Heyy, hello! So, I've been playing D&D for quite some time now, almost 6 years since I started. One of the DMs I played with introduced me to some small corrections to certain classes, and seeing those changes made me wonder: "Which classes and subclasses are falling behind due to their mechanics or numbers?"
This isn't meant to be a rework of any of the game's content, but rather a collection of small adjustments to existing classes and subclasses. I know some people will question why I made certain changes, so I'll explain my reasoning below.
Classes I Didn't Change
Bards: I'm not tweaking the best class in the game, sorry not sorry. Both mechanically and flavor-wise, the Bard is SO far ahead of the classes that actually needed tweaks.
Fighters, Barbarians, Clerics, Warlocks, and Artificers: For Fighters, Barbarians, Clerics, and Warlocks, I genuinely think they're mostly perfect the way they are. They fulfill their class fantasies and don't fall behind other classes when it comes to what they're supposed to do best.
For Fighters and Barbarians, the reason I didn't make any changes is that I thought, and still think, most of their problems come down to whether the weapons they get are good or not. Since I homebrew a lot of magic items, I haven't encountered many problems that didn't disappear the moment I gave them a good magic weapon.
I also have a mechanic called Advanced Weapon Masteries, which provides three different options depending on the weapon you're using. Technique focuses on defense, Speed is about moving around the battlefield more effectively, and Strength increases your average damage. In this system, Fighters and Barbarians are the only classes that can choose more than one Advanced Mastery, allowing them to use options associated with different weapons.
For Clerics, I only tweaked the Trickery Domain because I found it heavily underwhelming. Other than that, I think Cleric is one of the best-designed classes in D&D. I really don't see much room to argue that it lacks either flavor or power.
Warlocks are probably, in my opinion, the best-designed class in D&D, and that's largely because of Eldritch Invocations. I DO NOT, I repeat, I DO NOT, think every class should be as customizable as the Warlock, but I do think Eldritch Invocations are the perfect mechanic for the class.
As for Artificers, I think they're in the same situation as Rangers: both need a full-scale rework rather than a few small adjustments. I've already done that for the Artificer, but since I'm not nearly as interested in completely reworking the Ranger, I decided not to do the same for it.
Now, for What WAS Changed
Sorcerer: We all love our Sorcerers casting multiple spells per round, and I genuinely think it fits the fantasy of a bursty, chaotic spellcaster that the Sorcerer represents. However, I wanted to make sure that whenever they do this, they're aware that they're spending a significant amount of resources.
Rogue: I don't think the Rogue has any real problems outside of combat. As long as you're a good DM who actually understands how ability checks work, your Rogue shouldn't feel weak outside of combat.
In combat, however, both the base class and some of its subclasses fall behind. Because of that, I increased the number of Sneak Attack dice starting at level 10. I didn't introduce this increase any earlier because Rogues are already pretty strong at lower levels and don't really need it.
For the Soulknife and Assassin, I identified some weird mechanics that were holding them back. The Assassin dealing a teaspoon of extra damage once per combat is honestly trash, and the Soulknife is stuck using a weapon that never gets stronger, despite actively needing to use it for its subclass features.
Monk: I don't think there's anything wrong with Monks themselves. They're probably among the five best classes in the game. However, both the Warrior of Shadow and Warrior of the Elements feel like they get NOTHING for several levels. So I tried to build upon the existing ideas behind these subclasses to give them more interesting things to do.
Wizard: I know what people are going to say: Wizards don't need buffs. And I would agree IF these changes weren't being applied to my own campaigns, where I actively give my players powerful magic items.
This tends to put spellcasters in a much more balanced position compared to martial classes. When your Fighter has a +2 weapon that deals an additional 2d6 damage in tiers 2–3, they can actively outperform the Wizard in certain situations.
On top of that, most other spellcasters have some pretty strong class mechanics or are simply so good at their specific roles that they can outperform Wizards in those areas.
The buffs I gave Wizards mostly target their late-game features, which I find pretty lackluster. My goal was to reinforce their identity as the class that always has a tool for almost every situation, while also maintaining their versatility as a skill monkey.
Druid: Yeah, this class is dogshit.
I know some people will say Druids are broken, but as far as I'm concerned, the only decent subclasses are Stars and Moon, and even those are pretty lackluster.
Moon becomes dogshit beyond level 8, and Stars barely gets any substantial scaling throughout its progression, which honestly pisses me off to the moon.
The base Druid also gets some pretty underwhelming numbers for no apparent reason. Both Wild Companion and Wild Shape are practically useless to most Druids because of how poorly their numbers scale, and the class generally lacks a meaningful feature in tier 4.
As for the subclasses, I think they're moving in the right direction, but neither of them really offers enough to justify spending my action economy on their features.
And just to make something clear: I also think the Druid spell list sucks ass. Most of its spells are way too situational or simply weaker than what other spellcasters get. That's precisely why I think Druids should have something meaningful to do besides casting spells.
Paladin: Paladins are fine. I just made a small adjustment to let them retain some burst damage potential without bringing back the ridiculous burst they had in 2014.
Ranger: In my opinion, Rangers fall behind in practically every aspect. The only time they really feel good is when they're among the best DPR classes in the game, around level 3.
These changes are meant to make the Ranger's actual gameplay stronger and more enjoyable, not to fix every problem I have with the class.
THE ACTUAL CHANGES
CLERIC
Trickery Domain
Your Invoke Duplicity feature gains the following additional benefit:
Many Faces. When you expend a use of Channel Divinity to create a duplicate with your Invoke Duplicity feature, you can create one duplicate at level 3, two duplicates starting at level 9, and three duplicates starting at level 17. Whenever you move one of your duplicates, you can move all of them.
DRUID
Your Wild Shape and Wild Companion features receive the following changes. In addition, starting at Druid level 18, you gain the Primal Instinct feature.
Wild Shape. The maximum Challenge Rating of the forms you can assume with this feature equals one-quarter of your Druid level (CR 1/4 at level 1, CR 1/2 at level 2, and so on), instead of the value shown in your Wild Shape feature's table.
Wild Companion. When you cast Find Familiar using this feature, you can choose one of the familiar's normal forms or the form of another Beast or Plant with a Challenge Rating of 1/4 or lower, such as a Wolf, Violet Fungus, or Elk.
The maximum Challenge Rating increases to 1/2 at Druid level 5, 1 at level 9, and 2 at level 13.
In addition, once per turn, when you take the Attack action, you can forgo one of your attacks to allow your familiar to make one attack.
Primal Instinct. Starting at level 18, when you expend a use of your Wild Shape feature, you gain a bonus equal to your Wisdom modifier for 1 minute. During that time, whenever you make a D20 Test, you can add this bonus to the roll after seeing the result of the d20 but before the DM determines whether the test succeeds or fails.
Once you add this bonus to a roll, you lose it. You can have only one bonus from this feature at a time.
Circle of the Moon
Your Circle Forms feature gains the following additional benefit:
Additional Forms. When you assume a form using your Wild Shape feature, you can choose a Plant or Monstrosity, provided it doesn't have the Shape-Shift trait, in addition to Beasts.
The maximum Challenge Rating of the forms you can assume with Wild Shape is rounded up.
Circle of the Sea
You gain the Protective Tide feature at level 6 and the High Tide feature at level 14.
Protective Tide. Starting at level 6, a creature in your Wrath of the Sea form gains Temporary Hit Points equal to your Wisdom modifier (minimum of 1) when it enters that form and at the end of each of its turns while it remains in that form.
High Tide. Starting at level 14, creatures of your choice within the Emanation of your Wrath of the Sea feature have Disadvantage on attack rolls against any creature other than the one around which the Emanation is centered.
Circle of the Land
Your Land's Aid feature receives the following changes:
Land's Aid. You can use this feature as a Bonus Action instead of taking the Magic action. In addition, you add your Wisdom modifier to the damage and healing rolls made with this feature.
Starting at level 10, the effects of this feature occur again at the end of your next turn after using it.
Circle of the Stars
You gain the following additional benefit at level 14:
Star Map. When you assume your Starry Form, you can choose to gain the benefits of two constellations instead of only one.
SORCERER
Your Quickened Spell and Twinned Spell Metamagic options function as follows:
- Quickened Spell. When you cast a spell that has a casting time of an action, you can expend a number of Sorcery Points equal to 1 plus half the spell's level (round up) to change its casting time to a Bonus Action.
- Twinned Spell. When you cast a spell that targets only one creature and doesn't have a range of Self, you can expend a number of Sorcery Points equal to the spell's level (minimum of 1) to target a second creature within range with the same spell. To be eligible, the spell must be incapable of targeting more than one creature at the level at which it's being cast.
ROGUE
Your Sneak Attack feature receives the following change:
Sneak Attack. Starting at level 10, the damage dice of this feature progress as shown in the following table, replacing the normal progression.
| Rogue Level | Sneak Attack |
|---|
| 10 | 6d6 |
| 11 | 7d6 |
| 12 | 8d6 |
| 13 | 9d6 |
| 14 | 10d6 |
| 15 | 11d6 |
| 16 | 12d6 |
| 17 | 13d6 |
| 18 | 14d6 |
| 19 | 15d6 |
| 20 | 20d6 |
Assassin
Your Assassinate feature receives the following changes:
Surprising Strikes. During the first round of each combat, you have Advantage on attack rolls against any creature that hasn't taken its turn yet. If you hit a creature with your Sneak Attack during that round, it takes extra damage of the weapon's damage type equal to your Rogue level.
These benefits also apply when you make an attack against a creature while you have the Invisible condition, provided it knows neither your location nor your likely location.
A creature knows your likely location if you're within 20 feet of the last location where it detected signs of your presence.
Soulknife
Your Psychic Blades feature receives the following change:
Psychic Blades. The damage die of your Psychic Blade increases according to the progression of your Psionic Energy Dice. The damage die of the second blade, used with a Bonus Action, remains one die size smaller than that of the first blade.
MONK
Warrior of Shadow
Your Shadow Arts and Shadow Step features receive the following changes:
Shadow Arts. You can see normally in Dim Light and Darkness, both magical and nonmagical, within 60 feet of yourself.
Shadow Step. Starting at level 17, when you use your Shadow Step feature, you can expend 2 additional Focus Points to use Flurry of Blows as part of the same Bonus Action.
Warrior of the Elements
Your Elemental Attunement feature receives the following changes:
Elemental Strikes. Starting at level 11, while your Elemental Attunement is active, once on each of your turns when you hit a creature with an Unarmed Strike, you can deal extra damage of the same type as the attack equal to your Wisdom modifier.
Alternatively, you can expend 2 Focus Points to replace the damage of that attack with the effects of your Elemental Burst feature without taking the Magic action.
Starting at level 17, you no longer gain the Empowered Strikes benefit of your Elemental Epitome feature. Instead, the once-per-turn limitation of Elemental Strikes no longer applies.
Elemental Defense. Starting at level 18, while you're under the effects of both your Superior Defense and Elemental Attunement features, you gain Immunity to one damage type of your choice: Acid, Cold, Fire, Lightning, or Thunder. You can change the chosen damage type at the start of each of your turns.
WIZARD
Your Arcane Recovery, Memorize Spell, Spell Mastery, and Signature Spells features receive the following changes:
Arcane Recovery. Starting at level 9, you can also use this feature as an Action without needing to finish a Short Rest.
Memorize Spell. When you use this feature, you can replace a number of prepared spells with other spells from your spellbook equal to your Intelligence modifier (minimum of one spell), instead of replacing only one.
In addition, whenever you gain the benefits of your Arcane Recovery feature, you can also use Memorize Spell.
Spell Mastery. You can choose two Wizard spells of level 2 or lower from your spellbook, instead of one level 1 spell and one level 2 spell. These spells don't need to have a casting time of an action. You always have these spells prepared and can cast each of them at its lowest level without expending a spell slot.
Signature Spells. You can choose two Wizard spells of level 3 or lower from your spellbook, instead of two level 3 spells. You always have these spells prepared and can cast each of them at its lowest level without expending a spell slot.
Evoker
Your Overchannel feature gains the following additional benefit:
Overchannel. During the turn in which you use this feature, your spells affect even creatures that would otherwise avoid their damage. When you miss with an attack roll made as part of one of these spells or a creature succeeds on a saving throw against one of them, the creature takes at least half the damage it would have taken if the attack had hit or the saving throw had failed, but suffers none of the spell's additional effects.
PALADIN
Your Paladin's Smite feature receives the following change:
Paladin's Smite. Once per turn, when you cast Divine Smite, you can do so without expending a Bonus Action.
RANGER
Your Tireless, Relentless Hunter, and Foe Slayer features receive the following changes. In addition, starting at level 18, you gain the Unwavering Focus feature.
Tireless. The Temporary Hit Points granted by this feature increase to 1d10 plus your Ranger level (minimum of 1).
Relentless Hunter. The damage die of your Hunter's Mark spell increases to 2d6.
Unwavering Focus. Starting at level 18, when you cast Hunter's Mark, you can choose to cast it without requiring Concentration. If you do so, the spell's duration becomes 1 minute.
Foe Slayer. The damage of your Hunter's Mark spell increases to 2d8 instead of 2d6.
These are the adjustments I've been working with, based on the kinds of characters, encounters, and magic items I tend to use in my campaigns.
I'm not claiming these changes are universally necessary or that they would work equally well at every table. They're meant to address the issues I've personally encountered while playing and DMing.
I'd love to hear what you guys think, particularly whether you've encountered similar problems with these classes and subclasses. And if you are interested in more of my homebrew and other stuff I create, go check my Patreon.
Which of these changes would you actually use at your table, and which ones do you think go too far?