Salmon (which for some reason, has chicken) hoping her previous itchy issues weren't from her chicken based food and just her general allergies. Well, first 2 weeks she did great. Nice solid poops and less burping/licking. But after that, she was not feeling well and threw up all the food she ate that day, then refused to eat the Hills anymore. So I put her back on the PPP SSS for now until I can figure out something else.

I saw the PPP SSS Salmon has a Large Breed formula that has lower fat and slightly higher fiber (she is currently 62lbs) Has anyone had luck with that formula? Or are there any suggestions for a different WSAVA food without chicken that might meet her needs. She has a vet appointment in a week and a half for her glands, and will happily ask my vet for prescription food if it is necessary. I am just losing my mind trying to research the crazy amount of food options.


r/DogFood • • 16h ago

9-month-old Australian Shepherd – I just can’t find a food that works for him. Any advice?

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I have a 9-month-old Australian Shepherd, and pretty much ever since he came home at 2 months old, I’ve been struggling to find a food that works for him.

When I got him, his poop was absolutely perfect. The breeder gave me 2 kg of the food he was eating, but since I couldn’t find it anywhere, I had to switch to a different brand. I followed all the transition guidelines carefully, measuring every single kibble in grams and gradually introducing the new food.
Unfortunately, it didn’t work for him.
I tried pretty much every flavour of the same brand (Farmina N&D), but nothing worked. I also tried Taste of the Wild twice, with the same results.

Eventually, I decided to get a fecal test done.
Bingo! He had Giardia. Finally, I thought I’d found the reason behind all the digestive issues!

After treatment, his follow-up test came back negative. During that time, he was eating Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Diets EN Gastrointestinal, and his poop was actually pretty good on it.
Once he was clear of Giardia, I slowly started transitioning him back to N&D, but the problems returned.

Then I thought, why not try adult food instead, while supplementing with puppy/junior supplements to make sure he gets everything he needs?

Same story. No improvement. So… what now? What on earth should I feed this dog? 😅

His poop is usually formed when he first goes, but when I pick it up, it falls apart. The consistency is almost like thick yogurt. He’s never had actual watery diarrhea or a situation where we have to rush outside.

I’m currently considering trying Purina Pro Plan Sensitive Digestion, regardless of the ingredients, because honestly, I’m running out of ideas and just want to find something that works for him.

Has anyone experienced something similar with their dog? What food eventually worked for you? I’d really appreciate any advice or personal experiences. I’m getting desperate here!

One more thing: I’m based in Europe, so I don’t have access to all the dog food brands and formulas available in the US. Some of the recommendations I see online aren’t even available here.


r/DogFood • • 22h ago

Is my dog eating enough?

1 Upvotes

I have a 26kg 12 year old dog, kinda beefy.

I got her a new medium sized kibble a week ago that's grain free with:

30% Crude protein

12% Crude fats

4% crude fibres

8% crude ash

1,8% calcium

1,2% phosphorus

0,6% potassium

3.520 kcal/kg

I put her bowl down twice a day and she starts eating, then I take it away 10 minutes after she stops. I try to feed her around 300 grams a day as recommended by the label, 150g per meal, but she often only eats about 70-80g per meal. Even if I put her bowl a 3rd time she'll eat much less, and the total per day won't be more than 160 grams. I can maybe bring it up to 200 if I add a little bit of chicken fillet in there, but just barely. She keeps begging whenever we eat so I know she's hungry, but she's being difficult with her kibble. She doesn't really have any dental issues. Should I just keep going like this and let her eat however much she wants?


r/DogFood • • 1d ago

Feed Kirkland Cat Pate to my dog??

0 Upvotes

Our 3 year old rescue wire hair terrier mix loves Kirkland Pate dog food. We mix it with Blue Buffalo small breed dry food and she wolfs it down. We also have a cat and recently bought some of the Kirkland 3 Flavor variety pate for cats thinking he'd like it too. Of course, she doesn't. So I have 42 packs left. Can I feed this to my dog, continuing to mix it with the dry Blue Buffalo?


r/DogFood • • 1d ago

Help! New dog mom

4 Upvotes

New dog mom here, and I need some advice! 🐾❤️

We currently feed our Golden Retriever Hill’s Science Diet Large Breed Puppy Lamb & Brown Rice, but it’s getting a little pricey. He also doesn’t seem to do well with chicken, so I’m trying to find a good alternative.

I’ve been looking into Wholesomes Large Breed Puppy and Member’s Mark Large Breed Beef & Barley. Has anyone had experience with either of these?

Would you recommend making the switch or sticking with Hill’s? I want something that’s high-quality, supports healthy growth and joints, and is a good fit for a growing Golden Retriever.

Help this new dog mom out! 😂


r/DogFood • • 2d ago

dog food topper people... how are you not accidentally feeding 2 dinners?

7 Upvotes

I want to add some fresh food because my dog is bored with his normal meals, but I do not necessarily want to switch 100%.

Anyone using fresh dog food as a topper, how do you keep calories and nutrition reasonable instead of just adding a second dinner on top?


r/DogFood • • 3d ago

Hi everyone. Can anyone recommend good quality kibble for my 4 year old miniature schnauzer?

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone. Can anyone recommend good quality kibble for my 4 year old miniature schnauzer? | currently feed him Farmina, but he has been vomiting, having loose stools, and is very itchy, so I want to switch him out of it. Thank you in advance.


r/DogFood • • 3d ago

NutriSource Weight Management - Dog pooping A LOT

0 Upvotes

Our dog was on Ollie food for the last year since he had gotten sick with pancreatitis from a lamb based dry food. We’re trying to switch him to half kibble, half fresh food, but nervous about dry food since that’s what made him sick in the first place.

We just tried the nutri source weight management grain free kibble. He likes it, but is pooping extremely frequently, like this morning he literally went four times. The hoops are normal and solid, but noticeably frequent.

Has anyone else experienced this?


r/DogFood • • 3d ago

11 year old pitbull recs

3 Upvotes

Hello! My pitbull mix is now 11 years old and he has always eaten Purina pro plan sensitive skin and stomach salmon. Recently he got diagnosed with hyperthyroidism. Yes hyper not hypo. Due to this and the medicine he is on, he has a loss of appetite. I have tried buying different wet food like Blue, Buffalo and Purina and a variety of quality food toppers that he briefly liked but now I can't get my dog to eat much of anything. I did get blue buffalo kibble he quickly got over as well. Any recommendations for a picky eater?

Thank you guys, 🤎🐾


r/DogFood • • 3d ago

Cans potentially froze. Toss or throw in fridge?

1 Upvotes

My sister left my cat and dog food cans in the vehicle. I found out this morning. The can I opened this morning was thick as hell. I cannot afford to replace the cans for a few days. I can however buy a small bag of the kibble if needed(however this will NOT work with the cat food due to it being for a diabetic). Wondering if they are a loss cause or if they just need to go in the fridge and heated to serve.


r/DogFood • • 3d ago

Dry Dog Food Rec?

0 Upvotes

My aussiedoodle who just turned 1 year old does great on Jinx dog food. But she's not excited about it. When she was a baby she used to spin in circles for Purina but that's just puppy nonsense. Her stool has been perfect on Jinx and I don't want to change something that has been great. But I can tell whenever she eats it, it's out of survival more than it is excitement. I tried Open Farm for a few days but she wasn't very excited about that either. I got the Epic blend one. I was going to feed raw but backed out because she has a sensitive stomach. Besides adding fresh veggies etc. which I already do, does anyone know of dog food for a doodle that they will go bananas for? I have an unlimited budget so doesn't matter the price.


r/DogFood • • 4d ago

WPG owners, curious about your dogs!

1 Upvotes

Hi! I have an almost 2-year-old Wirehaired Pointing Griffon and I'm curious about everyone's experiences with feeding their dogs. What has worked well for you, and have you changed foods as your dog got older? Would love to hear your experiences!


r/DogFood • • 4d ago

My Dog is not eating Farmina Lamb and Blueberry food

0 Upvotes

My dog is not eating farmina N&D lambda and blueberry food.

For some reason he doesn't seems to be interested.


r/DogFood • • 5d ago

First time dog owner here’s what I feed

7 Upvotes

I’m honestly scared to make this post. I know that the dog community will NEVER agree on what is the appropriate or “the best” way to feed your dog. I picked up some iams mini chunks for the chihuahua I adopted yesterday. It was a bit short notice and I couldn’t find the small breed iams so I grabbed the closest one to it. It’s a 5lb bag. I’ve only given her the dry kibble so far but I want advice on add ins and toppers. I was planning on adding bone broth (daily) and dried sardines (tri weekly) to her kibble. I give her 1/4th cup 3 times daily. From what I’ve heard the biggest problem with iams is their quality control and “fillers”. $15 is as much as I’m willing to spend on kibble (not including toppers). Anything raw is out of the question. I hate meat, looking at it, touching it, smelling it, I just can’t. It must be cooked or freeze dried or I won’t touch it. I do always have fresh produce on hand, not sure if that would be beneficial to add to her diet or not. My chi is 9 months old and roughly 10lbs. Any tips?


r/DogFood • • 5d ago

Grain free Purina One

7 Upvotes

I recently started adding purina one true instinct grain free turkey and venison canned dog food to my dogs dry kibble as a topper. I did not realize it was grain free until I got home. Is this grain free formula associated with dcm? I'd like to keep mixing it in with his kibble because he seems to love it and is doing well on it. I did not see that any kind of peas or chickpeas are in the mix but I just wanted to ask.


r/DogFood • • 5d ago

What size kibble bag?

3 Upvotes

Looking to get new kibble storage containers for these family members <3

  • 10 pound Italian Greyhound. Currently eats about 1 total cup of Purina 30/20 a day
  • 75 pound Greyhound. Currently eats about 3 total cups of Purina Bright Mind a day

We'd like storage containers that I'll put the bag in and it's air tight and one we only have to fill monthly (yay small apt living with no storage). I'm terrible at math and calculating anything so I'm reaching out here to figure out the best option :)


r/DogFood • • 5d ago

Inukshuk dog food? Yay or nay?

0 Upvotes

my opinions are extremely limited. before you suggest Purina.... no. it's not in the cards. non of the Purina or Purina pro plan works for my dog or my wallet unfortunately.

currently my dog eats Caledon Farms Lamb kibble. he likes it, but it has rosemary in it... which he is allergic to.

he's allergic to a LOT, which is why our list is so limited.

while searching for other options that are 100% allergen free for my boy.. I came across Inukshuk- the marine variety, 26% min protein, has the perfect ingredients for him AND it's cheaper per kg.

**any opinions on Inukshuk as a food, as a brand? any horror stories? success stoies? do we love it, hate it, feel indifferent?**

my dog, Merlin, is 10 years old. he's a lean 24lbs Jack Russel mixed with mini poodle, I believe. He's moderately active, plays and goes for daily walks, but he loves his naps and lazy time.

Merlin is allergic to at leaat chicken and chicken egg, beef, rabbit, venison, turkey, halibut, sardines, shellfish, corn, wheat, sweet potato, mackerel, rosemary, flaxseed oil, and olive oil.

I'm a broke 24yr old, but I love my old man.


r/DogFood • • 5d ago

Best Fish Oil / Salmon Oil ?

3 Upvotes

Been using the grizzly pet products brand for months now and just thinking I’ll need to get a restock at a quarter bottle left, but the price increased on Amazon. I also realized that it’s not pure salmon oil, but a mix of a couple other fishes. Is it best to give strictly salmon oil instead?

Also I’m curious what other brands you’ve tried that’s effective for skin and coat. Looking at this Vital Pet brand, red bottle, on Amazon, can never tell if reviews are real these days haha.

Thanks!


r/DogFood • • 5d ago

Dog food

0 Upvotes

Whoever sent food to me from Costco, i want you to know how much I appreciate it. Thank you!


r/DogFood • • 6d ago

(Help) Trying to find the healthiest food for my Dog just getting started

10 Upvotes

Me and my wife just adopted a 3month old GSD mix from the shelter and I’m going down a rabbit hole trying to figure out the best food for him. I’ve read a lot about WSAVA and I’ve read some of the guidelines but that still doesn’t answer what brand a should trust. He’s 4 months old about 20Ib and currently eating a mix of fresh food and kibble we got from the shelter.


r/DogFood • • 6d ago

Puppy not eating her food

3 Upvotes

My little turkey is being very difficult with meal time. She is a mix (50% Doberman), 7 months old, and 44lbs. We have been feeding her Purina Pro Plan large breed puppy chicken and rice. She has always been a little difficult with eating it but we assumed it was because she was such a little puppy, teething, and we fed her three big meals a day. We definitely added some cheese or peanut butter or soaked and froze her food here and there to get her interested because we wanted make sure she was eating and growing at such a crucial time of development. Now she is 7 months and her growth is starting to slow down a bit so we are feeding her twice a day, just plain kibble, and not coaxing her or adding anything. She seems so frustrated. She will maybe take a bite but mostly just barks at it or ignores it completely. We give her 15 minutes and then take the food away. She gets a lot of exercise and mental stimulation. She happily will take treats or a bully stick or anything (although we have been limiting them to encourage her to eat her actual food). Her bag of Pro Plan is toward the end so I was thinking of trying a different kibble. Any and all suggestions and help is welcome. Thanks all!


r/DogFood • • 6d ago

Fussy 5 month pup & mix feeding

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes