r/shakespeare • • Jan 22 '22

[ADMIN] There Is No Authorship Question

304 Upvotes

Hi All,

So I just removed a post of a video where James Shapiro talks about how he shut down a Supreme Court justice's Oxfordian argument. Meanwhile, there's a very popular post that's already highly upvoted with lots of comments on "what's the weirdest authorship theory you know". I had left that one up because it felt like it was just going to end up with a laundry list of theories (which can be useful), not an argument about them. I'm questioning my decision, there.

I'm trying to prevent the issue from devolving into an echo chamber where we remove all posts and comments trying to argue one side of the "debate" while letting the other side have a field day with it and then claiming that, obviously, they're the ones that are right because there's no rebuttal. Those of us in the US get too much of that every day in our politics, and it's destroyed plenty of subs before us. I'd rather not get to that.

So, let's discuss. Do we want no authorship posts, or do we want both sides to be able to post freely? I'm not sure there's a way to amend the rule that says "I want to only allow the posts I agree with, without sounding like all I'm doing is silencing debate on the subject."

I think my position is obvious. I'd be happier to never see the words "authorship" and "question" together again. There isn't a question. But I'm willing to acknowledge if a majority of others feel differently than I do (again, see US .... ah, never mind, you get the idea :))


r/shakespeare • • 4h ago

Harriet Walter: Young people need Shakespeare more than ever

Thumbnail observer.co.uk
62 Upvotes

The actor has seen the transformative power of theatre in schools and prisons. The arts are no soft and fluffy add-on to society – they may be its salvation, writes Walter


r/shakespeare • • 10h ago

Got berammed, beranked, and bucked off in a buckbasket

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/shakespeare • • 7h ago

Are the early historical works worth reading as a newcomer to Shakespeare?

5 Upvotes

I finally decided to delve into Shakespeare having not read any of his work previously before, not even in school. The interest came from stumbling upon clips on Youtube of actors performing his work such as the recently departed Sir Patrick Stewart, along with Ralph Fiennes, Sir Ian McKellen and all the rest of Britain’s finest. Luckily, my late grandfather had what I assume to be the complete works of Shakespeare, separated according to genre. I looked up the chronology of his work, since I enjoy seeing an artist’s work (in any medium) in release order to see their growth. I figured out that his early work is comprised mostly of the Histories and Comedies. To be honest, the Comedies doesn’t appeal to my interest, at least for now, but as someone who have read historical texts mostly from Ancient Greek and Roman writers, I am perfectly open to the Histories. So I started reading Henry IV and though I haven’t really gotten all that far yet, it seems like a rather standard dramatized historical narrative with none of the flair and intelligent wordplay I expected from someone of Shakespeare’s reknown. It’s still good for what it is, but it’s not exactly what I’m looking for or perhaps expecting. So now I find myself tempted to maybe save the Histories for another day and jump straight to the Tragedies, since afterall that’s where most of his notable works lie. My question is, should I? Or should I stick with the Histories and try to find something to appreciate there?


r/shakespeare • • 7h ago

Help making playlist for Quince

2 Upvotes

Hi! Currently in a production of midsummer nights dream. And been tasked to create a playlist for Quince. Would anybody have any recommendations of songs I could include. Modern would be good but any era would be appreciated as my cast loves all genres.
THANKS


r/shakespeare • • 7h ago

Two edition checks: Tempest IV.i speech start, Cymbeline act 1 scene count

0 Upvotes

I have been building an index of the plays that will only answer with a line it can actually pull from its own text, so it quotes or it shuts up. Two things I would like checked by someone with a printed copy open.

  1. The Tempest, act IV, scene I, Prospero:

"You do look, my son, in a mov'd sort, As if you were dismay'd: be cheerful, sir: Our revels now are ended. These our actors, As I foretold you, were all spirits and Are melted into air, into thin air..."

Is that where the speech starts in your edition, and does the scene stand at IV.i there? My index has "We are such stuff as dreams are made on" a little further down inside the same speech.

2) Cymbeline, act I. My index numbers seven scenes in that act, so what another text prints as 1.6 lands at I.VII in mine. If Cymbeline is within reach: six scenes or seven in your act one, and what do you call the last one?

An error is more use to me than a confirmation. If a line sits somewhere else in your book, tell me where it sits.


r/shakespeare • • 1d ago

Love's Labour's Lost: Pastorall, Pastorall-Comicall, or Comicall ?

7 Upvotes

I'm having a hard time with this one. I guess nominally it's comical, because it fits the shoe, but I just seem to always regard it as pastoral. It strikes me as an escape from the grind, into a whole different kind of grind, aesthetics with asceticism in roundtable, retreat far from civilization. Sort of like a happy version of Wagner's Parsifal.


r/shakespeare • • 21h ago

tatuagem hamlet

2 Upvotes

Oie gente vocês podem me ajudar com ideias de frases da obra hamlet para tatuar?


r/shakespeare • • 1d ago

Meme Who is Brutus Bootless?

3 Upvotes

In Julius Caesar Act 3 Scene 1 right when they're about to stab the big guy all the conspirators are kneeling to ask for Publius Cimber to be unbanished, setting the stage for Casca (and the others) to strike.

Before he's stabbed, Caesar asks "Doth not Brutus Bootless kneel?" Now I know about Marcus Brutus (my goat) and Decius Brutus (the dream guy) but I don't know who Brutus Bootless is. He's never mentioned again.

All we know about him is that Caesar is implying he may be kneeling at the time. Is he related to the other Bruti?


r/shakespeare • • 2d ago

"Give sorrow words..." — Shakespeare's hauntingly beautiful reminder from Macbeth.

Post image
243 Upvotes

Holding grief inside just tears us apart from the within. Unspoken sorrow keeps whispering to a heavy heart until it breaks. Felt this deeply tonight, so I just wanted to share this piece of comfort with you all.


r/shakespeare • • 2d ago

Ask me if I'm happy??

Post image
32 Upvotes

Found on Vinted at a great price (in Italian with the original text side by side) very happy!


r/shakespeare • • 2d ago

Old Vic

Post image
43 Upvotes

Tickets now on sale for Henry V starring Damian Lewis at the Old Vic (took me 2 1/2 hours in online queue…)
Am having a Shakespeare weekend- Henry V on Sat, Julius Caesar at the Globe on Sunday!


r/shakespeare • • 1d ago

Meme Question

0 Upvotes

Why did Antony meet his downfall even though he chose the third casket, just like Bassanio? The same goes for Desdemona.

Translated with AI.


r/shakespeare • • 1d ago

Andrew Aguecheek is the guru of Twelfe Night

3 Upvotes

Aguecheek doesn't really aspire to anything. If he cloaks himself in ambition, it's borrowed robes. He is everyone's foil: Malvolio's, The Foole's, Sir Toby Belch's, Duke Orsino's, Viola's (fencer to the Sophy). He is like a black hole, in that you don't really notice he's there, but everyone's light disappears into him.

foole.

Beshrew me, þe knights in admirable fooling.

And.

I, he do’s well enough if he be dispos’d, and so do I too : he does it wiþ a better grace, but I do it more naturall.

r/shakespeare • • 1d ago

Revenge and/or vengence in Macbeth?

0 Upvotes

i have a essay to write on the topic Revenge and vengence for school, its pretty long (like 13 paragraphs) so does anyone have any tips? thanks.


r/shakespeare • • 2d ago

"Nobody; I myself

2 Upvotes

A reading I'd like to test against people who know the play better than I do.

**Othello is not naive.** "Free and open nature" is Iago's description (1.3), not the play's verdict. A man sold into slavery who rose to general, who meets drawn swords with "Keep up your bright swords" and demands "ocular proof," doesn't trust easily. I read the openness as a persona an outsider needs in Venice. Underneath he trusts no one, not even Iago, whom he threatens with death if the proof fails.

**Desdemona is the trusting one.** By Othello's own account, "She loved me for the dangers I had passed, / And I loved her that she did pity them." Pity, not understanding. She then pushes Cassio's suit ("his bed shall seem a school, his board a shrift") without seeing what it costs.

**The Willow Song previews the last words.** In 4.3 she sings "Let nobody blame him; his scorn I approve—" then breaks off: "Nay, that's not next." In 5.2: "Nobody; I myself." Same shape twice. First the song's resignation ("nobody"), then a self-correction ("I myself"). In the ballad as Percy printed it, the line is "Let nobody blame *me*." She changes "me" to "him" in 4.3, and returns to "me" with her last breath.

So I read "I myself" as more than a loving lie. It is a dying recognition that she never understood the man she married.

Has anyone made this connection before? I'd like to know where it's been argued, or refuted.

*(English isn't my first language. I used an AI, Claude, to help translate and draft this.)*


r/shakespeare • • 2d ago

fanfic I wrote

Post image
0 Upvotes

apologies if I'm not allowed to promote this on here! please feel free to take it down if so :>


r/shakespeare • • 2d ago

Can someone please help me figure out this monologue?

Post image
28 Upvotes

I’m auditioning for Romeo and Juliet in the coming weeks, and I’ve never really had much experience with reading/performing in verse, outside of certain classes. This is the monologue I’m performing, and I’ve marked it with the emphasized syllables underlined in blue, and the amount of extra syllables marked in red. I’m honestly just looking for any extra guidance on this lol, so some help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!


r/shakespeare • • 3d ago

Homework Hamlet "to be or not to be" soliloquy interpretation.

35 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I'm taking my first university philosphy class this year and we have to interpret "to be or not to be" in Hamlet. My issue is that my professor has a very unconventional interpretation that we are supposed to follow, that I just don't understand.

The common interpretation of this scene is that hamlet is asking whether he should live or die because he doesn't want to battle with his mind anymore. Hamlet says "to die, to sleep" and "when we have shuffled off this mortal coil" which aligns with that interpretation.

My philosophy teacher interprets it as: because hamlet is already being, he is not asking whether to be or not to be, he is asking how to be. In order to doubt your own existence you must be. both taking arms against a sea of troubles and fighting what brings you harm are not ideal because they both lead to eventual demise for you. Like the taking arms is affirmation of life and nilhlism both require there to be life.

We are expected to follow this interpretation to not get marks off, but im just very confused why it has to be so convoluded. I wasjust wondering if anyone else knows about this philisophical interpretation and how it should be wirtten?


r/shakespeare • • 3d ago

Antony’s speech might be the best use of verbal irony ever written. Keith Mitchell nailed it.

37 Upvotes

I’ve been watching all of the BBC productions of Shakespeare, all of which are well over 40 years old. I remember our high school teacher had us watch the 1978 production from said series. The actors’ affectations helped young me understand what was otherwise a difficult plot to fully grasp.

But I never understood as a junior in high school why Antony (Keith Mitchell) labeled Brutus as honorable, with Mitchell downplaying the verbal irony that went over my head at the time. I remember the teacher’s asking up to cite reasons why Antony’s speech was so effective. Never was the discrepancy between Antony’s descriptions of Brutus and Caesar (“honorable” and “ambitious, respectively) and their factual actions that belied those qualities brought up.

Rewatching it over 20 years later, I get it. I praise Mitchell for his subtlety (avoiding blatant sarcasm, that might come across as petty or contriving to his audience) and cannot imagine how difficult enacting said speech must be. With irony, there’s a fine line between spelling out the discrepancy between the truth and reality perceived by others. Mitchell does not make his intentions obvious, maintaining the moral high ground and also respecting Brutus’ request to not speak ill of them albeit in a roundabout, passive-aggressive way.

Damian Lewis did a fine job with that in this clip too - here!

https://youtu.be/q89MLuLSJgk

Kudos to all the Antonys out there that walked that thin line gracefully, conveying a convincing tone to those easily-swayed Romans without coming across as a disparaging, bitter man overtly seeking revenge.


r/shakespeare • • 2d ago

Translating Twelfth Night into Klingon (yes, really) - Arden 3 or 4?

7 Upvotes

EDIT: I didn't realize that the fourth edition won't be available until March 🤦

Hi all,

It might sound a little outlandish, but I'm part of a weekly Klingon Shakespeare study group. For context, there's a line in one of the Star Trek movies where a Klingon character says, "You have not experienced Shakespeare until you have read him in the original Klingon." This, of course, inspired the Klingon language community to create an "original Klingon" version of Hamlet, followed by Much Ado About Nothing. Our group has recently finished reading both, and now the task has fallen to me to "restore" the "corrupted Federation version" of Twelfth Night to its former Klingon glory.

I've been using what annotations and discussions I can find online, but I want to get a truly exhaustive annotated print version of the play, so I can better understand the meaning of the more obscure lines. Much of the fun of Klingon Shakespeare translation is adapting the situations, references, and puns (for example, Curio and Orsino's exchange about hunting the hart/heart is now about the chemvaH, because a Klingon woman makes noises like a chemvaH during courtship.)

I've heard that Arden is the best source for very detailed Shakespeare annotations, although I'm open to other suggestions too. I've also seen from posts on this subreddit that the print quality and font choice for the 4th edition leaves a lot to be desired, but the quality of the annotations and commentary is much more important for my purposes. After all, the Klingon Dictionary is infamously cheap and fragile, but it's the source document for our entire community. So, for those of you who have read both the 3rd and 4th editions of Arden Twelfth Night, which do you recommend, strictly on the basis of the contents?


r/shakespeare • • 3d ago

Earth/ground metaphors

7 Upvotes

It may sound extremely specific, but which Shakespeare works do you think feature the most / the coolest metaphors or wordplays related to the earth? I'm currently diving back into Hamlet and of course I'm finding plenty, so I am just wondering if there are more in other opuses


r/shakespeare • • 3d ago

Looking for pieces of text that changed meaning/impact over time because of the way slang and words have changed meaning.

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

Heyhey,

So I'm trying to read my copy of Shakespeare, and since English is not my 1st language, and I'm bad with names, this has proven to be a challenge.

For the names I found a solution: Marking them in Collours and keeping a post-it close-by while reading so I know who is who.

For understanding the text I have been trying my best, but ofcourse there are parts that are hard.

The thing is, I wanna understand the text as good as possible, and I am aware (but can't remember a single example, or find one with google that isn't behind a paywall), that some jokes, words, or even pieces of text have been lost to time, because the slang, meaning of words, or even the words themselves, changed.

I am looking for these, so I can anotate by book, but like said before, I have a hard time finding them.

So I was hoping this Subredit might help!

I am happy if you can give some examples (preferably including play, character & scene), or if you can point me in the right direction where I can find some that isn't behind paywall!

Any and all help is welcome!

Also, the reason the book is in such terrible state is because I bought it second-hand from the library (the stamp that they got rid of it is visible, but I crossed out which library since it would give away my town)


r/shakespeare • • 2d ago

Shakespeare’s Sonnets Equation, True or False?

Post image
0 Upvotes

It is my privilege and delight to announce that after 18 months debate between Avishai Roif, Matthew Collins and a chance essay discovered on academia that we can finally come to a decision on Alan Green's Great Pyramid Theory! Check it out...

Shakespeare's "Sonnets Equation", True or False:

On this most inauspicious day of the year, Friday 13th, I have some good news and revelations as a prophylactic to the disinformation and misinformation provided by Alan Green's "Shakespeare Sonnets Great Pyramid Delusion". While the controversial Shakespeare Authorship Contention was in "full swing" towards the beginning of the 21st century another academic supposition emerged amongst Shakespeare scholars, academics and cryptographers, namely was there any hidden structure, code or cipher contained in the 154 verses of "Shakespeare's Sonnets"? And furthermore since they were assumed to be of a 'biographical nature' if such a pattern might reveal the true identity of the author in the light of the Shakespeare Authorship Controversy itself and finally 'put it to bed'. Although my maths education was somewhat elementary I turned my attention to see if any "triumphal form" could be deduced numerically from its lines and verses. Sometime in 2016 the author Alan Green came up with a sensational (and I might add fantastical) theory that made some comparison with the number of stone courses of the Great Pyramid of Giza (Khufu's Pyramid) and the number of verses contained in Shakespeare's Sonnets. His public announcement coincided with the release of his first book in a series "De-Coding Shakespeare" which was followed by an internet website that was designed to explain the basis of his supposed discoveries and theories.

https://www.academia.edu/145187273/Shakespeare_s_Sonnets_Equation_True_or_False


r/shakespeare • • 3d ago

Richard II

11 Upvotes

I'm reading Richard II, I've reached Act 1, Scene 3.

Something tells me I haven't quite read our Richard right so far, he is NOT the good guy in this situation, or am I wrong?

I'm afraid I've lost the thread a bit:

Basically, did Mowbray actually kill the Duke of Gloucester, but Richard told him to do it?

The two contenders are getting ready for a duel... everyone's all set, and what does Richard do? Suddenly, he banishes them both.

Please don't Downvote me😅😅

it's pretty much the first time I'm reading a Shakespeare play without knowing the story beforehand

let's see how it goes from here 😁

It's starting to grow on me, though!