So, I'm working on designing a wargame, and in my limited experience, I've noticed that whereas on Land, unit weapons might have different damage values (1,2,3 like in 40k, or 1-2 in Turnip28), other games are almost exclusively just 1 (like Conquest TLAOK).
In addition, I've noticed that for warships (Battlefleet Gothic, Dystopian Wars, Castles in the Sky) attacks are usually masses of '1s', single instances of damage. Even BFG's Nova Cannons deal d6 instances of 1 damage, instead of, say, d3 instances of 2 damage. I'm trying to understand the design decisions here, but I'm guessing it's partly b/c with warships, they have it that each Wound is often a roll of the dice for damaging subsystems. D2 attacks deal more damage to health but incur fewer rolls for system failures.
Can anyone help me understand the reasoning behind these decisions? How do designers decide whether to go with more varied types of damage (40k) vs more generic instances of damage (Conquest, BFG)?
Edit(s): I just realised that part of the issue is that land units tend to be larger groups of low-health models, compared to the sea being smaller units of beefy models. If your game lacks damage overflow, then spending a D3 shot on infantry is a waste compared to a tank, but such a mechanic matters less on the sea where you get fewer instances of potential overflow.
-I also realised it probably has something to do with dice pools. 10 soldiers firing 1 shot gives a statistical pleasing dice pool of 10 attacks. A cruiser might fire, what? 4 shots? 6? 8? And their strong shots might be 2-4? So, to buff up the dice pool, designers just give them X-many shots and keep the damage at '1'.