r/RWBYCynics • • 20d ago

Rant Why I don't think Weiss should be demonized for the Boarbatusk scene (rant-warning) Spoiler

7 Upvotes

I legitimately don't understand why people demonize Weiss for accidentally summoning the Boarbatusk when the Trophy Wife (yes, that's actually her credited name in the V4 credits) insulted Vale and Beacon Academy/the people there who died during the Fall of Beacon. Weiss fought in that battle, and lots of the students that she went to classes with were killed during it, so of course she got mad. This is basically the equivalent of the parent of a Sandy Hook victim punching a conspiracy theorist/denialist in the face for saying that it didn't happen/was staged, which I bet any critics reading this would also do in that situation if they were one of those parents.

Also, they're displaying blatant sexism and hypocrisy by praising the scene in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban where Harry is so angry at his Aunt Marge for insulting the deaths of his parents James and Lily that he accidentally uses the engorgement charm on her, causing her to blow up like a balloon and float out of the Dursley house and into the sky, and then pressing his wand up to his Uncle Vernon's neck when he tries to push Harry into his cupboard room so that he can beat him up afterwards. They say things like "Harry's aunt got what she deserved for insulting his parents' deaths", and "Harry put his abusive uncle in his place".

Both were instances of a teenager accidentally lashing out from anger when a snobby, entitled person insulted the deaths of innocent people that were very close to them, but for some reason they're willing to praise the boy who lashed out when someone insulted the deaths of his parents that were killed by Wizard Hitler right in front of him (albeit when he was only a baby), while also condemning the girl who accidentally summoned a violent hologram when someone claimed that everyone who died in a terrorist attack/demonic animal feeding frenzy that she fought bravely in to save as many people as she could "had it coming" for "not being properly civilized". Make it make sense, people!

Also, for those of you saying "Weiss could've killed that woman! She should've been locked up in a mental institution for the rest of her life!", I have two rebuttals:

  1. Harry could've killed both his Aunt Marge and his Uncle Vernon (the former by making her explode from touching something sharp or going high enough up in the air for the pressure drop to make her pop like a balloon, and the latter by accidentally setting him on fire with his wand or something), but I don't see anyone complaining about that, and
  2. You could say the same thing about my late Vietnam veteran maternal granduncle (my mom's dad's older brother) who punched a Vietnamese-American restaurant waiter in the face and tried to strangle him after he had a flashback of being shot at/witnessing his squadmates getting killed by the Viet Cong when he saw that the waiter was Vietnamese, yet the judge who was assigned to his case disagreed and threw the case out/apologized to him for the police tackling him to the ground before arresting him/thanking him for his military service, just like Ironwood did for Weiss when the Trophy Wife demanded that she be arrested. For people who keep complaining about how RWBY portrays the military, these people have a surprising lack of respect for real world military veterans.

r/RWBYCynics • • Aug 26 '26

FUCK YOU, R/RWBYCRITICS!!! Remember kids: if someone tries to kidnap you, you're not allowed to defend yourself! Also, if someone gets hurt while trying to prevent you from getting kidnapped, then it's all your fault! /s

Post image
18 Upvotes

Also, another "critic" tried to blame Ruby, Jaune, Ren, Nora, and Qrow for not bringing antidotes/medicine with them. Apparently they were supposed to know that Salem had sent a maniacal scorpion Faunus after them, and prepare accordingly before they left for Mistral. Plus, gee, it's not like people in Remnant have the ability to make an invisible skin-level forcefield that protects them from stings or bites, which could potentially make it so they don't usually need to worry about that... oh, wait.


r/RWBYCynics • • Jun 21 '26

Complaint "People could hate on any other show. Why are people so obsessed with hating on RWBY? Actually, Why are Web animation shows getting so much hate? Why are their writers getting harassed?"

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/RWBYCynics • • Jun 17 '26

Meme RWBY has survived things that would have ended other shows. And yet Viz Media informed RWBY Fans that they have something special planned AND that Volume 10 is in production. Who was that youtuber that called RWBY "FemSlash Supernatural?" No matter what happens, it ENDURES and REFUSES to die!

Post image
32 Upvotes

r/RWBYCynics • • Jun 17 '26

Rant Just a reminder of what the people who talk about "rwby's wasted potential" and "monty's vision" come up with when they make a fanwork or a rewrite. Meinos Karen made a visual novel (JPDE) where you are a stereotypical Male Harem MC, and all LGBT are either abusive, in love with you, or villains.

Post image
28 Upvotes

Further note? All the women in JPDE are made stupid and weak compared to you, and all canon LGBT relationships such as Bumbleby are shut down so that you can sleep with lesbians and also the canon LGBT couples are rewritten to be abusive to each other so you can save the girls from the women abusing them.

In other words, the writers behind JPDE embarce the "domestic abuse" LGBT stereotype that has been debunked.

All of this, because the idea of a Visual Novel where you are a female/LGBT protagonist is taboo to RWBY fans.

I've spoken with the dude behind this fan novel.....he has literally said on discord that Monty Oum, a dude who crossdressed and designed women with pockets and designed Team RWBY AROUND their VAs? He felt that feminism and "wokeness" somehow "Went against monty's vision" and that by making this game , he was "preserving monty's vision"

Funny how everyone who talks about "fixing" rwby takes something that ,. while flawed, is MOST CERTAINLY PROGRESSIVE, and reduces it to patriarchal white supremacist garbage


r/RWBYCynics • • Jun 14 '26

FUCK YOU, R/RWBYCRITICS!!! Weiss didn't deserve what Jacques did to her, and my granduncle is proof

7 Upvotes

One of the RWBY criticisms that really makes me angry is that Weiss deserved to 1. have her heiress status removed, 2. get slapped in the face by Jacques, and 3. get locked in her bedroom by Jacques (with one critic even going so far as to say "bitch, this was your own fault!") when she summoned the Boarbatusk by accident because the Trophy Wife (that's actually the woman's official name, by the way) brought up her and her friends' trauma at the fall of Beacon by badmouthing both it and Vale, which is very similar to what happened to my late maternal granduncle (he was the older brother of my mom's late father).

Back in the 60's, my granduncle was drafted into Vietnam, which caused him to develop severe PTSD. Although he was mostly able to keep it under control, he unfortunately lost his composure in the year 1972. Namely, he had a Vietnam flashback and punched the waiter of a restaurant that he and his wife (my mom's aunt) visited for dinner in the face after he saw that the waiter was Vietnamese-American. The restaurant's manager called the police, who then tackled my granduncle to the ground and arrested him for assault. Based on the logic of what people are saying about Weiss, my granduncle deserved to be tackled and arrested. However, the judge that oversaw his case disagreed, as he threw the case out, apologized to him for how he was treated by the police, and thanked him for his service, kind of like how Ironwood responded to the Trophy Wife demanding that Weiss be arrested. This criticism is very insulting to both my granduncle and to military veterans in general, which is very ironic given how many members of the critics sub complain about how RWBY portrays the military.


r/RWBYCynics • • Jun 13 '26

Complaint How do so many people watch RWBY and ignore the fact that Ironwood is at eh end of the day, NOT a headmaster, but a military general who turns huntsmen that are supposed to protect all of Atlas into obedient little soldiers who will commit war crimes without question if he gives the order

Thumbnail reddit.com
8 Upvotes

r/RWBYCynics • • Jun 12 '26

Rant Jenn Tidwell , one of the people who worked with the RWBY Team? Had this to say about Hbomberguy making videos trashing on media like RWBY and on her co-workers...about how Hbomberguy has no media literacy and is a real jerk to people who he's never met but happy to slander

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/RWBYCynics • • Jun 10 '26

FUCK YOU, R/RWBYCRITICS!!! Team-HLRT (They're gone from tumblr now due to r/rwbycritics) pointed out that criticism of of media nowadays doesn't involve making criticism based around what they see, but now making criticism based on what they want to hate, and making up fake details in order to justify hatred.

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/RWBYCynics • • Jun 11 '26

FUCK YOU, R/RWBYCRITICS!!! And finally? The discussion about "Yang's anger issues"

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/RWBYCynics • • Jun 10 '26

Complaint Based on what one Youtuber had to say about RWBY Theorists and Qrow Branwen being Ruby's father...yeah, this actually makes sense...its projection on their end

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/RWBYCynics • • Jun 10 '26

FUCK YOU, R/RWBYCRITICS!!! The fanartist who made this fanart of Robyn Hill proudly declared she doesn't even watch RWBY, she just watches Judgmental Critter hate on RWBY. And its why people's attempts at redesigning RWBY characters COMPLETELY miss the point of the characters.

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/RWBYCynics • • Jun 07 '26

FUCK YOU, R/RWBYCRITICS!!! Let this be a reminder that the RWBY Hatedom tries to lie and gatekeep other people from watching RWBY. But the moment people give RWBY a chance, they find its actually a good show and they encourage it to others

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/RWBYCynics • • Jun 06 '26

FUCK YOU, R/RWBYCRITICS!!! I would've thanked her for the constructive criticism, because that's clearly what Yang was giving Ruby in that scene

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/RWBYCynics • • Jun 05 '26

Rant People who claim Ironwood was Character-Assassinated or that he was "botched by sloppy writing" make absolutely no sense

12 Upvotes

"Ironwood loses his aura he's still in dictator mode for some reason."

Penny? who ironwood forbade from having friends ever?

gaslightng and gatekeeping her?

volume? like having a giant mecha in argus without the populace's knowledge or consent while demanding their trust and loyalty, and having a racist nationalist base commander?

beacon? where ironwood demanded trust and respect but went behind everyone's backs with penny?

AND HE GOT OZPIN FIRED when Ozpin critiicized ironwood?

turning the huntsmen system into his own personal army and forbidding huntsmen from operating in atlas UNLESS they served him and him alone?

running mantle like a police state and using the very robots that attacked civilians....ot threaten mantle with compliance?

regularly doing whatever he wanted using his two council seats, but never stopping jacques corruption or abuse of faunus while ignoring checks and balances regularly?

ignoring and disrespecting the council at all times?

treating Robyn Hill as a terrorist for taking back the supplies he was stealing from Mantle without mant;e's permission?

treating robyn hill as a terrorist for empowering mantle's suppliers to boycott ironwood until he fixed the wall he ketp trying to degrade?

ignore volume 8, pretend it never happened.

ironwood's still a fascist dictator who backstabs everyone.

"he was favorable to rwby" NEPOTISM.

team rwby was seeing all of the EVIL ironwood committed...and people were upset Ruby didn't trust the dude who used his secret police aka the ace ops to arrest anyone protecting mantle from the grimm?

he didn't stop cinders' assault on beacon, he ENABLED IT.

Salem's agents were only able to do even half the damage they did because ironwood was an inexperienced soldier with no leadership skills or tactical skills whose only strategy was throw bodies at things and backstab others to get power while stealing from the poor.

oh, and dismantling established systems.

ironwood is a villain, not just an antagonist.

but his fascism brand and "good intentions" was something people found so appealing, they ignored the show and the details.

Yang and Blake didn't want to kidnap a political activist off the streets...ironwood wanted to. that's fascism.

Yang and Blake got Robyn to support ironwood.

ironwood backstabbed her in a heartbeat.


r/RWBYCynics • • Jun 05 '26

Rant RWBY's "critics" don't know what the word gaslighting means

9 Upvotes

Yesterday I found a person on the "critics" sub who adamantly argued that Ozpin gaslit Ruby into being the leader of her team so that her teammates could blame her if their future plans went wrong. That's the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard in my entire life, and it proves they weren't paying attention to the show. Ozpin picked Ruby to lead her team because she was the only member whose motivation for wanting to be a huntress (helping other people like her mother Summer did) wasn't selfish, which is also why he questioned Weiss, Blake, and Yang, but not her. Obviously this person doesn't know what the word gaslighting means, and deliberately ignores important moments just so they can jump to conclusions (i.e. make shit up) that they can force onto other members of their subreddit that have a similar mindset.


r/RWBYCynics • • Jun 02 '26

FUCK YOU, R/RWBYCRITICS!!! "It is beyond immoral to weigh one person's tragedy against another's in order to determine who's more deserving of sympathy"- Komaki Nakao from Fruits Basket

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/RWBYCynics • • Jun 02 '26

Complaint There was a dude on TikTok who made a fantastic video discussing how Ironwood from RWBY was always set up to be an antagonist, and showing how his execution was done well. Unfortunately, the Ironwood apologists began attacking the show on his video and bullied him off TikTok. Here is his legacy.

11 Upvotes

In fact, I tried posting this video elsewhere, and people who didn't even watch the video began attacking the show, screaming about "bad execution" and "sloppy writing".

Without even watching the video.


r/RWBYCynics • • Jun 01 '26

FUCK YOU, R/RWBYCRITICS!!! Just to show you further the struggles that Xel Writer as a channel goes through, and why smaller channels cannot thrive in a youtube climate of hate? These are three different youtube channels each attacking the same video he created of Robyn Hill

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/RWBYCynics • • Jun 01 '26

Rant I never would have imagined that 4 white conservative grifters would band together to form a hate channel where they harass an Indian dude who talks about things he enjoys, but welcome to RWBY fandom discourse. This is the new behavior by grifters. Attacking any channel that attempts to enjoy stuff

Post image
9 Upvotes

Seriously, type in Xel Writer's name into youtube, and see tons of videos from grifters hating on him...The poor kid just wants to talk about things he finds fun.

The Catlike character is the Vtube model Xel uses. As you can see? These 4 youtubers are basically doing whatever they can to hate on him.


r/RWBYCynics • • Jun 01 '26

Rant The "critics" are the most nitpicky and vindictive group I've ever seen

5 Upvotes

Seriously, the people on that subreddit are constantly dragging the show for small things that happened years ago. Case in point: it's been 7 years, and they're still calling Blake's "we're protecting each other" line from V6 "cringe". First of all, there was nothing wrong with that line, as it demonstrated that 1. Blake was no longer under Adam's spell, and 2. That she and Yang weren't afraid of him anymore. Second, that was almost a decade ago. Get. Over. It. Already! No wonder they hate Adam being portrayed as an abuser. It's exactly how they act: dragging their victim for even the smallest mistake (or something they view as a mistake), and continuing to so years/decades after the fact.


r/RWBYCynics • • May 27 '26

i have Found my home.....at last! a rwby subreddit that doesn't hate rwby......I AM FREE!

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/RWBYCynics • • May 26 '26

Complaint Remember how the people "Criticizing" RWBY have said that Neath Oum, Monty's Brother, somehow "never knew what Monty wanted" but somehow Hbomberguy did?

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/RWBYCynics • • May 22 '26

FUCK YOU, R/RWBYCRITICS!!! So youtuber Jeremynoir led a fascinating discussion about how RWBY seems to attract so much hate for a mere cartoon about autistic lesbians with guns, and I wanted to hear everyone else's feedback.

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/RWBYCynics • • May 22 '26

FUCK YOU, R/RWBYCRITICS!!! Like...no matter what the show and the writers and the voice actresses say, critics of shows like RWBY and SPOP will find a way to twist everything into slander towards the shows themselves

Post image
8 Upvotes