r/GradSchool • u/Aggressive_Onion8301 • 2h ago
Academics What exactly should I expect from office hours as a humanities grad student?
I’m a humanities grad student, and I might be overthinking this, but I’m genuinely curious about what office hours are supposed to look like.
A few days ago, something came up during a seminar that I found really interesting, but we moved on pretty quickly. I kept thinking about it afterward and wanted to explore it further. The thing is, it was a pretty broad topic, and I didn’t really have a specific question in mind. It also had nothing to do with my final paper. I was just interested in a few aspects of it.
I remembered that my professor had office hours that afternoon, so I decided to drop by.
We talked about it for a bit, and he said something like, “That’s an interesting question, but I don’t have an answer right now. You should email me about it later.” So we continued chatting about a few loosely related things, but eventually I ran out of things to say and left. The whole conversation lasted maybe 15 minutes.
Now I’m wondering whether I should have approached it differently. I feel like the spontaneous nature of office hours can sometimes make conversations a little aimless, especially when neither person has had time to think through the topic beforehand.
So I’m curious:
Is it normal to go to office hours just to discuss something intellectually interesting, even if it’s unrelated to coursework or research?
Should I email professors beforehand with the topics or questions I’d like to discuss?
Are office hours supposed to lead to something concrete, or is having a casual academic conversation already a perfectly good use of that time?