r/exjw • • 4d ago

Weekly Mini-Vent Megathread - November 15, 2026

8 Upvotes

What is this Megathread?

This is a dedicated space for short-form venting posts that do not meet the character limit for standalone posts.

Angry at your family, the Watchtower or the congregation? Having a REALLY bad day? Experiencing some big feelings and but don't have enough steam to make a long post about it? Welcome to our weekly mini-vent thread, the place where you can let it all out- in little bites.

Note: Standard sub rules still apply here, so please report any content that breaks the rules.

-------------------

If You are Considering Harming Yourself:

Please stay with us. Know you are safe and among friends and we will do whatever we can to help.

If you are inside the U.S., text "CHAT" to 741741. You'll be connected to a trained Crisis Counselor from Crisis Text Line. Or call the National Suicide Hotline at 988.

If you're not in the U.S. please click here for a comprehensive list of hotlines organized by country and additional resources.

If you are LGBTIA+ and need to talk, please contact the LGBT National Hotline at 1-888-843-4564 or find them online here.


r/exjw • • 3d ago

News The Rumor Mill: News and Gossip - November 16, 2026

13 Upvotes

What is this Megathread?

We get quite a bit of speculation, questions on upcoming updates, and general JW gossip in our sub. As part of our community engagement poll you folks voted for a special home to house shorter posts devoted to this type of exchange, so here we are!

Got a juicy piece of gossip from your KH or your JW social circle?  Want to ask a quick question about an upcoming announcement, or change? Heard a rumor from the WT or about something going on in bethel? This is what the weekly rumor mill thread is for. Just remember not to share anyone's PII, and we're golden.

Please Remember:

All the sub's rules still apply, so remember not to use these threads for activist drama or rumors about the personal lives of activists.

Have a Lot to Say?

This megathread is intended for submissions that are too short to be stand alone posts. If you have a rather lengthy comment, we might prompt you to spin it off into its own post for more engagement :) 

Welcome to the Rumor Mill, everyone. Gossip away!


r/exjw • • 11h ago

WT Policy New Feb 2027 Watchtower adds fuel for the UK to make new laws about Shunning

175 Upvotes

With everything going on in the UK with Sam (forgot last name) MP and the traction being made there. Around the Watchtowers use of Shunning.

Watchtower releases this in there newest watchtower. Under the chapter of “Whats prevents me from getting babtized”

Fear of failure. Makayla was five years old when her brother was removed from the congregation. As she grew up, she saw the impact that her brother’s actions had on her parents. “I was afraid that if I got baptized,” says Makayla, “I would make a mistake, be [removed from the congregation], and bring even more sadness to my parents.”

This just shows how much Watchtower cares about the family. They want you to live in fear.


r/exjw • • 10h ago

Venting How the hell does letting men have beards have a bigger effect than the blood issue??!!!

86 Upvotes

So recently, I have been more open with my thoughts about the organization and how I think that the org needs to take responsibility for making the blood rule, which has killed and hurt so many people, and then changing it.

And I have been responded to with the usual bull shit, "Don't let changes hurt your faith," "They don't need to apologise, because, in a way, they are apologizing by changing it." This is where I learned that my super PIMI elder dad almost stopped going to the meetings because beards were allowed. And my mom said that she thought that they had gone too far.

So you almost drew the line at men being allowed to grow beards, but not at the fact that rules they just made up have killed so many people, and then went, "Oops, never mind"? What the actual fuck?!

Why?! These people are so brainwashed; it's unbelievable.

Maybe it's because men not being allowed to grow beards affected more people? idk, I just need to vent, because this has been making me so angry.


r/exjw • • 1h ago

PIMO Life Yooo wtf so I’m a born in spent 28 years and waking up is a bit sickening

• Upvotes

so I’ve been waking up ever so gradually over the past 12 months like this just isnt it, right? like they have to be the only organisation that promises everlasting life but works you to death….

with the help of googling and what not the waking up process has been un comfortable to say the least how blind I was following This path of complete unhappiness thinking it was me never being spiritual enough to get the joy out of the spiritual weekly banquets 😂

I recently came across the definition of a cult…… what the fuck yo, it’s a cult, like no shadow of a doubt. I always took offence when people called it a cult. I was always told cults are easy to get into and hard to get out of that’s what a cult is… and silly me from a young age believed it. Wow what a shock to really read what a cult is. just crazy so many years wasted I can barely stomach meetings and the bs that gets taught and people eat it up, how is anyone actually getting joy from nonstop work. rinse repeat same shit every week?? that is no life… life is gaining enjoyment and giving back when you can and when you are able not every spare second we get.. wake TF up people 😂 sorry for the rant it’s been a long week


r/exjw • • 5h ago

Academic New first resurrection possibility undermines 1914.

20 Upvotes

At the recent annual meeting, the Governing Body raised the possibility that the first resurrection may not begin until the great tribulation. They made it clear that this was not a change in teaching, but simply something they could no longer be dogmatic about.

However, I think this introduces a much bigger problem than simply determining when the first resurrection begins. It calls into question the entire separation between Christ's invisible "parousia" beginning in 1914 and his future "coming."

Consider what Paul actually says in 1 Thessalonians 4:15 through 17. He specifically connects the resurrection of the dead and the gathering of the living with Christ's "parousia." He describes the Lord descending from heaven, God's trumpet sounding, the dead in Christ rising first, and then those who remain alive being caught away together with them to meet the Lord.

The Greek expression "hama syn autois" in verse 17 carries the idea of being "at the same time together with them." Paul is describing two groups being gathered together at the same event, not a resurrection extending over decades followed by a separate gathering much later.

Notice that Paul only identifies two groups. Those who have fallen asleep in death and those who remain alive until the "parousia."

The Watchtower's interpretation actually introduces a third group that Paul never mentions. These are Christians who survive the beginning of the "parousia" in 1914, but subsequently die and receive an immediate resurrection throughout the following decades.

Where does Paul describe such a group? He doesn't. That category only becomes necessary when you attempt to make his words fit the 1914 chronology.

The problem becomes even clearer in 1 Corinthians 15:51 and 52. Paul explicitly states that not all will fall asleep in death, but all will be changed at the "last trumpet." He distinguishes between those who have died and are resurrected and those who remain alive and are changed without experiencing death.

Yet the Watchtower's earlier interpretation required everyone to die before receiving their heavenly reward. They attempted to get around Paul's statement by arguing that those who died and were immediately resurrected had not actually slept in death.

But falling asleep is simply a figurative expression for dying, as Jesus himself demonstrates in John 11:11 through 14. Being resurrected immediately after death doesn't somehow mean that you never died.

This is also important because Paul connects these events with Isaiah 25:8 and Hosea 13:14 in 1 Corinthians 15:53 through 55, where death is swallowed up in victory. Those who remain alive experience that victory without ever entering the grave. The Watchtower's earlier interpretation effectively eliminated this group altogether.

Even the translation of the Greek preposition "en" as "during" in 1 Corinthians 15:23 helped support the idea that the resurrection continued throughout Christ's invisible presence. While "during" is a legitimate possible translation, nothing in Paul's statement establishes individual resurrections taking place over decades.

Then in 2013, the organization introduced the understanding that the remaining living anointed would be gathered during the great tribulation, connecting this event with Matthew 24:31 and Christ's future "coming."

But compare Matthew 24:29 through 31 with 1 Thessalonians 4:15 through 17. In both passages we have Christ coming, a trumpet sounding, and the gathering of his chosen ones. Yet Paul specifically associates these events with the "parousia," not some separate event more than a century later.

And what about the "last trumpet" in 1 Corinthians 15:52? If this trumpet is associated with the resurrection beginning around 1918, why would the gathering of the living still await another trumpet at Christ's future "coming"? Paul connects the resurrection and the change of the living with the same "last trumpet."

Now consider what happens if the first resurrection doesn't actually begin until the great tribulation, as the Governing Body is now suggesting might be possible.

The resurrection of the dead, the change of the living, the "last trumpet," and their gathering together would all take place in connection with Christ's future "coming."

But these are precisely the events Paul associates with Christ's "parousia"!

Previously, the teaching that the resurrection began around 1918 at least provided a connection between the first resurrection and the invisible "parousia" that supposedly began in 1914. If the resurrection is moved to the great tribulation, even that connection disappears.

And notice something else. In Matthew 24:27, Jesus describes his "parousia" as lightning shining across the sky. Then in verses 29 through 31, he describes his "coming" and the gathering of his chosen ones. Why should we assume these are two entirely separate occasions divided by more than a century, especially when Paul connects the resurrection and gathering directly with the "parousia"?

This is why I think the issue goes far beyond the timing of the first resurrection.

The Watchtower's older interpretation required separating events that Paul describes together, and even introducing an additional class of Christians who die after the "parousia" begins, something Paul never mentions.

Now the possibility being considered brings those events back together at Christ's future "coming," but that creates an even greater conflict with the claim that the "parousia" began in 1914.

If the resurrection, the "last trumpet," and the gathering of the living all occur at Christ's future "coming," and Paul explicitly places these events at the "parousia," then on what biblical basis can the two be separated by more than a century?

It seems to me that the real problem was created by separating the "parousia" from the "coming" in the first place. Once that distinction is imposed on Paul's statements, the resurrection has to be divided into stages, an additional group of Christians has to be introduced that die during the "parousia" and events Paul connects together have to be separated by decades. The newly proposed possibility doesn't resolve these problems. It actually makes the underlying contradiction much more obvious and undermines the entire idea that Christ's "parousia" and his "coming" are two separate events.


r/exjw • • 14h ago

News I got the cold shoulder today from an elder

101 Upvotes

Earlier this morning I drove to the train station to take the train downtown Chicago for my job. While I was the train station my former congregation always does cart witnessing every Wednesday morning at the train station. Since it was cold in the morning the cart witnessing was conducted inside the indoor waiting area. While I paid for my parking and waited outside one of the elders at my congregation noticed me and we looked directly at each other. As soon as he saw me he turned back around and went into Starbucks. Another 10 minutes gone by and he does the same thing again. He notices me and goes back into Starbucks.

I never had any beef with anyone or ill intent to bad mouth the entire organization. I was never baptized into their so called truth but found it funny that the head elder of the congregation didn't have the balls enough to even walk past me or give a head nod. I would of at least waved or said hi if he walked past me and acknowledged me. The funny thing is that this elder reached out to me directly when I've decided my family was done with the borg.

While on the train I felt sort of bad for those that actually are shunned. It sucks that the same brothers and sisters that people developed relationships with and thrown away like a piece of trash.


r/exjw • • 6h ago

HELP My parents found out I have a BF

21 Upvotes

So I’ve been PIMO for a while and have been for a couple months I have been trying for an exit plan to leave my parents house as I was still dependent on them for everything. I met this boy and we hit it off and we went on a date and he’s the sweetest guy ever, well we had sex and started a relationship after that. I met him while my parents were on vacation so I had the chance to be picked up by him without any problems and go on dates, my biggest mistake is that I accidentally let his name slip in conversation and it all went downhill from there. Eventually my mother and father found out the extent of the relationship and are begging me to break up with him and want me to talk to the elders. I’m super embarrassed since these are people who’ve known me since diapers and them knowing about my sex life is so embarrassing. However I can’t talk to my bf, can’t see him anymore at all and my mom even wants to take away my phone and block him or find his number to tell me to leave me alone. I’m 20 years old btw 🤦‍♀️. My dad cant look me in the eye at all. Idk what to do, my bf offered his place but even then it would be WAY too soon to move in together already. I feel trapped and idk what to do. Please help!!!

edit: to add context my family are brown immigrants and I am first generation. So in the Hispanic and Latino community in general, religion and culture is very deeply rooted, that is why my parents treat me like a child and don’t let me have my own autonomy. They think my bf took advantage of me and persuaded me to have sex with him which was never the case.

Also I was baptized in 2024, so if this were to come out I would be disfellowshipped as I am not at all remorseful about my actions. But it puts me into a very uncomfortable position as I would lose all of my support systems.


r/exjw • • 1h ago

Venting Meeting attendance and effects on mental health

• Upvotes

I need to talk about how decades of meeting attendance have taken a massive toll on my mental health. This is something I feel incredibly embittered about 😰 I want to hear from others with the same experiences.

Over the last few years I was finally given a diagnosis of Developmental Trauma (I grew up in a home of domestic violence), C-PTSD, BPD, agoraphobia. I already knew I had serious anxiety and depression. Plus a history of self harming.

When I got involved with the jws I was 17 and alone. For years (until I was programmed enough to do it myself) I was forced to attend meetings. Usual guilt trips, because God wants you there, we love you and you'll die at Armageddon if you don't do as you're told.

I can remember the day before the meeting: my mental health would take a massive nosedive. The self harm worsened. My mood dropped, I became visibly distressed.

Being at the hall was a form of torture. I wanted to hide from all the scrutiny. I would hide in the bathroom, cupboards, the back room, anywhere. Me being in floods of tears at the hall was normal. Me being distressed at the hall was normal. Me being unable to stop shaking was normal. Some people thought I was attention seeking. Some people got irritated with me, yet the messaging never changed: you need to be here. I hated it.

I could go on ad nauseum but I'd like to hear from others about their experiences. Was attending meetings traumatic for you? And can we be gentle with each other, please? Thanks 🫂


r/exjw • • 5h ago

Venting Parents thought me leaving was the reason bed bugs showed up

12 Upvotes

I honestly just thought about this and thought it'd be kinda funny to share and also showing how deep rooted my PIMI parents are in the org.

So a while back maybe like 2 months ago when I finally told my mom and dad I didn't want to be a witness, about like a week or two later bed bugs started showing up from my room. I still have no clue where they came from, probably the movie theater or something but I was worried they appeared because I wasn't keeping my room clean enough, but this brother we know from a different hall is an exterminator and told us it has nothing to do with filth they just get brought in so that was a bit relieving knowing I'm not filthy to the point of bed bugs. I did notice a bed bug about like 2 weeks prior but I didn't know it was a bed bug at the time so I didn't think much of it. Thankfully we did catch it before it got really bad so we got it taken care of pretty quick (tho I did unfortunately drop like 600 bucks on a new mattress but its ok because its a nice one).

Over the past few months I've been reading through my moms texts while shes away or sleeping to see what she's been saying about me since now I've left the org, and while this bed bug bs was happening I saw she texted my dad saying she thinks the timing of me saying I don't want to be a witness and the bed bugs appearing is too much a a coincidence and my dad agreed?? The bed bugs didn't appear because of divine intervention they appeared because I brought them in from god knows where, it has nothing to do with me leaving the JWs??? She said it to someone else as well and they agreed as well like wtf. I do also remember when mom and dad were in the basement talking while mom did laundry dad was getting pissed and said "he probably brought them in from one of his worldly friends that are so great" like ok come on. Like even when I told mom I had noticed one a few weeks prior, obviously before me telling her, I'm pretty sure they were still convinced Jehovah smited me with bed bugs for leaving the JWs.

Like I deadass wonder how at this point they still believe it. I know nothing will change their beliefs and I have no reason to try and change their beliefs, I respect the fact that people can choose what they want to believe. Even after the points I brought up as the reasons I left the org and the blood change, it obviously didn't do anything for them. I swear the average PIMI mind is just a boiling pot of bullshit 😭


r/exjw • • 9h ago

Ask ExJW If I tell a close friend I’m doubting is she required to tell someone?

24 Upvotes

I’m 23 and I still live with my family, so I’m under my parents headship even tho I’m an adult. I feel so alone and confused and I’m struggling so terribly mentally cuz I’ve started to be confused and doubt this religion. I’m in the baby’s room in the Kingdom Hall crying rn while the meeting is going I feel so terrible and alone and scared. If I tell a close friend that I’m doubting the religion and wanna look into it and study outside our publications, would she be like required to tell my parents or an elder? Idk if that’s a stupid question or not but idk. I know we’re always taught not to read “apostate” stuff online. But that’s what I first got into how I started doubting. So I feel like what if I’m wrong and I’m just going down a bad wrong path and this is the right religion and I’m just gonna skrew my life over. I’m so alone in this besides strangers on the internet and my 16 yo friend that’s left the truth to talk to about this stuff. Idk what to do, I’m so depressed


r/exjw • • 12h ago

PIMO Life This saying stays with me

36 Upvotes

I don't remember who said it, but it encapsulates my entire life as a JW, from infancy to now, as a ?? year old.

Something like: Most people dread Mondays. As a JW it is the opposite.

We look forward to Mondays and dread Saturdays and Sundays.

Sorry if I don't say it right. Please repost, dear exjw subredditor!

So true! What a sad life to live. Every Friday night, for as long as I can remember, I feel sad and imprisoned and frustrated.

I need my double scotch just so I can come to terms with the fact that I have to go in service tomorrow. And then at the hall Sunday. And I have to prepare a comment, so I'm not judged as not a good [insert title here]. I have to do this, have to do that, serve here, serve there, and smile like an imbecile while doing it.

I used to be grateful that I learned the truth. Out of 1000 people I had been drawn. What a privilege!

No more.


r/exjw • • 1h ago

HELP PIMI friend wants to leave

• Upvotes

Idk how to even start. Someone I used to be extremely close to reached out and told me they are looking to leave the Borg, but still have faith it’s the truth. For context, I left several years ago and am very openly queer, satanic, and “apostate”

They’re scared and having mixed feelings bc they are afraid of losing their family. But they have been on the brink for years with rule breaking and curiosity about “the world.”

Definitely bringing up some complicated feelings for me due to past history with them, but I try to be a safe harbor for anyone who’s leaving/left and needs some support with the transition. This is the first time though that someone has come to me saying they fully believe this is the truth still, but think they wanna leave nonetheless. I can’t help them deconstruct and I can’t console them with emphasizing how they’re following their conscience even when it costs them everything…. Because, well, they don’t want to deconstruct and they aren’t following their conscience. I want to help them leave, but I’m lost this time.

Happy to provide more context as needed. Love to hear other perspectives. This situation is oddly painful for me and disorienting.


r/exjw • • 16h ago

WT Policy An End to the 1914 date? 1919? - What does the new Watchtower say? (Also, you know all the new adjustments happening? It’s all part of Bible Prophecy!)

69 Upvotes

In the new February 2027 Watchtower (Study Edition) they don’t seem to be abandoning these dates 607bce, 1914, & 1919 just yet or anytime soon it seems.

The study article for April 12-18, 2027 “The Greatest Restoration of All” in paragraphs 6-7 (oh no, not six-seven still) they still point to 1914 as the year Jesus began ruling in Heaven. They also claim as they have before, “As foretold, the Messianic King then began his work of restoration on earth by giving attention to that small group of true Christians. They were tested, refined, and freed from captivity to false religion.” (So even if they may be making changes to seem more mainstream they still are in no hurry to distinguish themselves from “false religion.”) Not only did 1914 start the beginning of Jesus kingship but also it was when, “the times of restoration” began. (The restoration of pure worship since it went apostate in the 1st century.)

Paragraph 7 says, “By 1919,… [Jesus] appointed “the faithful and discreet slave.”

Paragraph 8 serves as damage control for all the recent changes (adjustments). They claim, “Jesus has gradually, step by step, revealed truths to his people, throughout these last days.” (Remember God and/or Jesus are the sources of the changes NOT men.) They say, “Jehovah’s people have seen exciting adjustments and refinements over the years, particularly in recent times.” Notice the last sentence of paragraph 8, “Each change assures [Jehovah’s people] that they are living in this extraordinary period of restoration.” (So PIMI witnesses if you are concerned of all these changes don’t worry! It’s all a part of Bible prophecy! The restoration of pure worship!)

None of this is new. It’s the same playbook they’ve been using. They cannot abandon 1914 because it won’t make the equation work. That is the destruction of Jerusalem in 607bce that leads to the 1914 date. Which ends up with Jesus finding the “small group of true Christians” and appointing them in 1919. 1914 + 1919= “the Faithful slave.”

They abandon the dates and they lose their self appointed authority.


r/exjw • • 12h ago

WT Policy Committee of elders - My thoughts on what’s next

23 Upvotes

My family and I woke up and totally faded 2 months ago. Among the so many things we have discussed are the judicial committees (now elder’s committees).

JW has always backed up these committees on James 5:14-15. Upon waking up and actually allowing myself to think, and with the help of this community, I clearly saw that assigning the meaning of ‘spiritual sickness’ to the phrase “Is there anyone sick among you” is going beyond what’s written, specially because the ending phrase “Also, if he has committed sins, he will be forgiven”. Therefore, the initial reason for calling the elders is physical sickness. So I thought, in order to look less radical, JW would eventually drastically change the committees arrangement.

Now, in the Questions from Readers, Feb 2027 they have taken what I think is the first step towards that. They wrote “there may be many instances in which serious sin is not the problem” and “James urges “anyone” who feels emotionally or spiritually exhausted to call the elders”.

I see this like what they did in the GB update which allowed autologous blood transfusions. They took a small step before the big blood update in September. Regarding committees, I think their next move is to radically change them, because James clearly says that the affected one is the one to initiate the help request. So a committee wouldn’t be warranted unless the affected person asks for it.

What are your thoughts on this matter?


r/exjw • • 8h ago

Ask ExJW My boss gave me a birthday gift this year, and it hit differently than I expected.

9 Upvotes

I grew up a Witness in a Spanish-speaking congregation outside Middletown, NY. No holidays, no birthdays. I always felt left out, like those were things that happened to other people.

I got disfellowshipped the first time as a teenager and the second time in my early 20s. Honestly, the first one wasn't as bad as people warned me it would be. But the holiday stuff stayed weird for years.

I turned 30 in August. My boss at the barbershop where I work, Iris, gave me a tiger's eye bracelet with a little Spartan helmet charm. I've gotten birthday gifts before, but never one from a boss. It meant something to me because my beliefs have changed a lot since I was raised a Witness.

After doing my own research, I've come to believe in astrology, and the stone and the helmet fit things I'd already been reading in my chart. That's my own conclusion from my own digging.

I'm not trying to tell anyone what to believe. Think of it like someone working on their car at night. I'm not the mechanic, I honestly couldn't fix a car if you paid me. I'm just the guy holding the flashlight so you can see what you're working on. You do the fixing, and you decide what's wrong with the car.

For those of you who've been out a while: was there a moment where a birthday or holiday gift hit you differently than it would have before? What was yours?


r/exjw • • 12m ago

Humor Imagine a conversation between two PIMOs in Twilight...

• Upvotes

– You're incredibly perceptive and cautious. You have pale skin, your eyes are hidden behind thick-lensed glasses, and you occasionally pay attention to the context of what's being said. During these two hours spent with us, you never nod along with the speaker. How old are you?

– Seventeen.

– How long have you been "not sleeping"?

– Long enough.

– I'm having a crisis of conscience over my assumption... I think that would seem to be quite presumptuous, but nevertheless, I believe I know what you are!

– Say it... Out loud... Say it.

– ...P-PIMO!

– Are you afraid?

– No!

– Then ask your most important question: What happened at ARC 2015?


r/exjw • • 6h ago

HELP pimo only child of a pimi couple, looking for advice on fading

5 Upvotes

hi all ! sorry if my flair is a little bland, i’m reaching out on this main sub (i have posted on the lgbtq one a few times) as i feel like im at a serious cross roads.
i am 23f PIMO and lesbian. i got baptized in 2020 and immediately started pioneering as that is what everyone wanted from me. of course my heart wasn’t in it as i already knew i was queer, only within the past few years have i admitted that i am lesbian. which i’m actually very open about ! i am one of the few young people in my congregation and since i grew up in it, everyone loves me and looks to me as a good example… which i am beginning to resent because that love is conditional, if they knew the real me they would hate me. the purpose of my post is to ask for some advice or to hear any similar stories to mine ? i am the only child of super PIMI parents and they’re a little older, they’re healthy now but i’ve known from a young age i would be the one taking care of them as they do age. which i do not resent in any capacity.

my father is an elder, and has been one for longer than i’ve been alive, he’s a very compassionate man and i experienced a very good childhood, i was spoiled and doted on and all of the things. i think that’s part of the reason why i feel selfish for wanting to leave (which im working through the feelings of selfishness in therapy). thankfully i am in college for a healthcare career and will be graduating in may 2027, and i have made some life long friends while in school. my parents are funding me mostly now, so i just work occasionally and focus on my studies.

however, i am in a relationship with someone and it is becoming very serious. it’s something i want to pursue long term and something that is very important to me. i recently have been struggling with lying to my parents about who im with and where i am (for context, my parents have always trusted me implicitly and i normally tell them everything), and sometimes even lying to my partner because im often embarrassed to be associated with a religion so homophobic and hateful. regardless, most of my loved ones know i’m lesbian, but everyone expects me to just suppress that integral side of me and pray that jehovah will fix me in the ‘new world’ which genuinely just sounds insane. i do not wish to be fixed, im pretty happy as is. i recently came out to my mother AGAIN because she refused to believe it was anything other than a phase. i also recently have ‘soft launched’ wanting to leave the organization to my dad. and he of course gave me the text book ‘i love you but i love jehovah more because he knows what’s best for you.’

when i graduate in may and pass my national exams, i want to get a job and hit the ground running so i can make enough for a small amount of savings and get an apartment in the city. my plan was to just move and never go to a meeting again, but i do not want my actions to have repercussions on my parents, they have been so good to me, and the last thing i want to do is cause them trouble. are there any ex elders who can weigh in ? if i move out and in with my partner, will my father be punished ? or if i move out on my own and stop attending meetings, will my father be punished ?

i also would like to know if i should continue having small conversations about me no longer believing in organized religion with my parents, as now that my eyes are open it’s all i really want to talk about. or should i just leave it be and blindside them when i just up and leave one day in the near future ? it is unfortunately a little strained in my house because my father did tell my mom i want to leave the organization, but we are all walking on eggshells around each other, do i add a little fuel to the fire ?

also, if anyone would share maybe some research topics, articles, and podcasts so that i can educate myself further and have faith that i shouldn’t have faith in this organization, that would be greatly appreciated ! i’m about to have a month off of school before my last semester and i will be stuck in the house.

once again, i apologize if this was a little scattered, i just have so much on my mind all the time. i genuinely just wish to be out and proud in peace, but i understand getting there is not going to be easy and i would love pointers that might make it a little easier. thank you for your time.


r/exjw • • 18h ago

PIMO Life What was your experience trying to refute evolution?

48 Upvotes

As Jehovah's Witnesses, simply believing in a creator wasn't enough—we had to let the world know just how gullible we were. We were told to take advantage of every opportunity at school to refute evolution, armed with "valuable" tools like the Watchtower’s Creation book.

Who among us didn't read that book during our school years? Who didn't ask their teacher for permission to defend the organization's creationist views? What was the outcome?

In my case, I worked up the nerve to challenge my teacher by asking why chimpanzees—supposedly our ancestors—still exist today, while more "evolved" creatures like Homo habilis or Australopithecus went extinct. My argument, which I had rehearsed for hours, was completely dismantled with one simple statement: "Nobody ever said humans descended from chimpanzees..."

How did it go for the rest of you?


r/exjw • • 14h ago

HELP Trying to fade but it's awkward and difficult - advice?

26 Upvotes

Both me and my husband are awake and pimo and have been for a year or two. We're both reaching our limits and want out. We stopped going on service completely for the last 6 months and probably go to 50% of meetings. Even just the occasional meetings make us feel insane because we can see through it all. We want to be done but the issue is our family and friends.

We are in the same hall as my family, my dad is an elder and my mom is a pioneer. We have a complicated dynamic but are somewhat close. I can tell they are concerned that we are becoming "spiritually weak," texting to ask if we're okay when not at meeting (I either blame sickness, exhaustion or just don't respond) and inviting us to go on service. The tiptoeing around them and making excuses is becoming so awkward and also anxiety inducing, sometimes I want to rip the bandaid off and tell them we're done but also I'm not sure if I can handle the big blowout that would cause. I know soon enough they will be asking what's going on and trying to "encourage" us.

We also have a very tight-knit friend group within the organization. A lot of them are lovely people albeit brainwashed and I know us leaving will upset a lot of them and they may want to try and talk us out of leaving once/if they figure it out. I have a lot of love for these people but also know how they are trained to love very conditionally. I was once a true-blue believer so I have understanding of why they would feel the need to shun us once it becomes clear we no long want to be witnesses.

I know people on here will say, "your family and friends don't really love you, just leave and start over etc" and while there's some truth to it, it's not that simple.

Anyway, I'm looking for advice on how to continue this fade successfully or whether we should "rip the bandaid off" and tell people we're leaving. We wouldn't disassociate but sometimes I think it'd be simpler to just say that we're stepping away from the religion. It feels so complex to navigate and to figure out the right path out for us.

If you've faded, stopped participating over night or even disassociated I'd love to hear your story, what went well, what you wish you did differently. Everyone takes a different path but hearing how others have done it successfully would be helpful.


r/exjw • • 12h ago

PIMO Life XJW interviews are so good, but always end up reinforcing my selfishness, does anyone else feel this way?

17 Upvotes

Each time I begin a new interview I feel like I can leave.

halfway through i start hearing how destructive leaving is so I feel selfish.

Towards the end, I always think that true happiness comes from leaving this cult, but my mind always goes back to that middle piece and what it would do to my family. My family is all i have


r/exjw • • 22h ago

PIMO Life Ok genuine question do JWs have anything good to look forward to at all through the year?

91 Upvotes

I have been on both sides of life and can honestly say life as a Jw can be absolutely boring as hell! With gta6 about to release im seeing how much hype people are looking forward to it although thats not my cup of tea but it makes me think what even is there to look forward to through the year. No Christmas or birthday. No week end parties unless you are part of a bubble in the congregation then you will always get left out. Every Christmas holidays are so depressing and boring to me as no one does anything or goes anywhere. No New Year’s Eve. What even is there to look forward to? Do not say to me that assemblies and memorials are the most enjoyable things to do. I can barely think of anyone who actually wants to go sit down for hours to listen to some generic program that could be sent to you in an email. Programs used to be kind of exciting when they actually released new publications at assemblies but now it’s just Jesus drama and some Bible reading and then the rest of the program is just reviewing what the Jesus drama played. Man it’s mind numbing! I liked it when they made it personal to your area with experiences ect. Not just cookie cutter parts. Anyway I digress, life is meant to be enjoyed, not just meetings and witnessing as they lead you to think. It can be very lonely on the inside around here, especially when no one really gives you a minute of their time nor will include you in anything. I have effectively just thrown my arms up in the air and said stuff it I’ll just do what I want to do, no one is coming to get out and do stuff with so I’ll just do it on my own.


r/exjw • • 16h ago

Ask ExJW Has anyone read this before??

Post image
24 Upvotes

I was not aware this article existed prior to today and im extremely confused. So they believed the slave was appointed in 1919 prior to this article and in 2013 they changed it. If so, why is the governing body called the FDS?? Was there an update after this update?


r/exjw • • 14h ago

Meetup Any other Christians who don’t have anyone to celebrate Christmas with this year? 🎄

18 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I thought I’d reach out and see if there might be anyone here in a similar situation.

I became a Christian about a year ago, and since then I’ve come to appreciate Christmas in a whole new way. It’s become a very meaningful holiday to me, and something I’m genuinely looking forward to celebrating.

The only problem is that my family are Jehovah’s Witnesses (hence why I’m posting in this group), and all of my friends already have plans with their own families.

I was therefore wondering if there might be someone else who also finds themselves alone this Christmas, or perhaps someone who would simply enjoy meeting new people and celebrating together.

I’m imagining something simple, like sharing some Christmas food, spending time together, talking about life and faith, and just having a cosy Christmas Eve.

I’m based in Sweden close to Lund, so ideally I’d love to connect with someone relatively nearby, but feel free to reach out regardless!

God bless, and Merry Christmas! ❤️


r/exjw • • 15h ago

Venting Today I was re-traumatised because I didn't expected fellow patient to be part of JW

20 Upvotes

I'm prepared when I talk to some JW and I expect them trying to change my mind.

(I'm out out of there for more than 10 years, I never got baptized. Our family is pretty serious about it, I'm the only one who got away.)

I always smile and then I change topic. When it's written, via message, I don't reply or I reply to everything else but that.

But today, I found out that fellow patient who I see daily in psychiatry hospital was also growing up as JW. She knew I was brought up by religious mom, but she didn't say anything about herself.

She obviously put the pieces together but she didn't ask me until after two or three weeks.

I managed to talk sh*t about JW in front of her (although I didn't mention them by their name before) and now I'm scared she will tell someone and somehow people in congregation where my family is will hear it and they will cut my contact with my family despite me not being officially removed.

But the worst thing is that she began to defend them. (She told me she's not active, she didn't know about blood change and she wasn't baptized.)

She was telling me that they're not a cult and how bloodless surgeries are actually much better and safer and how most of them are really nice people...

I immediately got into panic attack.

I felt so vulnerable.

It was only recently when I started talking in therapy about the trauma of growing up in this cult...

I admit I now question all the stuff I already went through - there's a tiny voice asking "what if what she says is true"...

I try to remember what pushed me away...

The lack of freedom. The patriarchy. The fear of world end. Now the court stuff, blood change, better understanding how manipulation works...

But somehow the panic attack is stronger than the "facts".

I thought that once I decided to really leave it all behind, it will be okay.

But maybe it's not enough.

Maybe the trauma is too big and re-traumatisation happens too easily.

Maybe my decision wasn't bold enough.

I'm really looking towards your insights, I'm kinda lost right now.