r/Salsa • • Feb 12 '24

Discussion: suppressing valuable discussion vs allowing slander and doxxing

74 Upvotes

This is the sub mod, reaching out for discussion on the influx of posts (and reports) regarding the recent posts about predatory behavior in the salsa scene. TLDR: In this post, I will talk a little on the current sub policy on moderation, discuss a bit of context on what I am required to remove from the sub, and then add my thoughts on path forward. The last will be up for some discussion here, as we try to figure out what we as an online salsa community want to be.

  1. Current mod policy: my current mod policy is to let upvotes and downvotes speak. Things are often reported that don't really break sub rules or are bad text posts by people who are annoying to many of you in the sub. I do not remove these posts. One of the reasons I do not is that, despite being downvoted into the negatives, many of these posts tend to foster a healthy amount of discussion and engagement in the comments that are relevant to the dance scene. Another type of oft-reported post are the ones that link to a site or blog or whatever. The current rule is not to spam them and not to sell anything. The reason is that there are things that you may not be interested in that others may find useful. Again, upvotes/downvotes do a lot of heavy lifting. In the cases that the line crosses from occasional self promotion to spam, I have reached out to those individuals via DM to help clarify the policy, and if required, temp ban them. My point is, generally I do not like using mod powers to shape the subreddit to be what I want, but rather what the community wants to see.
  2. Which brings me to my next point - things I must remove. According to reddit content policy rule 3 (https://www.redditinc.com/policies/content-policy) I am supposed to remove anything that reveals personal information or uses such to instigate harassment. The kicker: public figures may be an exception to this rule. And a public figure is "a person who has achieved fame, prominence or notoriety within a society, whether through achievement, luck, action, or in some cases through no purposeful action of their own."

As you can see, the whole thing is kind of murky, especially as it applies to the recent discussions on predatory behavior. As someone who takes part in another sport that is rife with these types of scandals (against children on top of that), I have personally seen that shining light into these corners of darkness has a huge effect. So I am not keen to suppress legitimate discussions about this topic in our community.

On the other hand, reddit is full of examples of failed witch hunts and anonymous bullying. And some of the discussions, veiled or otherwise, have been naming individuals who may not even be on this site to defend themselves. I'm not keen to allow mudslinging (especially without proof) in a subreddit that is meant to celebrate dancing. I can imagine a scenario in which a instructor or school uses the current discussions to cast unfounded doubt or outright accusations against an innocent rival.

So how to walk the line between useful discussion and baseless name calling?

3. Thoughts on path forward - I propose that we continue to allow upvotes and downvotes dictate what goes on the page relative to these discussions, with a couple of tweaks. Naming regions or cities in comments/posts is okay. Talking about your experiences about unnamed people is okay. Opening discussions on predatory behavior, what that behavior looks like from start to finish, and providing support in the wake of aftermath--all okay. What is not okay is accusing people by name in the top level posts or in comments unless you have a link to an objective article/police report/etc. that backs up the claim. Instead, I propose that you leave an invite at the end of your post/comment for any one to DM you if they would like to discuss details/names in private. Those that would benefit from knowing will still have the opportunity to find out what/who they should be careful of, without violating any reddit policies. It would also allow the two users to have a more frank conversation, and at the end of the day it will be for the requester to determine the credibility of the poster.

Is this a perfect solution? Of course not. But I've been a mod here for 12 years and this is the first time something like this has happened, so I'm happy to entertain other suggestions.

Lastly - I consider the Yamulee fight video to be an example the original mod policy. The post is relevant to the salsa community, and it doesn't violate any rules in and of itself. Yes--the juxtaposition of the OP's 2 only posts implies bias/agenda, but the upvotes/downvotes very clearly pushed the post to negative votes and floated context on the altercation to the very first comment.

That said, I am happy to discuss how to treat videos like this in the future. There is a very real argument that it is not relevant to salsa music or dancing and that it should be removed.

Thanks for reading my novel.


r/Salsa • • 3h ago

Critique my dancing (leader)

11 Upvotes

Hello!

I'm a leader who's been dancing for a couple of years (cumulatively). This is one of the first times I've filmed my dancing so would be delighted to hear any and all feeback on what I should work on. My follower for this dance is excellent so you're essentially seeing my leading in the most flattering possible light.

What stands out to me:

  • I need to smile more 😄 (I usually think I am smiling when dancing but apparantly not)
  • My footwork is a little all over the place; I'm generally stepping with the right foot but my stride distance is very uneven and I often have trouble keeping the dance confined to an isolated region.
  • My 180s need a lot of work (0:48)
  • I got mixed up with my armwork at around 1:30

ETA: Thanks so much for the feeback guys, it's extremely helpful! 🎉


r/Salsa • • 8h ago

Benidorm Beach Festival feedback

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I'm thinking about attending Benidorm Beach Festival and would love some feedback from people who have been there!

  • What's the overall vibe like? Are non-Spanish speakers welcome and is it easy to meet people?
  • How is the sound quality and the venue itself?
  • How are the dance classes and sociales in terms of quality?
  • Finally, is there a good Cuban salsa crowd? do they mostly dance On1 or On2?

Thanks a lot for your feedback!


r/Salsa • • 3h ago

Listen now live on World Salsa Radio: Son Montuno set đŸ”„

1 Upvotes

r/Salsa • • 1d ago

How to go back to 1?

4 Upvotes

Hi!

As a very beginner I couldn't really distinguish 1 from 5. Now I often can, but this leads me to realize I'm dancing on5 sometimes instead of on1. I would like to go back to 1, what's the best way of doing this?

Sometimes I just stop and restart on the 1 but this feels wrong and the follower is confused. I try to start twice with my left so the first is on the 5 and the second on the 1 but the follower is also confused. Any tips?


r/Salsa • • 1d ago

Survey

1 Upvotes

Hi! I am looking for participants for my survey!

Topic: Dancing, stress, subjective vitality and confidence
Audience: hobby and competitive dancers
Duration: 10 minutes

https://forms.gle/ivFwc447hYLi4Xhi6


r/Salsa • • 2d ago

How to break the quick-quick-stop habit?

6 Upvotes

Nearly a year into my salsa journey I'm working to clean up some bad habits. I'm a lead dancing on1 linear salsa but I don't think it matters for this question. My teacher noted that I stop instead of just slowing down on the 4 and 8 counts. I'd love tips on how to break that habit. He told me to glide on those slow steps but it's not quite clicking in my body.


r/Salsa • • 2d ago

SINGAPORE: Which of the numerous salsa schools in Singapore would you recommend?

2 Upvotes

I'm moving to Singapore next week and would like to hit the ground running with salsa classes. I've been dancing for about 1-2 years (Cuban and a little bit of bachata), taking classes on and off, going to socials, and honestly mostly learning from friends. I saw that Singapore has many different studios (e.g., En Motion, Caliente, Salsa Cubana Singapore), and naturally I'll go for trial lessons to check them out myself, but I'm just wondering if people have preferences.

Since I'm really out to dance for fun, I'd love a place that has good vibes and a good mix of people to find some social footing in Singapore too.


r/Salsa • • 2d ago

Dealing with Lower back pain

2 Upvotes

Hello all. How do you guys deal with lower back pain after hours of dancing? I can do 4+ hours of dancing but I’d like to do more dancing with less pain and build the stamina multi day events like congresses and festivals.


r/Salsa • • 3d ago

How do you get to know people from socials?

13 Upvotes

Hi everyone! Been dancing for a few months now as a lead and am at the point where socials are enjoyable (which is great!)

Just wanted to ask though, do people actually get to know others at socials? I feel like I just talk to people I already know from class or other places, and with follows all I say really is would you like to dance and thank you that was great!

Is it socially acceptable to chat with follows after dancing or even during the dance (I feel like during is tough because the music is loud, I have earplugs in and I’m also locked in haha)


r/Salsa • • 3d ago

Struggling with parties

16 Upvotes

Hi, I'm a male lead dancing for half a year. I always get hyped with the promoted parties and everyone saying yeah you should go, even as a beginner, no judgement, just practice blabla.

Then I go, manage to talk with a couple people for 15min, maybe dance one or two decent dances and a few awkward ones.

Walk around trying to fit in, but everyone is in groups and I only know some people, but not friends with anyone. Wait out the Kizomba mix and other stuff I don't know, sit alone, get depressed, go home.

That's the short of it, don't wanna whine too much.


r/Salsa • • 3d ago

Moved up a class and found it really hard

5 Upvotes

Looking for some reassurance. I've been attending a couple of different schools.

I started my journey about 2 years ago, where I did a beginners class 1 per week for about 3 months. When I felt ready I moved to the next level up where I attended it weekly for about 10months sometimes twice weekly. I didn't feel I was progressing as much as I would like. I still found it difficult to get through a song and felt really anxious about even post class practices.

I found another school where they offered longer classes. This was really good for me. I was getting approximately 2 hours tuition with at least a solid hour of pure musicality and footwork. I was beginning to learn how to practice by myself properly. This was at the same level as the previous school. It was the highlight of my week.

I've had a busy autumn and not been as much as I would like but I've been doing solo practice where I can, often daily. I went to class last night and moved up, and I found it really hard. I was so stressed and anxious. Honestly my confidence is shattered but I know I cant keep sitting in the lower levels hoping to get better.

I've got a private coming up with the instructor.

Just feel like people learn it so much quicker than me. I get so anxious in class that I genuinely feel like after 30 minutes nothing else goes in.

I know people will say get yourself to some socials, but knowing how classes went I worry I will go and it will damage my confidence even more

:(

I know I can be so much better than I show.


r/Salsa • • 3d ago

What's the journey of leads improvising on the dance floor look like?

5 Upvotes

Hi! I'm a lead and I'm looking for wisdom. I'm one and a half months into my salsa learning journey, and before that, I've been dancing for 15 years (choreography, hip hop freestyle, battling). Salsa is my first social dance.

I know about 10 moves and I feel good about my execution of them (my instructors have also affirmed my technique and my lead). And individually, when it comes to class and when it comes to the dance floor, I do each of those moves just fine.

It's stitching the moves together into a seamless dance that I'm still learning to do. I'm able to combine multiple moves that are already familiar connections from what I've learned in class (for example, right turn → enchufla, or left turn → cross body lead). It's just that often, I'll finish a move, not have a move prepared, and I'll just do a basic or two before I do my next move.

I want to get to the point where I don't have to do basics in between moves. And of course, there's nothing wrong with a basic in between moves; I just want to create more seamless dances where moves nicely transition into each other without needing an "intermission" of sorts.

What does the journey of this look like?

Does it just naturally come with time? Is there a way to practice for this skill? Both? Something else I don't know?

I'd love to hear from you. Thank you so much for reading.


r/Salsa • • 3d ago

De la comunidad Cubamusica en Reddit: EH “El futuro de la salsa está en lo urbano, porque la salsa es urbana”

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Salsa • • 3d ago

Help for a follower friend of mine

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Salsa • • 4d ago

Please critique my leading and general dancing (lead on1 La style, 1.4 years) 🙏

49 Upvotes

r/Salsa • • 3d ago

Looking for a instructor named Eddie Valentineor Valentino?

3 Upvotes

He's in the TX, MN and east coast scene, him and his boyfriend are super talented latin dancers, not just in salsa, I did not have any social media to connect and awkwardly asked to trade # to get more of his and his husband's routine and studio, does anyone know his socials? I recently made instagram and can't find him or his studios lol


r/Salsa • • 3d ago

How do you recognise a dance teacher at a social?

0 Upvotes

title

It's a bit of a weird situation, but dancers often falsely take me for a dance teacher. Part of it might be a case of mistaken identity, although definitely not all of it. It probably isn't my general level either because it doesn't seem to happen to significantly better dancers than me.

I figured if I got a list of what might cause this, I could identify what I do wrong. I could start every new interaction with "btw, I'm not a dance teacher", but that sounds like a great way to make a bad first impression by being potentially presumptuous.

There are several reasons why the current situation is unpleasant for me. Feom time to time some random follower attaches herself to me at a social, and that leads to a mismatch in expectations. As far as I can tell, in her mond senpai noticed her and took her under his wings. Meanwhile I'm categorically not going to teach her lesson, and on most occasions I don't even give feedback aside from generic praise. Also, some others might take my opinions as objective facts, and I don't want to carry that responsibility. Lastly, I'm afraid that someone might think I'm pretending to be a dance teacher, which I'm not.

EDIT: I think I framed my question very deliberately (see: title) because I know and understand reddit's limitations, and I'm trying to get something useful out of it. I might have overexplained my reasons and my situations, but again: title. Please. I appreciate when anyone tries to help me, but still.


r/Salsa • • 3d ago

Girls, what do you prefer:

2 Upvotes

I see guys that can dance really well with the beat of salsa or just stay in time throughout, but I also see some guys that know all the mover but can’t seem to learn staying in time with the music and some times it looked awkward for the lady.

Girls, What do you prefer: someone who can keep in Time with the music and knows how to lead well but has limited moves or some one who has all the moves in the book but has no rhythm.


r/Salsa • • 4d ago

Where can I find some video lessons for footwork like this?

Thumbnail youtu.be
2 Upvotes

Hi, beginner 2 months in and want to add some footwork practice here and there, can anyone guide me to resources that will teach some moves from this video? It looks so cool


r/Salsa • • 4d ago

De la comunidad Cubamusica en Reddit: đŸŽ·ÂżSabĂ­as cĂłmo naciĂł la icĂłnica trompeta de “Amores Como el Nuestro”?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

đŸŽ·ÂżSabĂ­as cĂłmo naciĂł la icĂłnica trompeta de “Amores Como el Nuestro”? El maestro Omar Alfanno nos cuenta la historia detrĂĄs de una de las melodĂ­as mĂĄs reconocidas de la mĂșsica latina, que dĂ©cadas despuĂ©s conquistĂł al mundo tambiĂ©n con “Hips Don’t Lie” de Shakira.

Alfanno es uno de los compositores mĂĄs importantes de nuestra mĂșsica, responsable de clĂĄsicos como “A Puro Dolor”, “El Gran VarĂłn”, “Conciencia” y “Que Alguien Me Diga”, canciones que marcaron generaciones y siguen siendo favoritas.


r/Salsa • • 4d ago

Recs for Private Salsa Classes in NYC

2 Upvotes

Hi! I’ve on and off taken salsa/merengue/bachata classes with my boyfriend and want to get back into it. Mentioned this to my sister and she was also looking at taking classes with her boyfriend, and so now we are looking at private classes for 4 cause we think it would be a fun hobby to pick up together

Ideally, we’d love to find someone based in Manhattan who we could continue learning with over time. There are a few different backgrounds and interests in the group: my sister’s boyfriend grew up dancing salsa in Venezuela, and my boyfriend’s mom side of the family is Dominican, so we’d also love to learn merengue and he wants to lean into that culture.

All that to say, we’re coming in with a mix of experience and fairly casual goals, so we’re hoping to find an instructor who is flexible and can tailor lessons to the group and we can become comfortable with over time. Ideally, someone who is familiar with and has a genuine connection to the dance cultures of Latin America, rather than someone whose experience with Latin dances is primarily classroom-based.


r/Salsa • • 4d ago

Salsa scene in Granada, Spain?

4 Upvotes

Anyone have any experience there? Just wondering what the scene is liked. Asked Claude and it recommended some places that all appear to be permanently closed so just wondering if anyone has real first-hand experience there....just wondering if a salsa scene even exists there.


r/Salsa • • 4d ago

Salsa keeps giving me so mixed feelings

16 Upvotes

Hi,

I am learning salsa for about a year now as a leader and parties still give me enormously mixed feelings. I have also participated in festivals, again with mixed feelings. Sometimes I feel awesome and sometimes i feel shit.

I learn on2 and In the school we learn "combos". Usually every 2 or 3 lessons we take a video of those combos and based on that we have a "repertoire of moves". My first problem is that I am a "system based" mind. So i have to deconstruct the sequences to separate moves. Like "After a shoulder check I can do x,y,z at timing a,b,c". Schools don't teach that way. They create long sequences of moves but those sequences contain flicks and hand tosses and many other moves I would never do really in a social. And, also, in the school the followers know the combo so there are many times I don't actually "lead"

Now i struggle with the following things:

(1) Even in festivals (but in my school too), we are being told frequently that we should not treat parties as "practice" and generally we should not try moves we don't know well. Instead we are being told "we should have fun"
(2) At the same time my school has no practice nights and they tell us to go to their parties because salsa is a social dance after all, this is where we will "learn" . But if I don't practice the moves I will forget them. If i go to the party and try to practice them combos then it feels like I am not dancing as I am focused to "execute the patterns" (and of course they don't match the music). This creates what I call the robot effect (which I also see to many other leaders). We move like robots trying to execute sequences of combos.

So, problem #1: where am I supposed to learn then? Would learning just the combos and the social parties just "built up " over time and expand my skills to be able to dance as I like? Or is the method wrong?

Because to me it seems highly inefficient.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Problem #2: I like to lead the follower around, with blocks, changes of direction etc keeping the hands connected (either open hold, or crossed hold etc) I am not sure if you can understand what I mean. I dont like 12312321 hand flicks and tosses. I want simple leading. In festivals I do see leaders leading like that. Just "lead her around", block, redirect, add a few turns, a copa, a frame redirection etc. No complex hand tricks.

In on2 the combos we learn have many flicks and tosses. Is that a teaching style? Because I feel like hand flicks and tosses are just "hacks" to transpose from one hold to another. So If i learn to lead without flicks and tosses, then I can add those later.

When I told my school that i would want to learn a few combos without flicks and tosses (as private lesson) they told me that this wont help me as a leader.

But really, one year later, I feel like even if I knew the footwork perfectly I would still wouldnt be able to lead the way I want.

Maybe Salsa is not for me? maybe the style I am being taught is not for me?

Maybe the way I learn?

I see leaders leading "the way I like". But I dont know how they learned to lead like that.

I feel that what I want to learn, is learnable much much faster that trying to build it indirectly via long repertoire of footwork shines and combos.

So I don't know If i am in the wrong school, or my approach of thinking is not right.


r/Salsa • • 4d ago

Learning salsa in Central America

2 Upvotes

Hey there, salsa newbie here as in I've never danced salsa or in general at all.

I'm planning on going backpacking from Mexico through Guatemala, El Salvador, Honduras to Nicaragua.

Do you think it is wise to do a salsa course in Europe before I get there, or do you know any crash courses where I could spend maybe 5 days to get a decent beginning?

I don't expect to be any good afterwards, but I think it'd be nice to know the basics for my trip :)