r/socialscience • u/Osho1982 • 7h ago
My study on crisis learning, transparency, and "second-order reliability" was just awarded the 2026 Charles Moskos Prize
I am excited to share that my article, "Crisis Response and Institutional Learning in the Israeli Military: Negotiating Transparency and Security in the Aftermath of the Tze’elim Training Accidents" (published in Armed Forces & Society), has been selected for the 2026 Charles Moskos Prize by the Inter-University Seminar on Armed Forces and Society.
Although the empirical case focuses on the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), the study was designed to bridge military sociology, High-Reliability Organization (HRO) safety science, and crisis communication. Whenever a high-stakes institution experiences a major failure (whether in defense, aviation, healthcare, or critical infrastructure), leadership faces an immediate dilemma: how to protect sensitive operational information while maintaining public trust and genuinely learning from what went wrong.
Using a longitudinal, mixed-methods comparative discourse analysis of the Tze’elim training accidents, the paper introduces the concept of "second-order reliability" and highlights three core findings:
- Reliability requires perceived accountability: In modern information environments, it is not enough for high-stakes organizations to be operationally safe and competent in practice (first-order reliability). To sustain legitimacy, they must also be perceived as transparent and accountable by external stakeholders (second-order reliability).
- Reflexive secrecy backfires: Over-relying on confidentiality or "security" arguments to shield an institution from scrutiny erodes public confidence and stalls genuine internal learning.
- Systemic scrutiny drives real reform: When internal investigations and public discourse stop at blaming individual operators or commanders, deep structural vulnerabilities remain intact. When external pressure focuses on systemic failures, it creates the institutional momentum needed for lasting procedural, structural, and cultural safety reforms.
Full open-access/journal link:https://doi.org/10.1177/0095327X251358661
I would love to hear how others across academia, safety-critical industries, and communications see organizations navigating the tension between institutional self-protection and transparency after a major crisis. Happy to answer any questions about the methodology, the Tze’elim case study, or the theoretical framework!