r/CritiqueIslam • u/edmlover1992 • 2h ago
Can Allah lie?
So my question to Muslims is this: Can Allah lie? And if he can’t, then I want you to seriously consider the dilemma I’m about to present.
The Quran acknowledges the Torah and the Gospel as revelations from God. It even instructs the people of the Gospel to judge by what God revealed in it (Quran 5:47).
So here’s where I struggle to understand the Islamic position.
If Allah cannot lie, why would He reveal His truth through Jesus Christ and His earthly ministry, only for another prophet, Muhammad, to come approximately 600 years later and contradict some of the most fundamental things Jesus taught?
And I’m not talking about cherry-picking a handful of verses. I’m talking about considering everything Jesus said, including His statements about His identity, His relationship with the Father, His authority, His death, and His resurrection.
Jesus explicitly said, “It is finished” (John 19:30). The Gospels consistently testify that He was crucified, died, was buried, and rose again on the third day. This isn’t some minor theological disagreement. It’s the very foundation of Christianity.
Yet the Quran, in Surah 4:157, denies that Jesus was crucified and killed in the way Christians believe.
So how do you reconcile these two accounts?
If Allah cannot lie, how can the Quran contradict what Christians understand to be God’s earlier revelation? And if the original Gospel was corrupted, where is the clear, historical evidence establishing when that happened and what was changed?
I’m genuinely asking because this presents a serious theological dilemma. Why would God give humanity a revelation through Jesus Christ, only for that revelation to be contradicted approximately 600 years later?
I’m open to hearing your explanations, but I think these are questions that deserve more than simply dismissing the Bible as corrupted.