r/onednd • • Oct 07 '26

Moderator Announcement MODERATOR ANNOUNCEMENT: Wizards of the Coast Unionization Efforts.

361 Upvotes

Some of you may already be aware that employees at Wizards of the Coast are pursuing unionization efforts. There is also a petition circulating for those who wish to express their support.

For anyone interested in learning more or supporting the effort, you can find the petition here:

https://actionnetwork.org/forms/uwotcpetition/

Sharing this information should not be interpreted as an endorsement or opposition by the r/onednd moderation team. We're simply making the information available to members who may be interested.

Unfortunately, previous discussions surrounding this topic have repeatedly devolved into personal attacks, hostility, and violations of our community rules. We've had to remove multiple posts and comments, shut down discussions, and issue bans as a result.

We recognize that people have strong opinions about this subject, and they're entitled to those opinions. However, disagreement does not excuse treating other members disrespectfully.

For the time being, we will not be hosting further discussions about this topic in r/onednd. This announcement is being provided for informational purposes, and comments will be locked. Additional posts attempting to restart the discussion will be removed.

This is not a judgment on the merits of unionization or anyone's position on the issue. It's a moderation decision based on the conduct we've encountered and our responsibility to maintain a civil community.

Thank you for understanding.

The r/onednd Moderation Team


r/onednd • • 3h ago

5e (2024) The D&D Next last playtest packet gave Fighter advantage on all saves. Would you rather have that, or Indomitable in its current form?

32 Upvotes

So as I said, the D&D Next last playtest packet featured a version of Indomitable - albeit as a 13th level feature - that gave Fighter advantage on all saving throws.

(At 9th level they instead gained a feature called Defy Death, which let them drop to 1 HP instead of 0 if they succeeded on a DC 15 CON save - essentially acting as a pre-death save. This feature had no use limits either.)

This was obviously canned on release, and the much more modest 1/long rest version was printed.

5.5e went in a different direction, and rather than increasing the number of uses, it increased the chance of success.

A lot has changed since then, there's been substantial power creep, and it also became clear that what happens at tier 3 and 4 is largely irrelevant to the majority of tables.

So here is my question.

**If you were playing a Fighter, would you rather have Indomitable in its current form, or would you rather have advantage on all saving throws starting from level 9?**


r/onednd • • 7h ago

5e (2024) What content from D&D: WoW do you plan to use outside of Azeroth?

30 Upvotes

I just got the FoundryVTT module for Dungeons & Dragons: World of Warcraft, and I fully intend to strip it for parts that I can use in non-Azeroth campaigns. I'm already aware that WotC has a list of content from the book that they're allowing for general use in officially organized campaigns, but what else do you think is ripe for the taking?

The Professions system I've already decided to make full use of. In fact, I overhauled it to line the professions up with the different tool profiencies in 5.5e instead of forcing everything to match the specific professions that exist in WoW. Instead of 14 professions, the version I'll be using at my table has 24. I'm also grabbing the Inscription Adept feat that was in that part of the book.

The Tauren Species is basically a new version of the Minotaur from Mordenkainen Presents: Monsters of the Multiverse when you compare their abilities, so I'm treating it that way.

I'm debating whether or not to let the Beast Master Ranger in my current Greyhawk campaign use the Beast Mastery Hunter's Pet Specialization feature instead of the base Ranger's Roving feature once she reaches Level 6. That plus letting the Primal Companion use the Weapon Mastery feature, which the Hunter also does.

I have to grab the Philosopher's Stone. I'm too big a fan of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood to leave that on the table, LOL. That new Figurine of Wondrous Power should also fit right in besides the ones from the DMG.

Anything else seem good? What would fit in other settings? What would feel too out of place? What would be well-balanced? What would be utterly broken? I wanna hear people's perspectives.


r/onednd • • 1h ago

Poll How should D&D handle saves at Tier 3 and 4?

6 Upvotes

It's a well known design flaw that saving throw math breaks down in the upper tiers of play, with numerous monster abilities and spells requiring saving throws that are either impossible or statistically unlikely in late game for anyone not proficient in them. These are often save or suck spells, meaning you take players out of the game completely without intervention.

D&D 5.5 addressed this with a variety of QoL improvements, such as upgrades to Indomitable, adding more save proficiencies to Rogues slippery mind, adding more Feat support for auto saves (Mage Slayer), and being more liberal with Heroic Inspiration (which gives you reroll opportunity for failed saves.

However, it didn't do anything to help the basic math problem. This can be slightly addressed by either:

  • Giving a flat bonus to all saving throws starting in T3 (half proficiency will grant between +2 to +3 to all "bad" saving throws. This pushes most T3 saves (17-19) to a 15-30% success rate, and pushes most T4 DC saves (21-23) out of 0% chance saves into passable territory.
  • Giving all classes a third save proficiency either in T3 or T4. This provides classes more coverage without having to burn a feat, while still providing glaring weak points that need addressed by feat spend and class abilities.

This matches the design philosophy of most earlier editions of D&D, which featured good saves and bad saves that both increased at different rates.

This doesn't fix the fact that some High CR creatures DCs will still be untouchable without help, but it will lessen it without impacting build options.

Would you want to see rules like these implemented, or do you think requiring parties to build around specific class save bonuses like Paladin Aura, Flash of Inspiration, and Bardic Inspiration dice along with taking Feats to improve save chance is sufficient?

All other fix ideas are very welcome.


r/onednd • • 17h ago

Other D&D Beyond Hit With Massive Malware Attack

Thumbnail
dungeonsanddragonsfan.com
65 Upvotes

D&D Beyond was one of hundreds of websites serving malicious code to visitors on November 16th. I put together this article about what happened and how to tell if you may have been impacted.


r/onednd • • 11h ago

Discussion Do "Martial Spells" have a place in 5.5e's design?

18 Upvotes

I will start by saying i am terrible at balancing, so what I'll say will only cover stuff like "making playing more fun" and "giving interesting options" and other buzzwords :3

Martial Spells? By "martial spell" i mean a "X/rest" ability that isn't a spell but functions with the same laser focus specificity (most spells are very clear in how they work - detect thoughts, for example, doesn't say "you read a creature's thoughts" but comes with VERY specific action, range and saving throws; and it's still one of the most "needs the dm to come up with something" spells!). They should, ideally, come of both In combat and Out of Combat Utility.

Cool Thing Button. I think it's very easy to feel bored playing a martial, even despite the amount of effects you apply between different attacks, masteries, brutal criticals and cunning strikes. Having a "do cool thing" button eases that burden. In addition, it's a very cool way to make a "signature" ability for your character/class that differentiates them in combat from other martials.

Out of Combat Utility. The fact that martials are beholden to the ability check system to interact with the world means that anything more specific than "stealth" required both a player to push the rules and a dm to make up rulings on the fly. Having a specially worded ability with specific rules would solve that problem.

Justifying limitations. Not being tied to magic makes it harder to justify a "X/rest" limitation. Why can the fighter only jump supernaturally far once?

Nonmagical Abilities. The biggest problem is the difficulty of coming up with strong yet decidedly non-magical abilities (i don't mind magical abilities, i think most subclasses can reasonably have them, but you need at least some nonmagical ones!). The abilities can (and should) be supernatural (for example, i wouldn't mind a fighter being so good at insight that he can replicate the effects of detect thoughts, or a ranger being so good at natural medicine that he can do some form of special healing that rivals cure wounds or lesser restoration) but shouldn't, for example, create matter or fire from nowhere. I still think it's an interesting challenge and i think it's very doable, but I'm not sure the difficulty is worth the payoff.

Mimicking Spells. We can cut out some work by simply making abilities that mimic spells. Can a barbarian shout so loud it induces a Fear spell? Sure! A rogue knows arcane so well he can Dispel Magic within 5 ft? Hell yeah!

A common system. I think it's important for these abilities to occupy a shared system (call them, Specialities or something) that allows for a common design space to be occupied. Also i think feats should be able to give these "Specialties".

Design Space. It is imperative that these "spells" aren't only attacks with extra effects, in the way battlemaster manouvers are.


r/onednd • • 8h ago

Discussion Are we underrating Entropic Embrace?

6 Upvotes

Most discussion of the new Entropic Embrace spell seems to be negative. I'd like to challenge that.

Advantage on attack rolls is quite easy to come by. Elven Accuracy feat is a popular Feat, and, if your roll has Advantage, raises the chance of proccing Entropic Embrace from 5% to 14.5%. Trying to proc the spell on your attack rolls maximises the chance you will still have your Reaction.

E.g. Suppose a dual-wielder attacks 4 times on their turn with Advantage. 52% chance that Entropic Embrace will proc. A 3-beam Eldritch Blast with Advantage gives a 39% chance. A level 5 Scorching Ray with Advantage gives a 68% chance! At these rates, this is not an once-in-a-blue-moon spell, it will proc almost every combat. And Entropic Embrace, when cast, is certainly very powerful.

As a result, for Elves with reliable sources of Advantage on attack rolls, I think this is an extremely strong spell. Casters who take it may want to carry around Entropic Embrace Spell Scrolls, so that they can still cast it as a Reaction on their turn without falling afoul of the "only one spell slot per turn" rule.

I am not suggesting building around this spell, or taking Elven Accuracy simply for this spell. But if you were going to take Elven Accuracy anyway, I think this spell is well worth taking, whether as a Warlock, a Void Elf, the Shadow Touched feat, or some other means.

Context and Background:

For those who don't know, the new WoW book contains the spell Entropic Embrace, a level 1 Necromancy spell for Warlocks. It lasts 1 minute, doesn't require Concentration, makes you automatically succeed all Concentration saving throws, and makes wherever you are standing Lightly Obscured. It also does a little bit of extra damage or healing once per turn. That's undoubtedly excellent for a level 1 spell.

However, you can only cast Entropic Embrace when you roll a d20 with Advantage or Disadvantage, and roll the same number on both dice. Even if the roll has Advantage or Disadvantage (many won't), that's only a 5% chance to cast the spell. And it costs your Reaction, which you may already have used by the time (e.g.) the Saving Throw comes around. So most discussion I have seen says that taking this spell isn't worth it, because you will so rarely get the chance to cast it.


r/onednd • • 1d ago

Discussion I think that the designers build for “vibes” too much

136 Upvotes

I’ve listened to quite a few design interviews for what goes into the creation of a subclass within 5.5 design. And something that I hear a lot is ensuring that the subclass “feels like the class fantasy that we’re trying to achieve”. Which is a laudable goal and one that they absolutely should be trying to get to. My issue is that it often feels like “crunch” and the numbers that support that feel are secondary.

I sometimes feel concerned that it seems like the designers are far less concerned about “is this idea for a class ability mechanically sound and satisfying?” as opposed to the idea of “does this class ability satisfy the fantasy we’re looking for”.

The latter question absolutely should be asked. I don’t think any class ability should be shipped out out of the door that doesn’t fit the fantasy of the class. But I also think that a lot of very flavorful subclasses get left by the wayside by the player base because they are undercooked mechanically.


r/onednd • • 8h ago

Self-Promotion Shore of the Dorahin: Update 1.3 | Official Trailer

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

Life is crazy sometimes in indie TTRPG dev.

After some delay, I’m happy to present our update 1.3 for Shore of the Dorahin.

Inside you’ll find:

  • 5 Pre-Generated Characters (Level 1): Complete with backstories connected to the region, ready to fast-track your Session 0.
  • Custom Redesigned Character Sheets: Interactive fillable PDFs improving character management, 5e compatible.
  • New Regional Map.
  • Everything is 100% FREE as part of the core oneshot module.

And everything is FREE still for our newsletter subscriber !
https://joust-studio.com

We have a ton more coming down the pipeline for the Songs of Lon-Gora universe !


r/onednd • • 15h ago

5e (2024) Lichdom for Eldritch Knights

6 Upvotes

Liches in the Unearthed Arcana playtests seem like they synergize really well with EKs with the ability to regain a combined 4 levels of spell slots and use Chill Touch to paralyze. This is of course a little campaign dependent as if you're not fighting humanoids you're overall less effective. I'm curious as to the viability of Lichdom as opposed to a more traditional EK. For my own character, I plan to go with GWM, Mage Slayer, Lich Initiate, Undead Grasp, and either Lich Ascension or Arcane Restoration aiming for a 20/18 or 20/20 split between Strength and Intelligence. I'm not entirely sold on Lich Ascension's benefits outside of lore. I'd be giving up on things like War Caster, Resilient Wisdom, Fey-Touched, and Heavy Armor Master but I'm not sure if it's worth it.


r/onednd • • 7h ago

5e (2024) D&D 5.5 Eldritch Knight spell list at tier 3

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/onednd • • 54m ago

5e (2024) Class and Subclass Adjustments

0 Upvotes

Heyy, hello! So, I've been playing D&D for quite some time now, almost 6 years since I started. One of the DMs I played with introduced me to some small corrections to certain classes, and seeing those changes made me wonder: "Which classes and subclasses are falling behind due to their mechanics or numbers?"

This isn't meant to be a rework of any of the game's content, but rather a collection of small adjustments to existing classes and subclasses. I know some people will question why I made certain changes, so I'll explain my reasoning below.

Classes I Didn't Change

Bards: I'm not tweaking the best class in the game, sorry not sorry. Both mechanically and flavor-wise, the Bard is SO far ahead of the classes that actually needed tweaks.

Fighters, Barbarians, Clerics, Warlocks, and Artificers: For Fighters, Barbarians, Clerics, and Warlocks, I genuinely think they're mostly perfect the way they are. They fulfill their class fantasies and don't fall behind other classes when it comes to what they're supposed to do best.

For Fighters and Barbarians, the reason I didn't make any changes is that I thought, and still think, most of their problems come down to whether the weapons they get are good or not. Since I homebrew a lot of magic items, I haven't encountered many problems that didn't disappear the moment I gave them a good magic weapon.

I also have a mechanic called Advanced Weapon Masteries, which provides three different options depending on the weapon you're using. Technique focuses on defense, Speed is about moving around the battlefield more effectively, and Strength increases your average damage. In this system, Fighters and Barbarians are the only classes that can choose more than one Advanced Mastery, allowing them to use options associated with different weapons.

For Clerics, I only tweaked the Trickery Domain because I found it heavily underwhelming. Other than that, I think Cleric is one of the best-designed classes in D&D. I really don't see much room to argue that it lacks either flavor or power.

Warlocks are probably, in my opinion, the best-designed class in D&D, and that's largely because of Eldritch Invocations. I DO NOT, I repeat, I DO NOT, think every class should be as customizable as the Warlock, but I do think Eldritch Invocations are the perfect mechanic for the class.

As for Artificers, I think they're in the same situation as Rangers: both need a full-scale rework rather than a few small adjustments. I've already done that for the Artificer, but since I'm not nearly as interested in completely reworking the Ranger, I decided not to do the same for it.

Now, for What WAS Changed

Sorcerer: We all love our Sorcerers casting multiple spells per round, and I genuinely think it fits the fantasy of a bursty, chaotic spellcaster that the Sorcerer represents. However, I wanted to make sure that whenever they do this, they're aware that they're spending a significant amount of resources.

Rogue: I don't think the Rogue has any real problems outside of combat. As long as you're a good DM who actually understands how ability checks work, your Rogue shouldn't feel weak outside of combat.

In combat, however, both the base class and some of its subclasses fall behind. Because of that, I increased the number of Sneak Attack dice starting at level 10. I didn't introduce this increase any earlier because Rogues are already pretty strong at lower levels and don't really need it.

For the Soulknife and Assassin, I identified some weird mechanics that were holding them back. The Assassin dealing a teaspoon of extra damage once per combat is honestly trash, and the Soulknife is stuck using a weapon that never gets stronger, despite actively needing to use it for its subclass features.

Monk: I don't think there's anything wrong with Monks themselves. They're probably among the five best classes in the game. However, both the Warrior of Shadow and Warrior of the Elements feel like they get NOTHING for several levels. So I tried to build upon the existing ideas behind these subclasses to give them more interesting things to do.

Wizard: I know what people are going to say: Wizards don't need buffs. And I would agree IF these changes weren't being applied to my own campaigns, where I actively give my players powerful magic items.

This tends to put spellcasters in a much more balanced position compared to martial classes. When your Fighter has a +2 weapon that deals an additional 2d6 damage in tiers 2–3, they can actively outperform the Wizard in certain situations.

On top of that, most other spellcasters have some pretty strong class mechanics or are simply so good at their specific roles that they can outperform Wizards in those areas.

The buffs I gave Wizards mostly target their late-game features, which I find pretty lackluster. My goal was to reinforce their identity as the class that always has a tool for almost every situation, while also maintaining their versatility as a skill monkey.

Druid: Yeah, this class is dogshit.

I know some people will say Druids are broken, but as far as I'm concerned, the only decent subclasses are Stars and Moon, and even those are pretty lackluster.

Moon becomes dogshit beyond level 8, and Stars barely gets any substantial scaling throughout its progression, which honestly pisses me off to the moon.

The base Druid also gets some pretty underwhelming numbers for no apparent reason. Both Wild Companion and Wild Shape are practically useless to most Druids because of how poorly their numbers scale, and the class generally lacks a meaningful feature in tier 4.

As for the subclasses, I think they're moving in the right direction, but neither of them really offers enough to justify spending my action economy on their features.

And just to make something clear: I also think the Druid spell list sucks ass. Most of its spells are way too situational or simply weaker than what other spellcasters get. That's precisely why I think Druids should have something meaningful to do besides casting spells.

Paladin: Paladins are fine. I just made a small adjustment to let them retain some burst damage potential without bringing back the ridiculous burst they had in 2014.

Ranger: In my opinion, Rangers fall behind in practically every aspect. The only time they really feel good is when they're among the best DPR classes in the game, around level 3.

These changes are meant to make the Ranger's actual gameplay stronger and more enjoyable, not to fix every problem I have with the class.

THE ACTUAL CHANGES

CLERIC

Trickery Domain

Your Invoke Duplicity feature gains the following additional benefit:

Many Faces. When you expend a use of Channel Divinity to create a duplicate with your Invoke Duplicity feature, you can create one duplicate at level 3, two duplicates starting at level 9, and three duplicates starting at level 17. Whenever you move one of your duplicates, you can move all of them.

DRUID

Your Wild Shape and Wild Companion features receive the following changes. In addition, starting at Druid level 18, you gain the Primal Instinct feature.

Wild Shape. The maximum Challenge Rating of the forms you can assume with this feature equals one-quarter of your Druid level (CR 1/4 at level 1, CR 1/2 at level 2, and so on), instead of the value shown in your Wild Shape feature's table.

Wild Companion. When you cast Find Familiar using this feature, you can choose one of the familiar's normal forms or the form of another Beast or Plant with a Challenge Rating of 1/4 or lower, such as a Wolf, Violet Fungus, or Elk.

The maximum Challenge Rating increases to 1/2 at Druid level 5, 1 at level 9, and 2 at level 13.

In addition, once per turn, when you take the Attack action, you can forgo one of your attacks to allow your familiar to make one attack.

Primal Instinct. Starting at level 18, when you expend a use of your Wild Shape feature, you gain a bonus equal to your Wisdom modifier for 1 minute. During that time, whenever you make a D20 Test, you can add this bonus to the roll after seeing the result of the d20 but before the DM determines whether the test succeeds or fails.

Once you add this bonus to a roll, you lose it. You can have only one bonus from this feature at a time.

Circle of the Moon

Your Circle Forms feature gains the following additional benefit:

Additional Forms. When you assume a form using your Wild Shape feature, you can choose a Plant or Monstrosity, provided it doesn't have the Shape-Shift trait, in addition to Beasts.

The maximum Challenge Rating of the forms you can assume with Wild Shape is rounded up.

Circle of the Sea

You gain the Protective Tide feature at level 6 and the High Tide feature at level 14.

Protective Tide. Starting at level 6, a creature in your Wrath of the Sea form gains Temporary Hit Points equal to your Wisdom modifier (minimum of 1) when it enters that form and at the end of each of its turns while it remains in that form.

High Tide. Starting at level 14, creatures of your choice within the Emanation of your Wrath of the Sea feature have Disadvantage on attack rolls against any creature other than the one around which the Emanation is centered.

Circle of the Land

Your Land's Aid feature receives the following changes:

Land's Aid. You can use this feature as a Bonus Action instead of taking the Magic action. In addition, you add your Wisdom modifier to the damage and healing rolls made with this feature.

Starting at level 10, the effects of this feature occur again at the end of your next turn after using it.

Circle of the Stars

You gain the following additional benefit at level 14:

Star Map. When you assume your Starry Form, you can choose to gain the benefits of two constellations instead of only one.

SORCERER

Your Quickened Spell and Twinned Spell Metamagic options function as follows:

  • Quickened Spell. When you cast a spell that has a casting time of an action, you can expend a number of Sorcery Points equal to 1 plus half the spell's level (round up) to change its casting time to a Bonus Action.
  • Twinned Spell. When you cast a spell that targets only one creature and doesn't have a range of Self, you can expend a number of Sorcery Points equal to the spell's level (minimum of 1) to target a second creature within range with the same spell. To be eligible, the spell must be incapable of targeting more than one creature at the level at which it's being cast.

ROGUE

Your Sneak Attack feature receives the following change:

Sneak Attack. Starting at level 10, the damage dice of this feature progress as shown in the following table, replacing the normal progression.

Rogue LevelSneak Attack
106d6
117d6
128d6
139d6
1410d6
1511d6
1612d6
1713d6
1814d6
1915d6
2020d6

Assassin

Your Assassinate feature receives the following changes:

Surprising Strikes. During the first round of each combat, you have Advantage on attack rolls against any creature that hasn't taken its turn yet. If you hit a creature with your Sneak Attack during that round, it takes extra damage of the weapon's damage type equal to your Rogue level.

These benefits also apply when you make an attack against a creature while you have the Invisible condition, provided it knows neither your location nor your likely location.

A creature knows your likely location if you're within 20 feet of the last location where it detected signs of your presence.

Soulknife

Your Psychic Blades feature receives the following change:

Psychic Blades. The damage die of your Psychic Blade increases according to the progression of your Psionic Energy Dice. The damage die of the second blade, used with a Bonus Action, remains one die size smaller than that of the first blade.

MONK

Warrior of Shadow

Your Shadow Arts and Shadow Step features receive the following changes:

Shadow Arts. You can see normally in Dim Light and Darkness, both magical and nonmagical, within 60 feet of yourself.

Shadow Step. Starting at level 17, when you use your Shadow Step feature, you can expend 2 additional Focus Points to use Flurry of Blows as part of the same Bonus Action.

Warrior of the Elements

Your Elemental Attunement feature receives the following changes:

Elemental Strikes. Starting at level 11, while your Elemental Attunement is active, once on each of your turns when you hit a creature with an Unarmed Strike, you can deal extra damage of the same type as the attack equal to your Wisdom modifier.

Alternatively, you can expend 2 Focus Points to replace the damage of that attack with the effects of your Elemental Burst feature without taking the Magic action.

Starting at level 17, you no longer gain the Empowered Strikes benefit of your Elemental Epitome feature. Instead, the once-per-turn limitation of Elemental Strikes no longer applies.

Elemental Defense. Starting at level 18, while you're under the effects of both your Superior Defense and Elemental Attunement features, you gain Immunity to one damage type of your choice: Acid, Cold, Fire, Lightning, or Thunder. You can change the chosen damage type at the start of each of your turns.

WIZARD

Your Arcane Recovery, Memorize Spell, Spell Mastery, and Signature Spells features receive the following changes:

Arcane Recovery. Starting at level 9, you can also use this feature as an Action without needing to finish a Short Rest.

Memorize Spell. When you use this feature, you can replace a number of prepared spells with other spells from your spellbook equal to your Intelligence modifier (minimum of one spell), instead of replacing only one.

In addition, whenever you gain the benefits of your Arcane Recovery feature, you can also use Memorize Spell.

Spell Mastery. You can choose two Wizard spells of level 2 or lower from your spellbook, instead of one level 1 spell and one level 2 spell. These spells don't need to have a casting time of an action. You always have these spells prepared and can cast each of them at its lowest level without expending a spell slot.

Signature Spells. You can choose two Wizard spells of level 3 or lower from your spellbook, instead of two level 3 spells. You always have these spells prepared and can cast each of them at its lowest level without expending a spell slot.

Evoker

Your Overchannel feature gains the following additional benefit:

Overchannel. During the turn in which you use this feature, your spells affect even creatures that would otherwise avoid their damage. When you miss with an attack roll made as part of one of these spells or a creature succeeds on a saving throw against one of them, the creature takes at least half the damage it would have taken if the attack had hit or the saving throw had failed, but suffers none of the spell's additional effects.

PALADIN

Your Paladin's Smite feature receives the following change:

Paladin's Smite. Once per turn, when you cast Divine Smite, you can do so without expending a Bonus Action.

RANGER

Your Tireless, Relentless Hunter, and Foe Slayer features receive the following changes. In addition, starting at level 18, you gain the Unwavering Focus feature.

Tireless. The Temporary Hit Points granted by this feature increase to 1d10 plus your Ranger level (minimum of 1).

Relentless Hunter. The damage die of your Hunter's Mark spell increases to 2d6.

Unwavering Focus. Starting at level 18, when you cast Hunter's Mark, you can choose to cast it without requiring Concentration. If you do so, the spell's duration becomes 1 minute.

Foe Slayer. The damage of your Hunter's Mark spell increases to 2d8 instead of 2d6.

These are the adjustments I've been working with, based on the kinds of characters, encounters, and magic items I tend to use in my campaigns.

I'm not claiming these changes are universally necessary or that they would work equally well at every table. They're meant to address the issues I've personally encountered while playing and DMing.

I'd love to hear what you guys think, particularly whether you've encountered similar problems with these classes and subclasses. And if you are interested in more of my homebrew and other stuff I create, go check my Patreon.

Which of these changes would you actually use at your table, and which ones do you think go too far?


r/onednd • • 21h ago

Discussion Which adventure has the best all-purpose Magic Items?

2 Upvotes

Like the title says, I’m wondering which adventure comes with the best magic items that would be good in any campaign? So for example Princes of the Apocolypse, even though it has really cool magic items, would not be a good candidate since many of the items are cursed, one of a kind Legendary weapons, or require an Elemental Node to recharge. Meanwhile the Runic Magic items in Storm King’s Thunder are flavorful, versatile, and would be fun no matter what adventure you’re playing. What other adventures have great items?


r/onednd • • 5h ago

Discussion We need to talk about Monk Weapons (And the November D&DB Drop)

0 Upvotes

In light of the most recent D&D Beyond Drops, I feel the need to rant a little. Hopefully my ranting will resonate with some people, and if not then I'd be curious to hear opinions.

Frankly, I find the current selection of weapons for a Monk really dumb. And this is made worse with the latest Drop, so I'll explain my gripes with that first.

So, in the latest Drop we get the following new weapons:

  • Bola (Martial Ranged - 1 Bludgeoning - Finesse, Thrown, Topple)
  • Pitchfork (Simple Melee - 1d8 Piercing - Reach, Two-Handed, Push)
  • Weighted Chain (Martial Melee - 1d8 Bludgeoning - Finesse, Heavy, Reach, Two-Handed, Graze)

Cool! New weapons types, each with distinct uses and very unique visual identities! But... Lets look closer.

First off, the Pitchfork is perfect. Exacty what you'd expect from a farmer's tool.

Now lets look at the Weighted Chain. Its Finesse, which is cool and certainly fits the intended visual for the weapon. But its also a melee Heavy - meaning it requires 13 Str - so its already messing with pure Dex builds. The rest of the properties all make sense, so thats good. Damage.... Its the lowest in the entire Two-Handed melee weapon with a 1d8, and its the only Martial Melee Reach weapon to not be a d10. WHY?! To balance for Finesse? You've already got to compensate for Heavy!! It simply makes no sense! Remove Heavy and I'd be ok with the dmg, but as it is the weapon just ends up feeling...pointlessly nerfed See edit for why this is redacted

And the Bola... Historically a hunting weapon, as confirmed by the description. WHY IS IT MARTIAL THEN?! This is the same as the Blowgun, in that WotC placed them in Martial for seemingly no good reason. Make them Simple weapons and the usage for them would be FAR more enticing (A Wizard True Striking with a Blowgun/Bola?! Thats cool!)

Now to actually reach the main topic: Monk Weapons

Simply put: Why are they so limited?! They have Simple Melee Weapons, and Light Martial Melee Weapons. Thats it. I presume it's to encourage melee combat rather than using a Martial Arts die on a Shortbow and zipping around the battlefield? But honestly...why prevent that at all?

Also, why only Light Martial Weapons?! There are Martial Finesse Weapons right there that have no particular reason to not be included!

What I propose, is that Monk Weapons should be: Simple Melee, Finesse Martial Melee and Thrown Weapons.

That way Monks can actually use weapons that scream "agility-based" without being actively nerfed by the inability to use their Martial Arts die. It would make Whips actually relevant! It would allow for Fencing-style Monks and would allow monks to use the new Weighted Chain, making the classic Meteor Hammer fighting style possible in general play. Oh and it would also make Darts relevant again after they completely dissapeared due to Monks no longer having access to them as Monk Weapons!

TL:DR

The November Drops weapons seem poorly implemented with questionable dmg for one and weird classification for the other. And Monks deserve access to all Thrown weapons and all Melee Finesse weapons in their Monk Weapon lists, for the sake of encouraging variety in builds without excessive tradeoffs.

Edit:

Having been reminded that Polearm Master does NOT require the weapon to be a polearm - despite the name - I now understand better the choices made for the Weighted Chain. So for now I'll excuse that design choice and instead criticise Polearm Master for being poorly worded lmao


r/onednd • • 19h ago

Homebrew World of Warcraft Tinker for 5.5e?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/onednd • • 1d ago

5e (2024) Thoughts on Rogue + War Cleric multiclass?

48 Upvotes

It seems to do everything rogues want.

  • Divine Order gives you proficiency with martial ranged weapons.
  • Guided Strike turns a miss into a hit. Very important for a class that isn't making extra attacks.
  • War Priest lets you use your bonus action to get sneak attack off, leaving your main action free to cast a spell or ready an attack for an off-turn sneak attack.

The downside is delaying Rogue features, but I'm looking at them, and the only thing I would miss for a few levels would be Reliable Talent.

Plus, "Church Assassin" would be fun to roleplay.


r/onednd • • 16h ago

Homebrew Revising some Barbarian features

0 Upvotes

Level 1: Rage (revised)

You can imbue yourself with a primal power called Rage, a force that grants you extraordinary might and resilience. You can enter it as a Bonus Action if you aren’t wearing Heavy armor. You can enter your Rage the number of times shown for your Barbarian level in the Rages column of the Barbarian Features table. You regain one expended use when you finish a Short Rest, and you regain all expended uses when you finish a Long Rest. While active, your Rage follows the rules below.

Damage Resistance. You have Resistance to Bludgeoning, Piercing, and Slashing damage.

Rage Damage. When you make an attack using Strength—with either a weapon or an Unarmed Strike—and deal damage to the target, you gain a bonus to the damage that increases as you gain levels as a Barbarian, as shown in the Rage Damage column of the Barbarian Features table.

Strength Advantage. You have Advantage on Strength checks and Strength saving throws.

No Concentration or Spells. You can’t maintain Concentration, and you can’t cast spells.

Duration. The Rage lasts until the end of your next turn, and it ends early if you don Heavy armor or have the Incapacitated condition. If your Rage is still active on your next turn, you can extend the Rage for another round by doing one of the following:

  • Make an attack roll against an enemy.
  • Force an enemy to make a saving throw.
  • Take a Bonus Action to extend your Rage.

(new) Your Rage is also extended on your turn if you took damage from an enemy since the end of your previous turn.

Each time the Rage is extended, it lasts until the end of your next turn. You can maintain a Rage for up to 10 minutes.

Level 1: Unarmored Defense (revised)

While you aren’t wearing any armor, your base Armor Class equals 10 plus your Dexterity and Constitution modifiers. You can use a Shield and still gain this benefit. (new) While your Rage is active, this base Armor Class increases by 1.

Level 7: Feral Instinct (revised)

Your instincts are so honed that you have Advantage on Initiative rolls.

Primal Defiance. (new) While your Rage is active, if you fail an Intelligence, Wisdom, or Charisma saving throw, you can expend one use of your Rage (no action required) to reroll the save, adding your Rage Damage bonus to the new roll. You must use the new roll.

Level 9: Brutal Strike (revised)

(changed) If you use Reckless Attack, you can forgo the Advantage granted by Reckless Attack on one Strength-based attack roll of your choice on your turn; the roll still has Advantage if another source grants it. The chosen attack roll mustn’t have Disadvantage from any source. If the chosen attack roll hits, the target takes an extra 1d10 damage of the same type dealt by the weapon or Unarmed Strike, and you can cause one Brutal Strike effect of your choice. You have the following effect options.

Forceful Blow. (changed) The target is pushed up to 15 feet straight away from you. You can then move up to half your Speed straight toward the target without provoking Opportunity Attacks.

Hamstring Blow. The target’s Speed is reduced by 15 feet until the start of your next turn. A target can be affected by only one Hamstring Blow at a time—the most recent one.

Level 18: Indomitable Might (revised)

If your total for a Strength check or Strength saving throw is less than your Strength score, you can use that score in place of the total.

Hardened Fury. (new) While your Rage is active, when an attack deals Bludgeoning, Piercing, or Slashing damage to you, you also have Resistance to any other damage that attack deals.

Level 3: Totems (revised)

This feature replaces the Barbarian’s Primal Knowledge feature. (new) You gain proficiency in another skill of your choice from the skill list available to Barbarians at level 1. In addition, you can coalesce elemental spirits into a totem that aids you and your allies. As a Bonus Action, you can plant one of the totems below into the ground in an unoccupied space you can see within 10 feet of yourself. (changed) A totem is a Small object that has AC 15 and Hit Points equal to twice your Barbarian level, and it lasts for 1 minute, until it drops to 0 Hit Points, or until you use this feature again. At the end of each of your turns, the totem pulses with elemental energy that fills a 30-foot Emanation.

Earthbind Totem. Each enemy in the Emanation has its Speed reduced by 10 feet until the end of your next turn.

Primal Knowledge Totem. (changed) You and each ally in the Emanation are empowered with nature’s focus until the end of your next turn. While empowered in this way, a creature has Advantage on ability checks using the following skills, and it can make such a check as a Strength check even if it normally uses a different ability: Acrobatics, Intimidation, Perception, Stealth, or Survival. After you plant this totem, you can’t do so again until you finish a Long Rest. You can also restore your use of this totem by expending one use of your Rage (no action required).

Tremor Totem. (changed) You and each ally in the Emanation have Immunity to the Charmed and Frightened conditions until the end of your next turn. If a creature was already Charmed or Frightened, those conditions are suppressed until the end of its next turn. After you plant this totem, you can’t do so again until you finish a Long Rest. You can also restore your use of this totem by expending one use of your Rage (no action required).

Wind Rush Totem. (changed) You and each ally in the Emanation gain a 10-foot bonus to Speed until the end of your next turn.


r/onednd • • 1d ago

5e (2024) Burning condition and shadows

6 Upvotes

In the new wow book there is a new feat called hit streak which causes creatures you attack with a fire spell to start burning.

To stopp burning you can take an action to give yourself the prone condition and roll around. Or doused, submerged, or suffocated the fire.

A shadow is immune to the prone condition. Does that mean, RAW, that a shadow can’t end the burning condition on itself (unless it somehow doused, submerged, or suffocated the fires)?

Edit: Solved!
“If you have Immunity to a damage type or a condition, it doesn't affect you in any way.”


r/onednd • • 1d ago

5e (2024) How Good is Hot Streak EK?

12 Upvotes

I know Eldritch Knight's aren't the best users of Hot Streak but it seems downright silly the amount of burning they can generate especially at later levels. With the combination of Green-Flame Blade, Conjure Minor Elementals, and perhaps an enspelled Elemental Weapon or Searing Smite, you can proc it on every attack if not more. Of course, a two weapon fighter might make the best use of this but I'm partial to GWM. My question isn't really about whether or not this is viable but rather how strong this would be compared to other semi-optimized builds. Is it better than Spirit Shroud? Are other EK builds just straight up better? I'm curious to see what everyone thinks.


r/onednd • • 2d ago

Character Building The Gojo: A Mystic Arts Monk "true tank" build (tanks AND solos 2 CR 7 Young Black Dragons, at level 8)

40 Upvotes

As far as "traditional" melee tanking goes, this build does it pretty well.

Defensively, you can stack Shield, Deflect Attacks, Patient Defense dodge, Evasion, Absorb Elements. Optionally add Blade Ward and Mirror Image.

Control-wise, you can cast Web, grapple/prone opponents (potentially into your own Web or Create Bonfire), Stunning Strike, and Booming Blade if you want that. With the Grappler feat, you get to do damage, stun, and grapple a creature all in a single hit. Stunned creatures auto-fail grapple and shove-prone saves,

Being able to replace an attack with a cantrip unlocks strong Action economy for options like Booming/Greenflame Blade, Create Bonfire, and Blade Ward.

The monk starts solid and also scales well into higher tiers (global saving throw proficiency, global damage resistance, etc.).

Flavor-wise, I imagine this character as similar to Gojo Satoru from Jujutsu Kaisen, whose ability causes attacks to never reach him, while being a strong hand-to-hand fighter with sorcerer magic mixed in.

Level progression: Straight monk is fine. You can dip rogue 1 or fighter 1 but I'll assume we don't.

Species: Pick your favorite, but a couple recommendations:

  • Hill Giant Goliath lets you turn Large (to grapple Huge+ creatures), and you can inflict prone without a save.
  • Wood Elf is great for getting you Pass Without Trace.
  • Haranir (from WoW book) gets you Spike Growth at 5th level.
  • Human is cool too

Feat choices:

  • Origin Feat: Pick your favorite, but I like Lucky for the help with Saves.
  • Level 4: Grappler.
  • Level 8: I'd prioritize DEX to 20, since it increases a ton of different rolls for you.
  • Level 12: +2 WIS, War Caster, Inspiring Leader, or Mage Slayer. I'd probably Mage Slayer, unless the party needs temp HP, in which case I'd go Inspiring Leader.
  • Level 16: Take something that gets your WIS to a nice, even number.

Spell choices:

  • Cantrips: Green Flame Blade or Booming Blade. Blade Ward and Create Bonfire are nice to have. Utility options include Prestidigitation, Mage Hand, Minor Illusion, Mending, etc. Mind Sliver is a trap option IMO, the debuff is too small to be worth using your secondary stat.
  • 1st level: Shield, False Life (unless you have another source of temp HP), Absorb Elements. Jump is nice to have.
  • 2nd level: Web. Nice to have: Misty Step, Mirror Image, Suggestion.
  • 3rd level: Cacophonic Shield, Slow. Maybe Hypnotic Pattern/Fear if your campaign doesn't have prevalent fear/charm immunity at this level. Counterspell nice to have.
  • 4th level: Nice to have: Dimension Door, Fire Shield, and Polymorph.

Case study: Soloing two CR7 Young Black Dragons (at Monk level 8)

The monk faces 2 Young Black Dragons in a white room with a low ceiling.

"If this battle was outside, it might be a little tough," the monk said.

"Would you lose?" one of the dragons asked.

The monk smirked. "Nah, I'd win."

Each Young Black Dragon has 18 AC and 128 HP. They can make 3 attacks a turn, at +7 and 12.5 average damage. They have a rechargeable breath weapon that does 49 damage (DEX save for half, DC 14)

The monk has 20 DEX, 16 WIS, and 14 CON. They pre-cast False Life at 2nd level (59 HP + 14 THP = 73 total), which has a 1 hr duration.

The monk's opening setup is to hit + stun + grapple (with Grappler feat) + shove prone (or use Hill Goliath's auto-prone feature), focusing on the first dragon until it dies. Once setup is done, monk uses blade cantrip for extra damage. The monk can use Create Bonfire or Web here to synergize with grappling + dragging, but let's keep it simple and instead just cast Blade Ward as part of the opening setup.

With Advantage from Grappler, the monk does ~36 DPR against the first dragon with Flurry of Blows, finishing it in 3.5 rounds once it's grappled and prone, or ~4.5 rounds including grapple/prone/Blade Ward setup. DPR drops to about 28 vs 2nd dragon, once Flurry of Blows runs out, but it's still enough to KO in 4.5 rounds (~5 including stun/grapple/prone setup).

The monk has +8 to DEX saves, meaning 75% of the time they take 0 damage from the acid breath, and 25% of the time they take ~24.5 damage, which they can mitigate with Lucky. On average the breath attacks are doing ~4 damage.

The monk has 18 AC, meaning the dragons have 50% base hit chance, going down to 37.5% with Blade Ward, 12.5% with Blade Ward + Shield, and 2% with Blade Ward + Shield + Prone. With 2 dragons alive, assuming the first is stunned 50% of the time and prone 40% of the rest of the time, the monk spams Shield, getting hit around 3*0.125 + 3*(0.4*0.02+0.1*0.125) = 0.43 times per round for ~6.7 DPR.

With 1 dragon alive, the monk probably runs out of Shield and Focus Points (except 1-2 saved to try and setup Stun+grapple+prone combo), but can keep it prone 80% of the time comfortably, and gets hit 3*(0.2*0.375 + 0.8*0.375^2) = 0.56 times per turn. The monk can absorb most damage through Deflect Attacks, leaving ~3 DPR afterwards.

Overall the monk finishes both dragons off in 9-10 rounds. Total damage taken is 4.5 turns * 6.7 DPR + 5 turns * 3 DPR = 45 damage total, surviving with about 28HP.

The monk is barely bloodied.


r/onednd • • 1d ago

Homebrew Revising some Rogue features

0 Upvotes
LevelPBClass FeaturesSneak Attack
1+2Expertise, Sneak Attack, Thieves' Cant, Weapon Mastery1d6
2+2Cunning Action1d6
3+2Rogue Subclass, Steady Aim2d6
4+2Ability Score Improvement2d6
5+3Cunning Strike (revised), Uncanny Dodge4d6
6+3Expertise4d6
7+3Evasion, Reliable Talent5d6
8+3Ability Score Improvement5d6
9+4Subclass feature6d6
10+4Ability Score Improvement, Cunning Resolve6d6
11+4Improved Cunning Strike8d6
12+4Ability Score Improvement8d6
13+5Subclass feature9d6
14+5Devious Strikes (revised)9d6
15+5Slippery Mind10d6
16+5Ability Score Improvement10d6
17+6Subclass feature11d6
18+6Elusive11d6
19+6Epic Boon12d6
20+6Stroke of Luck12d6

Level 5: Cunning Strike (revised)

You've developed cunning ways to use your Sneak Attack. When you deal Sneak Attack damage, you can add one of the following Cunning Strike effects. Each effect has a die cost, which is the number of Sneak Attack damage dice you must forgo to add the effect. You remove the die before rolling, and the effect occurs immediately after the attack's damage is dealt. For example, if you add the Poison effect, remove 1d6 from the Sneak Attack's damage before rolling. If a Cunning Strike effect requires a saving throw, the DC equals 8 plus your Dexterity modifier and Proficiency Bonus. (new) If a creature succeeds on its saving throw against one of your Cunning Strike effects, it has Disadvantage on the next saving throw it makes against your Cunning Strike effects before the end of your next turn.

Distract (Cost: 1d6) (new) You open the target's guard. The next attack roll one of your allies makes against the target before the start of your next turn has Advantage.

Poison (Cost: 1d6) You add a toxin to your strike, forcing the target to make a Constitution saving throw. On a failed save, the target has the Poisoned condition for 1 minute. At the end of each of its turns, the Poisoned target repeats the save, ending the effect on itself on a success. To use this effect, you must have a Poisoner's Kit on your person.

Trip (Cost: 1d6) (changed) If the target is Huge or smaller, it must succeed on a Dexterity saving throw or have the Prone condition.

Withdraw (Cost: 1d6) (changed) Immediately after the attack, you move up to half your Speed without provoking Opportunity Attacks. This movement ignores the Speed reduction from your Steady Aim.

Level 10: Cunning Resolve (new)

Your wits slip free of magical compulsion. When you fail a Wisdom or Charisma saving throw, you can take a Reaction to reroll the save, and you must use the new roll. Once you use this feature, you can't do so again until you finish a Short or Long Rest.

Level 14: Devious Strikes (revised)

You've practiced new ways to use your Sneak Attack deviously. The following effects are now among your Cunning Strike options.

Daze (Cost: 2d6) (changed) The target must succeed on a Wisdom saving throw, or it can't take Reactions until the end of its next turn, and on its next turn it can do only one of the following: move or take an action or a Bonus Action.

Knock Out (Cost: 6d6). The target must succeed on a Constitution saving throw, or it has the Unconscious condition for 1 minute or until it takes any damage. The Unconscious target repeats the save at the end of each of its turns, ending the effect on itself on a success.

Obscure (Cost: 3d6). The target must succeed on a Dexterity saving throw, or it has the Blinded condition until the end of its next turn.


r/onednd • • 2d ago

5e (2024) World of Warcraft book - what is a Felhunter?

31 Upvotes

On page 65 under the Legion Summoning it talks about a Felguard (which I can find on page 227) and Felhunters, which I cannot see listed in contents, bestiary list, or bestiary. What is it referring to?

SOLVED:

My book has an editing mistake where it says Felhunter instead of Felhound.

https://i.postimg.cc/Kc3Vg5Xs/Felhunter-typo.jpg


r/onednd • • 2d ago

Homebrew Revising some Ranger features (reuploaded)

14 Upvotes

Level 2: Deft Explorer (revised)

Thanks to your travels, you gain the following benefits.

Expertise. Choose one of your skill proficiencies with which you lack Expertise. You gain Expertise in that skill.

Languages. You know two languages of your choice from the language tables in chapter 2.

Wilderness Rites. (new) You can expend one use of your Favored Enemy feature to cast a Ranger spell you don't have prepared as a Ritual, provided the spell has the Ritual tag and is of a level you could prepare as a Ranger.

Level 6: Unwavering Mark (new)

Your focus on your quarry no longer has to be held; it simply holds. You gain the following benefits.

Instinctive Mark. When you cast Hunter's Mark with your Favored Enemy feature, you can modify the spell so that it doesn't require Concentration. If you do so, the spell's duration becomes 1 minute for that casting.

One Quarry. You can have only one casting of Hunter's Mark active at a time. If you cast it again, any earlier casting of it ends.

Seamless Pursuit. If the creature marked by your Hunter's Mark drops to 0 Hit Points on your turn, you can move the mark to a new creature you can see within the spell's range (no action required).

Level 10: Tireless (revised)

Primal forces now help fuel you on your journeys, granting you the following benefits.

Temporary Hit Points. (changed) As a Bonus Action, you can give yourself a number of Temporary Hit Points equal to 1d8 plus your Wisdom modifier (minimum of 1). You can use this Bonus Action a number of times equal to your Wisdom modifier (minimum of once), and you regain all expended uses when you finish a Long Rest.

Decrease Exhaustion. Whenever you finish a Short Rest, your Exhaustion level, if any, decreases by 1.

Renewed Focus. (new) Whenever you finish a Short Rest, you also regain one expended use of your Favored Enemy feature.

Level 13: Relentless Hunter (revised)

Taking damage can't break your Concentration on Hunter's Mark. (new) In addition, when you fail a saving throw to maintain Concentration on a Ranger spell, you can expend one use of your Favored Enemy feature to succeed instead.

Level 20: Foe Slayer (revised)

The damage die of your Hunter's Mark is a d10 rather than a d6. (new) In addition, when you roll Initiative, you can cast Hunter's Mark on a creature you can see within the spell's range (no action required), without expending a spell slot or a use of your Favored Enemy feature. You can apply Unwavering Mark's Instinctive Mark modification to this casting.


r/onednd • • 1d ago

Discussion Regarding Magic Equipment costs

0 Upvotes

I'm looking at item costs and some table habits regarding magic gear and would like to assess something with you guys.

There is no shortage of situations where the mundane item behind a magic version is technically more expensive than the magical one when you look at them. Splint and Plate Mail for example far exceed the usual costs for common and even uncommon magic items, same thing with firearms, and even lower-cost ones can hit that if you make them into barding. Technically any piece of armor could be Cast-Off or Gleaming or Enspelled, but this would frequently just mean some major cost cheats if you just go by the default costs.

So i mostly ask here, is it common for you to just separate weapon/armor and enchantment costs when it comes to those? Obviously the systems dont speak of this in any clear form but it feels me that this is the intended interpretation specifically for this case.