r/internationallaw • u/Calvinball90 • 14h ago
r/internationallaw • u/WeirdTheory5675 • 3d ago
Discussion Are ICJ advisory opinions the final word on a topic ?
Since they aren't binding even on organs of the UN , is it possible for member states to present counter arguments to it that could be more pursuasive than the opinion itself ? Does ICJ itself treat it's advisory opinions as settled jurisprudence ?
r/internationallaw • u/FerdinandTheGiant • 5d ago
Op-Ed The ICJ's Erroneous Standard for Proof of Genocide
r/internationallaw • u/WeirdTheory5675 • 6d ago
Discussion How does customary international law deal with the problem of circularity ?
Under the traditional two-element theory, customary international law requires:
1.General State practice (usus).
- Acceptance of that practice as law (opinio juris).
But consider the logical problem.Suppose States repeatedly refrain from doing something because they believe international law prohibits it.The traditional theory says that their belief that the conduct is legally prohibited helps create the prohibition.But if the prohibition does not yet exist, how can States believe that it already exists?
There appears to be a circular relationship:
1)A legal obligation is created because States believe it exists.
2)States believe it exists because they regard their conduct as legally obligatory.
3) Yet the obligation supposedly does not exist until the relevant customary process is completed.
László Blutman (2014), "Conceptual Confusion and Methodological Deficiencies: Some Ways that Theories on Customary International Law Fail' has a more empirical criticism; State practice is identified by examining State conduct , we identify opinio juris partly by examining that same State conduct.But we also use opinio juris to determine which State conduct is legally relevant. This seems to demonstrate empirical circularity , the evidence used to establish one element is also used to establish the other.
r/internationallaw • u/pobcheepobayeayeaye • 7d ago
Discussion ICC Summer Internship 2027
Hi everyone! I'm currently a junior at a university in America, and plan on applying to intern with the ICC for Summer of 2027. I was wondering if anyone has any advice for the application? It seems pretty straightforward so far but I'm worried I'll accidentally make a huge mistake or something. Any advice at all would very very much so appreciated, thank you!!
r/internationallaw • u/WeirdTheory5675 • 7d ago
Discussion How did the 4A framework for ICESCR develop ?
The 4 As which are Availability , Accessibility , Acceptability , Adaptability is the dominant framework for interpreting ICESCR that is used by the Commitee on economic and social rights
It's been applied to article 11(food , clothing and housing) , 12 (health) , 13(education) and to article 15 (culture)
How did this framework develop ? What is it's underlying legal basis ?
This seems to use the effet utile doctrine and a particular interpretation of the term "full realisation of the rights recognised in the present covenant"
Does realization include rights being effectively beneficial to the individual ?
r/internationallaw • u/Sissi060504 • 9d ago
News The Hague Academy Summer Courses 2027: Any WhatsApp / Telegram group for attendees?
Hi everyone,
I've just finalized my application/registration for the upcoming Hague Academy Summer Courses (Public/Private International Law session).
Is there already an active WhatsApp or Telegram group chat for attendees of the 2027 edition (for discussing logistics, housing in The Hague, travel, and networking)?
If a group already exists, please drop the link or feel free to DM me so I can join. If not, let me know if anyone is interested in creating one!
Thanks!
r/internationallaw • u/WeirdTheory5675 • 11d ago
Discussion Does article 11 of ICESCR require objective or subjective determination ?
Article 11 deals with addequate standard of living (including addequate food , housing and clothing) and to continuous improvement of living conditions.
Is adequacy decided subjectively from the perception of the state or individuals ? Or is there an objective criteria possible to develop for example in conjunction with specialised agencies which have these topics as part of their competence
r/internationallaw • u/divaofmup • 12d ago
Discussion International maritime lawyer career options globally?
I am starting the process to study for the LSAT and apply to law school. I am interested in international maritime law (currently based in USA). I grew up next to the Port of Los Angeles, and saw how port pollution impacted my neighborhood/ocean, and movement of goods via the port. I have spent the last 5-6 years working in climate/environmental policy in local government contexts. I want to go to law school and focus on maritime law, and directly address port pollution on a global scale. I also have a growing interest in learning about how climate change is impacting the maritime boundaries of countries with eroding shorelines. Where are the best places in the world to pursue this work? Is maritime law the right specialization? Does obtaining a law degree from the USA support me to pursue this work?
r/internationallaw • u/WeirdTheory5675 • 12d ago
Discussion Do treaty bodies have the competence to suggest state parties to remove reservations even if they aren't incompatible with the treaty ?
Assuming no reservations have been made to the monitoring provisions themselves
Would the treaty monitoring body have the competence to ask member states to remove reservations and also require reasons from them ? (For example as part of member states' reporting obligations under say ICCPR or ICESCR on the implementation of the covenant and difficulties faced)
It seems like treaty monitoring bodies aren't only legal interpreters of the covenant but can also monitor the technical aspects of implementation , but could they also perform "political" functions like these ?
r/internationallaw • u/SocraticTiger • 13d ago
News Top UN court to rule Nov 19 on Myanmar's Rohingya genocide case
r/internationallaw • u/Calvinball90 • 14d ago
Op-Ed The Expiry of MINURSO’s Mandate, Western Sahara, and the Foundations of International Law
r/internationallaw • u/WeirdTheory5675 • 17d ago
Discussion What is the source of authoritativeness of ICJ advisory opinions and Treaty body general comments ?
Given the non binding nature of these , is the fact that they're part of the institutional structure of the legal instrument where they derive their authority from ? Or their reasoning used ?
In the apartheid event where South Africa's credentials were rejected , the office of legal affairs of the UN secretariat proclaimed the practice as illegal however it still continued , which makes me wonder if authoritativeness through reasons can still be valuable even if no followed.
Edit; basically why do states follow these despite their lack of bindingness and why should states follow them ? I'm assuming it has something to be with reasoning used but I haven't seen concrete reasoning in many general comments
r/internationallaw • u/jseo13579 • 17d ago
Discussion Can mass deportation also fall into the category of ethnic cleansing based on government motives?
If mass deportation occurs as a result of government labeling a racial minority group as "social misfit" or "subversive element", would that constitute ethnic cleansing?
r/internationallaw • u/WeirdTheory5675 • 20d ago
Discussion Are host state agreements subject to denunciation despite having no express provision of withdrawal ?
The international law comission in its commentary on VCLT article 56 stated
> Treaties between one or more States and one or more international organizations include a class of treaties which although having no denunciation clause, seem to be denounceable: the headquarters agreements concluded between a State and an organization. For an international organization, the choice of its headquarters represents a right whose exercise is not normally immobilized; moreover, For an international organization, the choice of its headquarters represents a right whose exercise is not normally immobilized; moreover, the smooth operation headquarters agreement presupposes relations of a special kind between the organization and the host State, which cannot be maintained by the will of one party only.
https://www.icj-cij.org/sites/default/files/case-related/65/065-19801220-ADV-01-00-EN.pdf
The court also discusses the ILC report but it doesn't seem to have settled on any particular view.
The ILC's commentary says that the organisation's choice of headquarters is a right whose exercise is not normally immobilised. It uses this as a reason why headquarters agreements may be denounceable.But an organisation's right to choose or change its headquarters concerns its institutional autonomy.
The host State's right to terminate the agreement concerns the continued validity of its international legal obligations. Those are not necessarily the same legal question, there doesn't seem to be any reason to not presume that an organisation can be free to relocate while the host State remains bound by the agreement's obligations during the period in which it remains in force. The organisation's freedom to leave does not logically establish that the host State has an equivalent right to force the agreement to end. A headquarters agreement is not simply an ordinary commercial arrangement concerning the occupation of premises. It establishes the legal conditions under which an international organisation can operate within a State. So it seems there's no reason to presume that by their very nature these agreements would be withdrawable especially given headquarters agreements generally don't seem to contain a denunciation clause.
The ILC itself recognised that the smooth operation of a headquarters agreement presupposes a special relationship between the organisation and the host State, which cannot be maintained by the will of one party alone , so could mutual obligations with regards to this be inferred to ensure a smooth transition during denunciation ?
Edit; follow up question , assuming headquarters agreements aren't denunciable by their nature , would the member state which hosts the organization withdrawing from it have any legal effects also upon the headquarters agreement ?
r/internationallaw • u/posixthreads • 23d ago
Op-Ed [Just Security] Might The Gambia v. Myanmar Help Establish Genocidal Intent in Russia’s War on Ukraine?
r/internationallaw • u/WeirdTheory5675 • 23d ago
Discussion Is silence or non objection to state activities enough to count as subsequent agreement ?
Assuming states act in a certain way under the belief that what they are doing is legal or legally required and other states do not object or allow the state to act that way , could this be evidence of subsequent agreement in the context of treaty interpretation or customary international law
Edit; one thing I'm curious about is that does this mean that there's no such thing as Ignorantia juris non excusat when an international treaty law isn't clear or interpreted by an authoritative source ?
r/internationallaw • u/OkyEscritora • 23d ago
Discussion What legal protection does a ceasefire provide beyond stopping hostilities?
Peace talks over Ukraine, Palestine and Iran raise different legal questions. Sovereignty and occupation are central to some; others focus on preventing renewed attacks, limiting military activities or securing navigation. A ceasefire can stop fighting without resolving the disputes behind it.
Suppose states agree to suspend hostilities, accept monitoring and arrange civilian access or commercial shipping, and a third state offers security assurances that help persuade the parties. Some underlying disputes stay unresolved. The legal question is what protection those commitments create if the ceasefire breaks down.
The first distinction is between a political assurance and a binding legal obligation. Calling something a “security guarantee” doesn’t establish what the guarantor must do: a commitment to consult differs from an obligation to assist, and neither necessarily requires military intervention. Wording, intention to create legal obligations and any conditions attached all matter.
Agreements also have to distinguish obligations to stop particular conduct from obligations to respond to another party’s breach. Monitoring can establish what happened without giving monitors the authority or resources to enforce compliance, and a mechanism for reporting violations isn’t necessarily a mechanism for protecting those exposed to them.
Where territory remains occupied, a ceasefire line needn’t become an international border. Occupation doesn’t itself transfer sovereignty, and Article 47 of the Fourth Geneva Convention protects protected persons against losing the Convention’s benefits through annexation or through agreements between the authorities of the occupied territory and the occupying power. A settlement involving Iran raises other issues, such as commitments on attacks, military restrictions and maritime passage.
Consent is another issue. Article 52 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties provides that a treaty is void if its conclusion was procured by the threat or use of force in violation of the principles of international law embodied in the UN Charter. Negotiating during a war doesn’t by itself settle whether that rule applies.
These distinctions matter because an agreement can suspend fighting while leaving it unclear who owes protection, what triggers assistance and what response is legally required.
What provisions distinguish a ceasefire backed by binding obligations of protection from one that leaves the parties dependent on political assurances if fighting resumes?
r/internationallaw • u/Calvinball90 • 24d ago
Op-Ed Crimes Against Humanity in Myanmar’s Rakhine State: The Arakan Army’s Own Case (Part I)
r/internationallaw • u/prototyperspective • 24d ago
News International Criminal Court wins EU's Sakharov human rights prize
r/internationallaw • u/SectorSufficient854 • 25d ago
Discussion Studying International Law in Europe as an English Speaker
Hi everyone! I'm really interested in studying international law, and I was wondering if anyone who only speaks English has studied it in a European country other than the UK.
I'd love to hear about your experiences and recommendations! Which European countries would you recommend for studying international law if you only speak English? Is it possible to complete a degree in international law in Europe without knowing another language?
Any advice or personal experiences would be greatly appreciated. Thank you! :D
r/internationallaw • u/WeirdTheory5675 • 27d ago
Discussion Is there any practical legal Safeguards against USA obstructing International Organization Functions ?
USA routinely threatened and done a lot of things. Such as threatening withholding assessed contributions from UN , sanctioning ICC via visa restrictions , freezing assets ,restricting transactions , restricting services , creating risk for financial intermediaries.
I'm worried that America could get more radical like blockading permanent missions or removing the seat of the UN from the headquarters itself or worse given they already obstruct lawful operations.
Is there any actual practical or legal ways America could be challenged ?
Edit; https://www.un.org/unispal/document/auto-insert-185762/?
Seems like they already did this to an extent loosely
r/internationallaw • u/Calvinball90 • 29d ago
Op-Ed War Crimes Accountability in Finland's Prosecution of Russian Mercenary
r/internationallaw • u/WeirdTheory5675 • 29d ago
Discussion Are the purposes of the UN binding on member states themselves ?
The purposes are something that are of the organization itself and article 2 states
> The Organization and its Members, in pursuit of the Purposes stated in Article 1, shall act in accordance with the following Principles.
Which seems to imply that members are only required to act in accordance with article 2(except the CIL and peremptory norms codified) if they are pursuing those purposes.
The other obligations under article 104 and 105 likewise seem to only apply when member states decide to actually enable physical presence in the first instance. Is the security council decisions and the open ended article 56 the only functional obligations that states have under the charter ? And the requirement of registering their international agreements with the secretariat under article 105 ?
Edit; also just because vague or unclear provisions of the m charter is interpreted and applied a certain way , does that automatically means it's presumed to be legal ?
r/internationallaw • u/Sassybilli • Oct 18 '26
Discussion Careers in International Child Law
I have 4 years of experience Children's rights as a Researcher. I am planning to now pursue an LLM in the same domain from Leiden University but I am unsure about career prospects. Is such a niche masters helpful in someway to finds international jobs in the field or should I rather go for a International Human Rights Law focus LLM from Geneva or SOAS to broaden my prospects?
Thanks in advance :)