r/heinlein • u/goodhidinghippo • 8h ago
Discussion Just finished Stranger in a Strange Land Spoiler
Just finished and would love a discussion!
This was my first Heinlein, and in the last couple years I've read some other classic Sci-Fi like Dune 1-6, Brave New World, Frankenstein, so it was interesting to compare and contrast.
First off it was an entertaining and interesting read. I appreciated the wit - especially of cranky polymath Jubal - which stylistically reminded me of Catch-22. And like any good story, I enjoyed that different characters had distinct perspectives and opinions that challenged each other (That said, by the end the biggest cynics, Jubal and Ben, were converted into Mike's church).
I appreciated the structure of how the book built its "argument", and also understand how that structure takes a while to reveal its purpose, which took some patience and could be off-putting for some readers. The story starts off with a fairly sociological take on how Earth would react to Mike's presence - mostly people trying to exploit him for personal gain. But then deus ex Jubal appears, to set everything straight. I kind of love it when an author inserts themselves directly into their world, and felt like Heinlein was doing that here. Jubal is almost a thought experiment of a dude with unlimited liberal powers of law and medicine and art and philosophy who is free to do whatever he wants and express himself freely. A similar thought experiment to the God Emperor Leto II in my reading.
The first half of the book was a lot of Ben and Jubal and Jill, through mastery of law and politik and plain good will, seeking real justice for the naive but powerful Valentine Michael Smith as they introduce him to bring human. At times it felt like a near-future All The King's Men political thriller, with one genius at the center trying to unravel everything along with a cynical journalist fighting for the truth and a simple but caring nurse. That was fun!
The second half of the book was where things got weirder, more controversial, and more interesting. We left behind justice and turned to sex and religion - oh boy! The Martian/Michael ideals of free love and an absence of jealousy were interesting to explore, and I felt like Heinlein was really trying to make an argument here for real world people letting go of their hangups. Patty, the tattoo'd snake loving circus performer being closest to Michael in the end, the concept of Thou Art God, along with the political sections, spoke to a dislike of social hierarchies and institutional reigion which spoke to me.
Digging into the Fosterites and their satirically capitalistic religion felt right out of the Righteous Gemstones. The glimpses of Foster and Digby - and later Michael - as Old Ones was genius I think. So surprising and confusing at first, but ultimately they made sense and were really entertaining. In the end the story structurally resolved itself really beautifully into Michael's worldview and his Church - even Jubal was brought logically in tow by way of Occam's Razor. And Michael's experience as a carny paired perfectly with his evolution into a religious leader, even though he saw his Church as a mere tool, something people could grasp to introduce his otherworld ideas.
The ending was spoiled for me by Reddit unfortunately haha but I felt like Michael's sacrifice was very appropriate, very Jesus-y, and in character.
I still felt a tinge of queasiness at the cannibalism at the end but that was also appropriate in the story and heavily foreshadowed. I don't think Heinlein was advocating for that (even if he was seemingly actually advocating for Free Love) but rather prodding tabboos and other societal norms, which science fiction is perfect for. In the end that's what the book was, putting a mirror up to humanity - law, government, religion, and sex - using a Stranger. All wrapped in a fun story.
I have my critiques of course. There was plenty of blatant mysogyny which made me cringe. And I felt like the characters themselves were a little one dimensional, even Jubal, for all his intellectual complexity. I never really felt that attached to any of them, except perhaps Jill, who's just doing her best and trying to help people, although she's reduced to her "dottiness" and curvy form more than once, as is Patty. Most of the women are "dotty", blatantly subservient, and vain. I did enjoy Michael's evolution into a more complete Earthican and was cheering for him, but but he was always a little distant, they all were.
4/5. I was entertained and it was challenging, so I'd love to hear your thoughts!
