At the recent annual meeting, the Governing Body raised the possibility that the first resurrection may not begin until the great tribulation. They made it clear that this was not a change in teaching, but simply something they could no longer be dogmatic about.
However, I think this introduces a much bigger problem than simply determining when the first resurrection begins. It calls into question the entire separation between Christ's invisible "parousia" beginning in 1914 and his future "coming."
Consider what Paul actually says in 1 Thessalonians 4:15 through 17. He specifically connects the resurrection of the dead and the gathering of the living with Christ's "parousia." He describes the Lord descending from heaven, God's trumpet sounding, the dead in Christ rising first, and then those who remain alive being caught away together with them to meet the Lord.
The Greek expression "hama syn autois" in verse 17 carries the idea of being "at the same time together with them." Paul is describing two groups being gathered together at the same event, not a resurrection extending over decades followed by a separate gathering much later.
Notice that Paul only identifies two groups. Those who have fallen asleep in death and those who remain alive until the "parousia."
The Watchtower's interpretation actually introduces a third group that Paul never mentions. These are Christians who survive the beginning of the "parousia" in 1914, but subsequently die and receive an immediate resurrection throughout the following decades.
Where does Paul describe such a group? He doesn't. That category only becomes necessary when you attempt to make his words fit the 1914 chronology.
The problem becomes even clearer in 1 Corinthians 15:51 and 52. Paul explicitly states that not all will fall asleep in death, but all will be changed at the "last trumpet." He distinguishes between those who have died and are resurrected and those who remain alive and are changed without experiencing death.
Yet the Watchtower's earlier interpretation required everyone to die before receiving their heavenly reward. They attempted to get around Paul's statement by arguing that those who died and were immediately resurrected had not actually slept in death.
But falling asleep is simply a figurative expression for dying, as Jesus himself demonstrates in John 11:11 through 14. Being resurrected immediately after death doesn't somehow mean that you never died.
This is also important because Paul connects these events with Isaiah 25:8 and Hosea 13:14 in 1 Corinthians 15:53 through 55, where death is swallowed up in victory. Those who remain alive experience that victory without ever entering the grave. The Watchtower's earlier interpretation effectively eliminated this group altogether.
Even the translation of the Greek preposition "en" as "during" in 1 Corinthians 15:23 helped support the idea that the resurrection continued throughout Christ's invisible presence. While "during" is a legitimate possible translation, nothing in Paul's statement establishes individual resurrections taking place over decades.
Then in 2013, the organization introduced the understanding that the remaining living anointed would be gathered during the great tribulation, connecting this event with Matthew 24:31 and Christ's future "coming."
But compare Matthew 24:29 through 31 with 1 Thessalonians 4:15 through 17. In both passages we have Christ coming, a trumpet sounding, and the gathering of his chosen ones. Yet Paul specifically associates these events with the "parousia," not some separate event more than a century later.
And what about the "last trumpet" in 1 Corinthians 15:52? If this trumpet is associated with the resurrection beginning around 1918, why would the gathering of the living still await another trumpet at Christ's future "coming"? Paul connects the resurrection and the change of the living with the same "last trumpet."
Now consider what happens if the first resurrection doesn't actually begin until the great tribulation, as the Governing Body is now suggesting might be possible.
The resurrection of the dead, the change of the living, the "last trumpet," and their gathering together would all take place in connection with Christ's future "coming."
But these are precisely the events Paul associates with Christ's "parousia"!
Previously, the teaching that the resurrection began around 1918 at least provided a connection between the first resurrection and the invisible "parousia" that supposedly began in 1914. If the resurrection is moved to the great tribulation, even that connection disappears.
And notice something else. In Matthew 24:27, Jesus describes his "parousia" as lightning shining across the sky. Then in verses 29 through 31, he describes his "coming" and the gathering of his chosen ones. Why should we assume these are two entirely separate occasions divided by more than a century, especially when Paul connects the resurrection and gathering directly with the "parousia"?
This is why I think the issue goes far beyond the timing of the first resurrection.
The Watchtower's older interpretation required separating events that Paul describes together, and even introducing an additional class of Christians who die after the "parousia" begins, something Paul never mentions.
Now the possibility being considered brings those events back together at Christ's future "coming," but that creates an even greater conflict with the claim that the "parousia" began in 1914.
If the resurrection, the "last trumpet," and the gathering of the living all occur at Christ's future "coming," and Paul explicitly places these events at the "parousia," then on what biblical basis can the two be separated by more than a century?
It seems to me that the real problem was created by separating the "parousia" from the "coming" in the first place. Once that distinction is imposed on Paul's statements, the resurrection has to be divided into stages, an additional group of Christians has to be introduced that die during the "parousia" and events Paul connects together have to be separated by decades. The newly proposed possibility doesn't resolve these problems. It actually makes the underlying contradiction much more obvious and undermines the entire idea that Christ's "parousia" and his "coming" are two separate events.