Am I the only one who lost interest in The Detective Is Already Dead after Siesta died on the plane?
Seriously, Siesta was the entire reason I was watching this anime in the first place. The white-haired, short-haired detective was easily the most interesting character. She had the personality, the intelligence, the mystery, the combat abilities, and the overall presence that made the show entertaining.
Then she dies, and suddenly we're supposed to follow Kimihiko, the assistant who spends so much of the story trying to live up to the detective he lost.
I'm sorry, but that completely killed my interest.
I didn't start watching this show because I wanted to watch an ordinary guy spend the rest of the series mourning a character who was infinitely more interesting than he is. I wanted to see MORE of Siesta actually being a detective!
And the frustrating thing is that the series introduces such an interesting premise: a legendary detective and her assistant solving mysteries together. There's so much potential there. You could have developed their relationship, given us more cases, explored Siesta's past, and gradually revealed why she's such an extraordinary person.
Instead, you kill her off and shift the focus to the guy who was interesting largely because of his relationship with her.
Now, I've heard that the light novel gets into some complicated stuff involving Siesta's heart, Nagisa, and the possibility of Siesta appearing again. Apparently, she's not completely gone from the story. But that raises another question: WHY NOT JUST LET HER BE AN ACTIVE CHARACTER?
I'm not necessarily demanding that the protagonist be invincible or that nobody important can ever die. I'm saying that killing off your most compelling character early on is a huge gamble, especially when the replacement focus doesn't work for everyone.
So I have a few questions for people who've read the light novels:
- Does Siesta actually return in a meaningful way, or is she mostly just a memory, a voice, or an occasional appearance?
- Does Kimihiko ever become genuinely interesting as a protagonist in his own right?
- Does the story eventually deliver more proper detective mysteries, or does it mostly become supernatural conspiracies and action?
- Is the light novel genuinely worth continuing after the anime's first season, or am I better off accepting that this series isn't for me?
I heard there's a second season, so I'm curious whether the story improves. I'm willing to hear spoilers, including major revelations about Siesta's fate.
I just want to know whether the series eventually gives me more of the character who made me interested in it to begin with.
Because, honestly, a show called The Detective Is Already Dead somehow made me wish the dead detective were the actual protagonist.