r/anime • u/Gaporigo Blhttps://anilist.co/user/Gaporigo • Oct 10 '22
Awards The 2022 r/anime Awards Announcement and Jury Application
LINK TO THE JUROR APPLICATION
APPLICATIONS CLOSE OCTOBER 23rd 23:59 PDT!
Countdown
Welcome back to the 7th annual /r/anime Awards! It's once again time to watch a bunch of seasonals and argue about which one was best.
Changes in 2022
- This year we're introducing the Open Juror system, which is a more casual and less time-consuming Awards experience that allows jurors to be part of the Awards without necessarily watching a massive amount of shows. See the jury guide for more information.
- The Supporting Character category has been removed. As a result, Main Dramatic Character and Main Comedic Character have been renamed to Dramatic Character and Comedic Character respectively.
- Cast has been renamed to Ensemble Cast.
- Short Series now has 10 nominations.
- Following the success of the Mecha Special Award last year, we have expanded the Special Awards section to include multiple jury-run Special Awards. See the jury guide for more information.
- The genre allocations no longer explicitly lists a secondary genre, and jurors can more freely nominate shows if the primary category jurors do not pick it up. This has no effect on the public vote.
If you want to know more about our reasoning for these changes and/or specifically discuss them, refer to this comment where we've detailed each point more thoroughly.
Also, in case you missed it, here is how the Awards looked last year: Announcement | Results post | Website | Livestream
The Awards Process
The base format of the Awards still remains: The Awards are split into two groups, the Public and the Jury, who will each nominate anime and separately rank them.
The Public is everyone on /r/anime. You will have a comfortable amount of time to vote to nominate a number of shows per category on our snazzy website. The series/characters with the most votes will go on to become your official nominees. These nominees will be combined with the Jury nominees and then together they will form the final list from which both groups will vote and rank on. Public nominations start January 1st.
The Jury is a group of /r/anime users who have passed the Juror Application. Applicants are evaluated based on their ability to analyze anime and communicate their thoughts. They will select their nominees after thorough discussion, having familiarized themselves with the anime in their respective categories. These nominees will be combined with the Public nominees after which the Jury will watch all the nominations to completion and rank them to pick a winner.
The Categories
We have 21 total categories this year:
Genre Awards
- Action
- Adventure
- Comedy
- Drama
- Romance
- Slice of Life
- Suspense
Character Awards
- Comedic Character
- Dramatic Character
- Ensemble Cast
Production Awards
- Animation
- Background Art
- Character Design
- Cinematography
- Original Soundtrack
- Voice Acting
- Opening
- Ending
Main Awards
- Anime of the Year
- Movie of the Year
- Short of the Year
The Livestream
While 2022 is the 7th year of the awards, we'll be coming up on our 5th year of running a live stream of the results on Twitch, complete with commentary, clip reels, and guest appearances! As with everything else, we're working to make things even better this year, and the livestream team has lots of ideas that they'll be working on.
We'll have more information as we get closer to February, but for now you can check out the streams from previous years if you haven't! Follow these links for 2018, 2019, 2020, and 2021's broadcasts.
The Juror Application
Juror applications are now officially open until October 23rd 23:59 PDT (UTC-7). Jury members will then be selected and invited to the Awards by November 4th.
As with last year, we are opening applications early in order to give the jurors time to watch as many shows as possible before nominations begin. This also means that being a juror may be time-consuming. Your responsibility is from November to February, and you’re expected to familiarize yourself with most of the shows in your category. That said, there are rarely time-related issues if you only apply for one or two categories and if you have already watched a lot of shows.
If you still feel the time commitment is too much, why not sign up as an open juror? This allows you to hang out with other passionate anime fans and experience the Awards as a juror without needing to participate in the usual required discussion a category juror would need to.
If you want to know more about the specifics of being a juror, you can read the Jury Guide.
For more info about the role of an open juror click here.
If being a juror sounds like something for you, please click this link (or the one up top/below) and fill out the application.
We always need more people, so thank you so much for applying!
LINK TO THE JUROR APPLICATION
LINK TO THE ALLOCATIONS
LINK TO THE JURY GUIDE
That's all for today!
Expect more news from the /r/anime Awards near the end of the year, but we're off for now. If you have any questions, please leave a comment or message one of the Hosts:
/u/WinzKay, /u/Animestuck, /u/Kanzeon23, /u/unprecedentedwolf, /u/MisterJaguar, /u/Kenalskii, /u/awspear, /u/MyrnaMountWeazel, /u/thyeggman, /u/theyummybagel, /u/redoverthebed, /u/KoalaNugget, /u/Aztecopi, and /u/Vaxivop
27
u/AfutureV :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/AfutureV Oct 10 '22
I just want to say that the only Anime awards I care about are these ones. I deeply appreciate the job that is done here.
26
u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Oct 10 '22
Hiya! The applications to become a juror in the /r/anime Awards 2022 have now opened!
As Vaxi mentioned above, there’s a wide net of responsibility cast for those hoping to become a juror. Watching numerous shows, submitting short write-ups, discussing the reasoning for your decisions. I’ll be honest with ya: being a juror takes time. The days aren’t scored by the 'Hallulujah Chorus.' So, why become one in the first place? After all, there’s only so many hours left in the day for our leisure. Why burn the candle at both ends?
Well, do you believe in your heart of hearts that Komi-San was the catchiest OP of 2021? That the eclectic Sonny Boy should not have won Anime of the Year? That Jujutsu Kaisen was the peak of action? Then this is why you apply to become a juror! Expressing your opinion with other like-minded passionate individuals are the hallmark qualities of being a juror and this key position lends your voice a say on discussing just exactly why you believe (or not believe) the decisions that form the Awards. It’s the cliché of all cliché’s but they’re cliché for a reason: be the change you want to see in the world.
If you earnestly want to contribute to /r/anime, if you seriously wish to be heard for your views, if you sincerely believe that more and more we come to expect less and less from each other and you think this should change, then please consider applying. It will take some measure of time. It will take some amount of effort. But it will give an absolutely rewarding experience. Decisions are made by those who show up.
18
u/Kanzeon23 Oct 10 '22 edited Oct 10 '22
Hello, I'm /u/Kanzeon23, formerly known as /u/ocaria and I'm one of the hosts here for the /r/anime Awards 2022. I hope you guys enjoy the changes we made this year, and I’m looking forward to jurors being accepted and the Awards truly beginning.
Before that though, I'm happy to announce that a few members of the host team will be hosting the first /r/anime Awards Discussion Show (name pending) later today at 17:00 UTC, 1:00 PM EDT, or in 3 hours from this post going up. Me and a few others hosts will be discussing the changes to the Awards made this year and answering questions through Reddit Talk right here on /r/anime.
A direct link to the talk will be edited into this comment after we go live, and I hope to see you there!
Edit: We're going live on Twitch as well as hosting the talk here
16
u/SorcererOfTheLake x5https://anilist.co/user/RiverSorcerer Oct 10 '22
You have Play It Cool Guys listed in your allocations, but that's a 2 cour series so it wouldn't be eligible for this year's awards.
13
u/Miidas-92 :Db::Dd:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Miidas Oct 10 '22
Looking forward to applying for juror again this year. While host/mod was interesting (and lots of work, so really appreciate the work of you Hosts, especially the returning ones), I will admit the juror duty is the most fun one for me. Recommend anyone else that enjoy discussing and watching lots of seasonal stuff, to also sign up as jurors, since it's a real fun experience.
One question regarding the Apps. I see that the different questions, say that the questions applies to different categories. I wonder if this means we should only write stuff that apply to said category, or if can we include stuff outside of the categories said question applies to. As an example for the character question, how the OST or certain elements of the sound design is used to convey the emotions of a character, how underscoring is used in their dialogue to make their dialogue more playful, or how certain characters even got specific insert songs playing when they appear to change the atmosphere of a scene?
13
u/gangrainette https://myanimelist.net/profile/bouletos Oct 10 '22
Last year I watched Pompo the Cinephile thanks to the jury.
Keep on the good work !
11
u/kaverik :Ef::Eh:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kaverik Oct 10 '22 edited Oct 10 '22
Interesting set of changes, intrigued by the Open Juror system and wonder how it's going to work in practice. I do believe that the idea of creating a more lax atmosphere for the awards is sound and reasonable, just hope consequently more people show interest in applying in the first place. There's probably enough to do for everyone on the server, if they're willing to participate.
Anyway, I'm going to apply for Movie of the Year and Original Soundtrack. I hope to make it through - been a while since I've been a genuine juror, and looking forward to experiencing it once again!
Thanks to the mods and hosts for making the awards possible, and good luck to everyone applying!
9
u/Cryzzalis https://myanimelist.net/profile/Charaxify Oct 10 '22
Love to see the changes and constant development of the awards. I have less time than usual this year, but will still be aiming for the OP/ED categories. Best of luck to all applicants and thanks to the host team for the work they put in.
8
u/_Ridley https://myanimelist.net/profile/_Ridley_ Oct 10 '22
As much as I'd love to put in to be a romance category juror, I'm just too disabled to commit to that much writing. I'll have to just content myself with grousing about your choices after the fact lol.
8
u/goukaryuu https://myanimelist.net/profile/GoukaRyuu Oct 10 '22
Good to see it is finally here! I plan to apply again, for what will hopefully be my fifth year.
14
u/Vaxivop https://anilist.co/user/vaxivop Oct 10 '22 edited Oct 13 '22
If you want a how-to guide on how to get into the categories you want or how to properly apply as an open juror, check our Jury Allocation Guide here
Hello everyone. I'm Vaxivop, one of the hosts of the 2022 /r/anime Awards, and I will be detailing our decisions regarding the changes that have been made since last year.
The Open Juror System
This is the biggest change we've introduced this year and it was born from three different goals:
The two first goals are initially at odds with each other. But the inclusion of the third goal made it clearer on what we needed to do: Separate out category jurors, who are expected to commit time and energy into being a juror, from open jurors, who can enjoy a less time-consuming experience while still being part of juror activities or simply just vibe in the Discord server.
As a result, the requirements to become a category juror will become more challenging and they will be held to a higher standard once they join. The jury will then have higher quality members, fulfilling the first goal.
Meanwhile, becoming an open juror is easier and being one takes less time and effort, fulfilling the second goal. In addition, there are no hard requirements to watch and discuss dozens of shows, fulfilling the third goal.
Naturally as an open juror you don't have any direct influence on the main category results, but you'll be able to influence them through interaction with category jurors. Furthermore, you can take part in the Special Awards (see below). And finally, if you suddenly do feel like being in a category, it is possible for open jurors to become category jurors after they have joined.
We hope that the open juror system will result in more people joining the Awards and being part of our wonderful community without necessarily having the responsibility of being in a category.
Removing the Supporting Character category
In a way, this was a long time coming. From both a public and juror perspective, Supporting was one of the least popular categories. Only when there was some specific popular supporting character did the category gain any traction, and even then it was only for that character.
In addition, the distinction between a main character and a supporting character is blurry at best. We'd usually default to AniList which was often filled with mistakes and it almost always ended up messy. And practically speaking if a character is good enough they'll be nominated, supporting or not.
At the end of the day, this category was both unpopular, cumbersome, and not entirely necessary.
Renaming Cast to Ensemble Cast
Waaay back in 2016 this category was called Ensemble. That proved to be a confusing and unhelpful name, and we changed it to the more obvious word "cast". Unfortunately, this name doesn't carry the full intended meaning, which is not just "this is an anime with a lot of good characters" but also overall chemistry and feeling that the entire cast is in focus rather than one or two specific main characters.
The word "ensemble" carries that meaning perfectly but is also not immediately obvious. So we decided to combine the two words. In addition, both Wikipedia and TV Tropes uses the word "Ensamble Cast" which makes our naming more consistent as well.
Giving Short Series 10 nominations
Last year, we had feedback calling for more Short Series nominations. In addition, it's more consistent with the rest of the main categories.
Special Awards Expansion
Those that saw last year's livestream may remember the Mecha Awards, a fun little project by the hosts and jurors to highlight a genre that is normally not a mainstay category in the Awards.
It was deemed a great success that allowed jurors to participate in a more casual and relaxed manner. As such, we're expanding the Special Awards to include numerous categories that the jurors can participate in once they are invited. Participation in the Special Awards is more freeform and combined with the Open Juror System. This will allow jurors who are not part of the official categories to still discuss and analyze anime with the rest of the jurors.
Some of the Special Awards for this year are Music (genre), Antagonist, Art Style, and Sound Design.
No Secondary Genre Allocations
This is exclusively a juror issue, since the public vote only includes the primary genre anyway.
Historically, we have generally allowed jurors to pick up a show if the jurors in the primary and secondary allocations didn't want it. However, while the primary allocation is important from the public side, the secondary allocations didn’t do much in the long scheme of things. Jurors can already pick up shows if they can sensibly fit them into their genre regardless of allocation. And even jurors in the secondary category have to wait for the primary to drop it before it's eligible.
At the end of the day, you wind up with an allocation that does not have much purpose and effectively functions the same as not having a secondary allocation at all. So, we decided to remove it. All jurors can now pick up a show for their category provided it reasonably fits and the primary category jurors don't want it.
7
u/FlaminScribblenaut myanimelist.net/profile/girlbeast_val Oct 10 '22
Hooray, I actually watched enough currently-airings this year that I’ll actually feel somewhat confident participating in the Public Nomination/Voting! Looking forward to it~
7
u/curewaffle Oct 10 '22
Hi! Is Crayon Shin-chan Movie 29 (MAL link) eligible for awards this year? It's a 2021 movie which had its BD come out this year and it's been subbed recently.
7
u/polaristar Oct 12 '22
Now that I got sleep and a day off the questions were easier to answer than I thought.
I think my chances are good.
7
u/isthatsoudane https://myanimelist.net/profile/ojoulover Oct 12 '22
I'm excited by the new open juror position! I imagine kinks will need to be worked out, but it's exciting...because I do not have the time to be a full juror, but I'd love to be able to be more involved in the process. Glad you're experimenting with it!
6
u/thyeggman https://anilist.co/user/thyeggman Oct 10 '22
Hi folks, I'm thyeggman, one of the hosts for this year's awards. If you notice any errors in allocations let me know, I worked a lot on them this year. I already see some have been mentioned! There's a ton of anime, what can I say?
Good luck to everyone who applies!
6
u/Idontlikecovid Oct 13 '22
First time trying for a juror position, seems fun. Hope I get it :) Enjoyed answering the questions anyways
5
u/rotten_riot https://anilist.co/user/RottenOrange Oct 11 '22
Ngl I really like seasonal anime and the idea of juror sounds pretty fun, but looking at the samples I don't think I can write something so detailed lol
4
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22
What if someone just copy pastes analysis from mal?
4
u/Ruhrgebietheld Oct 10 '22
I told myself that I'd decide once the application drops whether I want to do it again or not this year. But honestly, I think I always knew that I missed this enough to apply again.
One question about the application: If a category is listed as being relevant to multiple questions, do we need to include it in our answers to each of them, or is just focusing on the aspects related to those categories in one question enough to get full scores for those cats? So, for example, since visual production is listed in all three questions, do we need to focus on it in our answers for all of them, or is it fine to ignore it in two of the answers and just focus on it in just one answer, in order to still get full points if we want to be in any visual production categories?
4
u/Zypker125 https://anilist.co/user/Zypker124 Oct 10 '22 edited Oct 11 '22
Couple of questions:
Also, I have to ask, is there a reason this year's genre allocation sheet constantly switches between referring to the anime between the Romaji and the English names? It makes it difficult for me to search up the anime in the sheet since it seems to flip-flop.
In terms of other observations:
First, I'm personally sad that Supporting was removed, it's probably a Top 3 favorite category for me, and this means that the number of characters that get nominated cumulatively in the awards significantly decreases. I personally feel like if we're removing the Supporting category, we should increase the total nominees in both Dramatic & Comedic to 10, but oh well. (IMO if I had to pick a category from last year to remove, I probably would have went with Character Design, but that might be unpopular)
Second, the genre categories seem even more uneven in quantity/quality compared to previous years, lol.
with juggernauts SxF and Kaguya going against each other.I also think that this year, the jury AOTY frontrunners seem less clear compared to previous years. Mob Psycho 100 S3 I guess is the one that comes to mind, but given how much love Tatami Galaxy gets, it wouldn't surprise me to see Yojouhan Time Machine Blues as a dark horse candidate. Also, the AOTY jury ranked Kaguya S2 2nd, so who knows, maybe S3 has a chance at getting AOTY as well. The AOTY nominations themselves should also be interesting, since unlike last year, I don't think there's a clear list of jury favorites (a lot of the highly-rated stuff from this year is stuff I don't think an AOTY jury is inclined to like). Most of the other Main awards have clear jury frontrunners (Revue Starlight and Girl from the Other Side for MOTY and
Encouragement of Climb for SSOTY).As always, good luck to all prospective applicants, and good luck to the hosts/mods!
4
u/OccasionallySara Oct 11 '22
Does this need to be a production element that has its own category or can we discuss something outside of those?
4
u/polaristar Oct 11 '22
Damn I'm really bad at music videos and an entire question is about them.....Also first question had trouble keeping it under 5000 characters.
I have to come back to this when I'm not tired from a 14 hour shift and have to comment on two rewatches...
4
u/Nebresto Oct 11 '22
Can I apply but not accept any positions if I win?
4
u/Gippy_ https://myanimelist.net/profile/Gippy Oct 18 '22
I might want to throw my hat in for this because the comedy genre picks last year were an absolute travesty. Zombie Land Saga S2 got in and won? Mieruko-chan got in? Girlfriend Girlfriend and Uramichi Oniisan got snubbed? Even Crunchyroll nominated Uramichi Oniisan. Comedy is subjective, but it seemed like the comedy jury was very close-minded and could not accept unconventional humor.
Shows like Teppen and Don't Hurt Me My Healer might not win, but the goal is to actually give low-budget unconventional comedy shows a chance, and to actually have real comedy shows as the jury picks. When someone thinks of a pure comedy anime, their instincts aren't going to gravitate towards Zombie Land Saga S2 or Mieruko-chan.
3
u/SpareUmbrella https://myanimelist.net/profile/SpareUmbrella Oct 20 '22
As a two-time former juror, I feel like this is not a good way to attract a diverse sample size of jurors.
Two of the three questions are reacting to short films. How do you hope to distinguish between two people who both want to be Romance jurors with these questions? How would you, based on the three questions provided, choose between two very different people who provide very different answers that both have no bearing on Romance or Sound Design or Voice Acting as categories?
I suppose you're trying to assess each applicants' analytical skill, but how do you intend to choose jurors other than those who score top marks?
I'm well aware that much thought went into these questions, so I'm not suggesting for one moment you just came up with random questions, but I struggle to understand how a good ED or OST juror for instance would be chosen from these questions.
7
u/Ashteron Oct 10 '22
I'm looking forward to seeing whether the juror AotY is the same as mine for the third time in a row.
2
u/Educational-Bug8587 Oct 16 '22
G
4
u/Theleux https://myanimelist.net/profile/Theleux Oct 10 '22
The Comedic and Dramatic character category decision is fantastic - supporting always ended up being a mess due to often low numbers of "good contenders" and often times great characters that acted as supports would get lost to Main due to an Anilist tag. So I think this compromise makes the categories much for fluid and will also help curate the results to be stronger for both.
4
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Oct 10 '22
Looking forward to seeing what /r/anime puts out to compare mine with, always a fun time!
1
u/Gippy_ https://myanimelist.net/profile/Gippy Nov 06 '22
Made it in as a comedy and drama juror! I am but one juror but I can assure you that I'll take this seriously and give due consideration to unconventional or sharper comedies like Girlfiend Girlfirend and Uramichi Oniisan last year.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment