r/luddite • • 4h ago

Technology erases humans' satisfaction (and more broadly purpose, doesn't it?)

3 Upvotes

Work is just cope because everything can be done by a machine. People's skills don't matter. This being accompanied by late capitalism makes everything absolutely nonsensical.

I honestly can't think of any fields that wouldn't be swallowed by technology. It was bad enough with computers and programs but it was too mechanical and lacked any coherent ability to do anything outside of the algorithm. Now no one even knows anymore what the algorithm is (and if there's any).

This makes any job absolutely unbearable Sisyphus work. If it some form of a utopia where everyone... but that's pointless to even to rattle about it.

So can there really be any fields that won't ve touched by this? We see even the maths has fallen. No one expected it to be so drastic and fast.


r/luddite • • 36m ago

I read for about a year to come to an understanding of genAI. This is the result. Let's not surrender what makes us human to commodification or capital.

Thumbnail
zenodo.org
1 Upvotes

r/luddite • • 17h ago

Poison In A Sippy Cup

2 Upvotes

We have built a society around eliminating effort.. In our pursuit of easier lives are we sacrificing the very skills, knowledge and independence that make us capable human beings?

We have become a society that is obsessed with making life easier.

Every inconvenience is now a problem to be eliminated. Every moment of effort becomes an opportunity for automation. Every task is something we can pay another person, machine or algorithm to do for us. We have built a culture around the idea that the less we have to do the better our lives become.

We call it progress. We call it innovation. We call it freedom.

When will we begin asking ourselves what all this convenience is costing us?

I no longer need to remember because my phone remembers for me. I no longer need to navigate because a voice tells me where to turn. I no longer need to learn how to cook because a meal can appear at my doorstep. I no longer need to wrestle with my thoughts because artificial intelligence can organize them articulate them and sometimes think on my behalf.

I have access to all the information humanity has accumulated, yet access does not guarantee understanding. I can have food delivered from every corner of my city yet many of us have never grown a tomato baked a loaf of bread or learned how to sustain ourselves without a supermarket.

We have mistaken convenience for advancement and comfort for freedom.

Perhaps the most dangerous part is that none of this feels dangerous.

I see poison rarely presenting itself as poison. Sometimes it comes in colors, sweet flavors and a convenient little cup with a lid. Sometimes it is offered to us as a gift something designed to make our lives better.

What if the very things making our lives easier are slowly making us less capable of living them?

What if we are raising generations who have never had to struggle to discover what they are capable of?

Perhaps the greatest danger of modern convenience isn’t that it does everything for us. Perhaps it is that eventually we forget how to do anything for ourselves.

The Outsourcing of the Human Mind

For thousands of years human survival depended on the ability to observe, remember, reason, adapt and solve problems. Our ancestors did not have the luxury of asking a device to remember where they left their tools calculate the amount of grain needed for winter or explain how to repair a broken roof. They had to know or they had to learn.

Knowledge was not something they could always access. It was something they needed to acquire retain and apply.

Today I live in a different environment. The average person can carry accessible information in their pocket than entire generations could have imagined. With an internet connection any question can be answered within seconds. With intelligence those answers can be summarized, interpreted, rewritten and delivered in whatever format I prefer.

This is an achievement. It is also a temptation.

There is a concept known as cognitive offloading. Researchers Evan Risko and Sam Gilbert examined this phenomenon in their 2016 review, Cognitive Offloading published in Trends in Cognitive Sciences. It describes how people use resources to reduce the mental effort required to complete a task. A reminder on a phone, a calculator or a digital calendar are all examples.

Cognitive offloading is not inherently harmful. In fact it can be useful. Human beings have always relied on tools to extend their abilities. Writing itself is a form of memory.

The concern is not that we use tools. The concern is that we become so accustomed to using them that we stop exercising the abilities we once had.

In a 2011 study published in Science psychologists Betsy Sparrow, Jenny Liu and Daniel Wegner investigated what became known as the ‘Google effect.’ Across four experiments they found that when participants expected information to remain accessible, on a computer they were less likely to remember the information itself and more likely to remember where they could find it.

In words people adapted their memory strategies to the availability of external information.

This does not mean the internet made participants un‑intelligent. It demonstrates that our minds adapt to the environments we create.

If we expect information to be there whenever we need it remembering the information might become less important to us than remembering where to find it.

Now consider what happens when this principle goes beyond remembering facts.

We ask search engines what to think about a subject. We ask algorithms what to watch what to read and what to buy. We ask intelligence to write our emails structure our arguments generate our ideas and solve our problems.

At what point does help become a substitution?

There is a difference between using a tool to strengthen your thinking and using a tool to avoid thinking altogether.

A calculator can help someone understand mathematics. It can also become a substitute for learning basic arithmetic. AI can help someone organize an argument. It can also become a substitute for developing the ability to form one. The internet can introduce someone to a subject but it can also encourage the illusion that reading a few paragraphs is the same as understanding it.

We are beginning to live in a world where the answer’s often easier to find than the understanding needed to judge it.

That difference matters.

A person who knows how to find an answer is not necessarily a person who understands the answer. A person who can write an essay is not necessarily a person who can defend its arguments. A person who can repeat information is not necessarily a person who can spot when that information is wrong.

We are building powerful external minds while risking the neglect of our own minds.

When Learning Becomes Optional

There was a time when not knowing something gave a chance to learn it.

You wanted to know how something worked so you opened it up. You wanted to learn how to cook a meal so you tried. You wanted to know how to get so you looked at a map. You wanted to learn a subject so you read, asked questions and spent time with it.

Not knowing was the start of a process.

Now not knowing is often seen as a problem that should be fixed right away.

A question comes to someones mind and within seconds a search engine gives an answer. There is little time spent wondering, thinking or trying to solve the problem on ones own.

The internet has made knowledge easy to find. Easy access and real learning are not the same.

Think about the difference between reading a short summary of a historical event and studying the facts that caused it. Think about the difference between watching a ten‑minute video that explains a science idea and spending an afternoon learning how that idea works. Think about the difference between asking AI to explain an argument and learning to spot the bad parts of that argument yourself.

The first choice in each example can be helpful. The problem starts when it is the choice.

We are getting used to eating conclusions without taking part in how they’re made.

This affects how our minds grow. Learning is not just moving information from one place to another. It needs focus, remembering, practice fixing mistakes and linking facts to what we already know.

A 2022 review in Nature Reviews Psychology by Shana Carpenter, Steven Pan and Andrew Butler looked at the science of learning especially spacing and retrieving. The review shows that actively remembering information and reviewing it again later can make learning stronger.

This is important because it shows that just seeing information is not enough.

Learning requires participation.

We must remember, think again practice and sometimes struggle. The process matters.

If we keep skipping the process we might become great at getting information but bad at keeping it and understanding it.

A society that can find everything but cannot understand it has not really become more educated. It has become better linked to information.

Those are two different achievements.

Artificial Intelligence: A Tool or a Replacement?

Artificial intelligence deserves focus because it marks a new step in moving human work to machines.

Earlier tools mainly helped us find information do math talk to others or automate physical work. Generative AI is now joining tasks that used to need thinking: writing, reasoning, summarizing, brainstorming, coding and making.

There is potential here. AI can make learning easier help people, with disabilities, aid science and let people break limits that once stopped them from sharing ideas.

It would be dishonest to say that every use of AI is bad.

Before we embrace every new application we must ask ourselves a question:

Are we using this technology to expand our abilities or are we using it to avoid developing them?

Picture a student who asks AI to explain a hard math idea then works through the problems on their own. That student is using a tool to help learning.

Now picture a student who asks AI to finish every assignment explain every reading and write every answer. The finished work may look good. How much of the real skill has been built?

The same difference also applies to adults.

There is a difference between asking AI to critique an argument you wrote and asking AI to create an argument you never thought of. There is a difference between using AI to spot gaps in your knowledge and using AI so that you never need to face those gaps.

The danger is not that AI will make people less smart. The danger is that people may grow too comfortable showing the look of competence while not building competence.

We must be careful not to mix output with ability.

A person can write an essay without having the ability to write one. A person can make a business plan without understanding the market. A person can get an explanation without knowing how to check if it is true.

This creates a risk: the more impressive our tools become the easier it may be to hide how little we really understand.

We should not judge progress only by what a person can make with help. We should also look at what a person can understand, question, create and do without help.

Technology should be a ladder, not a wheelchair for a capable mind.

The Disappearing Art of Feeding Ourselves

the most clear example of modern dependence is something as ordinary as eating.

For most of history getting food needed knowledge, work and participation in the natural world. Food had to be grown, gathered, hunted, raised, made, kept or traded.

The distance between the land and the dinner table was much shorter.

Today that distance has become almost invisible.

We walk into a grocery store. See shelves full of products from all over the world. We open a delivery app. Pick from hundreds of meals. We can get groceries delivered without going into a store we can get meals delivered without going into a kitchen and we can get restaurant food delivered without leaving the couch.

There is nothing with these conveniences. They can be essential for people with disabilities work schedules, limited transport, caregiving duties or other situations that make cooking hard.

We must ask ourselves what happens when convenience becomes the only way we relate to food.

How many people know how to grow a vegetable from seed? How many understand the difference between soil that can support a plant and soil that cannot? How many know when to plant, how to water or how to spot a plant disease?

How many can bake a loaf of bread without buying a premade mix? How many know what yeast really does? How many can make a meal without following a video or heating something that comes in a plastic container?

How many could feed themselves if the systems they rely on became unavailable?

These are not questions.

Cooking is more than mixing ingredients. It involves measuring, chemistry, timing, watching, problem solving and managing resources. Baking bread needs an understanding of fermentation, temperature, texture and time. Gardening needs patience, awareness of the environment, planning and an understanding of processes.

These are forms of intelligence.

We have somehow reached a point where buying almost anything is seen as valuable than knowing how to make something ourselves.

We have become consumers of the things that once required participation in their making.

This is not just about nostalgia for a time when people made everything by hand. Modern food production has saved lives cut down some kinds of scarcity and made nutrition more available in places. Farming and food distribution are great achievements.

The concern is not that we no longer need every person to farm.

The concern is that we have let the knowledge of how to sustain ourselves become more distant, from life.

I think you do not need to become a farmer to appreciate food production.. Understanding where food comes from how food is prepared and what it takes to grow food gives you a relationship with the world that buying food alone cannot give.

A garden teaches something about food that a grocery store cannot.

A loaf of bread teaches something about food that a delivery application cannot.

The ability to prepare a meal from basic food ingredients gives you a kind of independence that no restaurant can sell.

The Kitchen as a Forgotten Classroom

I remember when the kitchen was once one of the important places in a household. It was where practical food knowledge was passed between generations.

Children watched parents prepare meals. They learned to measure food ingredients handle knives recognize when food was cooked and understand that food required time.

Recipes were shared, modified and remembered. Mistakes were made. Meals were ruined. Lessons were learned.

The kitchen was a classroom without a blackboard.

I notice that many people can navigate a menu of restaurants but struggle to prepare a basic meal from scratch. We can identify our delivery restaurants but may not recognize the ingredients required to reproduce our favorite dishes.

This is not an accusation against people who order food.. Is it a suggestion that everyone should spend hours cooking every evening.

It is an observation about what happens when a basic food skill becomes optional enough that people stop learning it.

A 2019 randomized controlled trial led by National Institutes of Health researcher Kevin Hall and published in Cell Metabolism examined the effects of -processed and unprocessed diets.

Twenty adults participated in a controlled inpatient study. Participants consumed 508 more calories per day during the two-week ultra-processed diet period than during the unprocessed diet period despite the diets being designed to be similar in several nutritional characteristics.

This was a small short-term study and it does not establish that every processed food is harmful or that home cooking automatically produces a healthy diet. It does however provide evidence that the modern food environment can influence eating behavior in ways people may not recognize.

Our relationship with food is shaped by more than hunger. It is shaped by availability, convenience, portion sizes, preparation and the environments in which we eat.

When the easiest food option repeatedly becomes the default option our habits can change accordingly.

The question is whether we are still making decisions about what sustains us or simply selecting whatever requires the least effort.

Food is one of the fundamental requirements of human life. It is strange that we have become so disconnected from the knowledge involved in producing and preparing food.

The Culture of Instant Gratification

Modern society has created an environment in which immediate satisfaction’s increasingly available.

Hungry? Order something.

Bored? Open an application.

Curious? Search the internet.

Lonely? Scroll through media.

Need entertainment? There is a supply.

Need something ? Have it delivered.

We have built systems that allow us to satisfy a number of desires without enduring much waiting.

I have noticed that convenience can improve quality of life. It can give people time with family reduce unnecessary labor and make difficult tasks manageable. Again this is not necessarily a thing.

The constant availability of immediate satisfaction raises an important question about our relationship with patience.

Many worthwhile things require delayed gratification.

Growing food requires waiting for seasons to change. Learning an instrument requires practice. Developing strength requires consistent effort. Becoming knowledgeable requires reading, questioning and revisiting ideas.

You cannot download the experience of learning to play piano. You cannot order the satisfaction of harvesting a vegetable you planted months earlier. You cannot purchase the understanding that comes from attempting to solve a problem.

The finished product is available immediately in areas of modern life but the development of the person who could have produced it still takes time.

We are increasingly surrounded by systems designed to eliminate waiting while many of the meaningful human accomplishments depend on our ability to tolerate it.

This does not mean that convenience destroys patience. It means that an environment built around gratification can make patience less necessary in ordinary routines.

And what becomes of a culture when fewer people are accustomed to doing things that require effort?

The Difference Between Knowing and Doing

We often associate intelligence, with academic achievement, professional status or the ability to communicate sophisticated ideas.

Intelligence has many sides.

There is the ability to understand a theory and there is the ability to see why a plant is dying. There is the ability to solve an equation and there is the ability to find out how much material is needed to repair a roof.

There is knowledge and there is practical knowledge.

Both matter.

A person who can explain the agricultural supply chain but cannot spot a vegetable growing in the ground has a kind of knowledge than someone who has spent years cultivating food.

Neither is automatically better. But a society that does not value competence risks becoming more and more dependent on specialists and services for ordinary tasks.

Consider the basic abilities that once formed part of everyday household knowledge:

- Cooking meals from basic ingredients.

- Baking bread.

- Growing vegetables and herbs.

- Preserving food.

- Sewing and repairing clothing.

- Performing basic household maintenance.

- Reading a map.

- Calculating measurements.

- Managing money without relying on automated tools.

- Identifying. Evaluating sources.

These skills are not all equally necessary for every individual. Specialization is a part of society and there are good reasons we no longer expect every household to produce everything it needs.

There is a difference between specialization and helplessness.

Specialization means relying on people because they have expertise that you do not. Helplessness means being unable to manage the most basic problems when that expertise or service is not available.

We should not need to do everything ourselves. We should however remain able to do some things ourselves.

The ability to solve a problem without immediately outsourcing it is a form of independence that is worth preserving.

Are We Actually Becoming Less Capable?

This is where the argument requires care.

It would be tempting to claim that the internet, food delivery, artificial intelligence and modern conveniences are all causing a collapse in intelligence.

That conclusion goes beyond what current research can establish.

Intelligence is complex. Intelligence cannot be reduced to memory, attention, practical skills or the ability to perform tasks without technology. Modern technology can also improve education give access to information, support people with disabilities and expand opportunities for learning.

However we do have evidence that deserves attention.

The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development published its Survey of Adult Skills 2023 findings in 2024. The assessment examined literacy, numeracy and adaptive problem-solving among adults aged 16 to 65 across participating countries and economies.

Across the participating OECD countries and economies 26% of adults scored at the two lowest levels of literacy proficiency 25% in numeracy and 29% in adaptive problem-solving.

These figures should not be interpreted as evidence that technology has made adults less intelligent. They are measures of existing skill proficiency, not proof of a decline caused by convenience.

They do challenge the assumption that living in an information-rich society automatically produces a highly capable population.

We can have access to information and still have substantial weaknesses in fundamental skills.

We can have technology and still struggle with basic literacy, numeracy and problem-solving.

The question is not whether modern people are inherently less intelligent than generations. The question is whether our systems are consistently developing the abilities required to use the opportunities to us.

A society should not measure its health by the sophistication of its devices.

It should also consider the sophistication of the people using them.

The Attention Economy: When Silence Becomes Uncomfortable

There is another part of convenience that deserves consideration: our relationship with attention.

We live in an environment of interruption.

Notifications, advertisements, short videos, messages, breaking news, recommendations and endless scrolling compete for our attention, throughout the day.

We rarely have to seek stimulation. It comes looking for us.

This creates an environment in which quiet moments are increasingly filled with something.

Waiting in line becomes an opportunity to check a phone. Sitting alone becomes an opportunity to scroll. Eating becomes an opportunity to watch something. A few seconds of boredom can feel like something that needs to be corrected.

Attention is not an unlimited resource.

Reading a book studying an unfamiliar subject writing an argument or solving a complicated problem requires the ability to remain with something long enough to understand it.

The ability to concentrate is especially important because mental work often feels uncomfortable before it feels good.

There are times when a passage’s hard a problem seems impossible or an argument is not clear at first. These are the times when sustained attention is valuable.

If we keep abandoning tasks for easy distractions we may form habits that make continued mental work harder.

This does not mean that social media has always destroyed attention spans. Research about media and attention is complex and effects differ by media type by person and by activity.

The important point is that attention needs practice and protection.

A society that sees every moment as a chance for consumption should not be surprised when people find it harder and harder to sit with their own thoughts.

Convenience Is Not the Same as Freedom

We are often told that convenience gives us freedom.

Food delivery gives us freedom from cooking. Online shopping gives us freedom from stores. Artificial intelligence gives us freedom from some types of work. Automated services give us freedom from duties.

Freedom from a task is not always freedom in a wider sense.

There is a difference between having the ability to do something and having the choice to pay someone to do it.

A person who can cook but chooses to order food has a skill. Shows a preference.

A person who cannot cook and has no alternative relies on someone ’s work.

A person who can write alone but chooses to use AI still has an ability.

A person who has never learned to express their thoughts without AI may have a smaller range of independence.

The same difference applies to growing food fixing household items, managing money and solving problems.

We should be careful when we start describing the removal of duties as freedom.

Sometimes it is.

Sometimes it is simply a transfer of responsibility to another person, business or system.

And the essential the task the more important it is to think about what happens when that system fails.

What Happens When Convenience Disappears?

Imagine a disruption.

The internet becomes unavailable. Delivery services stop working. Grocery supply chains are broken. The electricity is unreliable. The systems that quietly support life become temporarily out of reach.

What happens next?

Who knows how to prepare food from ingredients? Who can grow something ? Who understands food storage? Who can fix household problems? Who can navigate without a map? Who can communicate organize and solve problems without automated help?

This is not a prediction of disaster. It is a thought experiment about dependence.

Modern society depends on expertise, basic facilities, transport, agriculture, communication systems and many forms of teamwork. No single person can reasonably rebuild all of these systems alone.

There is a difference between being part of an interconnected society and becoming totally unable to function outside its most convenient services.

Resilience is not the ability to do everything yourself.

It is the ability to adapt when circumstances change.

Practical knowledge helps that resilience. So does thought. So does the ability to learn something without immediately expecting someone else to give the answer.

We should want technology to make us more capable of navigating the world not able to survive in it.

The Value of Doing Things the Hard Way

the greatest irony of modern life is that we have become so focused on cutting effort that we risk losing experiences that give effort meaning.

There is something satisfying about preparing a meal from ingredients you chose yourself.

There is something about planting a seed caring for it watching it grow and eventually eating what it produces.

There is something about struggling through a hard book until the ideas finally make sense.

There is something empowering about fixing an object of immediately replacing it.

There is something, about creating something with your own hands.

These experiences connect us to the world. They teach us that things take time that outcomes need effort and that failure is often part of the process.

A garden does not care about your schedule. Bread does not rise because you are impatient. A skill does not develop because you wish it would.

The natural world works according to processes that cannot always be rushed.

Perhaps this is part of what we have lost: an appreciation for the fact that not everything should be immediate.

Not every task needs to be optimized. Not every moment needs to be productive. Not every inconvenience needs to be eliminated.

Sometimes the process is the point.

Reclaiming Our Capabilities Without Rejecting Progress

The answer is not to abandon technology.

It is not to reject intelligence stop ordering food or pretend that previous generations lived better lives in every respect.

Many modern conveniences have genuinely improved existence. Medical advancements, sanitation, refrigeration, transportation, communication and modern agriculture have prevented suffering and expanded opportunities on a scale.

We should be grateful for those achievements.

Gratitude should not prevent examination.

We can appreciate convenience while recognizing conveniences costs. We can use technology without allowing technology to replace our independence. We can enjoy prepared food without forgetting how to cook. We can use AI while continuing to develop the ability to think and write independently.

Perhaps we should begin by reclaiming some of the abilities we have allowed ourselves to neglect.

- Learn to bake bread.

- Grow a tomato plant.

- Cook a meal without a recipe video.

- Read a book without checking your phone.

- Attempt to solve a problem before searching for the answer.

- Write something without asking an algorithm to finish your thoughts.

- Learn how to repair something of immediately replacing it.

- Spend time doing something that requires patience.

These actions may appear insignificant. They represent something larger: a decision to remain an active participant in ones own life.

The goal is not self-sufficiency at all costs. It is capability.

We should be able to use tools because we choose to not because we have forgotten how to function without them.

The Poison in the Sippy Cup

Perhaps the dangerous thing about modern convenience is that convenience does not look like a threat.

Progress looks like progress.

Convenience looks like a commute, a faster meal, an easier assignment, an answer delivered in seconds and an entire world available through a screen.

Convenience looks like freedom from the responsibilities of being human.

There is a cost to every ability we stop practicing every skill we stop teaching and every responsibility we permanently outsource.

The cost may not be immediately visible. Convenience may not appear in a test score or a technological statistic. Convenience may show itself gradually in people who struggle to concentrate who cannot evaluate information independently who have never learned to prepare a meal, who cannot solve a problem without assistance or who mistake access to information for understanding.

We should not confuse the ability to purchase something with the ability to produce it. We should not confuse the ability to retrieve information with the ability to understand it.. We should not confuse the ability to generate an answer with the ability to reason.

There is nothing wrong with making life easier.

The problem begins when we make ourselves less capable in the process.

We have created a world where every human need can be met through a transaction, a subscription, an application or a machine.. We rarely stop to ask whether we are preserving the abilities that allow us to remain independent curious, resourceful and intellectually alive.

Perhaps we have become so preoccupied with making life convenient that we have forgotten what makes a person of living it.

I do not want to return to a time, without medicine, electricity, transportation or the extraordinary benefits of technological advancement. I want to live in a society where technology makes people more capable, not one where capability becomes unnecessary.

I want a generation that knows how to use intelligence but can still think without it. A generation that can order dinner but can also prepare it. A generation that has the internet at its fingertips but still possesses the patience to read, question, research and understand.

I want people who can grow something build something repair something create something and think something that did not come from an algorithm.

Because perhaps the real measure of progress is not how work we have managed to eliminate from human life.

Perhaps Progress is how human potential we have managed to cultivate.

If we are not careful we may find that we have swapped the abilities that made us human for the ease of never having to use them.

The poison was never advertised as poison.

The poison was packaged as a gift.

We handed the poison to ourselves smiling, without ever asking what was inside.

Poison in a sippy cup.

Sources

Carpenter, S. K., Pan, S. C., & Butler, A. C. (2022). The science of effective learning with spacing and retrieval practice. Nature Reviews Psychology, 1, 496–511. https://doi.org/10.1038/s44159-022-00089-1

Dunn, T. L., & Risko, E. F. (2016). Toward a metacognitive account of cognitive offloading. Cognitive Science, 40(5), 1080–1127. https://doi.org/10.1111/cogs.12273

Hall, K. D., Ayuketah, A., Brychta, R., Cai, H., Cassimatis, T., Chen, K. Y., Chung, S. T., Costa, E., Courville, A., Darcey, V., Fletcher, L. A., Forde, C. G., Gharib, A. M., Guo, J., Howard, R., Joseph, P. V., McGehee, S., Ouwerkerk, R., Raisinger, K., . . . Zhou, M. (2019). Ultra-processed diets cause excess calorie intake and weight gain: An inpatient randomized controlled trial of ad libitum food intake. Cell Metabolism, 30(1), 67–77.e3. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cmet.2019.05.008

Hume, C., Grieger, J. A., Kalamkarian, A., D’Onise, K., & Smithers, L. G. (2022). Community gardens and their effects on diet, health, psychosocial and community outcomes: A systematic review. BMC Public Health, 22, Article 1247. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-022-13591-1

McDermott, K. B. (2021). Practicing retrieval facilitates learning. Annual Review of Psychology, 72, 609–633. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-psych-010419-051019

OECD. (2024). Do adults have the skills they need to thrive in a changing world? Survey of Adult Skills 2023. OECD Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1787/b263dc5d-en

Panțiru, I., Ronaldson, A., Sima, N., Dregan, A., & Sima, R. (2024). The impact of gardening on well-being, mental health, and quality of life: An umbrella review and meta-analysis. Systematic Reviews, 13, Article 45. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13643-024-02457-9

Risko, E. F., & Gilbert, S. J. (2016). Cognitive offloading. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 20(9), 676–688. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tics.2016.07.002

Skitka, L. J., Mosier, K. L., & Burdick, M. (1999). Does automation bias decision-making? International Journal of Human-Computer Studies, 51(5), 991–1006. https://doi.org/10.1006/ijhc.1999.0252

Sparrow, B., Liu, J., & Wegner, D. M. (2011). Google effects on memory: Cognitive consequences of having information at our fingertips. Science, 333(6043), 776–778. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1207745

World Health Organization. (2024, June 26). Physical activity. https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/physical-activity


r/luddite • • 1d ago

What ways work for you??!

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/luddite • • 1d ago

Hey everyone, I put together this infographic exploring how modern convenience and surface-level tech consumption are slowly killing deep curiosity. We have the most powerful tools in human history (like advanced AI), yet we often use them just to scroll mindlessly, treating complex infrastructure l

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/luddite • • 2d ago

Tesla and Amazon are building the workforce a 1921 play imagined: One that never asks for a wage

Thumbnail
fortune.com
9 Upvotes

Workers of the world unite!!


r/luddite • • 3d ago

We need wisdom to protect ourselves from our own technology.

1 Upvotes

r/luddite • • 3d ago

What the Luddite were really about

Thumbnail reddit.com
7 Upvotes

r/luddite • • 4d ago

If AI is replacing jobs, why not reduce work hours keeping the same salary to ensure balance in civil society without causing economic collapse

Thumbnail reddit.com
12 Upvotes

r/luddite • • 6d ago

The Cal Newport Show | Why is Google Holding Schools Hostage?

Thumbnail
podcasts.apple.com
26 Upvotes

Newport might not be a Luddite, but he’s definitely Luddite adjacent. It’s kind of wild that Google is doing this, but I’m not surprised. These mega corps want to make money, they don’t give a shit about anything else. Least of all the quality of life or education of children


r/luddite • • 6d ago

Luddite art in Sydney Australia

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/luddite • • 7d ago

Durham, NC

3 Upvotes

Hi! Does anyone have a contact for the Durham, NC Luddite society?


r/luddite • • 9d ago

Industrial revolution is the new tree of knowledge!

4 Upvotes

Eating from the tree of knowledge was the first sin that drove man out of Paradise. But it was not merely an act of disobedience; it was the moment when consciousness was born, and an irreversible departure from the innocence of ignorance into the burden of knowledge.

Since then, man has carried this contradiction, the knowledge that liberates him from primal fear is the very same knowledge that opens new doors to anxiety before him.

Then came the Industrial Revolution as the great fruit of this new eating from the tree. Man understood the laws of nature, tried to subjugate them, built the machine, and changed the face of the earth. But that proved disastrous for his peace of mind.

In the past, man was ignorant of many diseases. Death came suddenly or mysteriously, but he did not live with the terror of waiting. Today, he knows that cancer exists, and that it may strike him or those he loves, without him always having the ability to prevent it.

This knowledge did not eliminate the danger; rather, it turned it into an anxiety that dwells in the mind.

Ancient man was less knowledgeable, but he was also less able to imagine evil before it happened.

Modern man, however, has been given by knowledge an eye that sees distant danger, so he lives with it before it occurs or imagines that it may occur.

Ted Kaczynski, in his analysis of industrial society, spoke about what he called the power process. He believed that man needs a real struggle for survival, and a sense that he controls his life and his surroundings, in order to feel his own worth.

But industrial society, which was born from the womb of scientific knowledge, made human life much easier, yet at the same time deprived man of much of this struggle.

Man came to live within a huge system whose details he does not fully understand, possessing only a small share of decision-making.

And all of this is one thing and the calamity called artificial intelligence is another thing altogether !

Then came the theory of evolution to strike at another foundation of meaning. The problem was not evolution as a scientific idea alone, but its impact on what man believed about himself and his place in the universe.

Religions had granted him a central position, telling him that he was created for a purpose, and that his life was part of a greater wisdom.

But the theory of evolution demolished this comforting image.

It made man a link in a long chain of changes and not the center of the universe, nor the being specially created to be master over what surrounds him.

What do y'all think about this ?


r/luddite • • 10d ago

Mega Thread of Digitally Minimalist (AI) to Work For?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/luddite • • 11d ago

Standing in the way of slop bowls: the woman blocking food delivery robots

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
34 Upvotes

r/luddite • • 13d ago

Groups that say they merely want to "pause" or "regulate" Gen AI are astroturfing

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/luddite • • 13d ago

No, we don't need "AI" for curing cancer. "AI" is actually making cancer worse!

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/luddite • • 14d ago

Sick of charismatic celebrity tech ceos being worshipped.

Thumbnail reddit.com
23 Upvotes

r/luddite • • 17d ago

"AI" is NOT "here to stay"...

Post image
59 Upvotes

r/luddite • • 17d ago

I don't care about the supposed scientific progress AI can make if it brings more misery in the long run.

111 Upvotes

Most of the arguments in favor of AI as a technology are related to the potential this technology has for humanity, whatever that same potential is supposed to be.

In reality most of the population won't care about this suppose findings. It's less on the fact that they can't understand them, but more so on the fact that they won't be able to experience those alleged advancements. AI just found the cure of cancer, great, but what about all the people that developed health problems during the time they were unemployed and weren't able to find any some sort of treatment because they are not able to afford one, because of the state they are? Unemployment can be hazardous for our own health on itself and that's the case for most of us who are Gen-Z. Also, there won't be actual people who will get recognized by the discovery because, well, no one actually participated on it.

The bottleneck of how these benefits are shared is not related to the speed in which these discoveries are made. It has always been related to politics, and humans themselves. Somehow these people (I mean the people who are developing these machines) believe if they invent god inside a bottle, suddenly all the problems of humanity will be solved. We already knew how to solve climate change but due to greed and politics we didn't comply to the goal. We even already know the actual amount of money to solve world hunger, but due to politics and greed this has not being made. Societal change is done when everyone, and I mean, everyone, joins together to reach a common goal. It's stupid how the resources are being wasted on a ""theory"" into a "miraculous technology" even though we already know how the solution has to be made.

Unfortunately, AI will never solve the inherent issues that we, as humanity, have no matter how fast the scientific progress is done. Ironically, those who hold the power to shape the development of technology are making the bet on leaving humans behind rather than integrating them into the equation. You can't solve societies' problems if all the systems that we have created, as a society, rely on humans, from the conception of an idea until the final product of it.


r/luddite • • 19d ago Bravo

We have a choice. We don't have to use Google, Meta, Apple, etc...

168 Upvotes

Yesterday I saw a Firefox browser ad which led to me think that I've completely forgotten about the existence of great alternatives on the market.

I think that the main reason those companies monopolised their power to such a great extent is because of our ignorance.

There is an increased awareness right now about using different companies' products and services, particularly because of their negative influence on the society, mental health, privacy etc. But if you think about it, there are so many alternatives ! For every product that you use

The monopolies and the system shouldn't control us. If tomorrow we collectively decide that we've had enough of it and just decide not to go to work, the system would collapse. We control the monopolies more than we think, but because of our ignorance it seems like the control is the other way around.

The market gives us a great capacity for freedom and alternatives. We can decide what we use, how and when. And if we don't like that someone is selling our data we can switch to something else.

Is an apple logo on your phone really that hard to substitute, for example? Or an app you hate but still use daily because its convenient? And even if you can't find an alternative for a product or service you use, it can probably be built in a matter of weeks now with a small team. The startup era might not be over, we need healthy alternatives more than ever.


r/luddite • • 28d ago

Has anyone succeeded in ditching laptops AND smartphones from their home?

36 Upvotes

I've long ago dumbed down my smartphone and only use it as a phone for calls and texts. That's the easy part. But I still have a laptop that often consumes a huge chunk of my free time, and it's never time I feel good about having spent. I always feel worse after several hours on the laptop. News, porn, unnecessary research. I feel much better on the days I stay offline. I'd like to cancel my home Internet, but my wife won't let me.

I'd like to ditch the laptop and use the library once a week to check email and pay bills. I want all the devices out of my life.

Has anyone succeeded in removing all Internet-connected screen-based devices from their lives? What's that like and how did you succeed in doing it? (Maybe you have and will never see this post, congratulations!)


r/luddite • • Oct 17 '26

What if we shut down the internet in 6 months?

Thumbnail
collapse2050.com
15 Upvotes

Just thinking out loud here. I'm a bit freaked out at this thought.

It's like my grandma going to bed with her eyebrows penciled on bc she doesn't want my grandpa to see her without eyebrows, ever. She's 81. She shaved them off as a teen and they never grew back very well.

If the Internet shuts down, guess what, grandma decided to clean the eyebrow pencil off before bed. Shits about to get real for grandpa tomorrow mornin'.