r/moviecritic • • 6h ago

In your opinion... Which Oscar-winning performance was the most indisputably well-deserved?

Post image
160 Upvotes

I mean a performance that was, without a doubt, the best of that year—even if there were other strong performances competing for the award.

There are certainly many, but the ones that come to mind right now are:

Meryl Streep — "Sophie's Choice" (1982).

Anthony Hopkins — "The Father" (2020).

What is your pick?


r/moviecritic • • 1d ago

Actors who are beloved despite a history of misconduct

Post image
4.2k Upvotes

just a few of many...

“Bill Murray’s ex-wife Jennifer Butler Murray accused the actor of assault, alleging that the Lost in Translation star hit her in the face in November 2007 and told her she’s “lucky he didn’t kill her.”

“The funnyman reportedly paid an approximately $100,000 settlement to a “much younger” female crew member on his latest film, Being Mortal, which suspended production in April after the then 71-year-old actor straddled her while on the set.”

“Richard Dreyfuss described Murray as an “Irish drunken bully.”

“Geena Davis alleges that Murray made her lie on a bed while he used a massage device on her, “the Thumper,” during the making of 1990’s Quick Change. “I said no multiple times, but he wouldn’t relent.”… “The point of this story is not to reveal that Bill Murray has a very dark side; that’s hardly news”

“Seth Green was just nine years old when he appeared on Saturday Night Live, where he says he had an unpleasant encounter with Murray backstage…Murray picked him up by his ankles and dangled him over a trash can while saying, “The trash goes in the trash can.”…”He dropped me in the trash can, the trash can falls over. I was horrified. I ran away, hid under the table in my dressing room, and just cried.”

“Oscar winner Anjelica Huston described Murray as “a shit”

“Charlie’s Angels star Liu claims that Murray hurled “inexcusable and unacceptable” comments at her during a rehearsal on the set of the 2000 action-comedy… Liu responded by allegedly throwing punches at the comedian.”

Laura Ziskin, producer of What About Bob? said “Bill also threatened to throw me across the parking lot and then broke my sunglasses and threw them across the parking lot.”

"Charlie’s Angels” director McG claimed Murray once headbutted him...“An inch later and my nose would have been obliterated”. Murray dismissed McG’s headbutt allegation as “complete crap,” adding that the filmmaker “deserves to die” for leveling it.


r/moviecritic • • 13h ago

Gary Oldman has to be one of the most versatile actors out there.

Post image
276 Upvotes

What's your take? Who according to you has versatility in choosing movies and characters?


r/moviecritic • • 1d ago

Be direct... who is the worst actor or actress you have ever seen?

Post image
5.7k Upvotes

I mean, someone who simply cannot act to the point where you can’t even understand why they keep getting roles.

These are just two examples, and there are certainly others.

What is your pick?


r/moviecritic • • 8h ago

Frank's Terror Lies in Henry Fonda's Calm Entrance

Post image
31 Upvotes

I had a private watch of Once Upon a Time in the West on my RayNeo GT. What sells this movie for me is the way Sergio Leone and Henry Fonda handle Frank in that opening scene.

After the McBain family gets wiped out and the killers step from the brush, the camera finally swings around to reveal the boss right before he shoots the last kid. There's Henry Fonda, carrying that quiet, reliable vibe we know from his classic heroic parts. He plays it with this unsettling calm.

That's the stroke of genius. If they'd cast some regular tough-guy actor as the railroad's hitman, the scene would just come off as plain vicious. But Fonda holds onto that familiar, steady energy while doing something horribly cruel. It feels deeply off to watch. Seeing the iconic screen hero stay so composed while doing evil in this film is what makes the character so terrifying.


r/moviecritic • • 22h ago

Is Crash (1994) Actually Good?

Post image
306 Upvotes

I still remember the first time I stumbled upon this movie and Videodrome.

I consider Crash the embodiment of the “90’s” feel.
For some reason, the characters’ silence was more profound than the dialogues.

The city feel. The industrial vibe.
The “platinum daylight” color shading.

I fucking love this movie.
But just like Midsommar. It’s a movie I cant figure out why I love it. Nor do I know what it’s REALLY supposed to mean.

I get that the sexualization and the accident fetishized thing is not for everyone.

But i cant deny how good this movie was made.
It really felt like a piece of art. A movie that was saying something. A movie that didnt try to hammer in its thoughts on you. A movie that didnt JUDGE its own characters.

I’m really curious how people think about it.

Is it a “misunderstood “ movie?


r/moviecritic • • 10h ago

Emily Browning, actress in SUCKER PUNCH, AMERICAN GODS, LEMONY SNICKET'S A SERIES OF UNFORTUNATE EVENTS, GHOST SHIP, SLEEPING BEAUTY, and lots more, is doing an AMA/Q&A in /r/movies today for anyone interested. Her new dark-comedy, THE FOX, is out in theaters soon.

Post image
19 Upvotes

I organized an AMA/Q&A with Australian actress Emily Browning. You may know her from things like SUCKER PUNCH, AMERICAN GODS, LEMONY SNICKET'S A SERIES OF UNFORTUNATE EVENTS, GHOST SHIP, SLEEPING BEAUTY, THE AFFAIR, CLASS OF '07, and lots of other stuff.

The AMA post is live here now in r/movies for anyone interested in asking a question:

https://www.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/1xzf5hs/hi_reddit_im_emily_browning_you_may_know_me_from/

She will be back at 7:45 PM ET today to answer questions. I recommend asking in advance. Please ask there, not here. All questions are much appreciated!

Her new dark-comedy, THE FOX, is out in theaters everywhere in 2 weeks. It co-stars Jai Courtney, Olivia Colman, Miranda Otto, and the late Sam Neill.

Trailer: https://youtu.be/_XEZHlWlZ_o?si=Zqoi6MoIZSpcZ2hm

Synopsis: In this darkly comic folktale, an affable foxhunter encounters a talking Fox who offers him an opportunity to transform his fiancée into the perfect woman.

Thank you :)


r/moviecritic • • 12h ago

People need to ease up on the interviewer here

Post image
20 Upvotes

Bond has always been heavily controlled by the Broccoli Family and has since been passed off to Amazon.

It’s not a stupid question to ask how much say Denis has during a shakeup in management that’s always been heavily controlled.. and I don’t think Denis got that which is why he gives such a weird response in sayin his control is “Massive” then staring at the dude.


r/moviecritic • • 4h ago

“I Play Rocky” directed by Peter Farrelly, starring Anthony Ippolito, Anna Sophia Robb, Toby Kebbell, P.J. Byrne

6 Upvotes

What makes this film work is that it captures the same feeling audiences had in 1976:
Hope.
The belief that ordinary people can achieve extraordinary things.
That's a message we could all use right now. In theaters this weekend, are you planning to watch it? Let me know what you think. Here’s my full review:

https://roselawgroupreporter.com/2026/11/keiths-movie-korner-i-play-rocky-is-a-knockout/


r/moviecritic • • 22h ago

What Movies Were Critics and/or Audiences Unusually Hostile Towards?

Post image
121 Upvotes

I know a lot of the dislike for The Cable Guy came from expectations of a certain brand of Jim Carrey comedy that was at it’s peak of popularity at the time. I think the unexpectedly dark tone and sometimes uncomfortable subject matter weren’t what people were looking for from the richest paycheck a comedic actor had received to that point.

In hindsight, this film brilliantly foreshadowed a world that already was and would soon become even more fascinated with true crime and criminality as entertainment. It also weirdly predicts parasocial relationships before we even really had the words for it.

In my personal opinion, The Cable Guy is the Taxi Driver of the 90s, brilliantly predicting an epidemic that hadn’t even happened yet.

Any other movies get a similarly bad rap?


r/moviecritic • • 3h ago

Who was the best Bond of all time?

0 Upvotes

There have been many actors who played 007, and people have very different opinions on them, but some of them definitely felt more 007 than others. Who's your favorite Bond and why? How do you think Robert Pattinson will be compared to the previous actors who played Bond?


r/moviecritic • • 5h ago

‘The Hunger Games – Sunshine on the Reaping’ movie review: a sharply cynical commentary changes standard prequel beats ⭐️⭐️⭐️✨

Thumbnail
faroutmagazine.co.uk
3 Upvotes

While frequently overstuffed and not entirely satisfying for those who don’t have a built-in affinity for where the franchise is headed, Sunrise on the Reaping is imminently watchable based on the slick craftsmanship from Francis Lawrence, who has nailed the style and tone of the series. This is the rare franchise that takes advantage of the IMAX format and commits to the inherent maximalism of its manufactured reality.

How much more steam The Hunger Games franchise has left isn’t clear, but Sunrise on the Reaping offers a return to what has made the series work, matched with the enthusiasm of a new generation.


r/moviecritic • • 1d ago

Josh O'Connor reportedly took himself out of bond casting, and I think it's a brilliant choice.

Post image
473 Upvotes

As we all know it's now confirmed that Rob pattinson is the new bond.

The same source earlier reported that Rob has the better deal from Amazon, i.e; just 3 movie deal and 1 million more than his competitors. Others have larger movie deals involving 4 to 5 movies. It seems pretty illogical to spend so many years doing a single IP. It is better to go for some good projects rather than tying himself down for a single project.

And also Denis villenueve is one of the main reasons this project has gained so much craze. Denis is going to Direct only one bond movie for Amazon and he will be going on to his next projects after this. The other bond movies gonna be directed by random Russos. So there is no guarantee those movies gonna work out well.

Rob pattinson may have gotten the deal now but he may regret this decision in the future when the bond movies take up the time and restrict from going on to other good projects just as he is tied down to batman 2. It's been 6 years since part 1 and there is no confirmation when it is going to be completed and when Matt reeves is gonna be back.

So I think It is good for Josh that the casting did not go in his favour.


r/moviecritic • • 12h ago

The judge is one off the best legal dramas from 2010s

Post image
10 Upvotes

In this movie Robert Downey Jr is playing the lawyer who went beck to his hometown to defend his father in court. Robert Duval got Oscar nomination for this movie and he definitely deserved.


r/moviecritic • • 1d ago

What do y'all think of Marilyn Monroe as a actress

Thumbnail
gallery
114 Upvotes

r/moviecritic • • 7h ago

12 Classic Gangster Movies Everyone Must See

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/moviecritic • • 5h ago

Batman movies tournament

Post image
2 Upvotes

Complet a draw (semifinals and the final!)


r/moviecritic • • 6h ago

Episode 257 - How to Rob a Bank (2026) Review - Overall, I thought it was a fun time. The third act devolves into a pretty standard heist movie. 2.5 out of 5.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

I'm pleasantly shocked a movie with this kind of message (9/10 times people could successfully rob a bank) would be allowed out into the world in these times.


r/moviecritic • • 1d ago

Did Sean Connery’s performance in Red October hurt Alec Baldwin’s chance of landing Patriot Games and C&PD?

46 Upvotes

Baldwin was the headliner until McTiernan landed Connery for the role of Captain Ramius. Connery completely stole the film with his screen presence. Thoughts?


r/moviecritic • • 2d ago

Robert Pattinson has been cast as the next James Bond

Post image
19k Upvotes

r/moviecritic • • 5h ago

Tim Burton movies tournament

Post image
0 Upvotes

Complete a draw (quarters, semis and the final!


r/moviecritic • • 21h ago

Charade (1963): 3/5

Post image
16 Upvotes

I liked how it took itself seriously and then would sprinkle in some funny lines. There were some repetitive moments, which made it drag on a little, but I enjoyed it overall. It’s officially a comfort watch.


r/moviecritic • • 1h ago

Review: Phantom India (2026)

Post image
• Upvotes

🎬 Phantom India (2026)

A journey through the streets, temples and artistic traditions of India, with a mystery unfolding along the way.

I had the opportunity to watch and review Phantom India, directed by Marlin Darrah. The film offers a fascinating glimpse of Indian culture, beautiful locations and a story full of questions.

Read my review on Moon Glimmer!
https://moonglimmermagazinex.blogspot.com/2026/11/movie-phantom-india-2026.html

#PhantomIndia #MovieReview #FilmReview #MoonGlimmer #IndianCinema #IndependentFilm


r/moviecritic • • 1d ago

Actors with the looks and chops, that you thought should’ve been A listers with longevity.

Thumbnail
gallery
638 Upvotes

Elisha Cuthbert. Edward Burns.


r/moviecritic • • 2d ago

Robert Pattinson’s filmography is crazy

Post image
2.7k Upvotes

He’s in Harry Potter, Twilight, Batman, Odyssey, Dune and now James Bond.