TL;DR: Invited a friend to a concert. Caught feelings. After the concert, suggested we check out a Christmas market two weeks later. Decided yesterday I didn't want to wait that long and found out she didn't either. I'm floating on thin air.
A bit over two weeks ago, I (37M) invited a platonic friend, K (33F) to a concert. We'd never hung out one-on-one before, but most of my closer friends weren't interested or able to make it and I figured it would be fun. I did not expect to catch feelings in the process. They were very mild at first, but I asked a mutual friend what they thought: "Proceed with caution. She's never thought of you that way - not to say she never would. Just get to know her better as a friend. Worst case scenario, you become closer friends."
We went from messaging every once in a while about tattoos, dating woes, and travel, to messaging every day about more personal things. I was excited, but nervous for the concert - I knew she only saw me as a friend, and I didn't want to let on that there was anything there. I kept reminding myself, "act towards her the way you would towards any other platonic friend." Leading up to (and at) the concert on Saturday, I pulled it off. At the show we talked non-stop. At one point we even got physically close, more than platonic friends might even in a crowded space, and it wasn't uncomfortable. At one point, it felt like she leaned into it. I found out Sunday morning from the mutual friend: "K said you looked good yesterday. Also, she noticed you got close and was into it." Knowing how painfully accurate Casually Explained's "Is She Into You" is, though, I didn't read into it. Not even when K herself told me later that evening that I looked good, that she enjoyed our time alone together, and that she'd be happy to do it again. Not even when she ❤️ reacted to my message saying "You looked nice as well 😊 I'd like that."
K loves Christmas, so I suggested we check out a Christmas market on the 27th that we'd talked about. She said yes, and our conversations got flirtier, more playful, and more personal. All positive signs, but it felt ambiguous - like there was a romantic undertone, but also enough plausible deniability to say things were platonic. I figured I'd take things slow, consider the Christmas market a "not-date," and properly ask her out after that. I wanted time to both move at its current pace (I am enjoying getting to know her better) but also fast forward to next Friday so I could see her. Last night I decided Friday was too far away, so I invited her over for dinner and a movie this weekend. At best, I expected a "that would be nice" or "I'd like that."
I did not expect her to tell me she'd wanted to say that the Christmas market felt far away. I did not expect her to say she was excited by the invite and that she was looking forward to it. I did not expect the number of 😊 emojis between us or the ❤️ reactions to messages. And I did not expect her to suggest Die Hard as the movie.
So yeah. I'm pretty happy today.