I’ve known a group of friends I met online for around 9 years. We’ve all met and hung out in person regularly, so it’s by no means solely online/long distance. The group is big, and branches out, and I’m not close with ALL of them, but most of them I am fairly chummy with. There’s around 12 of us total, and if I had to guess, 2 of them outright don’t like me. I can’t say why, I haven’t done anything personally to upset them, it sucks, but I don’t NEED everyone to like me, you know?
Anyhow, it’s been a great 9 years still and we regularly play hockey together. It’s something we can schedule for every week since everyone is so busy with life and family, we mostly get to only see each other at these meetups/league games. Before it was mostly casual, but we’ve done a Rec league over the last 2 years, so it’s gotten a lot more competitive but overall more fun! I play center usually, and I go anywhere I’m asked, whatever I’m needed at, even if I’m not the best at it. We do great though, and often outright win season games and playoffs, I’m proud of our little “Dad Bod Group”, lol! Well, our “Captain”, let’s call him, has been our shot caller. Him and I go way back too, we’re friends before teammates at this point, same with nearly everyone but those other two. 5 of our group are closer friends I introduced to the group at large, and everyone gets along amazingly well, even with the grumps who don’t like me, lol! It doesn’t matter though, I’m super happy they feel comfortable and made new friends, couldn’t ask for more.
However, recently, things started changing for the worse. Captain has always had a temper, and though he’s gotten a ton better, there’s this…source of elitism that’s going on and it’s creating a toxic environment. Captain has torn into me before about stuff involving the league, when I tried to introduce someone new named Corey a few years ago. I found Corey to be amazing, as a friend and player, but Captain said we had no room for him, and that I was “too busy eating Corey’s ass” to realize we couldn’t accommodate the guy. That was hurtful and immature, but I didn’t freak out on him over it, since it was just something said in anger when tempers were hot. I didn’t forget it though. Fast forward to the last year, Corey is an amazing addition everyone loves and room was made when Will, one of the wingers, had a daughter and needed to step down. Despite that, the toxicity keeps growing, both towards me and in general.
Captain suddenly introduces new people for upcoming season. Well, we don’t really HSVE the room, so suddenly I’m being rotated OUT to give the new people some games. I’m nearly the only person rotated out, and these new guys ARE better, but Captain scouted the specifically to give the team an edge, not because they are friends or anything, they’re unknown factors. One game was extremely important for me to play, I had visitors from out of town excited to come see me, but Captain sat me the entire game. I expressed after in a calm, but wordy (as you can tell), way how much this upset me and was totally unnecessary to do. He immediately turned it around on me, saying I shouldn’t “crash out” so hard for being sat, and I “always do this”. I’ve happily volunteered to be sat for SEVERAL games too, either because I had a bad night or I thought someone else could help us win, so I was seriously confused and insulted that he said this. It was “put on ice” (lol) for later with no real conclusion.
It kept getting worse, I was getting sat nearly every game, and for the entire playoffs last year, I was sat. Not because I was bad or failed the team, we won nearly ALL the time, but the people they scouted were better. Hell, they were scouted specifically to replace me, of course they’re better, but…I feel crazy here, I thought this was about playing as friends together while going for a big goal! I wasn’t failing or holding us back, but only I was being isolated from everyone and having my position taken by relative strangers. Some of the guys spoke up, but Captain is a self admitted control freak, so he shot them down along with me. These guys, my closer friends included, really want to stick together with the team, so I know they aren’t keen on risking their positions for my sake. Lots of the new guys went AWOL or leap-frogged to other teams using the records gotten with us, and I naively thought I’d get to play again, but…Captain scouted even more people, specifically in the positions I play, so it kinda starts feeling personal. I keep being faded into the background, and feeling hurt, which makes it harder to interact with everyone like I used to.
Again, I try to talk it out, but get accused of the same, that I’m too wordy, that it’s just a rec game, no need to take it seriously, and so on. After the third string of benches, they finally admit they could communicate better and will try going forward. More hopeful than ever, I come back for more, just for it to happen AGAIN, this time because a friend of one of the newly scouted people wants to play, so I voluntarily step out to give him a go with the promise I’ll be in next game! I show to next game, the friend is there all suited up and on the ice already…? And I’m told they’re sticking with him this week. I finally snap, pack back up, and go home. I don’t make a scene, nearly no one knew I even showed up besides Captain, but he texts me later that he was GOING to switch me over for the friend on the ice, but since I stormed off, he couldn’t! I think there’s a term for that somewhere, hmmm…
I responded, very upset, that I’m not buying the lies and gaslighting, that if he was going to have me in, he wouldn’t have had the friend suit up nor told me I was benched again this week. No answer for that, Captain deflects to other things and tells me these guys are more athletic and should be in anyhow, and I’m just aghast at what this group of “friends” has become, that I have to fight this hard just to be included, fighting battles most the others DON’T have to, especially Captain, who objectively is worse than I am. He’s the Captain though, so he’s safe. If he wasn’t Captain though, I still would never replace him, because that’s still insane to me to replace friends with strangers like this. If I were a true drag on the group, I just wouldn’t play, but that’s not the case. Anyhow, we both get heated, and he’s not insulting me like usual,, and I bust out the old insult he used, and said “if you weren’t so busy eating the new guys’ asses, you’d see how fucked up you’ve been treating me.”
Well, that must have thrown him through a loop, and he must not have remembered using it on me either. Cap didn’t contact me until the next day, and called me abusive and manipulative…which is weird, because that would insinuate I get my way, which I DON’T, clearly. Also something about how if I talked this way to a boss, I’d be fired, which is also super weird, since this isn’t a JOB. It’s a group of friends testing our teamwork. He tries the gaslighting I called him out on again and caps it off by saying if I’m plan on playing again, I should try another team. That he’s done talking to outside of a group setting. So not an outright kick from the team, but a clear sign I’m not welcome. I’ve taken time away from it all and haven’t met up with any of them since. I recapped the event with one of the group members that gathered us all up to begin with, but I haven’t heard back from him since. Not a word from any of the others either. I know a lot of the are averse to drama, and I sure don’t blame them! The others though, I thought I’d hear from them by now but who knows how I’m being slandered or demonized by Captain at this point.
I was at fault for being petty and reusing his same gross insult. I’m also sorry in general for being upset, I should have remained calm, but after these events and the roster string alongs, time after time after time, I couldn’t believe they kept doing it. I kept coming back, so that must have made it easy, I’m sure. I want to know if there’s a way to salvage this, or if I should cut my losses. I don’t want to lose the group dynamic, I built so much of this group up well before the “merge”, but the toxicity I mentioned is becoming a serious issue, and I don’t know if it’s possible to get through to them. I don’t hate anyone or want anyone to leave, I just wish there was some empathy and accountability, but since they aren’t being left out consistently, they don’t really know how crummy it is to lose all this time bonding and hanging together, then get treated like a wall decoration. It could be sunk-cost fallacy, but it’s way more a desire for how it was, all about personal connections. Anyhow, thanks for reading my “novel” if you did. I promise no AI wrote this, so I’ll proudly leave in any spelling or grammar mistakes, lol!
TLDR;
Friend group of 9 years plays hockey, self appointed Captain starts excluding me while picking up more athletic strangers. Fight ensues after several months of benching, words are traded, and Captain levels some serious accusations that are mostly projecting, and now refuses 1 on 1 contact. Looking to salvage it all or a clean way to break off while maintaining contact with those I get along the most.