r/hvacadvice • • Mar 02 '26

General Information About Bans and Rules

0 Upvotes

There has been an uptick on posts and complaints about mods banning. Please be advised, there are rules for the page. No ads (includes promotions for a company), Reddits rules, no crossposting, transparency and safety (this is a big one; we want homeowners to be safe, if you provide unsafe practices or advice (blacklisted items) or tell a user to dm you, the comment will be removed and you may get banned), blacklisted topics (basically topics that homeowners should not be fixing themselves, gas, some high voltage), civility, no companies asking for surveys, advertisements or general questions, and no market research or ai/SaaS.

Posts complaining about this are not allowed either. We are all reasonable and work in the trade, talk to us through ModMail and we can come to a solution. Complaining or namecalling will usually result in a ban, so be civil.

Remember, we are doing this in our freetime to help homeowners with their units, both the users and mods. The mods in this group are in the trade and have day jobs as all of you do. I've been in this trade for 10 years and still do hvac as my job, just traveling now for a manufacturer. Similar with every mod. It is actually a requirement to be a mod, you have to be in the trade, be approved, have good history in the sub and provide enough time to moderating it.

I thank you for your time and if you have any questions, you can comment on this or send us a mod message. No DM's, we will not answer these. Only ModMail.


r/hvacadvice • • Nov 13 '25

READ THIS I am assuming this is not normal.

174 Upvotes

I was loading the car for work when I saw this. It felt and smelled like steam not smoke. Did I just catch it at the end of the cycle or is there a mechanical problem such as a stuck motor? It was 40° at the time and no rain. Heat was set to 70 and the house was 70.


r/hvacadvice • • 14h ago

HVAC tech says this is mold in my ductwork. Is he right, or am I being upsold? (The Woodlands, TX)

Thumbnail
gallery
359 Upvotes

Recently purchased a ~30-year-old home in The Woodlands, Houston TX area. Had an HVAC technician inspect my downstairs and upstairs system, and he showed me these photos from inside the ductwork/plenum for downstairs, claiming the dark spots are mold.

The home has original foil-covered flexible ductwork, and I’m concerned about whether cleaning could damage the aging ducts.

A few questions for the HVAC pros here:

  1. Does this actually look like mold, or could it just be accumulated dust/dirt?
  2. Is professional duct cleaning safe for 30-year-old flex ducts, or would replacement be better?
  3. Would you recommend cleaning, replacing the affected sections, or leaving everything alone?

I’m not opposed to spending money if there’s a real issue, but I’d rather address the root cause than pay for unnecessary cleaning or treatments.

Photos attached are from the downstairs HVAC system and the return vent.

Appreciate any advice!


r/hvacadvice • • 10h ago

How can I hide this huge return they just installed? Without blocking the airflow.

Thumbnail
gallery
88 Upvotes

I can get a new decorative cover, but the duct is SO visible behind it 😭


r/hvacadvice • • 5h ago

Dusty stringy things on filter

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

Can anyone tell me what these might be? They seem dusty. We normally change out filters every three months but went five on accident this time. Never seen this in previous changes. Some things that were different during this timeframe. We had two additional people who lived with us. They had two cats and one of them vaped. They also cooked on the gas cooktop a lot more than I did due to being home during the day.

Edit to add: the tenants vaped, not the cats. 😂


r/hvacadvice • • 43m ago

Continuous 5AMP Fuse Blow

2 Upvotes

I have a 5 year old Trane furnace and AC unit. I noticed an outlet in the kitchen stopped working and the local GFCI switch was not resetting the outlet.

I went to the breaker board in the garage and turned off all the breakers. When I turned it back on, the furnace stopped working.

I assessed the furnaces and saw code E12. This indicates a blown low amp fuse ( 5AMP). I replaced the 5 AMP fuse with the same one but as soon as I turn on the breaker for the furnace I can see a spark and the 5 AMP fuse blew again.

Any idea why this is happening? There is a short somewhere? But where and is the outlet and the furnace correlated?


r/hvacadvice • • 58m ago

apologizes for the silly question

2 Upvotes

This is probably a dumb question, but the gas valve needs to be completely turned on, correct? I had some people do some work, and they shut it off, and I can't remember if the gas valve needs to be completely on.


r/hvacadvice • • 2h ago

Water Heater Almost afraid to ask (now with photo)

Post image
2 Upvotes

6 year old gas water heater. My black hose, my pioneer woman sun tea jug Light bulb for scale Roughly 3 weeks of dribbling Water heater not in a high traffic spot, was dismayed to find it soaked digging for Halloween stuff. I heat gun dried all the wood, dragging feet to see what kind of rot/black mold I might encounter under it.

What's cause of the dribbling? This never been an issue and it had its service in august.

Cheap fix right? Twist of a handle somewhere ...? 😐


r/hvacadvice • • 8h ago

Being told my heat exchanger needs to be replaced and need a gut check

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

I had my semi-annual HVAC maintenance completed last week for the beginning of the heating season in the northeastern US after having skipped it for a year. I have a Goodman high efficiency gas forced air system (Model GMSS920803BNAA) and the tech informed me that there is rust on the heat exchanger and that it needs to be replaced. Given the age of the furnace (9 years old), the tech said that it might just be best to replace the whole unit. I’m including photos of the issue, which I can confirm are from my system.

I know that a busted heat exchanger is a true safety hazard so no questions about replacement if it is time but I am just trying to figure out if this is normal wear on a heat exchanger or a real issue. Also curious what people think in terms of replacing the heat exchanger only or just doing the whole furnace.


r/hvacadvice • • 2h ago

Filters Return duck

Post image
2 Upvotes

They used cardboard on return duct off the filter box


r/hvacadvice • • 5h ago

Water Heater Should I be worried

3 Upvotes

We just had the thermocouple replaced, and now our flame looks like this. [GE, propane]


r/hvacadvice • • 3h ago

Furnace humming on startup

2 Upvotes

My furnace recently has started humming/buzzing upon startup, and continues for a few minutes while the air starts to push out... I can only hear it through a vent at the other side of the house, I can’t hear anything around the actual furnace… wondering if anyone has experienced this before I pay someone to come look.


r/hvacadvice • • 3h ago

What is the value of a sealed Ford branded 30 pound bottle of r 12

2 Upvotes

r/hvacadvice • • 6h ago

Quotes About to start getting quotes for a new system. What to look out for?

3 Upvotes

I have an aging Carrier AC that is on it's last legs and a gas furnace that is about to be so it's time to upgrade

Where do I even start? I'm willing to put some money into it to get a good system so I'm more concerned about getting a contractor special kind of system that won't last me as long

What kinds of questions should I be asking and/or are there things I should avoid?


r/hvacadvice • • 11m ago

New furnace, flue concerns

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Just a simple furnace change out but I'm concerned with how the flue (exhaust vent) is set up. Lots of messy tape work and not sure if there are any screws or twist-and-lock connections under the tape. When I am running the furnace, the tape gets scalding hot, almost too hot to touch it. Would I be wrong to talk to the owner of the company and ask if this work is done to code?


r/hvacadvice • • 12m ago

Help!!

1 Upvotes

My furnace is making this buzzing noise. I think I’m able to fix it i just need to know exactly what it is. It is working and blowing hot air.


r/hvacadvice • • 9h ago

another professional furnace install

Post image
5 Upvotes

this is what true quality looks like. take notes.


r/hvacadvice • • 1h ago

Zone board and damper

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

In June 2026, I had my HVAC replaced. At the time, the zone board and damper system was in good shape and decided to keep it.

In the last five months, the HVAC company has had to come out because wires were somehow crimped and caught in some door. This caused a fuse to short out. (Sounds like a safety fuse of some sort.) Broke again and they had to replace the transformer. 4th time out, the wires were crimped again when the transformer was installed and caused it to short again.

Yesterday, they had to come out a fifth time. This time, they say that the zone board and damper system need to be replaced. I argue that the shorts in the wiring, due to poor install of the system, caused the zone board to short out. They refuse to acknowledge that.

Am I crazy to think this?


r/hvacadvice • • 1h ago

How interchangeable are 50A51 boards? (Looking to replace a -506 on an old Trane XV90)

1 Upvotes

So, I figure they made the different 50A51 models for a reason, and I believe that KIT09370 is the correct upgrade part for the CNT1819 (50A51-506) in my old XV90. But then I see this 21M51U-843 that, according to a promo sheet by Emerson, "Replaces most White-Rodgers 50A51, 50M51, and 50M61 two-stage HSI controls with 80V or 120V ignitor".

The only 50A51's specifically mentioned in the cross-reference are the -405 and the -495. But there are a lot of different ones, and that "most" certainly gets my attention. Did the -506 use a different voltage ignitor? (... but then, since this kit includes a new ignitor anyhow, is it just a concern about wire thickness?)

If this Emerson setup is close enough, I could just order one from SupplyHouse and have it in a couple days. Looks like the plugs would line right up with what I have (both in shape and in how they're wired). The Emerson one does cost a lot less - about $250 vs $900 for the KIT09370. But is it close enough or just the express ticket to frustrationville?

Thanks in advance!


r/hvacadvice • • 1h ago

Inside the air handler…

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Renting a unit in a building built back in the 60s, original Kritzer still holding on. Building came around to change the air filter for the season but didn’t do anything about the insulation(?) behind the panel. Tried my best to get a seal around those old panels with tape but on our last humid day they were sweating.

Should I be afraid of what’s on that panel? Can I vacuum it safely?


r/hvacadvice • • 2h ago

Does Lennox Make Coated Coils?

1 Upvotes

A little back story: Lennox HVAC system is ~2 years old and last fall started generating a dirty sock smell. I'm familiar with the smell as we had it in a prior home with a Trane system. The company that installed that system ultimately had Trane warranty the coil and it was replaced with a coated one. Smell gone and it never returned.

The HVAC company who the builder used to install the Lennox system has stated the system is operating properly and the smells are "normal" this time of year. The senior tech who came out after multiple other techs inspected the system with no resolution said, "I've been doing this for 30 years and have never heard of anything like this." So either he's lying or his experience is very limited.

Ultimately, they cleaned the coil and put a tablet in the drain pan to correct the issue. That worked for about a week before the smell returned. They wiped their hands of it and never followed up with me after I requested further remediation.

This spring, I had someone come out and clean the coils and ducts more thoroughly hoping to remove anything that would be causing the smell. Fast forward to this fall and the smell returned.

I reached out the builder hoping they could get some traction with the installer to have a coated coil installed. I've been told a coated coil for this system is not possible. I find that hard to believe and am hoping someone here can tell me if Lennox offers them and if so, is it a part that falls under a warranty claim?

TL;DR Does Lennox make coated coils?


r/hvacadvice • • 6h ago

Heat Pump Heat not working. Two different technicians, two different diagnoses.

2 Upvotes

Just bought our house in July. First time having a heat pump. The unit is from 2005 (previous owner rented the house out for 20 years). We knew replacing it would come up sooner rather than later. Heat has been working until a week ago. Now something is preventing heat from staying on. Turns on for a couple seconds and then shuts off.

The first company I had out came the next day. I wanted to start with a small business that could get out quickly. His diagnosis was that there was a leak in the unit and it needed refrigerant. The refrigerant it takes is R22 so he recommended replacing the whole unit. He also saw several "band-aids" that had been put on the unit over the years by the previous owner and questionable electrical work.

We also have a 2-10 home warranty that the previous owner gifted us. I wanted to have them out to see if they would cover the $5000 towards unit replacement. It took the company they sent us through a week to come out. His diagnosis was that the reversing valve is stuck in the cooling mode and if we replace that we should be good. He said that cooling is working fine.

Thoughts? Do I get a third opinion and mention both issues to that technician and see what they say? I realize that just because one technician says one thing, it doesn't mean the other part isn't also true. I just want to be sure I'm not replacing the whole unit when I don't have to. And on the other hand, I don't want to go the other route of having to wait on the home warranty to get the reversing valve replaced, then find out there's more to it, then have to wait even longer if there's more issues.


r/hvacadvice • • 14h ago

HVAC unit has been making this noise… is it normal?

9 Upvotes

We keep our fan on Auto, heat is turned on right now. It’s a chilly fall morning so I’m thinking the vaporization is probably normal. Though I’m a little concerned on the noise it’s making when it “turns off”. It came back on within probably 60 seconds of this video. We have a tech coming out to service it next week but wondering if I should be concerned and try to get someone out here quicker than next week? Can anyone tell me if this noise is “normal”? Thanks in advance!


r/hvacadvice • • 8h ago

How bad is this?

Post image
3 Upvotes

10 year old Trane system, central Florida. Tech recommended replacing the UV light and cleaning the blower. Also mentioned a fogging service for the ductwork. Thanks for taking a look!