Part I / Intro
Hi, i'm Dirt, so recently i've been thinking about it a lot and let's be honest, napoleonic games are niche and often more like FPS (ex: Warband NW, Holdfast NaW) or RTS (NTW, LoB, March of the Eagles, etc)
Here i would like to take you on a journey with me to imagine a new napoleonic game. I, in advance, beg you to forgive my poor grammar, blame it on my frenchness i guess! ^^
April 1805, Napoleon has just been crowned emperor a few months ago, yet the European powers start to actively prepare for war.
You, in that context, start as a recently promoted in wether the coalition or the French side. You must assume command of a regiment which would be either Infantry, Cavalry, Light Infantry, Skirmishers or Artillery with many sub categories such as, for example, Hussars, Lancers, Cuirassiers, Dragoons, Carabiniers, Mounted chasseurs, foot artillery, horse artillery, gernadiers, etc.
The choice of nations would be :
Coalition :
- Austrian Empire 🇦🇹
- Russian Empire 🇷🇺
- United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland 🇬🇧
- Kingdom of Naples 🇮🇹
- Kingdom of Sicily 🇮🇹
- Kingdom of Sweden 🇸🇪
France and allies/vassals :
- French Empire 🇫🇷
- Kingdom of Spain 🇪🇸
- Grand duchy of Baden 🇩🇪
- Kingdom of Württemberg 🇩🇪
- Kingdom of Bavaria 🇩🇪
- Kingdom of Italy 🇮🇹
- Kingdom of Etruria 🇮🇹
- Batavian republic 🇳🇱
Neutral nations :
- Kingdom of Prussia 🇩🇪
- Multiple German states (Saxony for example) 🇩🇪
- Denmark-Norway 🇩🇰 🇳🇴
- Portugal 🇵🇹
Part II / Organization in countries
Rather than a grindy leveling up system where the game decide wether you rank up or not, have Kings, Emperor, Grand Duke, etc..., actually giving titles, ranks and stuff.
There you might say "Wait wait wait wait, Dirt, it's nice but won't people only place their friends in important positions ?" EXACTLY! But actually think about it, you are a young general who has done wonder in a meritocratic country so your rose to become one of the Marshalls of France, infront of you an Austrian empire where ranks are based on relations and status, leaving that kind of decisions and power to the player would give a real political dimension to the game and would make so that you'd have to be more involved and you'd have to actively reform the country.
But... How to chose a leader ?
Think about it, are people in the 1800s chosen to be king because of their ability ? No they are "born to rule" (incompetent or not), the idea, randomize the choice of the leader to actually make so that everyone has a fair chance to become a leader and to make so you will most likely never have twice the same leader.
But what if the leader is inactive or really really bad ? My idea would be to add a disatisfaction where you can vote between neutral, positive or negative and only the positive and negative opinion from player having played in the last 3 days would be taken in consideration. We could also index the weight of a vote on the influence that someone hold (rank/title).
Then if the vote gets up to 75% of disapproval officers could get the option to make a revolution. The revolution could either be one signle movement where someone is picked randomly again or maybe elected or perhaps something closer to a civilwar where people form faction for pretendent. However let's skip that matter for now.
Part III / Scale and view
I thought it through and through and i think that overall an MMO strategy games would have 3 options :
- The Commander Battle type of view : If you are not familiar with what commander battles are i would recommend you to play Holdfast NaW, M&B Warband on the NW dlc, or bot commander on roblox. The Commander battle is basically a type of view where you play as the commander of a unit on the field rather than a view from above, you are physically there and gotta give orders and participate in the fight. It's a good option because it's epic but when you think about it the idea of a Napoleonic MMO would be for it to be overall large scale across Europe, which means that past a hundred players or a few hundred players generating regiments and such would be come quite hard especially if the regiments are the scale of a real life regiment.
- The Total War type of view : A view from above where you gotta make your troops maneuver, like the commander battle you can see your soldier individually yet you are not there on the field, the main problem of this view would be tho that it doesn't solve the lag problem, still a lot of models/sprite to load.
- The lines of battle type of view : A full tactical view from above where units are more like chess pieces that you move (check on LoB to see more on what the unit looks like, it's a bit too hard to explain with my limited vocabulary ^^') The inconvenient is that it's not really immersive and even by giving like 5 batallion of line infantry for example to simulate a whole regiment it probably wouldn't be immersive enough and would most likely be repetitive.
But then what's the best compromise ???
To me the best compromise would be an aspect closer to Master Of Command when armies are moving on the Europe map and then randomly generated maps on which it would have a commander battle aspect for the battles in which the player play, also putting them on dedicated servers, it would also probably give people more immersion.
My ideas to resolve the problem of lags and lots of things to load ? Make a compromise and have a lower amount of soldiers in battles to make it still feel realistic but scale down the battle so they actually don't lag too much. Perhaps also be reasonable on smoke and sounds, yes sure not making it exactly as historically accurate might be a problem to some history nerds (i'm one too so ik what i'm talking abt xD) but i mean if you want to have the best game possible with the current technologies it would most likely be one of the best way to save datas for other things.
However if you have any suggestion or other ideas i would welcome them with open arms as long as you have arguments and as long as it's a doable/realist idea!! :D
Part IV / Diplomacy
Countries never behave nicely to eachother, ally, or war eachother because they just hate or love eachother. It's always a matter of interest. Here we don't want to make things too complicated since the main purpose of the game would be still for people to command units and fight eachother and have a lil taste of what being an officer during the napoleonic wars was like.
The diplomacy would be mainly just neutrality, allies, war.
No forced truth like in, for example, paradox interactive's games, no non-agression pact officially in the game, there it would be all words on treaties that player can chose to respect or disrespect.
You might be thinking "But wait, isn't this going to make things so risky that people will never ally ?"
And my answer is, no i don't think so, you see it's a matter of trust, everyone will at some point need allies by fear of getting conquered by an empire that is just clapping everyone or to just secure a border or anything. At some point people will have to ally, and the thing is that a good ally is more worthy than anything you'd most likely gain from backstabbing them.
Part V / Gameplay
The gameplay would really depend on your rank/status, the idea would be that anyway you'll be on the field, but an officer from lieutenant to colonel will direct a unit, an officer from brigadier general (Général de brigade) will lead a brigade of his type of unit (Inf, cav or art), a division general (Général de division) will lead a division that will make its own battle and Marshalls (Maréchal d'Empire (yes i know it's a dignity not a rank but that's not the topic) ) and chief-general (Général en chef) would be in charge of army corps and overall of theatres/fronts.
On the field itselves generals (except brigade), wouldn't give order to any unit but would have a map (like lines of battles) where they could give orders for unit to advance/position at a designated position. However they would only see their units and not the enemy on this map so they would have to act carefully enough so that they don't rush their troops in ambushes but recklessly enough so that it doesn't become a war of artillery/attrition.
The general would still be on the field tho so he can see from where he's standing where enemy units are positioned.
Order could either be an order such as "March 100 meters/foot/whatever to the north" or either a ping to which they'll have to go, however i feel like the order should be written directly by the general so that if they are not precise enough the unit will just get lost or do the wrong thing but if they are too precise the order can take too much time to be written then read and so not be pertinent by the time officers start following them, i also feel like a little time between when its written and when its received should be there to simulate the time the message get to them depending on how far they are from the general. If we wanted historical accuracy the order would have to be delivered by a player manually but i think it would complexify it too much. Perhaps an AI that could be intercepted ? But yet again i fear that it might be a bit too complex for a game.
Officers on their part would have to enact these order by following the instructions however they have the choice obviously not to follow them, but attention it might come at a cost! Generals and the leader of each nations get the power to sanction people who are at a lower rank than theirs (Obviously the only one who has the power on Generals is the leader except for Brigade General who, since he is in charge of a brigade and not an army is under the orders of the general of the said army.)
Officers would need to manually give the firing, movements, charge orders and a lot more, the speed of his troops to follow these orders would depends on the organization of the regiment, if drummers, flag bearers, fifer or any unit meant to help with the coordination is shot/killed then the regiments would lose in organization and the troops would be slower to follow the given orders.
There would also be a system of morale, death of troops meant to help with coordination will lower the morale (especially flag bearers) and overall casualties will also cause a loss in morale. Flags could also be captured, if a flag is captured then the regiments can try to retake it but if it fails it will have a big morale loss.
Part VI / Conclusion
I hope you enjoyed reading that text and i hope i haven't done to many grammar mistakes.
If you have any questions or suggestions they are more than welcome and i think it would be interesting to discuss about that idea a bit.
I also hope the text wasn't too dense, i tried to divide it as much as possible but i tend to make quite big paragraphs xD
I'll remind one last time that sadly that idea is most likely undoable or only with huge concessions on the number of bots, and if not then on other points! The idea here was mostly to write down my ideas since i've always been a big fan of strategy games with multiplayer campaigns even when it's at the initiative of the players!
Oh btw i know the Title is weird, i had genuinely no ideas xD
I hope you had fun!
Anyways you guys have a lovely day!
- Dirt