r/AskHistorians • u/-nhops- • 5h ago
r/AskHistorians • u/AutoModerator • 6h ago
RNR Thursday Reading & Recommendations | November 19, 2026
Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:
- Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history
- Newly published books and articles you're dying to read
- Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now
- Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes
- ...And so on!
Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.
r/AskHistorians • u/AutoModerator • 1d ago
SASQ Short Answers to Simple Questions | November 18, 2026
Please Be Aware: We expect everyone to read the rules and guidelines of this thread. Mods will remove questions which we deem to be too involved for the theme in place here. We will remove answers which don't include a source. These removals will be without notice. Please follow the rules.
Some questions people have just don't require depth. This thread is a recurring feature intended to provide a space for those simple, straight forward questions that are otherwise unsuited for the format of the subreddit.
Here are the ground rules:
- Top Level Posts should be questions in their own right.
- Questions should be clear and specific in the information that they are asking for.
- Questions which ask about broader concepts may be removed at the discretion of the Mod Team and redirected to post as a standalone question.
- We realize that in some cases, users may pose questions that they don't realize are more complicated than they think. In these cases, we will suggest reposting as a stand-alone question.
- Answers MUST be properly sourced to respectable literature. Unlike regular questions in the sub where sources are only required upon request, the lack of a source will result in removal of the answer.
- Academic secondary sources are preferred. Tertiary sources are acceptable if they are of academic rigor (such as a book from the 'Oxford Companion' series, or a reference work from an academic press).
- The only rule being relaxed here is with regard to depth, insofar as the anticipated questions are ones which do not require it. All other rules of the subreddit are in force.
r/AskHistorians • u/Wonderful_Buy_5925 • 3h ago
Since when do wizards live in towers?
In Western fantasy and fairytales, wizards are often depicted as living in towers. Dark wizards live in spooky towers, good wizards live in pretty towers, but it's always a tower. It's such a strong association that it's a clichè at this point.
I'm curious about the origins of this association. Is there a particular historical tradition, religious symbolism, or literary convention that explains why towers became such a common dwelling for wizards?
r/AskHistorians • u/Majovsky • 7h ago
I want to know more about origins of Zionism. What should I read?
So, I study Political Science, but as we like to say "Political Science is a interdisciplinary science", so I like to dive into history too. Recently I started to be interested in Zionism and its roots (and the israeli-palestine conflict, even though that's slightly different topic). Right now I have kinda surface-level knowledge about the ideology, but I want to know more and really understand it and how it influenced the never ending story of conflict we see in Kanaan today (kinda my new hobby now I'd say). I've already found some books I want to read – The Jewish State by Theodor Herzl (translated by Sylvie D'Avigdor), Ten Essays on Zionism by Achad Ha-am (translated by Leon Simon), A history of Zionism by Walter Laqueur, The Zionist idea by Arthur Hertberg, War on Palestine: A history of settler colonial conquest and resistance, 1917–2017) by Rashid Khalidi and, if available online, Righteous victims: A history of the Zionist-Arab conflict, 1881–2001 by Benny Morris.
I still need to determine in which order I'll read those books, define their possible biases and also my possible biases, but yeh, that's what I got in my list rn. I'd like to expand my knowledge as much as possible, so if you know of some book I don't have there and I should, feel free to suggest. If the book is available online, great! If it's free access, even better (I'm a poor student)!
r/AskHistorians • u/ratione_materiae • 8h ago
To what extent was Lee Harvey Oswald's job-hunting experience representative of, or standard for, his time?
I am hoping to get some input from economics or labor historians on this. I ask this in the context of the current labor market where some people report sending out hundreds or in some cases thousands of job applications and not getting any calls back.
From a modern 2026 viewpoint, it seems that the president of the New Orleans chapter of the Fair Play for Cuba Committee, L. H. Oswald (better known for other activism), had an extraordinarily easy time finding employment despite his lack of qualifications or job experience. Just based on U3 unemployment (5.5% in October 1963 vs 4.1% in October 2026), it would seem that finding a job should have been harder then compared to now. I am also interested in his potential career prospects had he maintained his employment at the book depository.
Specifically, I am seeking answers regarding the following. An answer on one or more would be greatly appreciated.
[1] Finding a job, even at minimum wage, within three weeks of arriving in a new city with no known connections, qualifications, or relevant experience seems extremely unlikely today. To what extent was this normal at the time?
[2] Securing an interview, even for a minimum wage position, the very next day through a "referral" by what amounts to a family friend who had no connection herself to the employer also seems rare today. It was still formal labor (as opposed to say, a seasonal farm job or day-to-day construction work). Was this standard in the time period?
[3] The Texas unemployment office was able to refer him to a position making well above minimum wage around a week after Oswald had applied to said office. What would his chances of actually securing employment through that referral have been, and was this a comparatively quick turnaround?
[4] The Warren Commission report notes that Oswald had hoped to "develop qualifications for employment as a junior executive through a work-study program at a local college". Was this a realistic goal for someone of his social status, qualifications, and experience at the time?
Per the report of the Warren Commission,
(chapter 7). However, also it notes that following his arrival to New Orleans on April 24, 1963,
he obtained work as a greaser and oiler of coffee processing machines for the William B. Reily Co., beginning May 10, 1963
(ibid.), just over two weeks after arriving to the city. [1] Additionally, chapter 6 notes that after hearing that a different friend's husband had found employment at the book depository,
As I understand, this position paid $1.25/hr, the then federal minimum wage. At 160 hours per month, he would earn approximately $200 per month. Per the BLS's inflation calculator, by CPI $200 is equivalent to around $2,200 in November 2026. By McDonald's hamburger prices (15 cents at the time vs around $2.50 in Dallas now), that would equivalent to around $3,300 today. It also notes that
On the same date, the Texas Employment Commission attempted to refer Oswald to an airline company which was looking for baggage and cargo handlers at a salary which was $100 per month higher than that offered by the Depository Co. [3]
Equivalent to around $3,300 by CPI or around $5,000 by hamburgers. Today, a worker making the Texan (= federal) minimum wage of $7.25 earns less than three McDonalds hamburgers per hour, compared to Oswald who was earning more than eight hamburgers per hour. All this for a 24-year-old who was a high school dropout with an undesirable discharge from the Marine Corps. [4]
Thank you in advance.
r/AskHistorians • u/GigaCucc • 8h ago
How many muskets that an army carried into battle were rendered inoperable after one or two shots?
So I hear all the time about how black powder fouled gun barrels, and the invention of smokeless powder combined with self-contained bullet cartridges revolutionised warfare, and it made me think about how many times a musket can be used/fouled before it needs a proper good clean and replace some parts.
Especially since muskets after roughly 1800 or so were intended to be mass produced and maybe not as quality as the stuff given to the smaller armies pre-Napoleon.
So if you have like 40 000 man army, how many muskets would you carry as supplies for this army? How many more would you need after one battle? Presumably more after you lost than after you won.
I guess, generally, I'm looking for more information on how regularly muskets are damaged or need replacing to keep an army operational.
This kind of question really does highlight for me the relevance of logistics as a thing governments and armies seemingly suddenly discovered and became aware of around the time of the Revolution.
r/AskHistorians • u/wglmb • 18h ago
When radium was discovered, it was marketed in many health fads. What was the public reaction when its deadly nature became apparent?
How did the public react after the discovery that their radium toothpaste, radium hemorrhoid cream, radium suppositories, etc., were in fact deadly? Presumably not well, but how long did it take for public consciousness to shift? Was it a subject of debate, where some people continued to use these products? Did it shake the public's confidence in science and scientists in an immediate and/or ongoing way?
r/AskHistorians • u/Sesquizygotic • 4h ago
Why did Herbert Hoover maintain such loyalty through the Great Depression?
1932 was a truly appalling time for the USA, with almost a quarter of the workforce unemployed, and the country undergoing a deflationary spiral that meant even those who had jobs were far worse off than they'd been a few years prior.
This raises the question, how was Herbert Hoover so popular? Yes, he lost in a landslide, but he was renominated and more than two fifths of voters still preferred him over the other guy. Who were these tens of millions of people that either approved of Hoover or detested the Democratic Party so much they thought the state of things at the peak of the Great Depression were preferable to them in power? By contrast, 1920 was a much less competitive election, despite the better economy and neither candidate being in power beforehand.
Furthermore, how could the Republican Party have thought that these Hoover voters were around in even greater numbers than they actually were, choosing to renominate the man that, fairly or not, was the obvious one to blame for the ongoing calamity? Even if no Republican could win, why didn't they think another Republican would lose by less, saving a bunch of down ballot Republicans with his coattails?
r/AskHistorians • u/Personal-Succotash33 • 31m ago
Was the popular view of marriage ever that it is primarily "for the purpose of reproduction", as Conservative advocates say?
Obviously this question will depend a lot on the era, but I ask it broadly because this is the way that it is stated by certain Conservative activists - that marriage has always primarily been for the reproduction of children and other sorts of arrangements are outliers.
Is this basic claim true? Or did marriages have other sorts of functions in societies other than reproduction?
r/AskHistorians • u/bird-up_rat-on • 12h ago
Why do Classic Maya inscriptions say a ruler "entered the road" or that his "white breath withered", and not simply that he died?
Maya monuments record royal deaths in set phrases: och bih, "he entered the road"; och ha', "he entered the water"; and k'a'ay u ? sak ik'il, roughly "his white breath withered". A plain verb for dying, cham, existed and is still used in Mayan languages. What did these phrases mean to the people who carved them: polite euphemism, or a statement of where the dead went? And did the choice of phrase depend on the place, the period or who had died?
r/AskHistorians • u/jschooltiger • 2h ago
On the American frontier, why were some log cabins constructed with logs placed vertically and others with logs placed horizontally?
I was at the Gateway Arch museum recently and in their displays they had a replica of an early log cabin; it mentioned it was built in the "French style" of having vertical logs driven into the ground with planks for outside cladding. They contrasted that with the "Swedish style" that is familiar to anyone who played with Lincoln logs, where the logs are placed horizontally and generally not clad on the outside.
What was the difference in philosophy in construction?
r/AskHistorians • u/Raspint • 32m ago
What was Eisenhower's day to day like during WWII?
It struck me that being the Supreme Commander of the Allied Forces during WWII was a big job. Like, a very big job. I'm assuming that tactical questions of "We will attack this fort, this beach, this hill with these units while these units run a distraction, etc" were delegated to people further down the chain of command and closer to the front lines. But I'm also sure that Eisenhower probably got no sleep for a few years.
Two related questions I'm asking:
1: What were Eisenhower's responsibilities and duties as the supreme commander?
2: What did these duties have him doing for most of his day?
r/AskHistorians • u/ClayHamster1821 • 18h ago
How did the Orthodox Church react to the Protestant Reformation?
Nearly 400 years after the Great Schism, how did the Orthodox countries react to the new Protestant denominations?
r/AskHistorians • u/valonianfool • 1d ago
Why didnt the Babylonian religion survive to the modern day?
Just like Israel, Babylon was conquered by the Assyrians and later the Persians, and their elites were exiled as part of the conquest. However, the Israelites would turn to monotheism and their religion survived into the modern day as Judaism, when no other faith in the ancient near east has survived.
Why didnt the Babylonian religion survive to the modern day?
r/AskHistorians • u/Taear • 20h ago
A well to do merchant leaves Newcastle in 1065 and comes back to England in 1075. How different are things?
The real question here is "how much did the conquest change England" but I'm curious just how different it would be if you left for ten years and came back
r/AskHistorians • u/valonianfool • 5h ago
Did queens in the ancient near east throw and host banquets?
In the book of Esther, queen Vashti throws a party for women in parallel to Ahuasuerus party, presumably her guests are the wives of all the important men at her husband's party.
Did queens in the ancient near east, including ancient Persia throw banquets, was it part of a queen's duty and were banquets gender-segregated?
Interestingly, there are some traditional interpretations which claim that Vashti and Ahuasuerus were in a struggle for power--which I never thought made sense, since its obvious all the power is on Ahuasuerus side, being able to demand anything from her and punish her for refusing--and Vashti's party was a challenge to his authority, making her guests choose between her and her husband as rulers.
I dont know if this interpretation comes from later writers not understanding the role of queens in ancient Persia, that royal women might have an expected role to play in politics, and especially political events such as banquets.
r/AskHistorians • u/SadhuSalvaje • 12m ago
When did Dionysius II of Syracuse die?
I was just reading “Plato and the Tyrant” by James Romm and have come across something confusing:
Wikipedia says that Dionysius II died in 343BCE but Romm describes him living a good bit longer even meeting Philip II in Corinth after the battle of Chaeronea.
His sources on this are Plutarch and Diogenes Laertius…so yeah definitely well after the fact.
Do we think those later stories were more literary/moral tales? Or are there other sources that back up these later adventures of Dionysius (Romm cited Atheneas as saying he may have ended up a devotee or Cybele , but again this is a much later account)
r/AskHistorians • u/Mango_RK • 2h ago
How Did Roman Religious Purity in Everyday Life?
While reading something about Caesar recently I stumbled across the position of Flamen Dialis, high priest of Jupiter which he held for a time. One of the very noteworthy things about this was just the huge list of restrictions on the job. Can't touch a horse, name a dog, have a knot in your clothes, touch iron, see an army, sleep outside of his own bed for three nights and many more. Some of these seem like ways of making sure the person in that position didn't get too much power, he had to stay in Rome and couldn't wield military authority but others just seem like straight up religious prohibitions for purity reasons, such as not being able to touch dogs or dead bodies. I know other important positions like the Vestal Virgins had similar restrictions on them.
Now obviously this was a very specific thing, the high priest of Jupiter, but it got me wondering about the average Roman. For the typical Citizen were there specific religious purity laws they had to follow as well? If I was on my way to make a sacrifice would I have to avoid touching any dogs on my way there as well? Would it have been considered bad luck or inappropriate for me to have a knot in my clothes in the temple?
Edit: Sorry the Title should have been "How Did Roman Religious Purity Work in Everyday Life?"
r/AskHistorians • u/TamGrenouille • 20h ago
I've been seeing a lot of videos of huge waves crushing onto ships lately and I've come to wonder about ancient ships or even more modern ones that actually crossed oceans. Do we know how often a ship actually got to its destination? Do we know something we did to at least try and counter disfortune
r/AskHistorians • u/CoffeeNova72 • 6h ago
Great Question! Did people in the 18th and 19th centuries write what we’d basically consider fanfiction today?
I’m a literature teacher and something that randomly got me thinking recently is whether fanfiction was actually a thing hundreds of years ago lol. I know people have been borrowing characters and retelling stories forever, but were ordinary readers in the 1700s or 1800s writing their own endings to popular novels or making up stories about their favourite characters? And if they were, did authors get annoyed about it or was it just seen as a normal thing? Would be really interested to know if any examples of this still exist, especially stuff written by regular people rather than published authors
r/AskHistorians • u/Matthew212 • 6h ago
Did Pompeii become "legendary" among the Romans, similar to Atlantis?
I know theres a map from the 1500s in the Vatican that does not have Pompeii on it.
Did Pompeii stop existing for the Romans or did it turn into a legendary place?
Or was it just not talked about because of how tragic it was?
r/AskHistorians • u/Cantparktheremate777 • 9h ago
What crimes did the Papacy execute people for in the eighteenth and nineteenth century?
https://www.reddit.com/r/WeirdThingsToLearn/s/zBWgG5DHrG
A related link
r/AskHistorians • u/brokenimage321 • 1h ago
What events were there in a medieval tournament? How were they "Scored?" And, how were the participants paired up?
I feel like this should be an easy question to answer, but I've been struggling to find a good answer...
Basically, my only real knowledge of medieval tournaments comes from the film A Knight's Tale, which is like saying "I learned about space exploration from watching Star Trek." But I'm curious what tournaments were actually like.
As I understand it, tournaments consisted primarily of a joust, with several other events on the side, including archery and duels with blunted weapons. Were there specific events for different types of weapons? Which were typically included?
I've found some rules online for how jousts were scored, and those are very informative. But how were the winners of the "duels" determined? First blood, first to "x" hits on their opponents' armor, etc.?
Finally: how were opponents paired up? Did they use a "bracket," or did everyone have a match against everyone else?
Thanks!
r/AskHistorians • u/seecat46 • 1d ago
Did US intelligence truly believe the MiG-25 was an agile "super-fighter," or were they aware of its actual role as an interceptor?
I find it hard to believe the CIA and broader intelligence community were actually that oblivious to its true interceptor role. Even putting aside the extensive intelligence network that the CIA had at the time, surely the industrial footprint alone would have given something away? Building a fleet out of heavy steel rather than aluminium and titanium would mean massive, noticeable discrepancies in raw material allocations, foundry outputs, and rail shipments things I would have tapped intelligence agencies to track.
Did US intelligence genuinely misread the MiG-25's mission and agility, and if so, how did they miss the industrial/metallurgical reality on the ground?
Where did the "super-fighter" narrative actually come from? was it an honest miscalculation by analysts? Soviet disinformation? Or the Pentagon exaggerating the threat to push F-15 funding through Congress?