r/patientgamers • u/Not-Clark-Kent • 2h ago
Multi-Game Review My Top 40 Games That Are Best Played On PS3: Ranked
Sorry for my brief absence. This one is special to me. I "grew up" on PS2, but PS3 was the first time I was able to spend my own money on games and followed gaming news. It was fun to revisit some of this, as well as getting to some titles I have had on my shelf for 20 years. Not everything aged well, but it was a fun era.
This is NOT a retrospective. This is a list of games that are exclusive to this console, or the console is the best way to play it NOW. Only the best version of a game can make the list. If you think I missed a classic game, there's probably an explanation in a comment I made on the post as to why, and what platform I recommend.
All games on a list are worth playing despite any criticisms I may have for them.
Ranking is not necessarily by which is the best, but in terms of what I most recommend playing. Perhaps my theoretical opinion is that the worst Mario is better than the best Street Fighter. But the best Street Fighter would still rank higher, because it's a unique experience, and the best version of that experience.
Only consoles & PC (Windows/DOS) are considered. No arcade/Neo-Geo, mobile, or other home computers. MAME is difficult to work with & high maintenance. Mobile changes architecture too often for all-time lists, and often don't support controllers. Other home computers rarely meet rule 1 & rarely have controller support.
I default to PC when available. If it's better on console, I'll put it on the console's list. Usually, it's better or the same on PC, and more accessible.
Games with the same name will be clarified by year or console within (). Games not released in North America will have the region abbreviation within []. Alternate names will be included within {}.
My lists are in increments of 10 to make it easier to track & for quality control. If there are 61 good games, I make a cut to make it an even 60.
#40: Resistance 2
Resistance 2 improves significantly with graphics & somewhat with aiming, but unfortunately conforms to the then-popular standard of only 2 weapons at a time. Having a toolbox of options was pretty much the main thing saving Resistance 1. For such a unique setting, the plot of 2 is surprisingly generic military shooter, which unfortunately doubles down on the things that DIDN'T work about R1. The devs seemed to realize this wasn't going anywhere, and decided to switch protagonists, tone, controls, and even subgenre for the third game. This sounds negative, but 2 is not without its moments. It's a fun ride, just a bit ho-hum in the greater context of an all-time list. I had fun playing through it & I enjoy the alien designs. I think some fellow PS3 fans will be shocked that this is so low. But I also think some PC/Xbox fans who tried it later will wonder why it made the list at all.
#39: ModNation Racers
MNR is a truly genius concept for competing with Mario Kart: going hog wild on customization. Tuner cars were already a fan-favorite feature in racing games for the upgrades & ricing you can do, so this was a no-brainer. The ModNation devs double the customization choices from even the most in depth Need For Speed game, and then allow a crazy amount of options for track creation as well. Customizing stuff is intuitive & very fun in this game. The physics are even good, which is rare to see for hyper casual arcade racers. Unfortunately, the rubber banding is WILDLY unfair, making the whole thing feel pointless. MNR is also badly optimized. There are truly absurd load times, occasional bugs, and frequent frame drops. Somehow the dev team managed to do even worse with the spiritual sequel LittleBigPlanet Karting, which is still badly optimized with bad rubber banding, then further chooses to pare down the customization significantly which is...the entire point of the game.
#38: Eternal Sonata
A JRPG about Polish classical music composer Frederic Chopin, in an adventure he dreams up as he is dying of tuberculosis. The summary says it all really. If you're willing to accept this bonkers concept and see where they go with it, I doubt you will be disappointed. If you're not interested, I am not going to try to convince you. That said, in a vacuum, it is a pretty good game. The battle system is inventive for a turn based RPG. The music, of course, is a highlight. It is 100% linear, but I don't mind that much these days. The story is heartfelt & has interesting things to say about life, though I will note that it isn't exactly life changing. It feels a bit like a young person trying to write from an old person perspective if that makes sense, which makes it more surface level than it is shooting for.
#37: Resistance - Fall of Man
Aliens invade in the 1950s, and unfortunately for us, they are able to make more aliens by infecting humans & incubating inside of us. After discovering you are the only known human to Resist™️ infection/transformation, you decide to put together a Resistance™️ force to destroy alien nests. Resistance tried to bridge the gap between Halo & WW2 FPS games, as well as add the fun of carrying an unrealistic amount of guns from boomer shooters. And it...sorta works! It's an early PS3 game. The aiming is not quite there (but not enough to be infuriating), no ADS, texture-wise it is an upscaled PS2 game, and the art direction is very washed out with the infamous 7th gen brown filter. Guns are good though, the alien guns in particular are creative. The level design isn't stellar, but decent & straightforward. Unfortunately they do absolutely nothing to capitalize on the fun of 1950s Americana, nor is it particularly fun with the SciFi. It's fun to play through, but not as memorable as it probably should have been.
#36: God of War Origins Collection {Chains of Olympus + Ghost of Sparta}
Chains of Olympus takes place before GoW1, and Ghost of Sparta takes place immediately after GoW1. Both should be played after 1 & before 2, since they explore Kratos' origins more than they break new ground. Both games are both relatively important to the lore while still remaining nonessential; a good combo for a spinoff. They are remarkably well done for PSP games, but we ARE comparing them to big boy console games though, so Origins can't go too high. They're starting to scrape the bottom of the barrel for Greek mythology characters too, though not as badly as GoW Ascension, and they do more interesting thing with Kratos than Ascension does. If you're not feeling Chains of Olympus, try out Ghost of Sparta before giving up, since it is significantly better.
#35: Tokyo Jungle
A pretty weird survival game about animals roaming around abandoned cities in a human-less post apocalyptic future. There is a noticeable pattern to the gameplay loop, generally hunting, avoiding predators, and marking new territory. But the mechanics are varied & can get hyper specific, which is pretty funny sometimes. Even one of the core mechanics is making sure you fuck frequently enough (good luck gamers) to have enough offspring to make sure your lineage survives as long as possible, which adds some roguelite qualities. There is a surprisingly robust roster of animals to choose from, and gameplay can vary significantly depending on what type of animal you are. So, this is nobody's favorite game, but I think half the fun of console gaming is being there for the "you had to be there" experiences. Cracking open a magazine (or browsing reddit/a gaming forum) and being like "Ok Sony, what have you got this month to tide me over? Animal Sex In The City? Alrighty then, let's go." Nintendo is the last company left who still does this, which kinda sucks.
#34: Twisted Metal [2012]
It feels like this "should" be the best Twisted Metal, but it is missing something. The story is still dark & edgy, but maybe more...cinematic? There is a certain magic to Black that this doesn't have. Even Head On, as radically different as it is from Black, feels just as authentic with its own brand of chaos. 2012 succeeds at having the best gameplay & graphics, but then again Black's physics feel better. Content wise, it is comparable to older titles, but the roster is very limited, the story is short, and the online lobbies didn't work that well. Maybe I just expected more by this stage of the series. 2012 is MILES better than literally anything besides those top 2 games though. Yes, even TM2.
#33: The Darkness
An FPS that combines dark superpowers in a similar way to Bioshock, which came out the same year. After losing someone close to him, a young man with ties to the Italian mafia gets bonded to the titular "Darkness", a creature somewhere between a demon and the Venom symbiote. As you might expect from this premise and being released in 2007, the story is very dark, and takes you many places, including the afterlife. Despite being a bit edgy, the story is the best part of the game; the pacing is great, and I find it engaging, even heartfelt at times. The frame rate is REALLY bad on hardware, but if you have a decent PC, emulation can fix that. It can't fix how awkward the aiming can be. On hardware, I was never suffering through the gameplay exactly, but you are playing this for the premise/story.
#32: 3D Dot Game Heroes
An adventure game inspired by Zelda, from the gameplay down to the pixel art of the NES original. It is charming, but does feel slightly manufactured. While I understand & even have historically asked for console competitors to fill blank niches in their roster, on the other hand, asking where Sony's Zelda is would be like asking where Nintendo's Halo or God of War is. There isn't one & there doesn't need to be one. Now, 3DDGH is not the full-on nostalgia bait slop that is so common nowadays, but it IS very smart about what buttons to push to make you remember fond memories of other, more original games. What it captures best is the sense of playfulness. It knows it is a game, and that is cool. And in some ways, this does set it apart slightly from Zelda, which tends to have a different tone. The minigames shake up the standard gameplay, and sometimes reference other old games, so that's fun.
#31: Army of Two
AoT is nearly a classic third person shooter. But not quite. The aggro mechanic is interesting even in single player, and even better in split screen. Being built completely around split screen gives it a lot of free points, since there are so few games like that these days and so few good 3rd person shooters before 7th gen. I think the sequel makes the wise choice to dispense with any kind of historical accuracy; at this point in my life, it is a little weird to see this completely unserious power fantasy set during the War On Terror. AoT is firmly tongue in cheek, which is appreciated, but neither is it satire. It doesn't have anything insightful to say about the war, PMCs, or really anything. And sure, the level design, plot, gun choice, enemy variety, and graphics are bog standard. But when you're blasting away with a buddy on the couch next to you, chugging a beer & riffing off each other's terrible jokes, an interesting plot would just be a distraction anyway. It's not that kind of game.
#30: Folklore
Sometimes rare games achieve "classic" status just for the aura that they have from being rare or unique. Folklore is...kind of one of these, but not egregiously so, like Rule of Rose for example. Folklore is legitimately good, but I'm not quite comfortable calling it a classic. The graphics & overall vibe/aesthetic is the reason to play the game. It doesn't even look very dated in today's terms, and even if it did, the art direction more than makes up for it. The murder mystery is engaging, and I like the combat mechanics, which involve using Folks in a strategic way. Unfortunately, the level design is linear & repetitive, made even worse because you essentially have to play each level twice. Rarely do I feel as though I learn or gain anything radically different than the first time around, so this feels like pure padding. It's also designed for 30 FPS, which is common for the console, and not too bad for this type of game. Unfortunately, some of the physics (particularly cloth) are tied to the frame rate; you can somewhat reliably bump it up to 50 FPS, but not 60.
#29: Killzone 3
I struggle to know where to rank this. 3 is good in the way that matters most for an FPS: the gameplay. In fact, the shooting is best on this list, and even competes with other best in class competitive shooters at the time such as Halo & COD. 3 has better graphics, I remember the particle effects being particularly impressive. 3's level design is solid for an FPS; therefore, moment to moment, the game is good. I just don't remember much of it. I have no idea what the plot of Killzone is, but I'm pretty sure we play as the bad guys. And not in a fun subversive way, more of a "rah rah jingoistic imperialism that they hoped we wouldn't think about too hard" kind of way. 2's campaign is not immune to this issue, but has better characters & level design. As a result, the highlight of 3 is the online; which of course doesn't exist anymore. 2 works online with RPCS3, but not 3 yet. Also, 2's online experience felt more exciting & memorable, despite 3 being more balanced & giving more reasons to play less popular classes. Even the shooting, which is objectively more precise with less input lag in 3, could be reasonably preferred in 2 due to being heavier, meatier, and with more forgiving reaction time. If you were to rank KZ3 in the top 10 though, I wouldn't argue much, it's more the criteria of the list.
#28: Heavenly Sword
God of War lite. I mean that in a good way AND in a bad way. It is innovative, in some ways. The motion capture is very well done, and particularly at the time it was a showcase of what later games such as L.A. Noire could accomplish on the same hardware. I love Anna Torv, and she is excellent in this. Andy Serkis is also a delight, particularly when motion capture is involved. The graphics are great in general, it is probably the best looking early PS3 title. The motion controls for archery (and optionally, panning the camera) were also ahead of their time. And yet, it really is just GoW's hack & slash base and...not much else. Not that there's much time to evolve, the game is about 7 hours, roughly half GoW's runtime. They even went with similar themes, and a similar vibe as GoW. The main character has a destiny to ascend with the power of the gods, but it also tells you in the opening cut scene that they are supposed to die at the end. The main character wields a curved magic blade given to them by the gods, that looks like it was designed by the same blacksmith. I like GoW a lot, and I liked this too...I just don't know why Sony would follow that formula so closely when they own both IPs. Also, it is an inconsistent 30 FPS on hardware. Still, there isn't really a bad moment to speak of, emulation fixes the performance issues, and the short runtime is not a detriment now that you don't have to worry about it being a good value at full price.
#27: Army of Two - The 40th Day
This is just more AoT, but tightened up. Bigger set pieces, better graphics, slightly refined controls. The main difference being that the humor, bromance, and amount of talking in general has been toned WAY down. Whether this makes 40th Day better or worse depends on how funny VS obnoxious you found the previous game. I think it's a step closer to being a classic than the first, but also since it's less memorable (for better or worse) & much more linear with less ways to approach a situation, it's another half step back. The well thought out couch co-op continues to carry the series. You could get enjoyment playing solo, but you're missing the point.
#26: Tales of Xilia 2
X2 does a lot of interesting things & takes chances, and I respect it for that. Like much Japanese media, the Xilia duology represents the contrast between old Japan & the rapidly developed modern Japan. The world of Xilia used to be a magical place where anything could happen, and now it is full of corporations where you are immediately saddled with unpayable medical debt after a train accident early game. You can react to this & yell at people who constantly harass you to pay up, but ultimately the young employee on the other end of the line is just a wage slave with no responsibility for the debt you incurred, and has been nice to you & upbeat the whole game. After being hired by corpos to "delete" offshoot dimensions that "shouldn't exist" and "will destroy our world if left alone", suddenly you're forced to ask yourself big moral questions when you're forced to decide whether to kill an alternate universe version of an old friend from Xilia 1.
Direct JRPG sequels don't often turn out that well because they tend to either be too similar with not enough plot scraped together that wasn't already done in the first game, or too different which alienates the fans. But X2 takes that inherent weakness, and chooses to emphasize & capitalize on it. You reunite with characters from the first game, but it's bittersweet; a metaphor for "you can't go home". I might actually write a pretty in-depth review on this, but to sum up: X1 is probably a better game for most people, and despite X2 reusing some characters & most of the map, X2 is a very different game, and the themes have stuck with me more. I can understand someone thinking it's a little too real though, and not what they look for in a video game.
#25: Soul Calibur IV
I have played SC4 a truly ridiculous amount, easily the most of any Soul Calibur, because it was the first with online & the character creator is a big step up from 3. However, it's only 5th best in the series, maybe 4th if you like it better than 1's simplicity. 4 doesn't do a single thing best compared to other SC games. The amount of single player content & the roster was a colossal step down from 3. The stage design is better than 5 & 6, but a step down from 2 & 3. Graphics & character creation are better in 5 & 6. Character designs are fine, but more fantastical (and unapologetically slutty). I prefer the near-grounded nature of 1 & 2, though I do have a soft spot for stomach-less Nightmare as a moment in time. The star power (pun intended) of Darth Vader was great for a guest character, but doesn't suit the setting, like at all. I still recommend playing it (unlike 5): the performance is great, it looks great, and the lore is a satisfying wrap up to the series, if short. But you don't need to play it as much as I did.
#24: Ratchet & Clank Future - Tools of Destruction
Next gen R&C was a strong step forward. I like it quite a bit, and I am very pleased that they kept the excellent 60 FPS optimization despite the impressive graphical jump. It does rank a hair below the original trilogy for me though. The series was getting samey by this point. The future gimmick is a good idea to set it apart, but it is not quite enough.
#23: Gran Turismo 5
The devs had a hell of a time trying to get this running at all on PS3 hardware, so it suffered delay after delay for 4 years. As a result, they didn't go as hard on the single player experience as GT4 did, and that's most people's main gripe with it. That, and Xbox got 2 of the best Forzas before it even came out, and 2 even better Forzas before 6. But this is a retro game now (good Lord) so that doesn't matter. It's still a very good game, ranking 4th best from a modern perspective in my opinion, though 6/5/3 is arguable (4>7>6>5>3>Sport>2>1>PSP). And the devs succeeded in getting it running smoothly, somehow, which is impressive for how pretty it is. It only ranks as low as it does because I slightly prefer 6, and 6 has sufficient content. If 6 didn't exist, 5 would occupy its ranking.
#22: Armored Core - For Answer
This may be my favorite Armored Core besides 6, and I don't even like mech games that much. The main reason is that it is just so fast paced & fun to play, and the customization is very in-depth. It's not perfect though, nor is it for everyone. The camera is inconsistent, the auto target is hyper sensitive, the menus are basic with black backgrounds, and the environments are peak desaturated brown 7th gen smear with little interactivity. It really min-maxed the shoestring budget by placing all effort into the gameplay, but for that alone, you should at least try it out. I'll take that over a boring but pretty AAA game.
#21: Sly Cooper Collection {1-3}
The least appreciated of the PS2 mascot trilogies. And I understand why: Sly is certainly the most linear & traditional mascot platformer of the bunch. But even Sly 1 is certainly no PS1 game, there is far more polish. You play as an international thief, and you must incorporate platforming, stealth, and basic combat in order to steal back your family's heirloom book of thieving techniques.
2 feels a bit more modern in a way that's hard to describe. Still linear, but more in-depth. It also added minigames, which can be fun but often far too hard, particularly the races.
3 ia more of the same as 2, which makes it less impressive. But it has plenty of ideas for level design & mixups to gameplay, and the story is a satisfying ending to the series. Do yourself a favor, and do not play 4, which has a cliffhanger ending. It ends here as far as I'm concerned, and 3 is not one to miss.
20: Puppeteer
At the time, one might have expected a 2D mascot platformer in the Year of Our Lord 2013 to be old hat, which is why it didn't sell well, but time has proven that assumption wrong. There is more than meets the eye. It's whimsical, but darker than it appears, like old school fairy tales dark. You quite literally lose your head at the beginning, and have to collect severed heads to attached to yourself that give you different powers. The presentation & art direction is perhaps the biggest selling point, with pretty graphics, a stage play format, and a narrator. The gameplay is pretty good too, using scissors to interact with the environment in a variety of ways.
#19: Battlefield - Bad Company
There is no debate whatsoever that Bad Company 1 & 2 have the best campaigns of any Battlefield, and as such, they are the best Battlefields for retro gaming. BC1 was the debut of the Frostbite engine, which allowed for impressive destruction effects for 90% of objects in the game. The story is about B Company, nicknamed Bad Company due to being comprised of fuck-ups. You're there essentially to be cannon fodder in a war against Russia, and your Sergeant is one day away from retirement. Of course, everything goes upside down, you're forced to go AWOL, and end up aiming to steal a stockpile of gold from a dangerous mercenary group. It has good humor without overdoing it as the 00s tended to; the characters are memorable & tongue in cheek while feeling completely real. The main downside is the enemy Ai, who can magically see you immediately even crouched behind a 6 ft wall. 2 is better in just about every way: the pacing, the dynamic levels, the variety, the graphics, the controls, the performance, the color palette, the "existing on PC". Still, even if we include the multiplayer experience, BC1 makes my top 5 Battlefield games, easily. It's just...fun.
#18: Jak & Daxter Collection {1-3}
I love all 3 games here, but admittedly they're a bit of a mixed bag.
1 is a classic 3D platformer. It doesn't reinvent the wheel in terms of gameplay or tone, but knocks it out of the park in the execution of every single aspect of the game. Definitely top 10 non-Mario 3D platformers.
2 takes a hard left into being a third person shooter open world game. Basically GTA, but rated T & easier to trick your parents into getting. The dark powers add a new dimension to the gameplay. The difficulty balance is a bit wack, but it's a good game, if dated.
3 ends the story in a satisfying way, evens out 2's rougher edges, and mixes up the semi open world gameplay with a Mad Max esque desert sandbox with vehicle combat. The light powers weren't as revolutionary as the dark powers in 2, but at least you have both here.
#17: Midnight Club - Los Angeles: Complete Edition
MC3 was technically an open world, but LA really defines the open world racing genre, with a city that is bigger than all 3 cities in 3 combined. This adds to the immersion, and so does the day/night cycle, weather, and better physics. 3 had some fun story beats, but LA's has perhaps the best storytelling in a racing game. Better graphics of course. LA shares a lot of the same flaws as 3 though; there is some chugging, and the extreme difficulty & unfair rubber banding may be even WORSE in LA. It has less content than 3, and less customization. But at the end of the day, it is a different enough experience, and an excellent cap to the series that Rockstar could be proud of.
#16: LittleBigPlanet
There was no "one game" that could be said to have brought back 2D platformers. But if there was, it was LBP. It is one of the first AAA 2.5D games, and it still looks beautiful today. The gameplay is good, but extremely approachable. More of an excuse to explore the theme park that is the level design. The vibe is very cute & fun, and pays tribute to many cultures around the world that the levels are based on. And when you finish the game? No you didn't! There is an incredibly well-made level creator, and tons of hyper specific unlockable content to make each level truly feel like it's yours. Same with the costumes & skins; customization is really the name of the game here. It took Nintendo 7 years to even attempt to copy it, and while Mario Maker may have a more interesting competitive scene, LBP still does a better job with the sheer level of creative customization options. It even had split screen multiplayer a year before New Super Mario Bros Wii. Truly, the only thing holding this game back is that 2 is better in every way, and 1's unlockable content can be imported into 2. Which is just a positive from a user perspective. LBP1 is still a classic, and you should definitely play it before moving all your stuff to 2. If only for the dev-made levels, which are a full length game by themselves.
#15: inFamous
inFamous checks all the boxes of what it's trying to accomplish. It looks great, it has a cool open world, the powers are expansive & varied without feeling like you're constantly in menus. You feel powerful but there is a reasonable challenge. The story is good, with well-done voice acting. The only downside is the performance, which chugs in hardware, and causes occasional glitches. You could nitpick. I suppose at times, you can see the seams of the gameplay loop; some of the side missions get a bit repetitive, but I still completed all of them each time I've beaten the game. Similarly, the morality system is a bit arbitrary & binary. Could be done better, but I'm sure glad it is there, it is a lot of fun for role playing purposes, especially in the superhero/villain genre. I have a lot of good memories of this game.
#14: Ico
To this day, Ico still comes up in conversations about video games as art. It is difficult to describe it here, because it is more than the sum of its parts, most of which are still good, mind you. The impressive visuals that still hold up because of the art direction. The music. The body language & unspoken bond between Ico & Yorda. The logical puzzle design. Being weak but not obtusely frustrating. The gameplay is usually the point of contention for most people, since you have to hold Yorda's hand the whole time, and you can't fight at the same time. From a raw gameplay perspective, this is bad & annoying, but it is simply part of her character & the experience of Ico. You would think that Escort Mission: The Game would suck, but you'd be wrong; as long as you have an open mind. Ico has such a consistent vision that coalesces into something beautiful. That being said, it is a "play once" type of game. Or at least once a decade or so when you forget the impact, or want to show someone the game.
#13: Ratchet & Clank Collection {R&C 2002, Going Commando, Up Your Arsenal}
There's a reason R&C has lasted significantly longer than its fellow PS2 mascots. Part of that is the polish, but there's also more to do. It is primarily a 3rd person shooter, but has strong platforming sections, and mixups like vehicles & controlling Clank to solve puzzles & make repairs.
The original is the most memorable in terms of story. Ratchet is a bit of a jackass at the beginning, but lovable. His Leroy Jenkins-ing through life is frustrating to Clank, the straight man, yet sometimes what is needed. Ratchet grows as a character, and he & Clank end up making a great team.
GC fixes the glaring aiming issue from 1, and the gameplay in general is refined, making it easier to return to. The story is not nearly as memorable, but it does have some fun with the concept of "OK the story is over...now what do we do?"
UYA goes wild with the upgrade system, but is otherwise just a solid entry with a plot that I confuse with GC's most of the time. It has well thought out level design for the platforming sections though. I don't know which I prefer between GC & UYA, but both are contenders for the best R&C game, despite being less memorable.
#12: Killzone 2
I still don't particularly like or understand Killzone's story, but it has the best characters in the series. Radec is the most memorable enemy, and some of your squad mates have good-ish banter. More importantly, the gameplay is excellent, the shooting rivaled only by Killzone 3 on this list. It's beautiful, and the online was legendary. It occupies a solid middle ground between Halo's slow time to kill & COD's madhouse, the same way it balances Halo's sci-fi with (old) COD's realism. The weightiness of the weapons & the way they combine with the crunchy sound design & animations are a particular standout. "Halo killer" it was not: Killzone caused a total of 0 competitive FPS fans to switch to PlayStation. But if your Xbox buddies were dragging you for playing Killzone over Halo, are least you could honestly argue "but have you tried it tho?"
#11: Skate 2
Skate 2 has a better storyline, a more cohesive open world, and is generally more immersive, realistic, and challenging than Skate 3. The thing that annoys me most is how clunky it feels to walk when not on the skateboard. It takes me right out of the experience each time, especially if I'm switching between 2 & 3. 3 also beats it in graphics & content, so I do give it a slight edge. But realistically, 2 feels the most like a memorable "must play" experience. Similar to LBP1 VS LBP 2: play Skate 2 first, enjoy the heck out of the experience, then move on to 3 where you will probably clock many more gameplay hours than 2. Except in Skate's case, you will secretly miss 2.
#10: Resistance 3
That's right: Resistance ranges from worst FPS on the list to the best. I'm just as surprised as you are. To achieve this, R3 had to course correct hard, and I'm pleased to inform you that they do pretty much everything right. It's not a generic war shooter anymore because there is no war. Humanity lost. We are what's left. You get your moment to "win", but it feels earned, instead of the previous protagonist being essentially the chosen one. The gameplay is MASSIVELY improved, with ADS, much smoother aiming, meatier sound design + force feedback, and they brought back unlimited weapons. The graphics are also significantly better, and less washed out and...7th gen-y than 2. There is even a good co-op split screen mode! The only downsides are the noticeably narrow FOV, frame drops on hardware, and the online was...fine, but not impressive at the time.
#9: Tekken 5 - Dark Resurrection
5 is best remembered as a PS2 game, but to me, it is THE PS3 fighting game. Dark Resurrection is a big step up from the original. It adds 5 new characters, several new modes, new stages, new moves for some characters, and much better balancing. Notably, it was the first Tekken to have online, and it did a good job from the start. And...it's still one of the best Tekken games in general. After 5's course correction, they started to get a lot more iterative, so it's a bit of a wash, and I also disliked the reliance on paid DLC. But by 8, the small improvements added up enough to be meaningfully better. 4 is the weird one which is fun to go back to sometimes, and 3 is the classic. Overall, in my opinion: 8>5DR>3>4>7>6>2>1.
#8: Motorstorm - Pacific Rift
MSPR is the anti-Gran Turismo in some ways. GT is a sim (or simcade by today's standards), while MS is strictly an arcade racer, though it does have physics realistic enough to feel "right". GT is legal motorsport track racing, while MS is off-roading with questionable people in between partying it up at a music festival in the desert. GT's graphics are very good, yet toned down & grey-ish, while MS has eye popping tropical colors with graphics that are nearly as good, but lean on even better art direction. GT is refined, while MotorStorm is dramatic. Which is better? Who cares! I love them both all the more for having such a strong identity. MS's track design is S-tier, it keeps your blood pumping with plenty of chaos. The choices in vehicles are nice, though personally I find them wildly unbalanced in certain tracks. PR is the best Motorstorm by a wide margin. I like the others plenty, but I just don't see a reason to go back to them. The first one feels like a proof of concept for Pacific Rift. Arctic Edge is a snowy, scaled down to PS2 version of PR. Apocalypse is the most unique, featuring asphalt driving & vehicle destruction, but overall not quite good enough to hit the list.
#7: Skate 3
It's hard to argue that Skate 3 is not THE definitive skating game experience, particularly for fans of real skating. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 1+2 competes, but it's much more arcadey. Skate 2 is better in some ways, but I think the amount of content triumphs here, which is further extended by a pretty solid level designer. The controls are a lighter/less realistic than 2, but more polished, and still heavier/more realistic than 4. I think it is possible to improve upon Skate 3, which is why it's not even higher, but we sure have not done that yet.
#6: Gran Turismo 6
6 is very similar in quality to 5, for slightly different reasons. 6 has better physics, customization, and more content. 5 has better progression, special events, and includes endurance racing. 6 doesn't have used cars, which can be considered either good or bad depending on your opinion. Personally I preferred not checking the used lot constantly, and just buying what I wanted when I wanted it, and knowing my bank account won't suffer as a result. The graphics are more advanced in 6, but are more stylized than 5. 6 was more of a mess on launch & came out too late, so very few people have stellar memories of it. But judging how the games are now in a vacuum, I'd say it's close to a direct upgrade from 5. Absolutely play both, neither are disappointing. Despite some unevenness, I'll hesitantly say that this is my third favorite GT.
#5: inFamous 2
For whatever reason, inFamous isn't talked about as much as it used to be, but it absolutely sits in the upper echelon of superhero games, next to Spider-Man 2018 & Batman Arkham. Just about everything is improved in 2, including the story. Whichever ending you get, the series definitively ends the plot with no dangling plot threads, which is something you just don't see too much, especially for the second game in a series. New Orleans is a rare setting to see in video games, giving a nice switch up to the overdone New York styled city from the first game. The powers are greatly expanded & noticeably more polished. 2 inherits a bit of the first game's chugging on hardware, but it's perfectly playable. I want more, and yet I don't. I'm glad it got a good ending instead of being done to death.
#4: Ratchet & Clank Future - A Crack In Time
CiT is, in my view, the greatest R&C to date. It isn't without tight competition. Rift Apart has better graphics & polish, but is nearly devoid of grit or charm. ToD is very good, but CiT polishes & improves spectacularly on ToD's foundation, making the Future series feel like almost a separate thing. And it pushes UYA's focus on customization innovations even further. I love everything about it. CiT is one of the greatest 3D platformers(?) of all time. Or is it more of a 3rd person shooter? Or action adventure? Whatever it is, it's one of the best.
#3: LittleBigPlanet 2
I'll keep it short: LBP is in the top 10 greatest 2D platformers of all time. It does everything as good or better than LBP1, and supports moving all content from 1 to 2. The level creator in particular is the most improved aspect, which was far and away the #1 reason to play LBP1 to begin with. The long history of community made levels have been backed up on community servers, and people still create new content to this day. You can play LBP2 forever...and I just might.
#2: God of War Collection {1+2}
For some reason, there is this persistent zeitgeist understanding that GoW was mindless blood & guts with no nuance before GoW 2018. Let me assure you, that is completely, utterly false. From the opening scene of Kratos throwing himself off a cliff, you know you're in for something special. GoW is a classic Greek tragedy. A testament to tenacity, yes, but just as much a warning about how societies make their own monsters & how rage can consume you. This is what originally cost Kratos his family, yet his response is to rage even harder. Kratos may not have learned the lessons he should have until later, but the audience does; the storytelling makes sure of that. The gameplay is also quite good, elevating hack & slash gameplay and keeping the camera pulled way, waaayy back so that you can truly see the scale of what is happening, yet easily see & control Kratos. And boy, is it beautiful, even on PS2.
2 is even better in just about every way, except arguably 1 has higher highs in the story. 2 is THE benchmark for hack and slash games.
#1: Metal Gear Solid - The Legacy Collection {MG 1-2, MGS 2-4, Peace Walker}
I'm not even sure what to say here that would adequately express how much these games mean to me. 2, 3, and possibly 4 could have taken the top spot alone. All together? Nothing else stood a chance. MGS has a lot to say about a lot of things, but is most often a tale about the American military industrial complex, and how we treat veterans. It is told with an honesty & accuracy that is only truly possible from an outsider's perspective. Even glimpses at the future have been shockingly on point, even the parts that are wildly over the top. Yet, MGS is not a satire or fully even a criticism. To the contrary, there is a certain reverence & appreciation for the West. Above all, MGS strives to be a very good GAME, and one that pays close attention to the details. It is quite easily one of the greatest game franchises of all time.
The Rest:
Think I missed a game, or question why I'd choose the PS3 version? Check here and here respectively.