r/PPC • u/No_Ad_7529 • 2h ago
Platform In-house marketer for a window/roofing company. I get 10% of revenue minus ad spend and my salary. Here’s my whole funnel. How do I get cheaper leads and convert more of them?
I'm the in-house digital marketer for a home improvement company (mostly window replacement, some roofing) in a big Southwest metro. It's just me: media buying, creative, landing pages, tracking. I also run part of the contact center that calls our leads.
**My deal**
- $8,200/month ad budget (mostly Meta)
- About $3K/month salary
- Bonus = 10% of revenue from my channel, minus ad spend, minus my salary
- So I get no bonus until my channel does about $112K/month in sold revenue. A $250K month pays me about $13.8K. A bad month doesn't come out of my pay. First review is at 30 days.
Put another way, my channel has to hit about 13.7x ROAS before I see a dollar.
**What I've built since June**
- Quiz landing pages, one for each ad angle, with no nav and nowhere to click away. ZIP code first, then window age, number of windows, problems, and timeline
- A lead hub that sends every lead to the CRM the moment it comes in, tagged with angle and UTMs. I can follow each ad all the way: lead → appointment → estimate → sale
- Pixel + CAPI with dedup, plus a custom "in-area lead" event so Meta optimizes for leads inside our service area instead of junk
- Paused during election season because CPMs nearly doubled. Relaunched Nov 4
- Tested Microsoft display. It brought bot/junk clicks, so it's off
- I call leads myself, I do confirmation calls, and I built an AI voice agent for our inbound scheduling line
- Rehash and add-on sales get credited to the lead source that brought the customer in. One $11.8K windows lead later bought another $51.5K
**Ads and funnel running right now**
- Cold lead campaign: static images to the quiz pages. Angles: "stop overpaying," window age, age-gated (40+/55+), number of windows. Some are branded, and some are unbranded native/clickbait style going to a generic "home guide" page
- Offer ads: $500 off, and buy 4 windows get the 5th free. I turned off the financing ad so Meta wouldn't flag the account
- Engagement campaign: 3 Reels (warning signs your windows are failing, a black vs. white frame poll, curb appeal before/after), used to build a warm audience
- Retargeting: page/Reel engagers, site visitors, and people who saw the quiz but never started it
- Instant form test (price-first creative: "10 windows starting at $X")
- Geo is about 12 cities. Feeds-only placements on statics. All Advantage+ expansion off
**Funnel, June 1 – Nov 3 (from our CRM)**
| Stage | Count | Conversion | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Leads | 261 | — | $84 per lead |
| Appointments set | 53 | 20% of leads | ~$412 per set |
| Appointments that ran (estimate given) | 21 | 40% of set | ~$1,040 per ran |
| Sold | 13 | 62% of ran | ~$1,680 per sale |
Average first sale is about $19.9K. About $22K in ad spend has brought in about $310K sold (that includes one big rehash and a few roofing jobs we passed to a partner).
**What that means for my bonus**
At those rates, $8,200 gets about 98 leads → 20 set → 8 run → 5 sold → about $97K. Break-even is $112K, so I'm about 16% short. Any ONE of these would close the gap:
- CPL down to ~$72
- Lead → set from 20% to 23.5%
- Set → ran from 40% to 46%
- Close rate from 62% to 72%
- Average ticket up to ~$23K
If 60% of set appointments ran and we set 30% of leads, that's about $217K/month, or roughly a $10K bonus.
**Where it's stuck**
Only about 40% of set appointments actually run. Our in-home consultants are mostly booked by the door-to-door team, so internet appointments get bumped or brushed off. Add normal cancellations, no-shows, and the spouse not being home. I don't control the consultants' calendars.
**What I need advice on**
**Getting more leads for less:**
Is $84 CPL normal for window replacement on Meta in a major metro? What are you paying, and with what setup?
Which ad styles are actually winning for windows right now? Price-first statics, UGC/talking head, native/clickbait, before/after, offer stacks, something else?
Which funnel style gives you the best cost per *sold job* (not just cost per lead)? Quiz landing page, instant form (volume or higher-intent), click-to-call, calculator/instant quote, booking page, something else?
Has anyone sent CRM stages (appointment set/ran/sold) back to Meta and optimized for those instead of raw leads? Did lead quality or cost actually change?
Outside Meta, what's given you cheap or free window leads? Nextdoor, direct mail around job sites, yard signs, referral programs, Google LSA, YouTube, partnerships, anything unconventional?
**Converting more after the lead comes in:**
What's your speed-to-lead setup and follow-up cadence for quiz/form leads? We set 20% of leads right now. Auto-text, AI calling, double-dial, how many touches over how many days?
What got your internet appointments from ~40% running to 60%+? Same-day/next-day booking, confirmation sequence, rep intro texts/videos, both decision-makers locked in, anything else?
How do you stop internet appointments getting bumped when consultants are full from other channels?
Anything you do between booking and the appointment (videos, texts, a "what to expect" page, reviews, retargeting ads) that measurably raised show or close rates?
**On the deal:**
- Is this comp structure fair, and what would you ask for at the 30-day review?
**TL;DR:** I get 10% of revenue minus ad spend and salary. My funnel runs $84 CPL → 20% set → 40% ran → 62% close, about $19.9K a sale. That's ~$97K a month against a $112K break-even. How do I get cheaper leads, which ad and funnel styles are working for you, and how do I get more leads booked and more appointments to actually run?