While I would like you to back up anything you claim I have said before linking these articles, I feel like we are reaching the end of your dialogue tree. I would also like to highlight that you have not responded to any of my points, but continue to make up stuff I am saying, while let me be clear once more, you can very easily read my comment.
While you can bring up articles from various Israeli media such as JTA, memri, or times of Israel, you can't seriously act like these are very credible sources right? There are articles from nazi Germany justifying the Holocaust, sure you would take issue with that?
While it's impressive you managed to find these articles from Israel, I'll try to provide a different angle instead.
These are all articles from this year, from the UN, unicef, or save the children. This is not what some Israeli official said 15 years ago, this is what they are actually doing right now.
While I am sure many Palestinians have said bad things about Jews, zionists, Christians, and many others. The reality of the situation is that what members of hamas say pales in comparison to what Israel does on the daily.
Show me where hamas kills 10+ Israeli children each day, or concentrates them to distribution centres so they are more easily gunned down.
Your tactics of Painting Hamas as the victims are incredibly stupid. And you are a disgusting piece of sht for supporting them.
You've figured out the quote feature so please use it when making allegations like this. You know I haven't so stop acting like a baby.
As if mass murder and slaughter of innocent people is not considered an action?
I can't believe the people in the Warsaw ghetto uprising were such terrorists, killing innocents! This is clearly proof they were trying to commit a genocide of Germans.
Your definition doesn't work because it could fit into the vast majority of mass killings, and they are obviously not all genocide. Jack the ripper targeted prostitutes, was that genocide?
To torture and abuse before murdering them,
So you actually believe they would risk their and their families life just because they think torture is fun?
use them as a bartering card
This is what I mentioned was their stated goal, trade for prisoners held by Israel. You would have seen that if you read.
human shields if Israel wins
For clarity human shields is a dog whistle the Israeli state uses to justify bombing hospitals and schools.
I will once again state that hamas would have done the 7th of October every day if they could. Human shields are a very real thing that both israel and Hamas use, once you take a hospital which is a protected zone and hide hostages there or hide your RPGs there it becomes a legitimate target as it is used for military purposes, hamas doing that is putting innocent palestinians in danger and it is infact used to maximize the casualties, hamas themselves said that it's good that palestinians die because they can just use them for PR and give birth to more later. Does this sound sane to you?? You can blame both israel and hamas for the suffering of palestinians or you can just ignore the fact that hamas literally makes it easier for israel to kill people and you can also ignore the palestinians who endanger their life by protesting against hamas. Instead of being selfish listen to the people. They are killed both from outside forces and from the people who claim to help palestinians while stealing aid and selling it X3 the price to people who don't even have money right now. It's insanity. It actually annoys me how little people like you really care about palestinians, not everything is hasbara. I learned about this topic for long before oct 7th and I have connections to this conflict. All i want is the suffering to stop but people just refuse to acknowledge that both sides need to take responsibility for wrong doings and reflect. No society is perfect so acting like palestinians aren't capable of making any mistakes is harmful and prevents peace.taking Criticism is important because without that you can't change for the better. Both israelis and palestinians should accept criticism.
Human shields are a very real thing that both israel and Hamas use, once you take a hospital which is a protected zone and hide hostages there or hide your RPGs there it becomes a legitimate target as it is used for military purposes
I will quote the Israeli journalist Amira Hass: "If I'm not mistaken, the Defense Ministry is in the heart of Tel Aviv, as is the army's main 'war room.' And what about the military training base at Glilot, near the big mall? And the Shin Bet headquarters in Jerusalem, on the edge of a residential neighborhood? ... Why is it all right for us and not for them? Just because they don't have the phallic ability to bomb these places?"
Let's turn your argument around, if an idf soldier takes their gun home, is that neighbourhood a valid target now? If an idf soldier is admitted to a hospital with their weapon, you would call that a military target?
This is such a stupid point to make because all military conflicts in the world deal with collateral damage and civilians, this isn't a new thing and somehow every other military on earth has figured out that you can choose targets where there will be less collateral damage, but Israel hasn't?
How about the clearly marked journalists that are killed by Israel constantly? Are they hiding hamas in their pockets?
The only conclusion is that Israel is targeting civilians and journalists, and then after the fact look for ways to justify what they did.
You can blame both israel and hamas for the suffering of palestinians or you can just ignore the fact that hamas literally makes it easier for israel to kill people and you can also ignore the palestinians who endanger their life by protesting against hamas.
Both the nazis and the Jews were equally responsible for the Holocaust right? If only the Jews would've listened to the kapos the Holocaust would've been less bad right?
Instead of being selfish listen to the people.
Selfishness is moving to a country, denegrating the native population as 2nd class citizens, and putting them in open air prisons, and then act like the victim when these people fight back.
Selfishness is acting like genocide is justified because the people group says heinous things or kills civilians when they try to fight back.
They are killed both from outside forces and from the people who claim to help palestinians while stealing aid and selling it X3 the price to people who don't even have money right now. It's insanity.
Like GHF that I brought up? While I agree this is bad, this is a problem which is solved the exact same way the genocide is resolved. Palestinians not being killed at aid stations is of course good, but Palestinians shouldn't require aid stations in the first place. You seem to argue for the pre October 7 status quo, where Palestinians are quietly being ethnically cleansed, but at least you don't have to hear about it.
That is not a solution, that is just a continuation of the genocide.
It actually annoys me how little people like you really care about palestinians, not everything is hasbara.
I should care as much as you, which is not at all because civilians died on October 7? You've effectively already said that you don't sympathise with them because of this and then turn around acting like I don't care? While your whole argument is that they should just die in quiet without bothering Israelis.
All i want is the suffering to stop but people just refuse to acknowledge that both sides need to take responsibility for wrong doings and reflect.
"I just want ww2 to end but I need both the Jews and the nazi to take responsibility for their wrong doings."
If I say you are ugly and in response you kill my whole family, do we both need to take responsibility or can we acknowledge that the actions are on completely different levels?
No society is perfect so acting like palestinians aren't capable of making any mistakes is harmful and prevents peace
I agree, which is why I highlight how silly it is for you to qualify your sympathy with them not killing any civilians. One on hand we shouldn't criticse Israel too much because they aren't perfect. But we also can't support Palestinians because they aren't perfect.
Criticism is important because without that you can't change for the better. Both israelis and palestinians should accept criticism.
This is the most unhinged one yet. Again, what criticism do you have for the Jews who died during the Holocaust? Does that criticism holds equal weight to the criticism you have for nazi Germany?
Criticism is healthy for personal and professional growth. Human beings have a right to live and exist. These are not comparable.
That's fine you haven't read any others so what's the point.
My point as to why your articles doesn't matter was in my comment, but you can find out why below.
I'll summarise with 2 questions here and maybe you could end with answering one of mine?
Do you think what hamas said in those articles is worse than the average 10 children being killed in Gaza every day because of Israel?
Considering the discussions around what is and isn't genocide, I am asking you for the fourth time, do you believe Israel is commiting a genocide against Palestinians?
View all comments
Show parent comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment