I opened an issue last year expressing my concern with tone of the donation notification, because it's extremely pessimistic and guilt-trippy. They never fixed it. I'm very inclined taking the liberty to just change the message myself through a PR, but the amount of patience it takes to actually get stuff done within the GNOME infrastructure is exhausting.
Why does Gnome even has to push for donations so hard when they provide the base for companies like RHEL? IBM has plenty of money. Same for Canonical. But they give nothing so we end users get “nagged” about it. Meanwhile a literal dot file installer has tens of millions to spend.
Corporate contributions to GNOME are mostly engineers on payroll, not money to the Foundation. The Foundation covers infrastructure, legal, events and admin, and it runs on a small budget. Red Hat employing developers doesn’t pay for any of that. Companies profiting from the base and giving the nonprofit nothing is exactly why the donation drives exist. Asking users isn’t the problem, the funding gap is.
If infrastructure and events are payed for by inividual donations, why is the GNOME website and event banners/posters plastered with logos of big tech companies?
Mb good question and you’re right, I put it too strongly. Companies do sponsor GUADEC and other events, which is why the logos are there. But that money is earmarked for those events and doesn’t cover the Foundation’s general running costs. Those rely on donations, advisory board fees and reserves, and the reserves ran out in 2024, so they can’t keep running deficits anymore. The logos show who sponsors events, not that the Foundation has money to spare.
But the website says the infrastructure is provided by Red Hat, Canonical, AWS, Fastly, CDN77, OSL, CloudDNS, abusix, Equinix, MacStadium and miniOrange.....
Why is there no logo thanking the individual donations, if they are that important for infrastructure?
Mb, you're right again, partly. A lot of the hosting and hardware is donated in kind by companies, which is why their logos are on the site. What the Foundation pays for itself is more the people side, like sysadmin time, admin and events, and donations help cover that. The GUADEC poster lists event sponsors, since companies are paying for visibility there. Individual donors aren't sponsoring the event, they support the Foundation's general work, and they're thanked through Friends of GNOME instead. Maybe it could be more visible though. Sorry for the mix-up earlier.
Gnome devs prefer uncluttered, and minimalistic shell, as tray icons fill up the tray, and colorful system tray icons look inconsistent. already background apps support is implemented in system menu, and extensions are already there.
tray gives you an illusion of multitasking. if you want app to run in background - minimize the window. the problem with GNOME's implementation of tracking background apps is that it is not always working ideally.
this does not work in the real world where people have messaging and/or email apps start at login and then run in the background. when I tried to run vanilla I had a stroke on every login seeing 5 windows auto-open at once in the same workspace and of course they didn't tile by themselves because Gnome knows best amirite?
That's what notifications are for, though. I don't have a constant icons in my phone's status bar telling me that Gmail, WhatsApp, SMS, Discord are running in the background.
How? Vanilla GNOME does not have minimize button. 🙂
If you want to use GNOME the "proper way" you should put every windows in one separated workspace but because it is not handled automatically on GNOME, you would do this by-hand after every f.n reboot.
Btw, there are a plenty apps, I would like to get i.e. notifications and they can run with low memory state in the background. It would be good, if I can reach them with one click, instead of 2 keypress + 3 click.
So, when you do not have the Tweaks and Extensions... Btw, I'll tell you the solution: w/ Super + H you can minimize.
We can agree with that, in GNOME, the background applications' problem and the whole application handling is not complete in this state.
Maybe, if the Wayland's implementation about the saving windows state + position will solve this, but it will be years until all mainstream application will use it.
OK guys. I DO NOT have a chance to see your setups and try them, so i cant judge you for using tray icons, and I dont want to do it. my comment was meaning that we cannot get rid of them in cases where there arent any applications that heavily rely on tray icon. In my own expirience tray icons really do not look good, but I am not using vanilla gnome myself - gnome is not minimalistic, it is barebones without extensions and tweaking. sorry for bad english if that is the case
Go get the desktop apps that require a tray because it's supported on every other desktop to change their mind then on using a tray icon to access basic functionality.
Gnomes leadership (BoD) is a mess. It's almost like it's in constant chaos. They make money just they don't get enough from the big corp greedy bastards and like most of the linux dev community, they aren't above begging users for money. Support them don't support them, gnome won't die from lack of charity - they might however, collapse from crazy leadership
Oh, I'll do it once devs add system tray, menu bars and basically stops going against any desktop rule just because they feel better than other desktop devs.
Funny you get spam for donations before system tray icons. I never expected to see this since they launched gnome 3 (yeah, I'm too old)
This is why open source projects suffer, you are using something for free made by unpaid volunteers on their free time, and you keep asking for more work for free. How about maybe try supporting so they can hire devs to do the work, or fork it and pay developers to do the work? Fucking shit
I don't want system tray icons - they are useless and I will never want them in Gnome. You're not paying Gnome for features you want - you're supporting their work. If you don't want to support them, then don't. But don't post some rage-bait about how you're not going to donate unless you get your specific wants. Switch to KDE Plasma or Xfce then.
Who told you that you can't have it? First and foremost, GNOME is a collaborative open source project, with people who have their own vision of the desktop experience, there's no ‘I’ or ‘me’ there, every feature addition or removal is thoroughly discussed publicly and collectively. Or do you really think it's just a particular minority within the community who do stuff just to spite others? That they didn't explain their decision-making?
Also, they've made a way to change or extend the functionality of your desktop via extensions to your liking, but if that's not enough for you, go ahead and join GNOME, try to implement a solution that will work out for everyone, such a pity it's not as trivial as writing ‘they have such a stupid mindset’ on the Internet.
I didn't say you can't have it. I am just voicing my opinion which is different from yours. Just because someone has a differing opinion doesn't mean they're wrong. You understand that, right? Use a Gnome extension and stop insisting Gnome put it into the DE because you absolutely have an opinion that it's necessary.
What makes you think that system tray icons are useless? I'd say that being able to fully close a program (such as Telegram, Steam, or others) is pretty useful.
Don't get me wrong, you shouldn't just donate if GNOME adds features you want, and not donate because they won't add a feature, that's pretty... questionable. But I don't see how system tray icons are useless at all.
They are absolutely not useless. multiple programs close to system tray which causes issues if you don't have the tray. There are programs which show status through the tray (Discord). I like the concept of not minimizing windows, but for programs like Steam, Discord, OpenSnitch (Why in the world would you want this open??) etc, that you leave permanently open in the background, putting them on some random workspace is just a bad experience.
Then those programs are the problem. I don't run Discord as an app, so it doesn't impact me, I guess. The thing is, Flatpak apps running in the background are shown in the top pill dropdown. For me, that's all I need.
Of course people have stipulations when they donate, which is why they only donate to certain things.
People regularly "donate and expect something in return."
You can donate without being purely altruistic—for example, giving for a tax break, public recognition, or personal satisfaction—and you can act altruistically without donating anything tangible.
Unironically, Google AI gave me that definition. ;) Or would that be ironically, in this case, since the person mentioned taking a hard stance against AI?
I'm not demanding anything, just stating what would motivate me to contribute, which is perfectly natural (everyone needs to have a motivation to donate, it's not as though we donate to every FLOSS project we come across, that simply isn't feasible unless one was very wealthy).
I personally don't feel comfortable donating to projects that endorse or accept AI for ethical and practical reasons. I ceased my donations to KDE for their stance on AI, which was in conflict with mine.
Gnome is largely made up of developers with a strong ethical and moral priority, and a dim view on AI, so I'm quite hopeful they move to adopt a policy similar to Cosmic's in the near future.
no thanks, no anonymous donations possible only paypal and like that. nothing against paypal, but why they insist reveal personal information to others?
GNOME had such a decline that this is a big NO for me. They transformed into the open-source Apple everyone hates. Sure, it's somewhat consistent, but I feel like they don't listen to their users about certain things.
•
u/AutoModerator 9h ago
Thank you for your submission.
You too can support GNOME! Become a Friend of GNOME and contribute to keeping our project going!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
•
u/srfreak 8h ago •
Im donating 5€/mo since almost one year ago. As looong time GNOME user it's the bare minimum I can do, imho.
•
u/MichaelMcEntire 1h ago
I sent them $15. Hopefully it helps.
•
u/gloombanana 8h ago
A bit aggressive tbh, it notified me 2 days in a row now.
•
u/ndaidong 7h ago
I'm willing to send few tens of dollar, if they accept Paypal there.
•
u/Reged1tFox 8h ago
•
u/evadingsomething 7h ago
Can't you just disable it? Iirc there is an option to do so. I honestly dont care I don't have the money but they deserve it
•
u/dthrdr 8h ago edited 6h ago
Why does Gnome even has to push for donations so hard when they provide the base for companies like RHEL? IBM has plenty of money. Same for Canonical. But they give nothing so we end users get “nagged” about it. Meanwhile a literal dot file installer has tens of millions to spend.
•
u/romulof 8h ago
Ok, but first add tray icons support
•
u/SnowyOwl72 1h ago
i would whenever they stop making it so darn difficult to disable automatic sleep when idling.
•
u/paulodelgado 11m ago
I don't even use GNOME anymore - I still donate yearly. They bring the Linux desktop forward. DONATE!
Also if you can, donate to the EFF (Electronic Frontier Foundation) - for those of us who value privacy and consumer rights.
•
u/ShizenFacen 4h ago
Gnomes leadership (BoD) is a mess. It's almost like it's in constant chaos. They make money just they don't get enough from the big corp greedy bastards and like most of the linux dev community, they aren't above begging users for money. Support them don't support them, gnome won't die from lack of charity - they might however, collapse from crazy leadership
•
u/cristomc 4h ago
Oh, I'll do it once devs add system tray, menu bars and basically stops going against any desktop rule just because they feel better than other desktop devs.
Funny you get spam for donations before system tray icons. I never expected to see this since they launched gnome 3 (yeah, I'm too old)
•
u/RatherNott 8h ago
I'd donate if they take a hard stance against AI.
•
u/ChocolateSpecific263 7h ago
no thanks, no anonymous donations possible only paypal and like that. nothing against paypal, but why they insist reveal personal information to others?
•
u/IAmABoredCat1590 6h ago
GNOME had such a decline that this is a big NO for me. They transformed into the open-source Apple everyone hates. Sure, it's somewhat consistent, but I feel like they don't listen to their users about certain things.
•
u/Beneficial_Bit1756 8h ago
Nope, never.
•
u/Aimless115 4h ago
After what happened with framework sponsorship getting corporations to sponsor is one hell of challenge.
Gnome image is at its lowest and trust on the project is also low specially around the foundation..
•
u/Busy-Scientist3851 5h ago
I would donate if they added native support for appindicators.
•
u/kingchili 5h ago •
No thanks. My favourite shell but the organisation is way too poisoned by politics to get any money from me.
•
u/Tanashio 3h ago
No i wont donate, u lack simple features
•
u/metux-its 3h ago
To hire more shamans ? Or financing more hate campaigns against competing technology ?
•
u/go222 2h ago
I will donate when they standardize a way get minimize buttons and a taskbar. It should be easy to set up. It does not have to be active by default.
•
u/Glittering_Welder607 2h ago
Voy a donar... Las MacBook's, iPhone's y viajes de los de la fundación GNOME no se pagan solos.
•
u/PersonalDatabase31 1h ago
This isn't real right? Imagine having ads in your os in 2026.