r/RWBYCynics • u/Monkey60t • 20d ago
Rant Why I don't think Weiss should be demonized for the Boarbatusk scene (rant-warning) Spoiler
I legitimately don't understand why people demonize Weiss for accidentally summoning the Boarbatusk when the Trophy Wife (yes, that's actually her credited name in the V4 credits) insulted Vale and Beacon Academy/the people there who died during the Fall of Beacon. Weiss fought in that battle, and lots of the students that she went to classes with were killed during it, so of course she got mad. This is basically the equivalent of the parent of a Sandy Hook victim punching a conspiracy theorist/denialist in the face for saying that it didn't happen/was staged, which I bet any critics reading this would also do in that situation if they were one of those parents.
Also, they're displaying blatant sexism and hypocrisy by praising the scene in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban where Harry is so angry at his Aunt Marge for insulting the deaths of his parents James and Lily that he accidentally uses the engorgement charm on her, causing her to blow up like a balloon and float out of the Dursley house and into the sky, and then pressing his wand up to his Uncle Vernon's neck when he tries to push Harry into his cupboard room so that he can beat him up afterwards. They say things like "Harry's aunt got what she deserved for insulting his parents' deaths", and "Harry put his abusive uncle in his place".
Both were instances of a teenager accidentally lashing out from anger when a snobby, entitled person insulted the deaths of innocent people that were very close to them, but for some reason they're willing to praise the boy who lashed out when someone insulted the deaths of his parents that were killed by Wizard Hitler right in front of him (albeit when he was only a baby), while also condemning the girl who accidentally summoned a violent hologram when someone claimed that everyone who died in a terrorist attack/demonic animal feeding frenzy that she fought bravely in to save as many people as she could "had it coming" for "not being properly civilized". Make it make sense, people!
Also, for those of you saying "Weiss could've killed that woman! She should've been locked up in a mental institution for the rest of her life!", I have two rebuttals:
- Harry could've killed both his Aunt Marge and his Uncle Vernon (the former by making her explode from touching something sharp or going high enough up in the air for the pressure drop to make her pop like a balloon, and the latter by accidentally setting him on fire with his wand or something), but I don't see anyone complaining about that, and
- You could say the same thing about my late Vietnam veteran maternal granduncle (my mom's dad's older brother) who punched a Vietnamese-American restaurant waiter in the face and tried to strangle him after he had a flashback of being shot at/witnessing his squadmates getting killed by the Viet Cong when he saw that the waiter was Vietnamese, yet the judge who was assigned to his case disagreed and threw the case out/apologized to him for the police tackling him to the ground before arresting him/thanking him for his military service, just like Ironwood did for Weiss when the Trophy Wife demanded that she be arrested. For people who keep complaining about how RWBY portrays the military, these people have a surprising lack of respect for real world military veterans.