r/IndianLeft • • May 30 '24

💬 Discussion A brief note on how the electoral CPI(M) betrayed the indian revolutionary cause.

79 Upvotes

The CPI (marxist) a political party in india currently in power in the state of Kerala betrayed the cause of indian communism by siding with reactionaries.

Many people on the left including non-indian leftists seem to have a soft spot for the CPI(M) , many seem to think of them as the last bastion of the left in India. They praise the high literacy rates and the higher life expectancy , but what they are uanble see is the reactionary nature of the party and the atrocities they have committed.

For some context : India is a semi feudal country under the grip of neo-imperialism by the imperial core. One system of opression that still persists in India is caste oppression which is based in the ownership of land. The untouchable castes (dalits) disproportionately make up the landless peasants population, while the oppressor castes generally own disproportionate amount of land, there are also middle castes who own some land but not a lot, calculations[1] by scholars Nitin Tagade and Sukhadeo Thorat, based on the All-India Debt and Investment Survey, show that members of the Scheduled Castes, who account for 18% of the country’s households, own only 8.5% of the land in India. On the other hand, upper-caste Hindus, who make up 22% of the households, own 28% of the land, Caste isnt just confined to the rural parts of india, but also the urban parts although it’s orgins are in ownership of land, people are frequently not hired and not allowed to rent homes because of their caste in urban india too.

What has kerela done to address this system of oprression? Perhaps they have redistributed land ? Maybe collectivized agricultre? They did redistribute land but only above a certain land ceiling , big landlords still remained. Infact huge swathes of dalits and indigenous people in kerela are still landless. Among the landless population, indigenous people are overepresented. You the reader might ask what offical data we have , we do have date but not on a large scale ,why? Because the “communist” goverment refuses to do a caste census! It refuses to reveal how much wealth which castes have, because that would reveal the monopoly of certain castes economically. Triple exclusion of dalits in Land Ownership in kerela[2], a study published in the journal Social Change, shows that low rate of land ownership by them is the result of a exclusionsary policy by the goverment! Does this sound like something a communist goverment would do?

This isn’t all. The goverment has also been involved in massacares of dalits. The Marichjhapi massacre, when dalit refugees from bangladesh came to indian they settled in Marichjapi. Schools and hospitals were built and many were involved in pisciculture. A press blackout followed and survivors today say[3], huts were burned, woman were raped, wells poisoned. The survivors of the massacare still to this day have not gotten any Justice.

These are not the actions of a communist party but a reactionary one doused in red paint and communist aesthetics. Even today, the first dalit leader in the politburo of the party was only admitted in 2022, 58 years after it’s creation, how utterly shameful.

I hope by this article I am able to convince you, the reader ,why as leftists we shouldn’t support the CPI(M).

Sources: 1. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/2394481118808107 2. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0049085716654814 3. https://thewire.in/history/west-bengal-violence-marichjhapi-dandakaranya


r/IndianLeft • • Nov 18 '25

🗞️ News [ Removed by Reddit ]

145 Upvotes

[ Removed by Reddit on account of violating the content policy. ]


r/IndianLeft • • 10h ago

💬 Discussion CPM leader Anil Basu shouldn't have said that in 2011. Do you think it costed a long term credibility damage? Translation below

8 Upvotes

"The girls who live in Sonagachi (a sex worker area of Kolkata), they don't even look at normal customers when rich customers come there.

Mamata is being paid by the USA, why will she consider the Indian (Chennai, Bangalore) clients. I am asking her, which rich client is paying you that much?"


r/IndianLeft • • 8h ago

Watch this

Thumbnail facebook.com
1 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft • • 1d ago

🎨Revolutionary Literature and Art Comrades in Mumbai visit Janchetna Book Stall at Mumbai Book Festival

Post image
11 Upvotes

Readers in Mumbai!

If you enjoy progressive and revolutionary literature, Janchetna is THE place to be. We have been working really hard these past few days to procure the best books from around the country and make them available at one place, that place being the Janchetna stall at Mumbai University's Kalina campus, where the Mumbai Book Festival is set to take place between 24th and 29th November. You can visit the stall anytime during these days between 11 am and 10 pm. We are really excited to meet you and share our love for books.

See you!

https://www.facebook.com/share/r/1HtrWZmuqn/

https://www.instagram.com/reel/Df1mFGHMBnj/


r/IndianLeft • • 1d ago

🪧 Activism Prizma needs more activists!

Thumbnail
forms.gle
4 Upvotes

For those who dream of a world devoid of exploitation and oppression of humans by humans , including Homophobia Transphobia, Patriarchy ...


r/IndianLeft • • 2d ago

💬 Discussion Govt taking down Instagram posts and accounts critical of government

14 Upvotes

Media not with Public, Jantar Mantar denotified, Govt taking down social media posts and accounts critical of their actions. How can one continue dissenting in such an environment?


r/IndianLeft • • 3d ago

💻 Media An Editorial on 'Dharti Abba' : Birsa Munda 🥀

Thumbnail gallery
9 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft • • 3d ago

🪧 Activism Communist LGBTI* Group Held Street Corner against Fascism and Patriarchy

Thumbnail instagram.com
10 Upvotes

Yesterday Prizma held a street-corner program against patriarchy and fascism. The progressive and democratic LGBTI* people also stand in solidarity with the students of SRFTI against saffron terrorism by the patriarchal, homophobic, and transphobic Hindutva fascists ie RSS-BJP. These very fascists, like the RSS-VHP, have taken a stand to protect the feudal patriarchal family structure and opposed the decriminalization of homosexuality in 2018 during its two days conference these year. The street-corner was also against the ongoing SIR-NRC project and the new anti-transgender laws by the fascist government.

Regarding the recent media interactions of the RSS chief, our position is clear: merely saying that LGBTI people have always been a part of Indian society (by Mohan Bhagwat) means nothing at all, especially when RSS-affiliated organizations like the VHP have taken a stance against the decriminalization of homosexuality and the government remains totally silent on the democratic and civil rights of LGBTI people, such as same-sex marriage. This is hypocrisy.⁡

⁡⁡


r/IndianLeft • • 4d ago

LaRgEsT DeMoCrAzy Despite having visa,she is not allowed to enter

53 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft • • 4d ago

💬 Discussion Unpopular Opinion: Mfers talking about wanting to beat up NEers deserve the Mussolini treatment idgaf

Thumbnail gallery
32 Upvotes

Bcoz HOW TF are ppl racist towards an entire community, some of who chose to be part of the wretched union of India even after repeated injustice. Ts legitimately boils my blood.


r/IndianLeft • • 4d ago

🗞️ News '1.27 Crore Hindu Voters Deleted' In UP SIR? In Prayagraj, Many Muslim Voters Struggle to Get Back on the Rolls - The Wire

Thumbnail
thewire.in
3 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft • • 4d ago

⏳ History The Making of Hegemony

5 Upvotes

Gramsci, one of the greatest Marxist to ever live, had said that in order to rule politically, a class has to rule culturally first. This makes the study of the history of culture absolutely essential for communists who want to establish the hegemony of the proletariats. The point of this piece is to present to you a nuanced version of how Hegemony is made. In doing so it is important to counterpose it against an already dominating and incorrect understanding of Hegemony that is quite popular on the left.

The understanding of Brahmanic Hegemony quite popular on the left is the Ambedkarite view. This view takes the existence of class society as a given and sees the consecutive non brahmanic castes as mindless imitators of the Brahmin caste (see. Caste in India 1916), thus becoming subsumed in the Brahmanic Hegemonic fold. But this is not how a ruling historical block is created. Such a pseudo psychological explanation of hegemony risks falling into equally pseudo psychological individualised solutions like marrying someone from a different caste. This is definitely a positive thing and should be encouraged but it is far from the actual solution.

This is where the historian Suvira Jaiswal comes in with a much more nuanced historical view. She shows that making of hegemony is a much more complicated process. The subalterns (the subordinate classes) are not subsumed in hegemonic culture without resistance. In fact she shows that the making of a hegemon is a process of constant negotiation and renegotiation between the ruling class and aboriginals. The inability of the vedic apparatus to inculcate the subaltern to the brahmanic worldview is precisely what gave rise to the Puranic apparatus. Then the purnanic apparatus too had to accommodate aboriginal deities/symbols/legends in the mainstream pantheon to negotiate its position as the hegemon. This is a process that is far more complicated than what Ambedkar understood and what Ambedkarites understand today. The prestige of the intellectual class or the Brahmins was never a given but rather manufactured by a long process of cultural negotiations in which the aboriginals made their own place in the Brahmanic mainstream. Symbols such as the boar, fish, lion, snake juxtaposed with Vishnu points towards a sort of differential assimilation in which the aboriginals were integrated into the Brahmanic caste order by accommodating aboriginal symbols into the mainstream Brahmanic pantheon. This process of differential assimilation can be still observed even today. In the North Eastern parts of India many aboriginal tribal groups exist whose customs show residue of pre class way of life. Yet the village chiefs (often called Gaonbura) in collaboration with the state have become capitalists. In relation to the cases where there was a strong secessionist impulse like in the case of ULFA (United Liberation Front of Asom), the ruling class had first used repressive forces against the secessionists but then accommodated them into state bureaucracy after their surrender. This process of a combination of repression and accommodation characterise what is called differential assimilation as can be seen from the next example.

The symbol of the horse deity Hayagriva is an excellent case study in this exercise as given by Jaiswal. The horse symbol was much older in Assam than other parts of the subcontinent. The horse came to this region from central Asia much earlier than in most other regions so it was symbolised and revered as a deity. We see a contradictory tendency when it comes to the horse deity in the Hindu pantheon. Sometimes Hayagriva is depicted as a protector of the Vedas other times as someone who steals the Vedas and gets slayed by the main Brahminic gods. This suggests that the Brahminic hegemony was not accepted passively by the devotees but rather it was a long process characterised by constant conflicts and truce. In this process the upcoming hegemon concedes to the interests and aspirations of the subaltern groups. The welfare states in modern times all over the capitalist world are examples of such concessions granted to buy the loyalty of the subaltern groups.

To show this is not something unique to India but rather a historical process as a whole I want to draw your attention to the symbolism of the dragon and its importance in Asia and Europe. It has been well established by historians that many ancient cultures revered the snake. The dragon deity is said to be only a mythologised version of the snake. The most interesting thing to note is the differential treatment of this snake/dragon symbol in Europe vs in Asia. In Europe various ancient cultures like Celtic, Gaulish, Welsh etc revered the snake and dragon most famous of which is Ouroboros symbol. With the coming of Christianity the dragon and snake were depicted as evil beings. We can point at the endless number of stories of knights (the warriors of God no less) slaying dragons but the most famous case is the snake that tells Adam and Eve to eat the forbidden fruit from the garden of Eden thus setting in motion the original sin.

In contrast, see the different treatment of the dragon in the far eastern cultures. In China for example, the Dragon is still revered as a holy symbol that brings good luck and prosperity. The idea of the snake or dragon being a malevolent monster is completely alien to this land. In one instance a dragon, namely Mucalinda, who is said to be the king of the Nagas (or the serpent king) is depicted as the protector of the Buddha. In another instance, the Buddha tames a venomous dragon (or serpent) that lived in the sacred fire, in order to convert the fire worshipping hermits led by the Kassapa brothers to his creed. It shows that when Buddhism arrived in these lands it had to accommodate the aboriginal snake/dragon symbol in the Buddhist pantheon. This is not a different hegemonic operation than the juxtaposition of the boar. fish, snake with that of Vishnu or the snake and bull with Shiva. The process of acculturation takes hundreds of years but it shows that it is not simply a straightforward process of many classes mindlessly copying a hegemonic class. Rather the hegemon is formed from a process characterised by many conflicts and negotiations.


r/IndianLeft • • 5d ago

Brahmanical Hindutva Fascism Hatred towards Buddha and Buddhism

Thumbnail gallery
14 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft • • 5d ago

🗞️ News Thoughts on the entire Jensen Huang Scandal?

1 Upvotes

I'm sure we've all heard of this news, given that its literally EVERYWHERE🤣 I wasn't even interested till social media kept spamming content related to this. I've mostly followed this via explainers on Youtube. Honestly, with regards to its impact on the AI industry as a whole, I doubt it will create a dent given that the company AMD (which happens to be owned by his cousin) is positioned to climb the ladder, along with a few a Chinese companies also seeing a rise in their fortune.

I've also seen ppl rubbish the claim that Chinese espionage is involved, and that this narrative is nothing but another scheme by Washington to ensure their monopoly over the AI market or something. Which I cannot sideline either, given that the Americans allegedly have known all along yet still chose not to inform him about one of his side pieces being a spy.


r/IndianLeft • • 5d ago

❓Questions Wanna understand more

8 Upvotes

So I've been leaning left (or so I think) this past year and I do wanna understand more on a specific topic that ppl on the left can be very defensive abt. Like I wanna know what and why without being called a liberal(it feels like a slur atp😭).

I've come across posts on other leftist or socialist platforms where there's multiple sides in regards to supporting China. Like I've seen some leftists criticize present day China becoming or presenting itself as capitalist and that there's restrictions that don't allow ppl to express dissent against the govt because their media is extremely regulated. And I've seen some ppl retaliate against this criticism with name calling and saying things that I genuinely do not understand. What I have understood from some informative comments is that we support the cause and under what little socialism China did have, it made huge changes for workers. And also defenses like China is not a true socialist state but it resonates with the ideology more so than its neighbouring countries. And that we cannot examine things in a black and white lense.

I just wanna like have better explanations than ppl just being super mean to eachother.


r/IndianLeft • • 5d ago

🎭 Meme/Comic The clown

Post image
6 Upvotes

Interested in seeing if one of them come here and comments like BJP IT cell mosquitos


r/IndianLeft • • 6d ago

🪧 Activism Street Corner against Patriarchy and Fascism in Kolkata

Post image
29 Upvotes

Prizma will be organizing a street corner in College street on 14th November at 2-30pm. We urge the democratic and progressive individuals, especially the democratic and progressive LGBTI* people to come !!!

Join in numbers!


r/IndianLeft • • 6d ago

Brahmanical Hindutva Fascism THE TREACHEROUS CONSPIRACIES OF THE SIR – ELECTION COMMISSION: THE FASCISTS EXPOSED! LET US STRIKE THEM DOWN! - Senkanal

Thumbnail
senkanal.com
6 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft • • 7d ago

🗞️ News BJP wins 77 civic seats in Tripura before voting even begins; (unopposed). CPM facing another electoral rigging against them.

Post image
39 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft • • 7d ago

🗞️ News 150+ Tribal Families threatened by the Maharashtra Forest Department, Thousands of Trees Already Axed!

23 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft • • 8d ago

Brahmanical Hindutva Fascism Saffron terror in Delhi: Fascist forces are a threat to even peaceful agitations! - Senkanal

Thumbnail
senkanal.com
10 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft • • 10d ago

💬 Discussion As an eco-socialist. Clean air should be a fundamental right for the working class.

Post image
81 Upvotes

Why is it that capitalists will let us breathe cancer, while urban working class will die without any safety net?

An air free of pollution should be our demand for the well being of our class. Do you agree?


r/IndianLeft • • 10d ago

Protest/March ☭ How unexpected 🙄

79 Upvotes

Oh no! The liberals signed some dumb bs! Who could've seen it coming? 🙄

Video credit: PEEK TV


r/IndianLeft • • 10d ago

Theory Labour and Creativity (Hindi)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
9 Upvotes

Dr. Taimur Rahman dismantles common economic myths from the misconceptions around classical political economy to the existential philosophy of Friedrich Nietzsche and explore the fundamental relationship between labor, creativity, and the capitalist crisis.

  • Myth 1: "Marx created the Labor Theory of Value" - The Labor Theory of Value (LTV) was the foundational discovery of Classical Economics, pioneered by Sir William Petty, Adam Smith, and David Ricardo.
  • Myth 2: "Creativity Is the Real Basis of Economic Value" - Creative innovation actually decreases the unit value of a commodity by reducing Socially Necessary Labor Time (SNLT), even as it floods society with material wealth (use-value).
  • Myth 3: "Creativity vs. Labor: A False Dichotomy" - Ideas don't build bridges or write code on their own. Creativity isn't an alternative to labor—it is the initial, conceptual stage of the labor process itself.
  • Myth 4: "Without Capitalists, Workers Would Be Idle" - We look at landmark organizational studies (Akerlof, Yellen, Herzberg, and the Hawthorne Experiments) proving that workers flee alienation and exploitation, but thrive when treated and paid well.

Theory playlist -