r/MensRights • u/Celda • Jun 11 '12
Facts and statistics detailing male oppression / disadvantage.
(Re-posted so I could make edits in response to suggestions - feel free to suggest anything more to add or change).
In the Western world, men are oppressed equally, if not greater, compared to women. You may find that hard to believe, but the facts below speak for themselves.
1. Women are treated better in all aspects of the legal system. For instance, women receive lighter sentences and a higher chance of acquittal, simply for being women. A recent 2012 study found: "men receive 63% longer sentences on average than women do," and "[w]omen are…twice as likely to avoid incarceration if convicted." This gender gap is about six times as large as the racial disparity
2. Men are significantly more likely to be the victims of violent crime (of which rape is included) than women - page 16.
3. Despite domestic violence being equally committed by women, for the most part only male perpetrators are arrested:
5. It is legal to circumcise male babies against their will. In some places, laws have been passed which forbid any attempts to make male circumcision illegal. Meanwhile, female circumcision is completely illegal, even though some types of female circumcision are equivalent in harm to male circumcision, and other types (a symbolic prick to draw blood) are non-harmful.
6. Men comprise over 90% of workplace deaths page 8.
7. Men commit suicide at over triple the rate that women do.
8. The vast majority of prisoners are men.
9. Men are doing worse in all aspects of the educational system, from kindergarten to university.
11. Reproductive rights. Men have none. Simply read this story.
12. Parental rights. Men have virtually none. See below.
A boy who is the victim of statutory rape must pay child support to his rapist.
A man who is raped while unconscious must likewise pay child support.
A man who fathers a child and wishes to take custody may have his child adopted out against his will
13. The majority of homeless are men.
14. Despite men's need being arguably greater than women, government spending to help women is 10 to 100 times greater than that to help men. That figure is unrelated to healthcare spending.
In 2009/2010 it was $1,516,460 toward men and $57,562,373 toward women. In 2010/2011 it was $3,740,800 toward men and $48,331,443 toward women. In 2008/2009 the province dedicated $561,360 toward men's resources and $98,983,236 toward women's resources. (figures are for British Columbia, Canada, but representative of Western society).
16. On some airlines, men were banned from sitting next to kids on airplanes, simply because they were men. Why? Because men are pedophiles, obviously. This ban remains on some airlines, such as Air New Zealand.
19. Selective service. Enough said.
Pretty sure there's more, but I'm getting tired.
You will notice that I have not even touched "social discrimination" such as a group of women, on a popular talk show, cheering and laughing about a woman who cut off and destroyed a man's penis simply because he was divorcing her. Or gender stereotypes forcing men to work to their deaths, treating men as predators and pedophiles, that sort of thing.
That is because I recognize that though social discrimination is bad, ultimately you still have choice and agency. People can mock you for being a male who likes sewing, but ultimately you can still choose to do it or not. But that pales in comparison to actual oppression, where you genuinely have no choice about the matter.
Note the numerous examples of governmental and legal discrimination against men.
These are examples of real discrimination, where there is literally nothing you can do about it. Not "discrimination" where women do more housework.
Most of the discrimination against men described here government-enforced discrimination, which is involuntary, non-consensual, and inescapable.
For instance, if you are a male victim of domestic violence, you cannot simply choose to walk into a government funded men's shelter - they don't exist. You cannot choose to call the pro-male police who fairly punish female batterers; there is only one police, and they are likely to arrest you if you do make the call.
In contrast, a lot of discrimination that feminists discuss is what I call societal discrimination, which is voluntary, consensual, and less significant.
Feminists state, as evidence of discrimination, that women do more unpaid housework due to societal norms. Even if that is true, given that surveys are biased and do not include male work like car repair, exterior house repair, etc. that is not discrimination since women are choosing to do more housework. They are choosing to be involved with men who do less housework, and choosing to tolerate such a state. They make that choice freely, without coercion. That is why it is not discrimination.
Now, do you still think that male privilege is so great, female privilege is non-existent, and that women are oppressed and men are privileged? If so, you're in denial.
27
u/AnthonyZarat Jun 11 '12
I was forced to change seats because a minor was sitting next to me on Air France. This happened in May 2010.
Air France is NOT one of the airlines that admits to a discriminatory anti-male seating policy. Only British Airways, Qantas, and Air New Zealand admit to anti-male seating discrimination. However, many other airlines do the same thing, but do not admit it.
7
u/CandidIgloo Jun 12 '12
I think that to the uninformed, 7 and 8 don't really have the impact they should. Most people already know that men commit suicide much more often than women, but also believe the factoid that women attempt many times more, thus making it seem like women still have it worse in that department. If you can refute that factoid in this list with a link, I think it'd be stronger.
Similarly with 8, I'm sure some people will just think "yeah well, men commit more crimes!". Being able to show that it's much more than that would go a long way.
It's a pretty great list all in all, but imo is a little bit weakened by a lack of citing on those two.
9
u/MechPlasma Aug 17 '12
It might be a little late to point it out, but you forgot the death penalty - since capital punishment was re-introduced in the US 40 years ago, 99% of those executed in the US were men. Only 12 were women. The last three being in 2010, 2008, and 2005.
I can find some sources if you need them.
1
u/QuigleyQ Jun 27 '12
Does anyone have a source for point 18?
11
u/genuinemra Jun 11 '12
Is this the list Ignatious Loyola was working on? If so he forgot to add a section detailing the shocking prevalence of male-on-male violence.
15
u/AnthonyZarat Jun 11 '12
Also, you forgot to mention that Obamacare contains 148 special provisions and programs for women ... and zero for men. Even though men have far worse health outcomes than women, and even though men die more and earlier from all but two diseases compared to women, and even though federal healthcare spending is already 65% on women.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '12
I think a part of me just died inside...
... another part of me has just come into existence. I am an MRA and I don't give a shit who knows it.
-5
u/paigeboy Sep 28 '12
New poster: I am a 39 year old, white male; I work at a major university as an Accounting Technician. I have in the last year become a subordinate to a 25-year-old white female working on her MBA. I have eighteen years of experience in my field, in accounting. This is the newest communique from her.
"Thank you again for taking the time to meet with me on Wednesday to discuss the expectations that I have of the staff in our department. As I mentioned, to be successful in this department one must proficiently complete tasks that are assigned to them and be able to communicate effectively to contribute to a cohesive working environment. To communicate effectively I expect that you will treat your colleagues and your superiors with respect at all times. To elaborate, you must maintain professionalism and emotional stability at work. Examples of intolerable behavior are insulting/snide comments, belittlement of others and insubordination.
I will expect that if you find yourself in a situation where you need to express your concerns and cannot do so in a professional manner, that you take the necessary steps to address those concerns independently (perhaps using one of the resources listed below) and then meet to address your concerns, in a professional manner, with the person(s) involved. I expect that you can differentiate between the more appropriate and less appropriate means of addressing a problem and that you choose the most effective and courteous method of communication. Without improving your ability to communicate professionally and effectively, the concerns will be documented in your coaching and performance evaluations and you will not be successful in this department.
As mentioned in our meeting, you have several resources available to you as a CU staff member. Listed below are resources that you might consider, in addition I always welcome you to discuss your progress with me:"
Does this sound familiar to anyone?
-11
u/FireTruth Sep 18 '12
correction... men are the victems of domestic violence much more often then women... lets not pretend its eqaul.... all it takes is a pair of eyes and ears to see women hit men and threaten to hit men much more often
4
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 13 '12
[removed] — view removed comment