It was mass killing with the intention of killing all members of israel.
Textbook genocide.
So to summarise, yes you are trying to diminish the term genocide by comparing what hamas did during one day to what the state of Israel has been doing for over 75 years.
If October 7 was a genocide you might as well say Al qaeda committed genocide against Americans on 9/11 because they "had the intention of killing all Americans".
And with your definition you'd have to agree that Israel has been commiting genocide for over 75 years right? And far more successfully as well.
This means that based on your definition we end up in a situation where a nation has committed genocide against a people group for 75 years, and the other group for one day. And in your mind these are even close to comparable?
Claiming that October 7th was about "killing all members of israel" is also incredibly ludicrous since this would mean that you claim that Hamas intented to invade and occupy all of Israel following the attack, which is obviously ridiculous.
The people who died on October 7 were victims of an attack. Just like 9/11.
The roughly 100 children who die in Gaza every day are victims of genocide. These are not comparable situations.
Hamas Are terorists that use terror, to press their claims. Israel on the other hand, trys through bombing to destroy as much infrastructure as possbile. To make living in gaza unberable. The endgoal is to displace them and settle gaza. This is textbook genocide. The same thing did the serbians, who cleared entire villages and caused a mass exodus of hundred of thousand of people. Same thing.
I am using your definition, don't blame me if you think it's bad.
My problem with your statements is that you are confusing 2 different things.
actions done with the intent to destroy a national, ethnical, racial or religious group.
And
Hamas intended to kill as many Israelis as they are able to
If you claim the second statement fits genocide, you could claim any terrorist attack in history is genocide. You could claim many serial killers are commiting genocide, people in militaries around the world are individually commiting genocide. Just because they are trying to kill as many X as they can.
This is exactly what I mean when I say you diminish the meaning of the word genocide.
If you want to claim I'm twisting your definition again, feel free to quote me. I don't much care for you making up stuff.
And can I get a confirmation, do you believe Israel is commiting genocide to Palestinians?
I have to assume you aren't reading my comments since you haven't responded to any of my points. And when I respond to your points you pretend I said something different like comments on reddit aren't public.
I don't know if this tactic usually works for you but on reddit I can go back and check your previous comment and what you said is:
You can call absolutely call the october 7th attacks a genocide or you could also call the actions of palestinians over the last 100 years genocide.
Hamas intended to kill as many Israelis as they are able to, their intentions are very much public and clear, and very much fit the definition of genocide.
To which I responded
If you claim the second statement fits genocide, you could claim any terrorist attack in history is genocide. You could claim many serial killers are commiting genocide, people in militaries around the world are individually commiting genocide. Just because they are trying to kill as many X as they can.
This is exactly what I mean when I say you diminish the meaning of the word genocide.
So I'll respond again with further clarification.
Claiming that "Hamas intentions are to destroy Israel and the Israeli people" is obviously obtuse, and you know that.
This is true either if you take just October 7 (where their stated goals were putting pressure on Israel because of the al-Aqsa mosque, and taking hostages to trade for Palestinian prisoners), or on the basis of their existence.
Hamas exists to resist Israeli occupation and to fight for freedom for Palestinians. This does not necessitate the destruction of all Israeli people, but could mean the destruction of the Israeli state as it exists today.
The intention of the Warsaw ghetto uprising was to stop the nazi regime from continuing the Holocaust, so did they commit genocide?
Al qaedas goal was to topple the west, were Americans the victoms of genocide on 9/11?
This is all leading to the obvious part you've missed in your comment, which is that even if you were to claim Israel is a victim of genocide from hamas, that doesn't mean that every action hamas takes is genocide.
If we are in 1938 Germany and a German boy hits a Jewish boy, is that genocide? No, maybe assault, maybe a hate crime. However, that doesn't mean there wasn't a genocide going on at the same time.
What I am saying is, the intention of genocide doesn't make it genocide on its own, you have to actually take actions towards that goal. Why would hamas take hostages if they just wanted to kill all Israeli people?
So, to reiterate, Al qaeda wants to topple the US, they commit 9/11, does this constitute genocide in your eyes?
And led me to back to what I asked before:
This means that based on your definition we end up in a situation where a nation has committed genocide against a people group for 75 years, and the other group for one day. And in your mind these are even close to comparable?
With your definition do you believe Israel is commiting genocide to Palestinians?
if the hat fits. Sadly lots of communities in history have been tarnished with the same brush - why special treatment for Israelis that don't stand up for errrr something as human as you know 'no genocidal actions plz' by their regime.
Sure.. Would you like to apply the same logic to the Palestinians and paint them all as rapists and murders or would you like to admit you were wrong? Because last I checked their own goverment raped and murdered everyone they saw on Oct 7 then brought back the bodies so that the people could dance in the streets with them.
I don't recall the Palestinians ever holding "Right to Rape" protests, because Israelis literally did that to protect IDF prison guards that raped and murdered Palestinian prisoners.
Also, no it's not remotely fair to paint with the same brush. Palestinian support for Hamas literally rises whenever Israel attacks them, but their hasn't been an election held in Gaza since 2005. That's over 20 years ago and literally over 50% of the population is below the age of 20. So you're trying to hold them accountable to a government that most people in Gaza never even voted for.
History didn't start on Oct 7, you should look up what happened during the peaceful protests during the Great March of Return. As Nelson Mandela said when he visited Palestine, "Except in cases where we cannot get [peace], where we cannot proceed, or we cannot move forward. Then if the only alternative is violence, we will use violence."
Edit: For the people who think I'm lying, here's the sources
View all comments
Show parent comment
68
u/Double-Truth-3916 Jul 19 '25
So, anyone born in Israel is automatically a genocidal murderer?