r/RWBYcritics • u/HellishStampede • 9h ago
DISCUSSION It honestly grinds my gears how useless the girls were in the mansion
I know crapping on Ruby, Weiss, and Blake for twiddling their thumbs and sipping tea in the mansion isn't anything new. After rewatching it though it's even worse than I remembered.
If you think they're staying put because Nora got her rad lightning scar, they aren't. They're staying put because they are completely flabbergasted at how bad things have gotten, to the point where they literally can't plot their next move. Weiss even wonders if they should just sit tight and wait for an imaginary army to somehow come to Atlas's rescue like the Riders of Rohan.
When May barges in saying she can give the girls a lift to help protect Mantle in the crater the girls object saying "People are dying here in Atlas too." While doing jack about it. And then Ruby gives this moral speech about doing things together and that's how we'll get through this which is funny because they are still doing nothing to help and when they could've worked with Ironwood they lied to his face.
When Ruby suggests breaking Qrow and Robyn out of jail, May gets fed up and confronts them. She asks if they're going to help the Mantle crater or if they need a lift to the frontlines in Atlas, reminding them that this is a situation where not everyone wins. Blake, Weiss, and Ruby just stand there like deer in the headlights until Klein knocks on the door.
It turns out that while the girls were sipping tea, Whitley actually took the initiative to call a doctor for Nora. This earns him Weiss's affection, right after she pointed a weapon at his face despite Willow telling her that Whitley is a victim of Jacques's toxicity too. Then Whitley, not Weiss, almost solves the Mantle transport issue on his own when he remembers his family owns a fleet of cargo ships that can evacuate people.
Then as Ruby and Blake start up the private generator, Blake glazes Ruby for keeping going even when she doesn't know what to do. This is despite Blake going behind Ruby's back with Yang to tell Robyn about Amity, and never even giving Ruby a heads up about it.
These are the exact same girls who forced Atlas to stay put and thought they knew better than a general, even when they had no plan whatsoever and were completely lost on who to save next.
And then we have Ruby saying, "There are no sides!" right after she lied to Ironwood and told the whole world he couldn't be trusted. And Ruby asks herself, "How did it all get like this?" At that point, her self-awareness had to be lobotomized right along with her gun-nut quirk. It is directly her fault that Atlas stayed put long enough for that Grimm river geyser to shoot up and let Monstra land, all because she chose to lie to Ironwood and couldn't accept Mantle being abandoned as she's doing nothing to help save Mantle.
It's honestly amazing how reprehensible these three girls are, and Yang still has them beat for being the most annoying out of the four.
What do you think?