I've been Eastern Orthodox for a large portion of my life. I was baptized Protestant, Crismated Orthodox, had a "correctional baptism" by an Orthodox monk to correct any wrongs that could have happened in the Protestant baptism. I have recently begun seriously studying Catholicism, particularly the historical claims of the papacy and the possibility of entering full communion with Rome.
Something I've recently learned has raised an interesting concern for me.
From what I understand, under Eastern Catholic canon law, an Orthodox Christian entering communion with Rome is ordinarily enrolled in the corresponding Eastern Catholic Church rather than the Latin Church.
While I understand the reasoning behind preserving Eastern Christian traditions, if I eventually became Catholic, I would specifically want to become Latin Catholic, not Byzantine Catholic.
I come from a long line of Western Catholics, and I'm the only one in my family who entered Eastern Orthodoxy. My ancestry is entirely Western European, and my family's religious heritage is rooted in the Latin Church.
Although I've spent 14 years practicing Byzantine Christianity, that's largely because Eastern Orthodoxy was the tradition available to me. There isn't a Western Rite Orthodox parish in my area, so I've never really had the opportunity to practice Western Christianity within Orthodoxy.
Over time, I've developed a strong interest in traditional Western Catholic spirituality, particularly the Traditional Latin Mass, Benedictine monasticism, Gregorian chant, and the Latin Divine Office.
If I entered Catholicism, I would want to reconnect with the Western Christian heritage of my ancestors rather than remain canonically attached to the Byzantine tradition simply because I happened to become Orthodox years ago.
Someone who converted from Orthodoxy to Catholicism recently explained that he was automatically enrolled in the Byzantine Catholic Church, even though he primarily attends Latin parishes. He emphasized that canonical enrollment doesn't prevent someone from attending any Catholic liturgy, which I understand.
However, my concern isn't simply where I'm allowed to attend Mass. I would actually want to belong to the Latin Church canonically.
I understand that a formal transfer of canonical enrollment is possible, but I'm unsure how difficult that process is or whether it could be arranged when entering Catholic communion.
So I have a few questions:
- Can an Eastern Orthodox Christian request enrollment in the Latin Church when entering full communion with Rome, rather than first becoming Byzantine Catholic?
- Would my Western Catholic family ancestry and sincere attachment to Latin spirituality be considered legitimate reasons for such a request?
- Would I need permission from the Holy See, or could the local Latin bishop and appropriate Eastern Catholic authorities handle the transfer?
- Has anyone here actually gone through this process, and what was your experience?
- Would it make any difference whether I was originally baptized Catholic or Orthodox?
I want to emphasize that I'm not criticizing Eastern Catholicism. I respect its traditions and understand why the Catholic Church works to protect them.
But I also believe the historic Latin Christian tradition deserves the same appreciation. If I eventually become convinced that Catholicism is the true Church, I'd love the opportunity to embrace the Western Catholic heritage of my own family.
I'm still discerning and haven't made a decision to leave Orthodoxy. I'm simply trying to understand what my options would be.
I'd especially appreciate responses from Catholic priests, canon lawyers, or former Orthodox Christians who have experienced something similar.