I (24F) am in a friends-with-benefits situation with Kyle (22M). We've been consistently hooking up for about 7 months. We were never exclusive, but over the past few months, we've made the mistake of kind of catching feelings for each other. Or at least, feelings that go beyond what a typical FWB situation should probably involve.
We've both acknowledged that, despite having great sexual chemistry, we'd be pretty incompatible in an actual relationship. On top of that, if anyone in our friend group found out what was going on between us, it would make things incredibly awkward and complicate a lot of friendships. So we've agreed to keep things between us a secret, and we've both acknowledged that we're never going to date.
Despite knowing that, there's still some level of emotional attachment. He's genuinely very sweet and caring, and we do a lot of romantic things together just for fun. We both know it's not going anywhere, but I guess we've gotten comfortable in this weird little arrangement.
Here's where things get complicated.
I have a really close friend, who we'll call Stella (25F). We've known each other for years. She was also engaged to my cousin (25M). We were friends first, and they actually met through me. They've been going through a pretty rough breakup over the past few months. They both had their issues, but to be honest, Stella was generally the bigger problem in the relationship which is why we started having problems in our own friendship. One of the reasons they initially started having problems was because, after a particularly bad fight, she drunkenly flirted with Kyle. My cousin and Kyle are friends, and Kyle didn't entertain it, so their friendship remained unaffected.
About a month ago, Kyle told me that he'd slept with someone else. One thing we've always agreed on is being honest about our sex lives for safety reasons, so this wasn't an issue for me. We're not exclusive, and I wasn't upset that he'd been with someone else. I was just curious about who it was because it's the kind of thing we normally talk about.
What was weird was that he suddenly didn't want to tell me. That had never really been an issue before, so I jokingly pushed a little and asked why he was being so secretive. He eventually laughed and said, "Who's the worst person you can think of?" I jokingly responded with Stella, considering the history between her, my cousin, and Kyle.
He laughed, and said absolutely not, and I didn't push further because, at the end of the day, it really wasn't a big deal.
Fast forward to about a week ago. Stella and I had a pretty long conversation about everything that had happened between her and my cousin, and we've tentatively started rebuilding our friendship. Yesterday, she came over to my house for the first time in forever. We were having some girl time and catching up when she casually mentioned that she'd been sleeping with someone but didn't want to tell me who.
This immediately struck me as odd because Stella is probably the biggest talker I know. We have very few boundaries when it comes to what we share with each other, and we normally tell each other EVERYTHING.
So I started throwing out names out of curiosity. Eventually, I jokingly said Kyle.
And she folded.
She proceeded to tell me EVERYTHING. How they'd been hooking up at least twice a week for approximately three months, how she felt about him, how she was starting to develop feelings, how much she liked the way he treated her, and basically every little detail about their situation. She went into everything, and I just sat there listening.
She also mentioned that he knew he was sleeping with someone else but that she had no idea who.
I didn't tell her it was me.
And honestly, I feel like I'm losing my mind a little.
Not because Kyle slept with her. Again, we're not exclusive, and I have no grounds to be upset about him sleeping with someone else. It's more so the fact that he deliberately hid WHO it was from me, especially considering the history between them and my cousin and even my own issues with her. He made it seem like this was some random, one-time hookup when, in reality, he's apparently been going back and forth between the two of us for months.
But I think what bothers me most is hearing about their situation from her perspective. All the little things she described, the way he treats her, the affection, the romantic gestures. Things that I had privately convinced myself were special to our situation. For example, how he'll come up behind her and hold her while she's cooking.
It's like something just clicked in my head. I suddenly realized that all these things I thought were unique to whatever weird little connection we had are probably just things he does. And I don't know why, but hearing someone else describe those same experiences completely broke the illusion for me.
I think I've also been struggling with the realization that while I thought we had this unspoken understanding of what our arrangement was, he's been maintaining essentially the same dynamic with someone else, and I had no idea.
I don't necessarily think this is something worth ending our friendship over. We're not in a relationship, we never agreed to be exclusive, and technically neither of us has done anything wrong, apart from the lying. But I'm honestly just really sad about it. And given that he lied about that, it makes me question what else he might have lied about. It also kind of makes me angry because I was perfectly fine in a regular FWB situation but HE was the one who started blurring the lines, asking what-ifs about a serious relationship, trying to take me on dates instead of just hanging out as friends, saying "I love you" during. All while having a whole other situation going on. I think our friendship can be preserved but I dont think I'll ever be able to look at him that way again without feeling angry so our FWB situation has to end.
All I ever asked for was full honesty and clear communication so I could move accordingly and I would have been perfectly fine getting what we both wanted without all the extra stuff and I never would've allowed myself to feel anything if I had known what was going on outside of me. Though, given that it was Stella, of all people, I might have wanted to end what we had going on because we have been on the outs these past months and passing a man between us makes me feel gross.
It's weird because I know we were never serious, and I know I shouldn't have expected anything more from this arrangement. But now all of these memories that I previously looked back on fondly make me feel a little stupid and, honestly, kind of used.
I don't know. I think I just needed to get this off my chest because I can't talk to anyone in my actual life about it. I don't even know exactly what I'm looking for by posting this. I feel like I'm going a little crazy over something that, on paper, shouldn't even be a big deal. And i hate that something that was supposed to be fun and light-hearted got complicated and is making me feel like this.