Which album best showcases each member's individual contributions? IMO:
Nate: But Here We Are. The bass is so melodic and prominent, it really is the highlight of the album for me.
Taylor: Concrete And Gold. The drums are intense, heavy, and super creative. Though his best straightforward rock drumming might be One By One.
Rami: Concrete And Gold. The most synth-heavy album, the one for which he joined. Honorable mention to Your Favorite Toy for solidifying his place as an ensemble player, providing more of a canvas for everyone else with a few nice moments of prominence.
The guitarists are harder for me to pin down because it's not always clear who's playing what. But I think...
Chris: One By One. No solos on the album which is a bit of a bummer, but this one has the most audibly distinct guitar parts, where there's definitely 2 people playing different parts that warp and play around each other. And maybe I'm imagining it but it feels like his early aughts punk influence is more prominent in the writing too.
Pat: again hard to say but the album that feels the most like his energy is probably Wasting Light. It's between that and Your Favorite Toy for me.
Ilan: Obviously Your Favorite Toy, but Are Playing Where??? Volume 1 is nothing to sleep on. His takes on the classics are fresh and unique.
And of course Dave. Tempting to say self titled because he did everything, but they developed so much after that point.
As a singer-songwriter it's probably In Your Honor. That album is a massive achievement showcasing his depth and versatility.
As specifically a rock vocalist I'm thinking One By One.
As a guitarist I think There Is Nothing Left To Lose most shows his specific style and sensibilities.
As a drummer probably The Colour And The Shape, those drum parts are absolutely iconic.
What did I get wrong or right here?