r/Libraries • u/Snoo-21321 • 4h ago
Staffing/Employment Issues Title: New Academic Librarian Being Manipulated Into Paying for a Staff Holiday Party – Is This Normal in Academic Libraries?
I'm in my mid-twenties and graduated with my MLS in May of this year. I started my first full-time professional position as a Librarian in July, working in a fairly large academic library. Although I'm considered a relatively new librarian, I am not new to working in libraries. Throughout both my undergraduate and graduate studies, I worked in academic libraries as a Student Assistant and Library Assistant, so I have several years of experience in the library environment.
Our library employs at least 30 Student Assistants across various departments. I am an entry-level librarian, I do not supervise anyone, and I have no administrative responsibilities or authority over the Student Assistant program.
A few days ago, I was pulled aside by one of the senior librarians and informed that, because I was the newest full-time employee, I was expected to organize and host a holiday party for all of the Student Assistants.
There were several things about this conversation that immediately struck me as inappropriate.
First, I was explicitly told that the library would NOT be funding the event. Instead, I was expected to organize the entire party as a personal courtesy to the Student Assistants and pay for everything out of my own pocket. I was also instructed not to discuss the matter with my supervisors or anyone else in administration. Apparently, I was simply supposed to accept the responsibility, plan the event, pay for it myself, and send out the invitations.
Second, I was told that this senior librarian had already started telling the Student Assistants that a holiday party was being planned. I was essentially informed that if I refused to organize it, I would be disappointing all of these students. To make matters even more uncomfortable, this person suggested that my upcoming performance evaluation might not go as well as expected if I didn't follow through.
Let me emphasize that this person is NOT my supervisor, has no supervisory authority over me, and has absolutely no authority to assign me personal financial responsibilities.
I found the entire conversation incredibly manipulative. I am a new professional, I want to establish a good reputation, and I certainly don't want to create unnecessary conflict in my first year. However, being told to spend my own money on an event that I was never asked to organize, while simultaneously being instructed to keep it a secret from my supervisors, seemed like a massive red flag.
I decided to go directly to my actual supervisor and explain exactly what had happened.
As it turns out, there was considerably more history behind this situation than I initially realized. The senior librarian had misrepresented the circumstances. Apparently, the former Dean traditionally organized and personally funded a holiday party for the Student Assistants. The current Dean discontinued that practice, and this decision has been a source of ongoing frustration for some employees.
Rather than accepting that the tradition had ended, this particular librarian apparently decided to put the responsibility on the newest full-time employee and use guilt, pressure, and implied consequences to make it happen.
I was also informed that this individual has a history of attempting to manipulate newer employees in similar ways.
Unfortunately, because the initial conversation took place privately and was essentially a he-said/she-said situation, there wasn't much my supervisor could formally do about the interaction itself.
However, I wasn't comfortable simply letting the situation go.
I sent a very direct and professionally worded email to the librarian who approached me. I included that librarian's supervisor, my own supervisor, and the Dean on the correspondence. I made it very clear that I had never agreed to organize or personally finance this event, that I was not comfortable being pressured into doing so, and that I would not be taking responsibility for planning or paying for a holiday party that was neither an assigned job responsibility nor an approved library activity.
I also wanted administration to be aware of what had happened, particularly the instruction not to discuss the matter with my supervisors and the suggestion that my performance evaluation could be affected by my decision.
Now, apparently, I have managed to upset quite a few people.
Some are angry that I brought the issue to administration, while others seem upset that I reopened what has apparently been a longstanding and rather sensitive issue surrounding the former Dean's holiday parties.
But honestly, I don't see how any of that is my responsibility.
I am happy to contribute to a positive workplace environment. I enjoy working with our Student Assistants, and if the library wanted to organize a holiday gathering, I would have been perfectly willing to help coordinate something within my professional responsibilities and an approved budget.
What I am NOT willing to do is spend my personal money to compensate for an administrative decision, accept responsibilities that were never assigned to me, or allow someone to use my status as a new employee to intimidate me into doing something I am uncomfortable with.
So, I have a few questions for other academic librarians and library professionals:
- Have any of you experienced this kind of manipulation, particularly from senior colleagues who seem to view newer employees as easy targets?
- Is there an expectation in some academic libraries that the newest full-time employee should take on responsibilities or expenses simply because they are the newest person?
- How have you handled workplace guilt-tripping, intimidation, or attempts to make you feel responsible for maintaining traditions that administration has discontinued?
- Would you have handled this differently, or do you think I was justified in bringing the matter directly to my supervisor and the Dean?
I understand that being new means learning workplace culture, building relationships, and occasionally taking on responsibilities outside your immediate comfort zone. I'm certainly not opposed to helping out or being a team player.
But there is a difference between being a team player and being manipulated into spending your own money because someone more senior thinks they can get away with it.
I'm particularly interested in hearing from other academic librarians who have navigated difficult workplace politics, especially early in their careers. I would appreciate hearing how you established professional boundaries without becoming labeled as the difficult new employee.