Hi everyone, in this post I'll share some non-technical info on how you can quickly vet out likely AI portfolios based on sound, and if you need an experienced set of ears to give an opinion I'm offering it for 1€ per review as it can't be free (I'm not expecting too much but if there is a lot of demand, I'll have to update this rate for my own sanity though).
I'm fishe, I've been a producer and sound designer for 6 years and a jazz musician for 10 years. I joined the game scene around 2 years ago participating in game jams and started contributing to commercial projects at the start of this year with 4 credits so far.
Back in 2022 I also did a ton of academic research around the emerging gen AI music tools at the time, although admittedly I haven't followed as much since the modern counterparts like suno and udio came around. I noticed a lot of the "tells" from before haven't really changed though, only having become more well disguised as the tech improved, and I've been familiar with what they sound like for longer than most.
I currently have two ongoing small projects and have been looking specifically for one more surreal, or just very weird project to contribute to, which unsurprisingly seems pretty hard to come by.
Since I'm not really competing for conventional projects atm, I wanted to try offering an unbiased composer's opinion, hopefully helping both prevent some scams or deceipt (e.g. people inflating their experience level) and send more work the way of someone who would otherwise get buried that really deserved a chance.
Under the hood, a lot of the tech behind image and music gen is similar, and indeed, music does also have a lot of parallel AI tells like the piss filter equivalent and morphing/merging shapes well known for generated images.
For the musical piss filter I'm referring to a constant sound of warping and quantization present throghout the music. If you are unfamiliar, as a test, try pulling up a youtube video and slow the playback to 0.5x, then slowly speed it back up until you barely hear the artifacts. If you spot this type of sound in someone's work it doesn't automatically mean it's AI, question if it sounds intentional, and if not it should be a red flag, any producer worth their salt should know to clean this up, unless the track is older, then you could argue that the piss filter is an aesthetic choice, maybe idk...
For instruments, listen out specifically for instruments that should sound "smooth", like flute, sax, tonal percussions, acoustic instruments, etc. And judge if they sound unusually "jagged" or even "retro" instead in a way that doesn't seem intentional.
Morphing is harder to notice, one thing I can suggest trying is switching your attention to the background instead of the elements that usually lead your ears, do they make sense? or does it start to sound mushy somehow like an optical illusion falling apart once you look at it from a different angle?
If you have some good ears you can also try paying some attention to the mix style too, specifically where things don't seem to add up. I notice for example modern AI tends to create fairly cohesive sounding balance and arrangements, which paired with the artifacts and unusual lo-fi-ness of the master doesn't really feel like the same person made those choices.
You can of course also check if the files have been watermarked through SynthID.
- How can people still deceive you?
Well... for one AI MIDI generation tools exist, the underlying principle is again technically similar except the output is created as note instructions that can be plugged into your virtual instruments of choice essentially bypassing the tells mentioned above. In which case I'm sure many composers will still agree that there are aural quirks to the way AI music is arranged that I won't go into in this post, it's probably much less common as it requires extra work to make it sound passable, and harder to tell apart with high confidence either way.
This post was mainly focused on AI scams but of course there are many other scams and disingenuity that have been around for longer, like stolen work, fake resumes, and even things that have come full circle to becoming generally accepted like miming. At the end of the day you just end up going along with your gut, and after that if you still need a second opinion I can provide ;)