I have got a theory that the Egyptian government knows this isn't the way to go, and yet they do it to destroy walkablity/pedestrian culture so they can crack down on protesters if a revolution happens. Anyways, the op who posted this in NUMTOT also posted Urban Mobility in Greater Cairo: A history of patchwork solutions.
Edit: Just so everyone is clear, more lanes means more traffic. Widening a road will only induce demand and travel time might actually get worse. The only way forward is to replace cars as the main transportation method by making them bare the full economic cost(road construction/maintenance, negative externalities) and heavily investing in public transit.
And the USA is a very large country . It’s hard to organize protest because most of the population is like 3,000 mi away from our capital or more so for Alaska and Hawaii
it isn’t that hard to organize large protests in the US
eg., Occupy Wall St.; March for Our Lives; Woman’s March; March for Science; People’s Climate March; February 15 Iraq War Protests; 2015 Armenian March for Justice; Telegramgate…
I don’t think walkability, or a lack thereof, breaks the will of protesters considering people continue to take protests onto highways—the least walkable space.
East coast is pretty walkable, but they've been developing with drivability as a priority. Further west you go the more bring able to drive got prioritized over walking and public transport.
This is where I'm from and I'm heartbroken. My hometown used to be a paradise in the desert until successive governments mismanaged the population growth.
This is an assault on my eyes both metaphorically and literally. Thanks to this "Improvement" a bunch of dirt got into my eyes and I got allergic and seriously thought I was done for. Not only that but also so many trees were cut down and the scenery is just so bleak and miserable now. If they want to reduce traffic, they oughtta improve public transport and actually enforce traffic laws, but this is too logical and this is Egypt so we have to choose the most inefficient way. I love my country and it sucks seeing it slowly pass away. :/
No it isn't, widening roads doesn't fix congestion. Heck, sometimes it makes it worse. There are quite a few articles and vids on induced demand, look them up.
1- It has been done a million times, it never works. Cars are cancerous cells of cities, you will not build your way out of congestion. It's an inefficient use of public resources.
2- Engineers shouldn't have a say in this, it's the job of urban planners.
because building a train in Egypt isn’t as simple as laying down one track and dropping a locomotive down
Egypt geography makes it really easy(and relatively cheap) to build HSR; 98% of the population living on the Nile in dense cities will make cost scale down. Caspian Report is not an authoritative source, dont use him as your main source. Anyways I meant investing in metros, buses, etc.. Ideally there should multiple mass transit option and Egyptian cities density make that possible.
and if op wants buses, that’s just cars with the same problems.
...I just can't. How daft can you be? Comparing the capacity of a single car to a bus is just so... Here's a scene on what I tried to explain on induced demand
73
u/TheHadramiguy Jan 16 '20 edited Jan 16 '20
I have got a theory that the Egyptian government knows this isn't the way to go, and yet they do it to destroy walkablity/pedestrian culture so they can crack down on protesters if a revolution happens. Anyways, the op who posted this in NUMTOT also posted Urban Mobility in Greater Cairo: A history of patchwork solutions.
Edit: Just so everyone is clear, more lanes means more traffic. Widening a road will only induce demand and travel time might actually get worse. The only way forward is to replace cars as the main transportation method by making them bare the full economic cost(road construction/maintenance, negative externalities) and heavily investing in public transit.
17
u/Abdo279 Jan 16 '20
إنا لله وإنا إليه راجعون. ربنا يعوض علينا في بلدنا اللي بتدمر قدام عنينا و احنا متكتفين
14
u/Heliopolis1992 Jan 16 '20
This is where I'm from and I'm heartbroken. My hometown used to be a paradise in the desert until successive governments mismanaged the population growth.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '20
This is an assault on my eyes both metaphorically and literally. Thanks to this "Improvement" a bunch of dirt got into my eyes and I got allergic and seriously thought I was done for. Not only that but also so many trees were cut down and the scenery is just so bleak and miserable now. If they want to reduce traffic, they oughtta improve public transport and actually enforce traffic laws, but this is too logical and this is Egypt so we have to choose the most inefficient way. I love my country and it sucks seeing it slowly pass away. :/
10
u/TiemenBosma Jan 16 '20
شو صار؟
1
u/jennyigotyour8675309 Nov 23 '22
I was wondering if anyone knows where this place is exactly? I'm doing a uni project and planning to use this as a site!
11
u/BarryMccoinin Jan 16 '20
Progress.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '20
We the best
1
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '20
How many years apart are these photos?
-18
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '20
They are making wider roads, which is good
-4
u/the_fightero Jan 16 '20
نأمل ان الفكرة تتعمم على الجمهورية كلها
0
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment