r/signal • • Sep 16 '26

Beta Discussion Signal enables phone-numberless registration for Android beta users

Thumbnail community.signalusers.org
427 Upvotes

r/signal • • Sep 04 '26

Announcement Pushing your vibe-coded messenger will get you banned

783 Upvotes

A couple times each week, we get some rando pushing a new vibe-coded messaging app. These are presented as though they are finished, established products but have various red flags. Some of the common ones are:

  • Codebase is only months (or days) old
  • A single developer
  • Codebase has very few commits
  • No indication of the developer's security or cryptography bona-fides
  • No indication of security review by reputable external parties
  • No indication the developer is equipped to support and maintain production software

These projects are the very epitome of security-compromising suggestions (Rule 4).

If you look at the rules here, security-compromising suggestions are actually allowed, but you must be clear about what the security/privacy downsides are.

Pitching your educational, experimental project as though it is a professional-quality security tool can cause real harm to people.

It's great that you're building stuff and trying new things. Keep doing it. There's even room here in r/signal to show off your educational experiment, as long as you (a) tie the discussion to Signal and (b) participate in this sub more generally.

The moment you act like your experimental project is a serious, seasoned security tool, we will show you the door.


r/signal • • 4h ago

Feature Request Why no default timer for all chats?

0 Upvotes

It's a bit of a bummer that there's no such thing as default timer for all chats in the settings. For some reason we only have a default timer for chats that we ourselves start. Why do you think that's a fact? I'd really like to see the generalized burner happening.


r/signal • • 5h ago

Article Signal brings chat folders to iOS (beta)

Thumbnail aboutsignal.com
1 Upvotes

After Android and Desktop, chat folders are now available in Signal iOS beta version 8.39!


r/signal • • 1d ago

Answered photos delete for everyone?

38 Upvotes

My boyfriend and I have broken up and over the years I sent him several nudes via Signal. I know he may have downloaded them already, but I’d still like to delete for all on the app. When I delete a message I sent him, it gives me the option to delete for everyone or delete for me. I just tried to bulk delete some photos, though, and it only gave me a single option: delete. Is this a quirk of the system, is it also deleting for him? I also wonder if it means he’s blocked me. Thanks. We’re talking years worth of stuff, so if it only deletes on my phone I don’t wanna bother. I’m on a iPhone in case it matters.


r/signal • • 8h ago

Help Desktop App Updates

0 Upvotes

Why does the desktop app update three times daily?


r/signal • • 1d ago

Android Help Syncing the new on device format backup offsite without taking phone space

3 Upvotes

Hello, I was wondering if anyone had found a method of moving off the new signal backups (the deduplicated new format in folders instead of .backup files) to an offsite server.

To describe my old setup, i had signal take an on device backup and once it was done i had an external app named foldersync to send that backup to a webdav server i control in the cloud and then delete the .backup from my phone so i could claim the storage back.

Although recently the new format came along with folders and multiple files, and while i find it a pretty good upgrade especially the deduplication feature (I checked my signal back ups folder recently on said webdav server and noticed it is nearly reaching 1tb of backups!) it sadly would not work well with foldersync to my knowledge. Since signal relies to have the old backup on device in order to deduplicate it.

Unless signal had some kind of method to connect to a webdav/sftp/ftp/whatever protocol server by itself and put the backup there by itself. I am not exactly sure how i can keep my offsite backups system going.

The only idea i had is if it is somehow possible to mount a network share in a specific folder similar to how it is done on linux but i cannot find anything that would suit my needs.

I am aware that signal offers their own secure backups service for a cheap price (Which i just subscribed to) but i would prefer to also keep my own backups if possible.


r/signal • • 1d ago

Android Help Double check mark but not delivered

2 Upvotes

Where I live has intermittent reception (shitty Australian NBN satellite).

Often I'll get a bunch of messages come through at once, sometimes a day afterwards.

However on the sender's side, it will say delivered (two circles, not black). Someone just low key accused me of ducking them (I owe them money). They sebt me a msg last night but I didn't get it till this morning. The internet was definitely working last night as I was listening to music.

My phone is kind of old (its either an S8 or S9) and my android version is 9.

Sometimes people will respond to a msg I sent and it won't even show as two black circles, but they must've seen it because they responded.

Is this a signal bug or is my phone too old to function properly?


r/signal • • 8h ago

Discussion This is why Signal get disabled, because this is important?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/signal • • 1d ago

iOS Help Long list of old signal groups

5 Upvotes

Apologies if this is a common issue; I couldn't find anything in reddit or Google search but wasn't sure what search terms to use.

When I go to add someone to a new group chat, Signal now lists every group chat to which I've ever belonged. Previously it listed the most recent groups up top so it was easy to find new groups. In my case this is a list of hundreds of chats because I've organized a weekly event for years with a new group of people each week. Most are empty from disappearing messages. They are deleted from my phone and do not appear when I search for the group name. How can I find these groups to leave them in bulk or one by one, or is there a way to simply get the old functionality back where Signal shows "recent groups" at the top when adding a person to a group?


r/signal • • 1d ago

Help Messages inconsistent across phone and desktop?

1 Upvotes

I'm having a wierd issue. I have signal installed on one phone, and one desktop app, and the messages I can see in a group are completely inconsistent.

It looks something like this:

P1: Hi! <- Sent from desktop, visible on both
P2: Hi back! <- not visible on desktop
P2: How's stuff? <- not visible on phone
P1: stuff! <- sent from phone, not visible on desktop
P2: Stuff is cool!<- not visible on desktop
[you get the idea]

And then some of the missing messages show up after an hour or so, completely out of order.

What's going on, and is there a way to fix it? (Some form of reset so it stops happening, maybe?)


r/signal • • 1d ago

Android Help Automatically save photos to the internal gallery?

4 Upvotes

Similar to WhatsApp.

Possible on Android?


r/signal • • 1d ago

Help anyone else get weird buzzing during calls?

6 Upvotes

my girlfriend and i frequently call on signal and discord, usually with sound canceling off (ios feature included). and whenever we are on signal specifically, there will occasionally be this strange short buzzing sound, like a bug is flying by the microphone for a moment, or like somebody is humming with low bitrate.

does anyone else have this issue? it doesnt really bother us but we both mention it as "ah the bees are back"


r/signal • • 2d ago

Android Help Add donations via Play Store credit/balance

11 Upvotes

Now that numberless account registration is an official option and is working correctly, having the option to donate via my Play Store credit/balance would be great.

Registering a numberless account via this way is possible, so adding the flow for donations should be easy?

I have a big amount of Play Store balance and don't think I'll ever use it all, would love to donate most of it and get the Signal donor badge.


r/signal • • 3d ago

Blog Post Proudly nonprofit

Thumbnail signal.org
149 Upvotes

r/signal • • 2d ago

Help Question about blocked user messages

1 Upvotes

If I've blocked someone and they deleted the entire conversation for everyone after being blocked, will unblocking them delete the messages on my end? I'm trying to utilize the search function, which I can't do now that I've blocked them.


r/signal • • 2d ago

Discussion READ BEFORE YOU SWITCH PHONES!

0 Upvotes

Hey all. I didn't know what to tag this with, this is a sorta-awareness, sorta-help post, but I don't think there's anything i can do so I'm just gonna spread awareness of the issue. Skip to the bold text at the bottom if you don't care about my story.

My mom recently switched phones, from an iPhone 13 to the new iPhone 18. When setting up the new phone, she transferred her data from her old phone by sitting the old one next to the new one during setup. Once her new phone said her data had been 100% transferred, she took her new phone and started doing stuff. She hadn't opened Signal yet.

Well, she had to go to the pharmacy, and at the pharmacy she ran into my older sister and her littles. My mom decided to give her old phone to the eldest of the children (don't worry, they weren't that little, but they were kids), and so she factory reset her old phone with the help of my other sister. Remember, her new phone said her data had been 100% transferred. Even the Wi-Fi password came over automatically!

Weeeeell... Later on, she finally opened Signal. It still needed her to log in. No worries. The issue is, she was stuck on a screen where she can either recover her past messages with a 64-character code, or start fresh.

So, I don't mean to be rude, but... What were they thinking? Why would you make that the (at least as far as we're concerned) only option? We're pretty sure there's nothing we can do, she's researched everything and there's nothing she can find. How is she supposed to get a code from an app installation that no longer exists? This is her first time switching phones whilst using Signal, last time she switched phones she didn't use Signal.

This doesn't seem like that big of a deal on the surface, but oh, yes it is.

My grandma died of pancreatic cancer in 2023. I don't really want to get into the details, but the hospital failed her baaadly. It was not fair. Well, the only service she used (from when my mom, grandpa and grandma all switched, up until she died) was Signal. My mom's texts with my grandma are literally gone. There was no warning, she never knew Signal didn't sync her messages to her account.

She is beyond devastated. She is crushed over the situation, there really doesn't seem to be anything she can do. She trusted Signal because it's the app for "privacy", it's the "non-profit", "no ads", "no trackers" app. The good app, not owned by a giant tech conglomerate. The trustworthy app. But now all of her texts with her dead mom are completely gone.

If you know ANYTHING we can do, please do not hesitate to leave it in the comments! I presume she's gotten past that screen because she was just on a call with my dad on Signal, but I don't want to ask at this moment because they're still on the call, and also she's extremely sad about the whole thing, i don't think she wants to talk about it. At this time, the messages have not been restored.

Anywho, BEFORE wiping your old phone, PLEASE make sure your text messages have transferred over to Signal properly. Do NOT trust the default iOS data transfer process to carry over Signal messages. It does not seem to work.


r/signal • • 3d ago

Article Know Your Contacts: Usable Authentication for Secure Messaging

Thumbnail tsmr.eu
32 Upvotes

r/signal • • 3d ago

iOS Help I can’t download and view pictures

Post image
12 Upvotes

I’ve been noticing for a while the pictures others and I have sent on Signal can’t be viewed or downloaded. This suddenly happened a long while ago despite having disappearing messages off, never deleted the app, and a good internet connection.

Although I only have a few chats, the issue seems to apply to every past media message sent. Someone did seem to have the same issue before, but updating Signal and being on the latest version unfortunately doesn’t fix it.

I’d appreciate ya’ll for your help! Thanks a lot!


r/signal • • 3d ago

Feature Request Selfhosting?

0 Upvotes

When or will some day it happen that we can selfhost signal? like matrix element chat? And local only notifications with vpn etc


r/signal • • 4d ago

Android Help Backup didn't work. I followed the directions.

7 Upvotes

If anyone could successfully help me, I'd really appreciate it. I had to restore my Android phone that held my Signal account. I also have multiple computers that I was using for the same account and my messages still show there, and I created a backup using the Desktop Backups function. I sent the 3 files to myself using another app and saved them on my Android. I uninstalled Signal and re-installed it, then followed the prompts to to restore from a desktop file. I located the folder and put in my key. It showed that downloaded the files (66 bytes or so). But, no chats show in the app. I have performed this cycle multiple times.

Am I doing something wrong? What could be amiss here?


r/signal • • 5d ago

Discussion phone number

28 Upvotes

I read that Signal now supports registration without a phone number. Is it possible to remove the phone number from an existing account? Also, is it true that you have to use Google Play to pay for this? That seems pretty dumb, since many people, myself included, don’t use anything Google or apple


r/signal • • 6d ago

Help Ding dong noise

5 Upvotes

Hi, is there a way to turn off the ding dong noise when a call connects? My undiagnosed echophalia makes me repeat it every time. TIA.


r/signal • • 6d ago

iOS Help view once media screen capture

2 Upvotes

i’m wondering if the view once media can be screenshotted by whoever i send it to. would i be notified if that were the case?

think of sending some saucier pics with face, but idk.

thanks!


r/signal • • 6d ago

Android Help Trying to send video, getting cut

8 Upvotes

I tried to send a video, 34mb in size and a minute and a half long, and Signal only sends the first five seconds.

I've sent longer and larger videos in the past. What is wrong?

Version 8.36.0