r/UrbanHell • • Jul 19 '25

Concrete Wasteland Bnei Brak, Israel. 8th most densely populated city.

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

643 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-4

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '25

the vast majority of jews today in Israel have arrived only a couple of decades ago. By that logic Indians should colonize the caucuses en masse because its the homeland of the indo-european languages.

6

u/maven-effects Jul 21 '25

The vast majority of Palestinians come from Egypt and Jordan. Why do you think that is?

1

u/Echo693 Jul 20 '25

...after being forced out their homeland. Pro-Hamastinians seem to ignore that part, as if Jews are originated from Europe or anywhere else around the globe but the land that literally carried their name.

The Palestinians have never held any sovereignty over "their land" and yet they claim it is theirs. Jews had kingdoms and the peak of their religious structure, the Temple, in Jerusalem - centuries before the Arabs even invaded that land - let alone the creation of Islam or the Palestinian entity in the the 60's - and yet you claim that they are colonizers?

If a nation loses its rights for its homeland after losing it - then the "Palestinians" have no case at all. If a nation is allowed to preserve its claims even losing the land - and we are to wrongly assume that the Palestinians were a nation during the 30's, 40's and the 50's - then both Israelis and Palestinians have the right to call this land their homeland.

One side agreed to share it since the 30's - the other side kept rejecting it.

1

u/-Krny- Jul 21 '25

Not all of them. Many are from Europe and had never ever set foot in the land they wanted to steal

0

u/Echo693 Jul 21 '25

Typical Pro-Hamastinian denial. Nah, my friend - Jews are not, in fact, originated from Europe. This is a Middle Eastern Ethnoreligious group.

So they can't be colonizers and they're not "stealing" anything; Zionists agreed to share the land since the 30's.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '25

I also want to share some land of yours, y’know, because god promised me.

1

u/Echo693 Jul 22 '25

Damn, you've got me there little bud! Such an amazing reply, I need time to process the stupid strawman that you've made.

In other words: I've never used the "god gave me this land" argument.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '25

gypsies originate in india I don’t see why it’s fair to give them a state in india today? there are some european descendants in Pakistan, where’s their state in europe? what about native americans, who are subjugated in their own home, when will europeans return to their homeland?

1

u/Echo693 Jul 22 '25

Oh uh, someone is moving the gate now. I'm glad that you've realized how idiotic your strawman was though, we're getting there buddy.

Next: Jews were forced out of their homeland but they never really completely left it. For the most part - it was desolated until the late 20's where a lot of local Arabs came in out of economic (not national) needs. So if you agree that the Jews, as an ethnoreligious groups, is originated in Israel -you can't claim that they are foreign to this land. Note that there was no other state or any type of sovereignty over this land by the made-up entity of "Palestinians" - at any point.

A colonizer is someone who is foreign to land. Claiming that the Jews are foreign to their own homeland only shows your lack of knowledge. It's factually a false claim.

As for the native Americans? In my opinion they have the right to establish their own separated state but this is just my personal view. I'm not even sure that they actually pushed for that throughout the years though.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '25

you are arguing for moot points, I bet your IQ is so low you don’t even realise.

Yes Jews did originate in Israel, no shit buddy.

Many israelis have their origins in europe, not the middle east.

Both of the above can be true, you dumbass.

Secondly, even if ALL israelis have their origins in Israel, then it’s no different from all the roma who have their origins in India. So let’s make a gypsy state in india, right? And if you support the native americans to get back their homeland, by comparion, it means you support the forceful eviction of modern americans, because that’s been a national policy of Israel.

And yes Jews were forced out. They were forced out of everywhere. So why do the ones forced out only claim israel when half of them have their genetic roots in Poland? As far as I’m concerned I support an Israeli state in Germany, that would be more apt. Jews were already living in the arab world prior and after to WW2.

1

u/Echo693 Jul 24 '25

You literally built your whole argument on a strawman and the moment you've been called out - you've changed the argument. You're בךקשרךט not in a position to talk about anyone else's IQ, and i'm being gentle.

Many israelis have their origins in europe, not the middle east.

You keep ignoring the historical fact that Israel, not Poland, was and still is the Jewish homeland. Yes, even if the Jews didn't even born here, as a group - it was their homeland (and unlike the "Palestinians" - they used to have sovereignty over this land).

If you are an Afro-American which never set his foot in Africa, does it erases your African roots? Does it makes you a native American? Knowing that you're not smart enough to answer this question i'll help ya: No. They still have African roots and therefore they are still descents of Africa.

And if you support the native americans to get back their homeland, by comparion, it means you support the forceful eviction of modern americans, because that’s been a national policy of Israel.

If native Americans would have assemble into a one national group with one national goal of having a separated "Native American" state, it would have been another case and I would've support a similar solution to what the UN suggested for the Arabs and the Israelis, yes. But this is not the native American case.

So why do the ones forced out only claim israel when half of them have their genetic roots in Poland?

Because they are part of an ethnoreligious group which factually had it's homeland in Israel - before they were forced out throughout the world, including Europe. They never saw Poland as their homeland just like the Palestinians who are born in Lebanon or Iraq doesn't see them as their homeland. Jews, as a group, had their self-determination over 3,000 years ago in Israel. Being forced out of the land does not erase their historic connection.

→ More replies

1

u/YourBestDream4752 Jul 20 '25

What? Where are you getting that ‘fact’? About 80% of Israeli Jews were born there - https://www.jns.org/at-76-israels-population-stands-at-9-9-million/?utm_source=chatgpt.com. Additionally, around half of Israeli Jews are Mizrahi, meaning that they are descendants of the 800,000 Jews expelled (ethnically cleansed) from Muslim MENA countries after the Arab League’s defeats in 1948, 1967 and 1973.

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '25

You’re forgetting the fact that Israel had to convince ME Jews to move to Israel under their One Billion Plan and it included false flag attacks like the Baghdad bombings to escalate a plight of Jews, Iraq even forbade their Jews to leave until they caved into foreign pressure.

Hundreds of years of peace between communities, ruined by a bunch of secular Eastern Europeans and their toxic Zionist ideology.

3

u/YourBestDream4752 Jul 21 '25

 You’re forgetting the fact that Israel had to convince ME Jews to move to Israel

Oh great, now you’re denying the persecution of hundreds of thousands of Jews by Islamists.

 included false flag attacks like the Baghdad bombings

“DA JOOS did this, DA JOOS did that, DA JOOS fucked my fuck”

 Iraq even forbade their Jews to leave until they caved into foreign pressure.

Which is all the more reason to leave.

 Hundreds of years of peace between communities

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA bro are you serious? What kind of TikToks are you watching where they straight up deny the countless massacres that took place in MENA against Jews.

 ruined by a bunch of secular Eastern Europeans and their toxic Zionist ideology

Ruined by a bunch of theocratic regimes invading the secular, UN-mandated, democratic country in order to annex it and ethnically cleanse the Jewish population, losing to said country despite invading from all side except the fucking sea and then persecuting their own Jewish population so that they were forced to leave to said secular democracy*

0

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '25

always the victim lol

2

u/YourBestDream4752 Jul 21 '25

In the context of Jews in MENA, yes

0

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '25

so jews in europe were not victims? lol

2

u/YourBestDream4752 Jul 22 '25

Yeah, they were victims a whole bunch of times in Europe as well, what’s your point?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '25

eternal victims

1

u/YourBestDream4752 Jul 22 '25

Okay? I mean, if we’re talking about the settler movement then no, they aren’t the victims unless the moderate ones get attacked by Palestinian extremists. But otherwise yeah pretty much

→ More replies
→ More replies (1)

0

u/bigbootystaylooting Jul 20 '25

What a shitty understanding of ancestry, Indians have no ancestral connection to the Caucasus, the Indo-european migration evolved over time & the culture wasn't the same when it reached India vs at its origin.

Also the fact not all Indians speak Indo-european languages, even then it's not a religion like Judaism which carries more significance. Plus the most important factor, Indians have their own country & don't have to worry about being persecuted because of it.

And indo-aryan migration wasn't due to being exiled, and it's spread out to Pakistan, Bangladesh, Nepal, Sri Lanka,etc.

Truly senseless.

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '25

You could argue that the existence of Israel and its policy against Palestinians and Palestine is putting the global spotlight on Jews and is increasing adversity against Jews which is putting Jews at risk of discrimination and feeling alienated especially in Europe and the US where there are a large number of Jews.

Having escaped Europe because of antisemitism, did Zionists really think they’d be welcomed with open arms into a region where they’d kick out the Palestinians and antagonise its ethnic brothers across the ME