r/ModSupport • • Mar 01 '19

An Open Letter on the State of Affairs Regarding NSFW and Underage Depictions of Fictional Characters on Anime/Manga Subreddits

The situation

It has come to the attention of many moderators of various anime subreddits across the site that there has been a crackdown on behalf of Reddit against certain kinds of images posted in our communities, on the basis that these images “sexualize underage fictional children”.These posts have been removed without warning and in some cases the users (including moderators and prolific contributors to the communities) posting these images have also been banned without warning.

These decisions on behalf of Reddit have been presented to us as continued implementation of long-standing Reddit policy, despite the fact that these widespread removals have only recently been enforced. Many moderators can attest that individual members of the Reddit Administration team have previously stated that there were no problems with this type of content being posted on anime subreddits that are currently being removed. For all intents and purposes, to the moderators of anime communities across Reddit, these are new rules being carried out that are out of our control.

As leaders of our respective communities, we find ourselves confused on how to enforce these new standards, that have not been communicated to us by Reddit, but have nevertheless been enforced upon our communities without our knowledge nor our consent. Through this letter, we hope to open up a dialogue between anime subreddit moderators and Reddit Admins to determine what content is and is not acceptable on Reddit.

For the sake of clarity, we have no problem complying with the new standards Reddit has enforced on underage fictional characters. Content involving underage fictional characters (commonly referred to as “lolis” or “shotas” in these communities) remain a small part of the overall anime community, and we do not find it imperative to the survival of our communities to continue posting content that could cause legal problems for Reddit. However, the way this policy has been enforced gives us cause for serious concern regarding how the implementation of this policy will affect our subreddits moving forward. We would like to present our grievances and implore Reddit to consider some of our requests so that we can work together to maintain healthy, functioning communities that are both enjoyable for users while also falling well within Reddit’s rules and content policy.

As an illustration of how these rules have affected us, we will list three examples of removals that have caused concerns or confusion regarding the enforcement of this rule on anime subreddits:

These are only examples of the numerous images users have been banned for in the Reddit anime community. Across many subreddits, we collected reports that the “Anti-Evil Operations” (Reddit’s enforcement team for content reported directly to admins) have started acting more frequently and have removed inherently non-sexual images that we can only assume were troll-reported. So far, the only response from the admins was given with the unbanning of one user, with the following explanation:

That said, in this instance, taking into account the nature of the post in question, along with the fact that this represents your first infraction, a second review has determined that a permanent suspension is not warranted in this case. Your account will be reinstated.

Implying that the image is indeed against Reddit’s Terms of Service

We note that images “contextualized lewdly” are also forbidden, but this vague stipulation would not apply to the pictures above, as well as many other removals. The first link was inspired from a screenshot and posted on /r/pouts, a sub dedicated to cute content of anime characters pouting, the second was posted in the discussion thread of the episode the screenshot was taken in, and the third image is a standalone Valentine’s fanart.

This has caused confusion for mods across many anime communities.

The new way Reddit enforces its policies has left moderators confused on what content is and is no longer tolerated. We will list a few considerations using the above pictures as examples, although they only illustrate broader problems with the vagueness of the current policies.

In the first example, the character (aged 16) is shown wearing a swimsuit. According to the admins, this would count as sexualized content. However, we note that an equitable application of this rule to all content across Reddit would logically entail the removal of all the pictures proud dads post of their daughters winning swimming carnivals, of all pictures of artistic (censored) nudity such as sci-fi incubator tubes, of all pictures featuring cosplay of skimpy/suggestive comic characters such as Wonder Woman and Catwoman, and all pictures of beach/pool episodes in high school series. We have not seen, and do not expect to see such removals across other communities on Reddit. Yet, it was confirmed that the post is indeed in infraction to the rules.

As we mentioned, it would be excessive to remove all content featuring exposed skin, both in and outside anime content. Related to that, the second image is a screenshot picturing a character (aged 3 days) without clothes yet still humbly covered. We insist that said picture, be it as a standalone, in the context of the episode it comes from, and in the context of the comment where it was posted, is not even remotely sexual in nature. Once again, we wonder if the admins want us to remove all content where characters show a moderate amount of skin, and if they believe this to be a practical rule to enforce across Reddit.

In both of those examples, the source images (or its inspiration) came from episodes of shows that were broadcast on Japanese television, and streamed on the American anime platform Crunchyroll without any age restriction. This means that the content is already curated, and shouldn’t be shocking for anyone, especially for users who are actually watching this type of show. Is there any particular reason for Reddit to have stricter guidelines than TV ratings and if so, where exactly is this line drawn?

The second aspect of these removals is the age of the characters. The admins have stated that “whenever possible, when evaluating reports of minor sexualization pertaining to known anime characters, we will first make an effort to check the canonical age of the characters”. This contrasts with some recent bans and removals (for example, the /r/NewGameXXX subreddit, dedicated to characters that are adult and in the workforce, was banned). It is also impractical in a medium where the canonical age of adults can be counted in days while that of lolis could be in centuries. Currently, the removals are inconsistent with any written rule, the policies of various anime subreddits, and the type of content allowed across Reddit.

To summarize the problem: the recent removals have not been adequately explained or justified, nor have clear new rules been communicated to moderators of the affected communities. Some of these removals seem rather heavy-handed and inconsistent with the type of content that is tolerated across the rest of Reddit. The combination of these factors make understanding and applying the new rules difficult (from both a moderation and user perspective) and give our community a feeling of being unfairly targeted.

How mods reacted to and interpreted the new policies

At /r/anime, we have always heavily regulated NSFW content, regardless of the age of characters and when that policy was updated last year, we promptly updated our rules accordingly.

While we have since long enforced the Reddit policies, it seems now this is no longer enough.

As moderators, we are expected to uphold Reddit’s ToS within our communities. Quite frankly, this is not possible with the current state of Reddit policy. We have not been informed of what is acceptable and what is not, and consequently we cannot be expected to consistently remove content that Reddit would want us to remove. Moreover, we cannot convey to our users what exactly they are not permitted to post and thus cannot effectively protect our active contributors from having their accounts suspended. In fact, we moderators ourselves cannot predict what content we post to our own communities may or may not get our accounts suspended, suddenly decreasing the manpower of our subreddits’ mod teams and potentially forcing them to scramble to find new moderators to continue to effectively curate our communities. This state of affairs is not good for the health of the anime community on Reddit and consequently is not good for Reddit itself, which is built on the contributions of its users and volunteer moderators.

As mods, we have a lot of experience on what users typically share or find offensive in our communities. If you have doubts, or want us to upgrade our standards, you can rely on our help. We already spend a significant amount of time ensuring that all rules are applied consistently and understood by the community, as well as educating users.

What we ask — Clarifying the current ToS

We understand that Reddit does not want to be a platform where images of sexualized children, including fictional ones, are shared. We are more than happy to comply with this, however we feel that the examples above do not fall under this category.

Drawing hard boundaries around what counts as sexualized is understandably difficult, yet few of us would agree that simple swimsuit pictures count as such. We firmly believe that none of the above images have sexual connotations, with or without context.

Another aspect of this rule is that, according to the ToS, this restriction applies to “minors or someone who appears to be a minor”, and removals look at the canonical age of characters to check if they are under 18 (among other things). We feel that this is a very uninformed way to apply the restriction, as the large majority of anime characters come from a high school setting or are otherwise underage, even if they don’t necessarily look like it. Combined with the overly broad interpretation of “sexualized content” described above, this would effectively ban a significant fraction of anime content.

We also note that, in the anime community, “she’s actually 500 years old” is a very common trope. Other quirky scenarios that could cause issue with canonical age ruling include characters that age over time, alternate universe versions of characters, characters that canonically age faster than humans, etc. As a consequence, looking at the canonical age of the characters seems to be going against the spirit of the rule.

This ambiguity has left some users scared of posting legitimate content (some also went further and removed any potentially rule-breaking post in their history, despite those posts not having been removed in the past). Not knowing where the line is drawn, and taking into account the harsh punishments that have been used, they cannot be certain that an admin will not consider their content rule-breaking and lead to a ban of their account without a warning or clarification.

What we ask — Revising the current policy on NSFW anime content to make it realistically enforceable, and ask moderators for their feedback on what can be done

Trying to enforce vague and overly broad rules would be counterproductive. Users are unlikely to completely stop posting problematic content, and are likely to try to skim the rules, while mods need to toe an ambiguous line between moderating content and keeping their subreddits alive.

More explicit content than what Reddit allows is regularly broadcast on kids channels and even mainstream TV channels (Adult Swim is more than unabashed). This content has been scrutinized by a producer for an appropriate Parental Guide rating, before being offered on popular streaming services such as Crunchyroll.

We ask that Reddit reconsiders its current policies, not to repeal them, but instead to rewrite them in such a way that can all work together for a consistent and collaborative enforcement. To this end, we believe that communication with the moderators is key: they have the best knowledge of their content, their users, and what anime actually is. Let us help you.

Conclusion

Don’t go down the path of Youtube, Tumblr, Discord and many other social media giants when it comes to actively pushing away a major sector of the community that creates and shares content. A middle ground exists; let’s reach for it. Don’t hold a conservative viewpoint on anime, and consider revising the anime related section of your NSFW content policy. Remember that banning any ‘lewd’ depiction of a character under 18 is impossible to enforce due to the vagueness of that word and the numerous varieties of content in anime itself. Ask for the help of moderator teams and don’t rush into banning users based on the personal beliefs of the admin on duty.

The moderators that signed this letter understand that Reddit’s new policies aim to reduce content which could cause legal issues for the platform. However, we would like Reddit to reconsider its stance on these current policies, clarifying and rewriting them such that we can ensure that all rules are applied consistently and understood by the community, as well as educating users. Please involve us, so that we can continue to give the best Reddit experience possible to our respective communities.


Below is a list of subreddits that signed this open letter. We all represent a segment of the community that has been affected by the recent events. Feel free to open the discussion with us in this thread or contact us directly to resolve this issue and prevent future conflicts.

/r/2anime_irl4anime_irl /r/absolutelynotanimeirl /r/anime /r/anime_irl /r/animearmpits /r/AnimeBlush /r/animebooty /r/AnimeDubs /r/animefuckingdying /r/Animelegs /r/AnimeLounging /r/animemes /r/AnimeMILFS /r/animenocontext /r/animereactionimages /r/AnimeSuggest /r/Animewallpaper /r/araragi /r/Ashihentai /r/awenime /r/awwnime /r/AzureLane /r/CedehsHentai /r/Chiisaihentai /r/churchoftooru /r/CitrusManga /r/CumHentai /r/cutelittlefangs /r/cutetraps /r/DarlingInTheFranxx /r/DBZ34 /r/DDLCRule34 /r/DeathMarch /r/Dekaihentai /r/DomesticGirlfriend /r/Doujinshi /r/DragonMaid /r/ecchi /r/Embarrassedhentai /r/Endro /r/Evangelion /r/ElriosArtGallery /r/fatestaynight /r/Fire_Emblem_R34 /r/fitdrawngirls /r/Flip_Flappers /r/Futanari /r/GATE /r/Hentai /r/HentaiCleavage /r/hentaifemdom /r/HentaiLesdom /r/Hentai_gif /r/Hentai_irl /r/HighschoolDxD /r/HimeCut /r/Horimiya /r/ImaginarySliceOfLife /r/InfiniteStratos /r/jav_gifs /r/Kaede /r/Kaguya_sama /r/kazumin /r/kemonomimi /r/Komi_san /r/KonoSuba /r/Kuroihada /r/KxS /r/LoveLive /r/macross /r/Mahouka /r/Masturbationhentai /r/MiyuEdelfelt /r/MH34u /r/MonsterMusume /r/Muchihentai /r/OneTrueKongou /r/OnePunchMan /r/OneTrueBiriBiri /r/OneTrueIchigo /r/OneTrueRem /r/OneTrueYume /r/OsuSkins /r/pantsu /r/Pokeporn /r/Railgun /r/rosariovampire /r/rule34lol /r/rule34overwatch /r/RWBY /r/Saber /r/shieldbro /r/smugs /r/SSSSGRIDMAN /r/SteinsGate /r/Sukebei /r/Thighdeology /r/toloveru /r/Toonami /r/Toradora /r/Tsunderes /r/Twintails /r/Uniform_hentai /r/VillagersGoneWild /r/Waifusgonewild /r/Watamote /r/Watashi_ni_Tenshi /r/WeCantStudy /r/Xenoblade_R34 /r/YagateKiminiNaru /r/ZeroTwo /r/ZettaiRyouiki


Feel free to open the discussion with us in this thread or contact us directly to resolve this issue in order to prevent further confusion and conflict.

9.2k Upvotes

1.9k comments sorted by

154

u/theguyfromuncle420 Mar 01 '19 edited Mar 02 '19

What kills me is admins can remove shit like this but I contact them about a guy literally cyberstalking me, calling me nigger across hundreds of accounts, finding my girlfriends social media and harassing her there, false reporting everything I post and spamming the same abuse across every post and get ignored.

Context: https://www.reddit.com/r/MMFB/comments/anyog1/im_tired_of_this_guy_stalking_me_emailing_me_and/

It just reiterates what I and many others believe that the admins only care about things that can potentially cost the site money, that’s it. Still no block button on the website to protect against harassment

57

u/pokemans3 Mar 02 '19

Still no block button on the website to protect against harassment

That's what kills me actually. There's a block feature built into Reddit but you have to report their post to access it on desktop as far as I'm aware. Which is amazing.

45

u/theguyfromuncle420 Mar 02 '19

It’s not even a real block button. It’s just a mute button, they can still see your content/comment etc

→ More replies (28)

22

u/xStaabOnMyKnobx Mar 02 '19

They don't care about your safety, they only care about their appearance and viability as an advertising platform. Remember ViolentAcrez or whatever his name was? Probably the most prolific pornographer on the entire site ever and it was only when major news outlets started talking about him that the admins decided they no longer wanted him to be a part of the community.

12

u/Bhima Mar 02 '19

lol. The admins made a special award "Pimp Daddy" just for him and it was all great stuff... until it was the national news.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

9

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '19

and yet, ironically, people still perpetuate this "reddit gold" meme, giving money to a site that is increasingly corrupt, like most other historical examples of few holding power. It's like people are so psychologically sold-in to the "culture" here that they don't even realize what they're doing.

If you want to show your support, that's what the fucking upvote button is for. It's 100% free, and does more to get the post seen than throwing your money to the people you disagree with.

→ More replies (9)

6

u/DragonPup Mar 02 '19

Get it reported by a major news network and suddenly the reddit admins will care.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/nijio03 Mar 02 '19

What that person is doing is illegal and you can contact the police, mentioning to the media that reddit allowed this to go on would also help wink wink

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (51)

56

u/joe4553 Mar 01 '19

Honestly I think Reddit has a few main goals one to be able to say to advertisers they took care of any problems and are actively removing any offending content while putting as little effort as possible. It’s easy to target mods so that they can enforce vague rules for you. They’re just trying to maximize profits, I would encourage the anime community to stop buying any gold or silver.

24

u/porygonzguy Mar 02 '19

It’s easy to target mods so that they can enforce vague rules for you.

Yep. That's why, when a couple of years ago the reddit modteams and admins had their discussion to hammer out how the admins could do better, the admins turned around and came up with a whole bunch of new rules for how mods should behave which did absolutely nothing to solve the issues that had been raised in multiple discussions.

10

u/Crimson_Steel Mar 02 '19

Tbh it's time for another blackout. Maybe even permanently. Start shutting things down and moving out.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/psychospacecow Mar 02 '19

I swear there's a bot that gives gold whenever someone says not to, because comments like this always have gold.

14

u/DiGreatDestroyer Mar 02 '19

Don't give me gold oh non existent bot, it certainly isn't my longest held desire.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '19

Yeah, I don't know why people keep saying it's a legal issue.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (16)

24

u/DurdenVsDarkoVsDevon Mar 02 '19 edited Mar 02 '19

This is a fantastic, level-headed essay that outlines the current issue. I am ecstatic that the anime community at large has made a unified, formal response such as this. I agree with every sentence, and you've done an excellent job outlying some of the most bizarre examples. That valentines one is mind blowing, and I was unaware of it. There exists no rational defense.

Thank you for taking a stand. This is truly wonderful, and makes me very happy to be a part of the anime community.

→ More replies (11)

22

u/rentedtritium Mar 01 '19

It seems like just from a logistical perspective, you can either be vague about how you determine age or vague about how you determine what's sexually suggestive.

But if you're vague about both, that's really going to make things difficult for everyone involved and is going to end up with a ton of false positives (and false negatives).

9

u/TheTweets Mar 02 '19

I think age is the easy one, or rather easier one, as it can be defined with fairly-close rules - Do they appear immature, either physically (under 16) or mentally (incapable of caring for themselves)? If so, treat them as a child.

While there's tough calls to be made on it, it's still easier than defining what is "sexually suggestive" simply because so many people have so many different opinions on that.

That said, I think right now the definition of "sexually suggestive", despite being completely hidden, is far too puritanical.

Showing some skin shouldn't be treated as "sexually suggestive" unless the context for showing that skin is such that the person showing the skin is intending to cause arousal, for example. A woman wearing a bikini or a man walking around without a shirt, while it may be arousing to some people, is not inherently sexually suggestive and the two terms very much need to be separated as such.

I think this is the core issue - somebody is looking at something and thinking "would this potentially be arousing to somebody?" not "is this sexually suggestive in and of itself?" - The terms are being conflated.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (4)

8

u/landoflobsters Reddit Admin: Safety Mar 07 '19

Hey mods, we appreciate the thought you have put into this post and the confusion you may be feeling as we have enhanced our enforcement capabilities around so-called “loli” content. We hope we can clarify some things for you.

You may be noticing more actioning of this type of content as we have gotten better at detecting it. We understand that this may make it appear as new policy. However, the reality is that our policy on sexual or suggestive content involving minors has specifically called out cartoon depictions of minors for more than a year now, since its last major update.

Our intentions are not to be unclear about this policy, and we understand that it can be frustrating when it seems that way. However, as you know, our constant refrain is that policy must be applied contextually. We will always try to take the context of a post or comment into account when we are evaluating it – as should you. Because of that, we are not able to go into a deep discussion here with you on individual scenarios. We look at each individual case on its own terms (this is also why we sometimes take longer than you’d prefer when we’re evaluating things). If we are finding common confusion around a given policy, we may consider that an indication that a small update for clarity is needed. This is what led us to specifically add the word “loli” in the policy – we found that the original rule, although it mentioned anime, seemed not to be getting through to certain communities.

We’d also like to clear up one thing that appears to be causing confusion around this policy – it is not always a question of the image itself. Comments and contextualization matter. Even if an image of a minor is SFW, if the comments and discussion around that image are suggestive, then a violation is created. This is why you may have seen SFW photos come down under this policy. Nevertheless, we are human and we may make mistakes. This is why we have an appeals process, the overturn rate of which we publicly report. If you think we took action in error, please make use of this process – this is how we can catch mistakes and adjust how we implement our policy. At least one of the examples you provided was overturned due to an appeal. That's the system working – please use the system.

To be 100% clear: we know that many of you disagree with this policy on principle. Nevertheless, it is in place to protect children and obey the law. Please respect that we take this very seriously and err on the side of caution when it comes to any content involving depictions of minors. The best guideline we can give you to help clarify this rule is that, if it would be creepy to post with regard to a human minor, please don’t post it with regard to an animated minor.

5

u/AnimeMod Mar 13 '19

Hi landoflobsters, thanks for getting back to us. We’re glad to receive an open response from the admins of this matter because we feel it really needs some clarifications.

At the high level, we believe many of your points are correct. We appreciate that context is necessary for determining how to apply policy and that how a post stands in regard to the rules is going to be more than the objective content of the post itself, but also where, how, and in what manner it's posted, and in general what is the believed intent of the OP. No objections to any of that here, that's pretty obvious. Nevertheless, we have some concerns as to the methods you guys seem to be using to determine how posts featuring minors are being contextualized.

To get to the point, trying to determine the context of a post through the comments poses several problems, both for users and moderators. To us, it would seem that someone making a suggestive comment on a post is already establishing (or changing) a context. It can (and often does) completely change the intent of the poster. As such, it seems unfair to ban the OP of the post rather than the ones who commented. In turn, the comments can (and often do) be made in jest, as references or as memes, and outright banning them is also very harsh.

The second concern is that this system seems very open to abuse. Anyone who has a personal grievance with the OP can make suggestive comments, getting them banned. This is prone to trolls and brigading (we know, from talking with other mods, that concerns about brigading have already been reported to you). It is also likely to target active users even more than casual ones, because they can be targeted despite having the best intentions.

There is also some concerns that the context (which, as you say, matters), is not always taken into account with as much attention as what you said. One example would be the episode screenshot mentioned in our original letter. Another is the New Game NSFW subreddit that was banned. You have mentioned the appeals process, but frankly, appealing a ban against your account is time-consuming, energy-intensive, and stressful. As mods, we would rather avoid putting faith in the appeal process and instead reduce mistaken bans of our users to a minimum to begin with.

We would like to stress that this isn't an intractable problem. If you have an issue with people making suggestive comments towards minors we can absolutely institute rules that ban this in our communities. In fact, this kind of feedback is exactly why we are asking for clarifications. As an example, /r/hentai recently announced changes to their rules to ban context that specifically calls out the age of characters when it is not clearly the intent of the artist to make them appear underage, including several popular memes (users of anime subreddits will certainly recognize the “lolice” and “FBI” memes that are ubiquitous). Would you encourage this kind of enforcement across other subreddits?

If this is not what you are looking for, then we still don’t understand what you are expecting our communities to do. Before this response, we had no idea that suggestive comments were a problem, and nothing we had seen from Reddit's side had indicated to us that it was something being taken this seriously. Additionally, we still have some concerns from the original post regarding how we are confused as to how to bring our communities in line with Reddit's content policy that have gone unanswered. For instance, from what we have picked up from admin messages in the past, it seems like Reddit defines a character as being a minor if they are canonically under 18. But this frankly doesn't make sense when applied to anime; we can very easily provide a long list of anime characters who could appear as children for external observers, but are canonically adults and act as such. From previous statements, we were led to believe that the artistic intent behind the picture would be a good reference (“is the character intended to look like a child, in this context?”), but recent admin actions seem to contradict those statements. If we cannot refer to those previous policies, there are also a number of edge cases (alternative universes, characters who get older in their series, “X years later” scenarios...) where this causes problems that we aren't sure how to respond to, and we feel totally left in the dark. As such, we would greatly appreciate being able to enter into a dialogue with some admins where we can hopefully clarify what the intent of the rules is and enforce it in a way that is coherent with what the admins are trying to achieve. We could also help you express the policies in a way that is more familiar to people involved in the culture of anime communities (your use of “loli” is nonstandard to us, for example). Perhaps, if you are open to this, we can also provide some answers from the perspective of people steeped in this culture as to questions you might have, so that you might be able to write clearer and more effective content policy that applies to anime communities. But we understand if you don't think this is necessary, and in any case it's more important to us to understand exactly what you want us to do before anything else anyway.

If you are willing to talk to us in depth about this please let us know your preferred means of doing so. Modmails, Skype, Discord, even if you just want to continue it in this thread, anything's fine by us.

On a final note, we'd just like to say that we understand Reddit's strictness towards content depicting minors, and even if not all of us absolutely agree with Reddit's stance on principle (and, to be clear, many of us do agree. It's a broad church), the goal of this letter is not to undermine or challenge that stance. All we want to know is how precisely you want us to do this, because at the moment we are lost, and we fear that this lack of clarity is preventing us from effectively cultivating our communities and protecting our users posting legitimate content.

→ More replies (21)

39

u/SpareUmbrella Mar 07 '19 edited Mar 07 '19

Hi u/landoflobsters

Before I go any further, I'll explain I'm not a mod of an anime-related subreddit, but I am a concerned user. Like you I am concerned about the prevalence of sexually suggestive content involving minors, and I feel like the open letter signed by the anime community at large was an attempt to seek clarity on the current rules concerning loli content.

However, the reality is that our policy on sexual or suggestive content involving minors has specifically called out cartoon depictions of minors for more than a year now, since its last major update.

I'd like to start here, if I may. The difficulty the mods are facing is how exactly to enforce this rule. Does your definition of 'minor' concern the canonical age of the character in question, or how they appear, and if it is that latter, what metric do you have for determining this?

As I'm sure you're aware, there can be a grave disparity between the published age of an anime character and how they might appear on-screen. For instance, Yoko Littner is listed as 14 years old, but Aoba Suzukaze is 20.

I'm sure you can appreciate the difficulty in moderating this kind of discrepancy in appearance when that decision is based solely upon the appearance of the character in question, and not their listed age.

It is this inconsistency that the open letter from the anime community at large sought to address, and I'm afraid you have simply not addressed this point in any meaningful way.

Comments and contextualization matter. Even if an image of a minor is SFW, if the comments and discussion around that image are suggestive, then a violation is created.

How exactly should this be dealt with?

Under the assumption a violation is created, how exactly is this so? I assume Reddit in general has no information regarding the age of her users, so is it entirely improper for a 16 year old girl to find a 16 year old male anime character attractive?

How do you plan to effectively and fairly address this? I understand Reddit has legal obligations to consider (Well you don't in light of the First Amendment, but let's pretend you do) but there is simply no way for Reddit to adequately judge when appreciation for the aesthetics of a character go beyond innocent infatuation to paedophilia.

Moreover, I would assert that appreciation for a fictional character cannot be measured in the same way as appreciation for a real minor.

Given the above, how on Earth can you expect moderators to understand exactly when edgy banter, comments, memes, and the like have gone too far? There is simply no objective standard one can apply with regards to this sentiment, and it is wholly unfair to punish subreddits for the actions of their users - actions they cannot understand are against the rules because no consistent standard exists.

There is plenty more I could say, but I feel this dialogue should exist between Reddit and the moderators of the Anime community at large.

They asked for some kind of consistency, and you have supplied none. You have not answered their questions, so what is a mod to do?

12

u/cedehh Mar 09 '19

They dont care what we do apparently. We wanted to know how we can follow their rules and have our communities function, saving them time as we mod posts ourselves...

They respond with this. We will still be picked off one by one. They do not respect the anime community enough to even remotely tell us how to avoid being banned.

Im shocked this response was made over no response since makes their view of us even more clear...

Protecc the children by not telling the mods how to do so to their standards, makes sense /s

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (108)

21

u/Melbuf Mar 07 '19

my question is when are you gonna go all nazi on the real porn subs?

18

u/Xiaxs Mar 07 '19

My question is when are they gonna ban the real child porn (the people posting on Barely Legal subreddits that aren't 18+) and leave DRAWINGS on a PIECE OF PAPER and the people posting them alone.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/war_story_guy Mar 07 '19

When they start posting anime pictures apparently.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

20

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

With all due respect, drawings are not real children and don't need protection.

19

u/Yay295 Mar 07 '19 edited Mar 07 '19

don't need protection

Actually, as we can see from decisions like this, drawings do need protection. Protection from censorship.

→ More replies (7)

19

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

protect the fictional children and obey laws that don't exist

Wew.

banning for comments

We China now.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/Kicken Mar 07 '19

Nevertheless, it is in place to protect children

How many children have you protected so far? :o

16

u/TheGreatFox1 Mar 08 '19

Given the studies showing that violent video games have no impact on IRL violence and that legal porn reduces rape rates... the number is negative.

The policy the Admins put in place increases the amount of children raped.

I can't help but wonder if that's their intended goal?

→ More replies (2)

18

u/grizzchan Mar 07 '19

Unfortunately you haven't addressed many of our concerns at all. I hope you will address them, because this answer is just as vague to us as your policy "clarity" update of several weeks ago. It has hardly answered any of our pressing questions.

First, the impractical policy of checking the canonical age of characters. As the OP and the comments have made abundantly clear, the concept of canonical age in anime is completely meaningless. It's merely an arbitrary number.

In almost every depictions of an anime character, one could argue that said character's age is not the same as the intended age in the depiction. Simply because in most cases, the appearance of a character is not enough to accurately estimate their age.

This is why we think you should reconsider this part of the policy, as it is straight up asinine to enforce

Secondly, there's the first example given in the OP post. /u/holofan4life (the user who was banned for posting this image) was told in the response to his appeal that you, the admins, still consider this image to be rule-breaking.

We would like to know how, in your mind, this image is rule-breaking. Because this example leads us to believe that you're holding anime to a stricter standard than actual real-life content.

Third, you consider the apparent age of a character when determining whether a post is rule-breaking, but only when it comes to anime. There is a subreddit called /r/FauxBait (highly NSFW), which features NSFW content of adult women that look underage. Apparently this subreddit is considered by the admins to be completely in line with the ToS. Yet when the same practice is applied to anime, suddenly it's a breach of the ToS.

Normally I'm not one to argue that the canonical age should make any difference when it comes to allowing NSFW content of fictional characters. But there is a clear double standard being applied here. Anime content is being held to a higher standard than real-life content, which is one of the most backwards practices I've ever seen.

We ask that you do not hold anime content to a higher standard than real-life content. Regardless of whether that means the content of /r/FauxBait will not be allowed, or that NSFW content of "legal lolis" will be allowed.

These aren't all of our unaddressed concerns, but they're three of the major ones that we would really like to be properly addressed.

→ More replies (11)

17

u/Nomnomvore Mar 07 '19

So when will any discussion of games involving crimes get banned? This is like equating GTA5 with actual violence. Drawings Do. Not. Have. Age. I don't know why this is so hard to understand.

16

u/SpudeGG Mar 07 '19

Yeah, ban all discussion about GTA because it promotes gang violence. Oh, if anyone mentions Breaking Bad, it promotes the manufacture and sale of drugs, better ban that too. Game of Thrones has rape in it, better get in before the new season and ban anything relating to such matters so as to protect the populus.

Look, reddit. Whatever you want to put as rules on your site, fine. But make the rules clear, and stop using bullshit excuses. "We don't want to be affiliated with that sort of stuff" would be fine. Protecting children is getting a bit out there.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/bluebolide Mar 07 '19

It's in place to protect children

breathes in

AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Abedeus Mar 07 '19

Great response.

tl;dr fictional blood and gore is good, hate subreddits that brigade people are great, but imaginary characters and drawings of them are no no.

Nevertheless, it is in place to protect children

Bull fucking shit.

and obey the law.

Law of which country? Saudi Arabia? Better start banning pictures with ankles visible, in case someone from SA sees it.

The best guideline we can give you to help clarify this rule is that, if it would be creepy to post with regard to a human minor, please don’t post it with regard to an animated minor.

Do you apply the same logic with scenes of violence and murder? Are scenes of rape between adults fine? Will Game of Thrones, which shows teenager get raped in one of its early episodes, be banned from Reddit?

11

u/Kicken Mar 07 '19

The best guideline we can give you to help clarify this rule is that, if it would be creepy to post with regard to a human minor, please don’t post it with regard to an animated minor.

Actually, if you apply this standard as if it was reality, pretty much all content is disallowed, since we didn't get the subject of the "photograph" to agree, and thus, it is all involuntary pornography.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

16

u/HENTAI-IS-GOOD-FOR-U Mar 07 '19

to be 100% clear

Clear as mud.

protect children

Anime characters aren't real.

obey the law

Isn't illegal.

Absolute morons.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/_Eltanin_ Mar 08 '19

Well this clarifies fucking nothing.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/bWoofles Mar 07 '19

Good to know you guys are going to destroy this site like tumblr

→ More replies (5)

15

u/theguyfromuncle420 Mar 07 '19

How does this bullshit have 10 upvotes? And also when’re you gonna implement a proper block button? It seems like you lot make your admin posts with your cool orange flakes and never reply to criticism. The top comment on this post, mine, is about your failure to act against cyberstalking and harassment, yet you’re banning users and subs for this?

You clearly only care about things that affect your bottom line. Investors and advertisers don’t want to be associated with loli shit so you’ve banned it, it doesn’t affect you to help victims of harassment though. So know what will affect you? When I go to news agencies and expose your blasé attitude to it. Just like you banned that one guy who used to post jailbait stuff once you got called out by Anderson cooper,

14

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

I second this

It's amazing that Reddit staff let so much serious harassment and abuse go on this site with impunity, knowingly and willingly ignoring reports about it for literally months (and according to some users, even years) while suspending other people for minor or arbitrary BS reasons

30

u/thepervertedromantic Mar 07 '19

specifically called out cartoon depictions of minors for more than a year now

That is the problem, the only reason there wasn't major blowback for you guys a year ago was because it wasn't being enforced as worded. Lip service to placate vocal minorities is somewhat understandable, but the actual censorship we've seen carried out in recent weeks is not.

Nevertheless, it is in place to protect children

The non-existent children (and adults which seem to be effectively included aswell) that are depicted need protection? What about all the non-existent pedestrians who die in the majority of Grand Theft Auto clips? Does this mean we can expect rules to protect them as well? Where does this rabbit hole end? Fictional events have been repeatedly shown to have no impact on real world crime in multiple studies going back decades. This is not an acceptable excuse for the censorship of fictional material on a platform that markets itself as a forum for open discussion. If I can't post a screenshot of a show that was aired on network television there is a problem with the rules.

and obey the law.

What law? Reddit is a US company and the PROTECT act outlines very clearly where the legal line between actual child pornography and acceptable free speech is and the site rules seem to completely disregard that. If you're talking about foreign laws, then what other standards can we expect to be held to? Saudi Arabia? China? No amount of censorship of fictional works is acceptable and citing human rights abuses in other parts of the world as a defense is a joke. If you are actually under the impression that the company you work for is legally obligated to remove such content then please speak to your legal department.

Your response is extremely disingenuous as your excuses for this insane rule don't even hold up to a moment's scrutiny. It makes me wonder what the implications of such a reply are. Either the administrative team are fools who are drinking their own koolaid or they think the users of this site are fools who won't see through these paper thin excuses immediately. Either way it makes Reddit's administration look bad.

14

u/Syyiailea Mar 07 '19

I was gonna give this gold, but that would just be putting money into Reddit's pocket for this horrible decision. Regardless, fuckin' ace reply.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/Idomenos Mar 07 '19

Nevertheless, it is in place to protect children and obey the law.

Calling BS on both counts:

obey the law.

BS. Reddit is a US company, and the content posted historically on r/anime etc is legal under Ashcroft vs Free Speech Coalition.

to protect children

BS, for several reasons:

  1. Drawings are not children.
  2. See No.1.
  3. Given that 95%+ of anime protagonists are minors, given your official admin response, posting screencaps of airing anime series is a bannable offense.
  4. Idiocy knows no limits.
  5. See No.1.
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (17)

14

u/Cacophon Mar 07 '19

if the comments and discussion around that image are suggestive, then a violation is created.

So if a bunch of degenerates start perving over otherwise innocent pictures (like say this picture of a rainbow like holy shit look at the CURVE) then its possible that it becomes NSFW and the person who posted the picture is now banned, even if they did not contribute to the lewd conversation around it?

At least one of the examples you provided was overturned due to an appeal. That's the system working – please use the system.

Banning a user abruptly for something that's not their fault and abides by your rules is quite blatantly a broken system.

There are literally memes about this.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/FreeSpeechWarrior Mar 07 '19

When did reddit decide to abandon freedom of speech as a goal and why?

We understand that this might make some of you worried about the slippery slope from banning one specific type of content to banning other types of content. We're concerned about that too, and do not make this policy change lightly or without careful deliberation. We will tirelessly defend the right to freely share information on reddit in any way we can, even if it is offensive or discusses something that may be illegal. However, child pornography is a toxic and unique case for Internet communities, and we're protecting reddit's ability to operate by removing this threat. We remain committed to protecting reddit as an open platform.

https://www.reddit.com/r/blog/comments/pmj7f/a_necessary_change_in_policy/

You're censoring CARTOONS now.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/PandavengerX Mar 07 '19

as we have gotten better at detecting it.

This is a real arrogant thing to say to a letter that opens with 3 pieces of evidence to the contrary. Increasing your false positives is not getting better at detecting anything.

14

u/Mobiusyellow Mar 08 '19

So an OP of a post is responsible for the contents of the comment section? On what planet is that reasonable?

13

u/ReverieMetherlence Mar 07 '19

extreme violence, gore and torture is ok

nazism, Holocaust denial is ok

extreme communism (which is literally forbidden in many countries, including mine), stalinism, Holodomor denial is ok

discussion of potent, life-destroying drugs is ok

drawings are not ok

The hypocrisy is real.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/ShimaWarrior Mar 07 '19

comments and contextualization matter

So if someone posts a video of, say, their toddler learning to walk, and one pedophile comments some creepy shit, that can create a "violation", thus resulting in the poster being banned? Why not just delete the comment? Ban the commenter?

And answer me on this - why exactly can some drawing of a fictional underage character be ban worthy, yet videos of real humans dying is still fine? Even the death of children is allowed on r /watchpeopledie.

Do you honestly fucking think that's worse? Are you really that shitty? Not just you, this whole company? Some lines and colors are worse than human death?

But I'm sure you won't answer. Because you have no answer.

→ More replies (6)

11

u/DaLinkster Mar 07 '19

Wow that was that was a lot of lip service for for something that doesn't really answer any of our concerns. If anything, now knowing the idea that even other users comments will get your post removed makes this even worse. Seems like it could be heavily abused.

I just want to know what matters more, canonical age or their appearance? It seems like if one or the other is out of line, then it's enough to warrant a suspension. And in any case, is executed horribly.

Lewd images of characters representing full grown adults being removed because canonically they're under aged. Whether it they're 17, or 2. This character from 'Rising of the Shield Hero' for example looks like a grown woman and acts like an adult, but is under the age of 18.

Or images of women of legal age being removed because someone decided they were too petite to represent an adult. Which feels like that leans too heavily on someone's opinion. This character from 'New Game!' for example is a legal adult but had lewd images of her removed anyways.

The idea that this "protects children" is ridiculous. What children are you protecting? These are drawings, not children. Nobody is physically hurt making them, and nobody is physically hurt looking at them. Looking at them doesn't turn you into a pedophile as much as playing violent video games makes you a murderer.

It's OK if reddit doesn't want to host this kind of content. The mods are more than willing to comply. But it's beyond stupid to not have any coherent and reasonable guidelines to follow. Without any, they're on a constant guessing game of questioning on whether content break reddit policy, which seems to heavily factor so much on admin opinion.

13

u/Kicken Mar 07 '19

r/Hentai mod here! Raphtalia has gotten people permanently suspended before. Read more about that in my post here.. (Post includes NSFW imagery) It includes a (censored) example which was banned, in which she is depicted as fully adult. The ban ignores that she isn't human and thus, human standards of age of consent are rather silly. Further, the ban was most likely due to report brigading, rather than any merits of the image itself.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/masterpatter Mar 07 '19

So you can get suspended for posting a competently SFW drawing because of other peoples comments of which you have no control over.

What?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/ArcaneGarbageman Mar 07 '19

Jesus Christ what a horrible response. Literally didn’t address any of the points about the rules being ambiguous “durr hurr we’ll just take things case by case” nice job guys

10

u/glassmousekey Mar 07 '19

Please clarify the "protect the children" line. Fictional children have no rights. NSFW posts are tagged as such, so real children between 13-18 yrs. old aren't supposed to see them. Who are you protecting?

9

u/Theleux Mar 07 '19

Incredibly disappointing response, to be quite honest. This doesn't help these communities in the slightest.

Why don't you focus your efforts towards removing actual pedophiles... or dealing with subreddits that go way outside of the rules (watchpeopledie comes to mind), than dealing with FICTIONAL characters that do not exist at all?

9

u/Caridor Mar 07 '19

>The best guideline we can give you to help clarify this rule is that, if it would be creepy to post with regard to a human minor, please don’t post it with regard to an animated minor.

How does this extend to charactars who were under 18 in the show, but are very obviously, physiologically, different? Previously, it's been said admins use "canon age" to decide if someone is a minor, but this new advice seems to contradict that or else you could say goodbye to every porn sub on reddit, since all of them were at one time, minors.

9

u/notaburneraccount Mar 07 '19

Why are we punishing someone who posted a SFW picture because of the actions of the commenters?

9

u/frosthowler Mar 08 '19

You have managed to write five paragraphs and clarify nothing.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/JBHUTT09 Mar 07 '19 edited Mar 07 '19

I would respect you guys a lot more if you just came out and said the truth, which is:

We're trying to make a lot of money, and the general public finds these images weird, so they pose a potential problem in regards to getting as much money as we can.

But the fact that you are trying to preach this self-righteous bullshit from your high horse is just insulting. You're not protecting anything except your increasing profits. Stop lying about it and you'll get less push back.

Edit: Also, if you are acknowledging that this is a highly subjective topic where context is crucial and interpretations will differ, then you need to handle it differently than you have been. Permanent suspensions as the first response is not fair to users. Why not simply do what many mod teams have been doing for years? Just remove the post and inform the user. You get the content off of your site, and the users don't resent you. I cannot think of any downside to this. Do not punish as if this were a black and white issue when you are acknowledging that it's highly subjective.

→ More replies (23)

8

u/Shin_Ken-Oh Mar 07 '19

What exactly is the point of punishing the poster over the comments to their sfw post? It's not going to get rid of commenters who think underage anime characters can be attractive or stop them from posting "suggestive" comments elsewhere on reddit.

Would this eventually apply to non-image discussions as well? If there was some new hardcore ecchi anime featuring high school aged characters would the episode discussions be removed if enough people post "suggestive" comments about the fanservice and underage characters?

8

u/reseph Mar 07 '19 edited Mar 07 '19

Comments and contextualization matter. Even if an image of a minor is SFW, if the comments and discussion around that image are suggestive, then a violation is created. This is why you may have seen SFW photos come down under this policy.

I'm confused. You're saying if the comments from other users start to stir something up like that on a SFW image post, action is taken against OP/post instead of the commenters? We've already seen suspensions occur for posters as provided by this thread body. Shouldn't action be taken against the commenters and only them (assuming OP wasn't participating in the questionable comments)? If you're taking action against the post instead, aren't you just encouraging hostile brigading?

Gonna need some clarity on this, especially for moderators to understand how this is enforced.

8

u/Tropenfrucht Mar 07 '19

Hey I am totally not interested in all that Loli stuff but I have one thing to say in this regard, I'd rather have a potential pedophile release his urges/stress over fictional content than rather going outside and doing it with real children

Same with the youtube "suggested" playlist that has been exposed a while ago, I'd rather see those pedophiles have their conversations on a site where it can be tracked than on a site where actual childporn has been uploaded to

I mean if they get off to children that are not getting abused and are only dancing, its still creepy no offense, but a lot better than having those people engage on actual CP sites

→ More replies (2)

8

u/psychoscooter69 Mar 08 '19

Damn, Reddit has gone downhill. The stupid “good parents” and “morally right” people come on here and instead of ignoring or blocking the subreddit from their own view in anyway they cry and bitch about it and then the retarded fucks who “help control” content at the headquarters ban it instead of providing steps to help just those people figure out how not to view it. To you worthless shit heads who cry about shit like “loli”, get the fuck over yourselves, pull your head out of your asses and fuck off, and to the Reddit “officials” who don’t seem to understand that since they work in America where loli is legal as long as you don’t do it in the real world, please pull your heads out of your asses, find the nearest blunt object and ram your fucking head into it until you realize that YOU ARE BASED IN AMERICA. And then realize that people who are into loli aren’t pedophiles, because that would mean anyone into straight must be homophobic and anyone into furry must be into bestiality. I guess the best way to summarize this is that you guys are basically profiling your community, insulting us, and doing nothing but being assholes. Also, what the fuck do you mean “protecting children” with all the porn and the fact that when ANYONE goes on Reddit 50/50 and can see someone CUT IN FUCKING HALF? You are so good at “protecting children” I feel as if you’re as good at protecting children as Momo.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Cry_For_The_Moon Mar 07 '19

what a retarded argument, comparing drawings to real children, seriously?

Comments and contextualization matter. Even if an image of a minor is SFW, if the comments and discussion around that image are suggestive, then a violation is created.

Calling this idiotic wouldn't even be close to how laughable it sounds

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

Okay, I'll take this opportunity my beliefs on this topic, a topic that is very divisive everywhere, especially in more progressive spaces I often operate in. I don't think there's any problem with animated sexualized depictions of minors. I don't see how it harms real people. In fact, rightfully in court it has often been argued that it gives pedophiles an outlet that doesn't involve children coming to harm. Pedophiles are, frankly, people too. They need to be able to live in society just as much as anyone else, and stigmatizing and casting out will only lead to more children being harmed and understanding not growing. There's a lot of layers to this discussion, from how society views pedophilia, what is allowed by law, and the actual effects of animated sexualized minors. But I think this really just boils down to people thinking it's weird. I think most people aren't willing to think this through rationally due to a gut instinct that it's wrong and bad, even if they don't know about the effects. I want to hold that discussion if possible instead of just shifting the discussion to legality in different countries or other arbitrary meaningless concepts. I want to know how these images lead to children being harmed, and what the evidence for that is.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

There is NO law that enforces the removal sexually exposed cartoon fictional characters!!!!

Loli hentai is 100% legal in the United States.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/przem700 Mar 07 '19

Is this really the thing highest on your priority list right now? Drawings of not real people? Emphasis on not real. In case some people don't get it.

6

u/CeaRhan Mar 07 '19

. Nevertheless, it is in place to protect children and obey the law.

Ficitional children don't need anyone's help to protect themselves from something that can't hurt them. Please don't use that excuse, we know that there is pressure on you guys, but we all know there is no "protecting children" in this.

The best guideline we can give you to help clarify this rule is that, if it would be creepy to post with regard to a human minor, please don’t post it with regard to an animated minor.

This part says it out loud, as it is devoid of any common sense to anyone who reads it and there is no debate to be had about it, just like the fact we need O2 to survive isn't debatable. Just please be direct.

11

u/raydawnzen Mar 07 '19

it is in place to protect children

Very big thinking emoji goes here

→ More replies (4)

11

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

if the comments and discussion around that image are suggestive

What percentage of the comments or discussion have to be "suggestive"?

50%?

1%?

Is a single comment thread enough?

Can you define "suggestive"?

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Funktronick Mar 07 '19

Will I get banned for posting this sexy fan art of my 16 year old character sticky stickerina? https://i.imgur.com/alYeh4T.jpg

→ More replies (5)

5

u/AnimeSin512 Mar 07 '19

What's most problematic in my eyes about your statement is the contextualization through comments part. By your definition I could post a SFW image and someone could make a comment that is suggestive. Then I in turn as the image poster get a ban. This makes as much sense as YouTube over correcting and punishing content creators for commenters statements.

In essence I could go to anyone's SFW post, make suggestive comments and they'd get banned for a violation because the context of the comments somehow dictate the context of the post. That is how you just described the issue as. You're essentially shooting the messenger in this case.

Doesn't it make more sense to go after commenters in these situations?

What about first time offenses on posts? You don't warn and instead ban users. That's very heavy handed. There's a vast difference between Loli hentai which would more warrant a ban and the posts used in this example. Look at u/HoloFan4Life and his post. The admin repeal notes said they essentially stood by their statement and that his post was in violation but since it was a first time offense he got a pass. You find content all over the site that are just as bad if not way worse then a picture of Kaguya in a bikini. It was a non-provicative depiction of a scene that happened in the original medium.

I get that you can't be hyper specific as no two situations are exactly the same, but being super vague is also equally bad, if not worse. It leads to options for abuse of power and causing fear amongst the communities who just want to appreciate a medium of entertainment that is just something the admins clearly don't understand.

I would suggest you review your rules still and clarify. The rules you stated are too open to interpretation and no real clarification has actually been presented. I know the job of being a Reddit admin is hard as there are millions of posts and thousands of reviews that must be done but your current policies are hurting many more communities both including and excluding ones that signed this petition and hundreds of thousands to millions of anime fans that are Reddit users.

Not all anime fans appreciate or agree with Loli content, but censorship leads to oppression and should not be done unless there is harm being done. A good example is anti-vaxx movements are causing undeniable real world harm that is proven to spread disease.

Posted on mobile. Please excuse grammatical errors.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

Reddit is a bunch of nazis who pretend that their personal crusades are mandated by laws somewhere. They are a US company, and US law does not apply to this content.

5

u/JMEEKER86 Mar 08 '19

Nevertheless, it is in place to protect children

So the average age of Reddit Admins is <4, yes? Because that's when kids are able to tell the difference between reality and fiction. If we're going to start protecting the fictional children then how about we start banning Grand Theft Auto for promotion of gangs and violence or Game of Thrones for rape, incest, and murder? You're insane.

and obey the law.

It's legal in the US, where Reddit is located, so which country's laws are you trying to comply with exactly? Saudi Arabia? China? Reddit used to be big on free speech, but now you're fucking censoring cartoons because you don't like their legal content? Fuck off.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

What children are you protecting you dumb fuck

5

u/alien122 Mar 08 '19

Even if an image of a minor is SFW, if the comments and discussion around that image are suggestive, then a violation is created.

Ok I don't understand this. So if I post a a completely SFW post without sexualizing it, and other people come in and sexualize it, I'm at risk for getting banned? How is that fair?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/thardoc Mar 09 '19

this entire response is a middle finger.

9

u/brothertaddeus Mar 07 '19

Drawings aren't children. Drawings don't need to be protected and aren't illegal (at least not in the US).

→ More replies (8)

9

u/Kayroz7 Mar 07 '19

This should become the most downvoted comment in reddit history. What a stupid, garbage response. You could have said "We are doing it because we want to do it" and at least it would give you points for honesty.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/jneapan Mar 07 '19

Good job addressing none of the concerns the mods have so carefully laid out and giving the standard evasive answer that clarifies absolutely nothing. You should go into politics. How long until all anime subs are banned, btw? That seems to be the goal of your Chinese overlords, if one is to believe these kinds of conspiracy theories.

9

u/NauFirefox Mar 09 '19

This is an insulting joke of a response.

Clearly you don't appreciate the thought put into the post, or the confusion people are feeling. Otherwise you would have given the smallest amount of clarity to the rules instead of this PR nonsense.

I understand your policy has for a year extended to cartoon depictions, though generally mods and admins rarely clashed on their definitions. There was little issue because the mod teams subjective perceptions of what may or may not be ok seemed to match up with the subjective idea's of the admins. And while discussion on the subject popped up from time to time, it was a matter of 'nothing we can do, but we know the rules'.

Now we don't know the rules. In fact, your post has only made it more confusing. If an image is ok, but comments are suggestive it's a violation? Is that for the artist or for the commenters?

This is why you may have seen SFW photos come down under this policy

So as an artist, you're banning my work for people leaving creepy comments? In what world am I getting punished for other people commenting on my work on social media? And this is official rulings from an admin stating clarity?

So ok, even if what is or is not sexual is subjective as all hell, there are pornography subreddits here. So what's considered underage. Well in reality that's easy, you're 18, or you're not. But in art?

Yea turns out the laws of physics don't really apply, artists don't always list an age, and ages that are listed can clash with the art style applied. That's not even to mention non-human anatomy of demons, vampires, robots, aliens. If you can imagine it, it can be drawn. So what's the age limit on humanoid looking robots? What about demons? What about a demon that looks like a girl? What about a person who died and was re-incarnated, acts like an adult, talks like an adult, but is in a child body. What about super powers or shapeshifters?

The reason for all this drama lately was one simple thing, subjective opinions of admins and mods are now misaligned.

You have a rule that implys people are one of the worst types of criminals. A rule that is applied to real child exploitation. And you are applying it to drawings on a regular basis as admins to permanently ban moderators and frequent users, who have zero understanding of where your subjective opinion of what a drawn minor might be after you banned a pornography subreddit involving all adult characters for looking too childlike.

Then when we ask for clarity you say "if it would be creepy to post with regard to a human minor, please don’t post it with regard to an animated minor."

Did you miss the part about banning all adult subreddits and different art styles? Not to mention inhuman art that resembles people?

The rules are yours to make, we have to follow them. Our feedback can only go so far as words and votes. But for fucks sake draw a line in the sand we can actually see and that mods can enforce.

Don't say 'use your judgement' after perma banning several mods for not matching your subjective judgement and expect all the other mods to just wait to be banned when they don't fit your undefined rules next. All we want is clarity.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/oreopocky Mar 07 '19

Just say you don't like anime

→ More replies (1)

8

u/DurdenVsDarkoVsDevon Mar 08 '19 edited Mar 08 '19

protect children

brb I'm going to harm a child by doodling..

Edit: I did it. Children everywhere have been irreparably harmed. Throw me in jail copper.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/DarkChaplain Mar 09 '19

You're such a terrible hypocrite, it really gets under my skin.

You talk about protecting children and photos when it comes to 2D drawings, or even screenshots of official media, of entirely fictional characters. Your decisions are entirely arbitrary (one could call them an "asspull", really), inconsistent and often expose your ineptitude and ignorance of the "context" you call so important in your post.

These decisions are very clearly not made by somebody who is even halfway familiar with this medium in particular, let alone the characters in question. Not that I would expect this from site admins and moderation concerning only a single medium of art, when there are more shows, books and comics released on a weekly basis, year after year, than any 10 human beings could keep up with even if they had no need for sleep. But you are simply utterly out of touch with this form of media, the culture, the fandom and everything about it. I seriously doubt that you even understand the full meaning or context of the term loli, for that matter.

On the same page of "protecting children", maybe you could explain how it happens that there are so many resurging groups of actual pedophiles on social media, including reddit, and even Silicon Valley online publications, that are campaigning for "pedophilia tolerance" these past few years. There are literally people on Twitter, right now, sexualizing toddlers and calling themselves activists.

There've been more cases of real child molestation reported in the US the past years than in decades over in Japan, despite some pretty hardcore material being sold at conventions. Child abuse, both sexual and not, is a real problem in the United States. As somebody living in Europe, I cannot even laugh about how dreadful the state of things in the so-called Land of the Free has become. And yet instead of policing obvious hotspots of actual teenagers sharing nudes on reddit, it is fanart of fictional characters you are going after? For shame, reddit.

So what's next? Are you going to ban discussion of Nabokov's novel "Lolita" on reddit? How about those schoolgirl outfit wearing nude models, including professional porn actresses from the US with their twintail hairstyles and cheerleader outfits? How about all those sexual roleplay subreddits with their "daddies" in extremely explicit scenarios?

Your priorities are, to say it in good German, fucked.

And frankly, you are utterly foolish to claim that you have gotten better at detecting it. You're like an anti-virus program that claims one's entire Steam game library is infected - in need of uninstalling.

4

u/darthhayek Mar 08 '19

This is clearly just a pretense for further banning anything that liberals disagree with. Will you be deleting transgender subs if this is really about pedophilia?

→ More replies (10)

4

u/sc_emixam Mar 08 '19

Exept it's a fucking lie

4

u/Kibouo Mar 08 '19

Obey the law? Chinese ones? But you're an American company...

4

u/Triggers_people Mar 09 '19

So much for net neutrality and article 13 but you decide to make the same mistake with this absurd rule, this isn't to protect anyone but yourselves from your advertisers.

People cannot even post normal pictures of fully clothed drawings of children and they are getting banned left and right, so yeah good job on the censorship, I'll be dying to see the end of Reddit.

4

u/doctor_whomst Mar 09 '19

it is in place to protect children

It doesn't really make much sense to protect people who literally don't exist

4

u/Thromordyn Mar 09 '19

it is in place to protect children

Bullshit. They aren't real. Fictional content cannot harm real people.

4

u/manateesmango Mar 09 '19

Even if an image of a minor is SFW, if the comments and discussion around that image are suggestive, then a violation is created.

Then why can't you just remove the comment that is creating the violation? That makes no sense and can seriously impact the fanart community across dozens if not hundreds of subs.

4

u/IchigoRadiance Mar 10 '19

I think most realize just how B.S. this statement really is.

Over the past few years I've noticed something quite alarming in many of these popular sites, and that is how backwards their rules are. These sites put so much effort into stamping out lolicon artwork to some degree or another, and yet refused to deal with the more disturbing real life content. Users report it and sites do nothing or the offending poster gets a slap on the wrist.

Reddit appears to be no different where users have mentioned posts involving actual children where the comments were sexualizing said children with no consequences. Some of the content itself has been reddit has left it up according to people even on this very post whereas reporting such content on other sites would result in a swift removal and report to the authorities. If Reddit truly cares that much about children, why is such content and content left up when it involves actual children?

It's obvious why, because Reddit doesn't truly care. That's why Tumblr did nothing when people reported child porn on it's site, it's why Youtube did nothing when people reported creepy comments and videos on it's site, it's why discord has so far done nothing when people report child porn on it's site and all these sites do or will do nothing until there is some big scandal and then these sites do or will do something about it, but either they overcorrect or they focus on the wrong things, not actually fixing the issue, but trying their hardest to appear as if they are fixing the problem, and doing so in the cheapest way possible, like putting a bandaid on your arm when you've broken your leg.

It should be obvious by now that all of this is due to money.https://medium.com/@jbonesy/hang-on-whats-going-on-with-china-big-tech-61bd99716f68

Whenever one of these sites get a big investment from a Chinese company or try to break into the Chinese market it always seems to follow that the rules become increasingly stricter. It also explains why most of the content being censored seems to be the content coming from Japan.

10

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

Anime characters aren't real though.

7

u/feralshrew Mar 07 '19

I'd say this response reads like you didn't bother reading the OP before composing this, but I suspect rather that you do not care and that there will be no clarity because obfuscation is the intention.

I would really like a response to the question of whether or not this policy will be equally enforced on content featuring real life porn models that look underage, especially those who deliberately attempt to appear underage.

If a pornographic manga of adults dressed in school-girl uniforms is worthy of a ban, is porn featuring photographs of real life adults dressed in school-girl uniforms also worthy of a ban?

This policy is not clear at all as it appears to only be applied to drawings and explicitly NOT applied to photographs of actual people, which seems to be a completely nonsensical approach to implementing the policy as it is laid out. This is a large source of the confusion.

Please address it.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/SeethingEagle Mar 08 '19

What a joke, the admins have just jumped onto a terribly slippery slope. The harmless will be removed and the harmful will stay nice and comfy. Seen it happen over and over again, and now reddit is hopping on the train. So much for a “freer platform of expression”

7

u/Jawkess Mar 08 '19

So basically if one guy in the comments says "That's hot", the post could be taken down?

Aight

→ More replies (2)

7

u/cedehh Mar 09 '19

This... this answers nothing.

We NEED to know what constitutes a minor to you all now.

Schoolgirl is a porn fetish outside of hentai, posts are being removed just for being schoolgirl even if they look of age...

Rule34 content - 90% of characters are canon age 16-17 and look of age, the rules on that have been subjectively enforced and leave communities and posters confused.

We want to know if the rule is them actually being drawn to look underage not being allowed or if you are committed to randomly removing subs and users who post characters that look of age too now. Dont say that was the policy before lots of your anime subs came together because we are blindsided for a reason :/

You have been giving into mass reports bombs which is against site wide rules as well...

People are currently worried reddit is going the path of Tumblr, prove to us otherwise by explaining in detail how we need to mod our communities so users and subs dont keep getting banned...

You took the time to respond so please do again, so many communities and posters were counting on this response. And many had given up... Then now you do respond but answer nothing for how we can survive.

We all want to follow the rules. PLEASE help us do so.

→ More replies (104)

21

u/spaghetticatt Mar 01 '19

These post removal admin actions pop up in your mod logs, right? It's not hidden?

Just making sure I have this correct - this is mostly related to admin intervention about OC creator post removals and bans, and the subreddit ban? No repercussions for moderator teams for not removing the content, correct?

25

u/ShaKing807 Mar 01 '19 edited Mar 01 '19

These post removal admin actions pop up in your mod logs, right? It's not hidden?

Correct, this is concerning admin interference on our subreddits with no communication between admins and moderators.

Edited for clarification.

15

u/Liru Mar 01 '19

These post removal admin actions pop up in your mod logs, right? It's not hidden?

Honestly? It's a crapshoot. There are some actions that pop up in the modlog, and some that are quietly removed with no modlog entry at all.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/HandofBane Mar 01 '19

No repercussions for moderator teams for not removing the content, correct?

I'm aware of at least one moderator who was permanently suspended, though he actively posted content to /r/doujinshi and that was likely the excuse given.

→ More replies (5)

21

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '19

I'd love to see a public response but I don't think you'll get one. The admins are completely oblivious to the fact the bar they've set for removing fictional NSFW content is next to impossible to enforce, nor was it ever necessary to begin with.

→ More replies (6)

18

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '19

I feel like reddit thinks they can automatically dictate what anime fans think then they see these images. The vast majority of us don’t see anything remotely sexual in most of these images.

Sexualization happens in the mind, so when determining if something is sexualized you have to look at objective social morays. If girls are allowed to wear swimsuits in public and no one arrests their parents for creating child porn, then it should be allowed in anime. Unless something is overtly sexual (IE showing actual genitals/nipples, which seems to be the standard everywhere else) you can’t prove that it’s being interpreted in a sexual way or for a sexual purpose.

Really liked the point about the context too. Kaguya isn’t a sexualized show by any means. That was literally just a beach scene. Are animators supposed to draw characters wearing full clothes in the water? Of course not.

4

u/donkeynique Mar 02 '19

I think part of the issue with the beach scene type stuff in anime is definitely a perception thing. When we think of western media, underaged girls aren't typically portrayed that way in bathing suits. A chest forward, butt out pose, winking at the viewer with a slightly upward angle is not something that would be applied to minors as it's very easy to read as a sexually inviting scene setup. Kids don't have to be in full clothing at the beach, but the way the scenes are setup and the way the characters are shown off matters.

11

u/JMEEKER86 Mar 02 '19

Except you do sometimes have stuff like a teenage Ariana Grande dancing in a bathing suit while being hosed down on Victorious which air on Nickelodeon.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

35

u/AdministrativeWind0 Mar 01 '19

(Throwaway account because this is a controversial topic and I don't want to associate my main one with it)

A lot of communities on reddit are going to need to come to a couple of difficult realizations in the near future:

  1. reddit is no longer a scrappy little community site that just wants to host as many communities as possible, no matter what they are. In the last year and a half, they have taken 500 million dollars in investment from venture capitalists. That's 10 times as much as they took in the previous 12 years. This is not the site it used to be, it's a serious business now. People gave them a ton of money and they're expecting a return before long.

    As part of that, reddit does not care any more about the "principle" of hosting your controversial communities or content. If it seems like it has the potential to cause trouble to them, they will not hesitate to ban a bunch of your users, or quarantine or kick you off entirely. They do not care about the effects on your community or the aftermath. If you appear to be detrimental to the site and its monetization opportunities, they don't want you here.

  2. It is in the admins' best interest to clarify their actions as little as they possibly can. Every clarification is just a future restriction that will make it more difficult for them to act in the future ("but you said..."). They barely announce changes or plans any more, and respond to almost all inquiries with form-letter macros. If you're a subreddit that's hosting content that's questionable and requires a lot of clarification, you're almost certainly not one of the mainstream, profitable ones, so they do not care about helping you understand what they're doing or why any more. They want to deal with you as little as possible, and if it annoys them enough they will just get rid of you.

12

u/DurdenVsDarkoVsDevon Mar 02 '19

I agree, but in the past popular, mass efforts to change admins' improper behavior has been successful. Perhaps the anime community is too small, but goddamnit we should try.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '19

Bingo, you nailed it. They want to clear up the site further and further for investors and advertisers and could not care less about your communities; for all they're concerned they'd RATHER you go elsewhere because that solves the problem too.

I don't know why people are so surprised about this and scream about 'free speech' when Reddit are a private organisation who can and will do whatever they want certainly to secure investors. Not saying that I agree or disagree with their rules, but people need to come to a realisation that this is how they operate.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/garyp714 Mar 02 '19

It is in the admins' best interest to clarify their actions as little as they possibly can.

HR is not there to protect you, it's there to protect the company.

→ More replies (12)

48

u/thisismyanimealt Mar 01 '19

22

u/Sandtalon Mar 01 '19 edited Mar 01 '19

And Patrick Galbraith's anthropological work, including his PhD dissertation The Politics of Imagination: Virtual Regulation and the Ethics of Affect in Japan and his earlier paper Lolicon: The Reality of ‘Virtual Child Pornography’ in Japan.

These men and women insist on the distinction between actual and virtual, fiction and reality, and in so doing draw a line. This line is not always clear and clean, which is precisely why it is insisted upon and maintained through collective activity and practice. Opposed to virtual regulation by the state, fans of comics, cartoons and computer/console games in Japan speak of moe, or an affective response to fictional characters, and an ethics of moe, or proper conduct fans of fictional characters. What this means in practice is that they insist on the drawn lines of fictional characters and on drawing a line between fictional characters and real people. In the ethics of moe, proper conduct is to keep fictional characters separate and distinct from real people, even as fictional characters are real on their own terms and affect individually and socially.

Also the psychiatrist Saito Tamaki's book Beautiful Fighting Girl and the collection The End of Cool Japan.

13

u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19

I never thought I'd see someone else link to Galbraith's The Moe Manifesto in support of an argument, so I will as well.

In particular, I'd like to point to the third part of Galbraith's interview hosted by Pause and Select. Its always better to provide the opportunity for people to have an informed opinion, instead of a blind one.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (12)

11

u/Kicken Mar 01 '19

Thank you for these links. Is there a proper article regarding the first?

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Xiaxs Mar 02 '19

I think that it's absolutely ridiculous that people think there's a connection between lolis in anime and real pedophiles.

Yes, pedophiles like loli porn, and some have been caught with loli porn along with real child porn, but correlation, as FUCKING EVERYONE KNOWS, is NOT causation, and thinking so is, frankly, fucking retarded.

Do these people also believe fans of Black Metal burn churches? Or hows about video games? Does this make people murderers?

Anyone with a brain would obviously answer "no."

The crackdown on loli content is because "it's gross".

So are feet. Do you wanna ban feet or foot porn?

Or hows about blowjobs? Some girls are repulsed by the idea of sticking a unit in their mouth. Should that be illegal?

Even if they explain WHY they're doing it, it's still absolutely preposterous.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (18)

14

u/pieman7414 Mar 02 '19

Good luck, hopefully the admins will stop acting like they're giving you guys a paycheck or any actual compensation for your time

→ More replies (1)

13

u/xBrobeard Mar 02 '19

To be honest. This was never really an issue until they took money from Tencent. The chinese company notorious for censorship and pushed it down our throats. Just saying.

4

u/7InTheMorning Mar 03 '19

That's worrying.

As far as I know, all porn is banned from China, with varying degrees of people getting caught depending on whether the officials find it hot or not.

A lady even got ten years in prison for being a fujoshi. They actually have bounties.

Imagine if that shit goes west.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (14)

12

u/notveryhardboiled2 Mar 01 '19

"For the sake of clarity, we have no problem complying with the new standards Reddit has enforced on underage fictional characters. Content involving underage fictional characters (commonly referred to as “lolis” or “shotas” in these communities) remain a small part of the overall anime community, and we do not find it imperative to the survival of our communities to continue posting content that could cause legal problems for Reddit."

Well that was a fancy way of saying "fuck those people" Thanks for sticking up for parts of the anime community. The legal trouble is near non existent if its not real children. Loli hentai exists on many platforms no problem. To be told "Hey we will ban those users outright to save ourselves" Is literally no fucking better. A little worse if anything. Fuck you too guys. Expected better from a bunch of anime related moderaters. Especially places like doujinshi, azur lane, hentai, dragon maid and some others. Lolis are a core part of these things.

"Reddit does not want to be a platform where images of sexualized children, including fictional ones, are shared. We are more than happy to comply with this"

I am more than happy to apply to that rule to REAL sexualized children. 100% no argument from me.

I DO NOT comply with CHARACTERS who have a story age. Fuck that, not in the slightest bit. Could not disagree more. A character can not have an age and calling them children is, in my opinion, insane. There is no sentience, no feeling, no IQ. They are characters, they cant be kids. Voiced by adults no less.

If you feel its so bad quarantine the sub that features it. Thats it. Censoring to the point of a ban and outright blacklisted is absolute bullshit. Throwing a "small portion of the community" under the bus is disgusting.

There is nothing to protect. There is no harm being done. Casting out that portion is basically like saying we are wrong, disgusting and should have no platform. That is absolutely sick and I will never agree or comply to that. I honestly couldnt be more furious you mods banded together to say that. Its like getting stabbed in the back by people you trusted to help speak on your behalf.

Not even a "If we have to, we will. We dont agree with it" just "Hey whatever keeps us safe, will do"

So this isnt a decensor plea at all then. This is just cry for rule clarification right?

→ More replies (22)

72

u/HandofBane Mar 01 '19

I sincerely wish you all luck. You're asking for clear transparent policy from site admins who - at the highest levels - have shown they are mostly bad at communicating clearly with the userbase (there are exceptions, but exceptions don't make the rules). Tack on that the primary hiring pool for day-to-day gruntwork admins comes from one of the most puritanical sex-negative cities on the planet that view the most inane things as lewd, and you're facing a serious uphill battle.

44

u/BurntJoint Mar 01 '19

Yeah good luck indeed, but their puritanism only extends as far as the awareness of their advertisers goes since they seem to care more about anime children than the sexualization of real children right now.

Myself and others i know have submitted dozens of posts of minors in a NSFW masturbation subreddit to no avail. Take this post as an example(the post is SFW the subreddit isnt), in this gif there is a 14 year old and a 15 year old, as well as the comment section containing the source video which has several more minors included. The removed comment at the bottom is asking for fapping material of the 14 year old btw, thats a common sentiment left on a lot of posts with underage members.

Since none of the posts have been removed in the months since they were reported, and no feedback given to any of us who have reported it i guess its fine to create a subreddit that allows people to masturbate to real children, just not animated ones.

→ More replies (49)

8

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '19

Same. I've seen how this goes down (hell, anyone in the last few months can just look at Tumblr) and honestly the best option is to start jumping to an alternative before the site completely alienates the community. I'd be shocked if there aren't any that currently exsist. It doesn't even have to be perfect; just functional enough with constant support that it can grow.

The real problem is with advertising it. Hope the communities here can make a large clap for the right site when the time comes.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (17)

6

u/Poke_Mango Mar 02 '19 edited Mar 02 '19

Sadly you're not the first set of communities to be targeted like this. Something similar happened a few months back within the eating disorder support sub community.

Just like this, some content could be on the fence depending upon a given interpretation or precedent for enforcement elsewhere on Reddit. Even so the admins didn't bother notifying the moderators of potential issues and instead chose to seemingly at random ban full communities, quarantine others, and leave many worse offenders untouched to this day.

Many people have reached out to the admins, but we haven't gotten a proper explanation of what happened that triggered the bans & quarantines. I doubt we ever will. They simply don't care and don't have a reason to. They just offloaded any fallout to already overloaded crisis hotlines anyway. Two or three of the communities that have been left or were made in the wake did get some vague paraphrasing of the rules we already knew. Ultimately though it's left the entire community feeling ostracized by Reddit, constantly in fear of losing the already limited support systems we have left.

I hope they don't handle this as poorly, but whatever has been happening internally at Reddit has definitely caused some confusing and questionable action. And there's such a low chance of successfully appealing, especially full subreddit bans, that it's just gone for good if they don't decide to give notice and try to remedy issues first.

6

u/Tralan Mar 02 '19

Reddit band /r/jailbait - Good. It depicted underage girls sexually, and there are actual victims of this crime.

Reddit bans loli porn from the site - it's art and has no victims, but that's understandable because it's creepy and still kinda pedo-ish.

Reddit bans any depiction of underage anime girls regardless of context because someone somewhere might jack off to it - wait, what? So I'm going to get banned for posting a picture of a frog girl doing something awesome or funny because someone might see it as sexual?

Fine, I'm openly jacking off to every piece of art ever posted on Reddit, regardless of context. Art, in general, is no longer allowed on Reddit because I am sexualizing it. Statue of David? Banned. All memes? Banned. /r/redditgetsdrawn? Banned.

6

u/bossbarret Mar 03 '19

They won't reply. I belive so

6

u/cedehh Mar 03 '19 edited Mar 03 '19

Thank you! This needed to be said and visible in a big way. Its an absolute joke the way this has all been handled and very concerning... Hope for a response and clarity on things so all sides can move on without needless confusion. If the Anime community isnt big enough for a bare minimum response then can't imagine anything being so in similar spots. It would literally be less work for them if they told us how to do our part haha.

So 🤞🤞🤞 - r/CedehsHentai

11

u/KaBar42 Mar 02 '19

/u/cheetahsperm18 got banned again a couple of days ago.

Fuck the admins.

→ More replies (11)

10

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '19

I don't get this. I'm not into the whole cartoon girl thing but it seems stupid to enforce real life guidelines on it. They're not real girls. Seems simple and obvious. How do you determine if an image of ink and paint or digital pixels is "underage"? I don't know. I dont have a dog in this particular race but censorship is never a good thing as far as I'm concerned.

11

u/zenoob Mar 02 '19

The idea is that it might comfort people that are into this IRL that they're normal and ultimately make them act on their urges.

I'm honestly unsure if that's how it works. Countless people already complained about how absurd this train of thought is when talking about video games. And so far, I've seen more studies arguing that there is no correlation between consumption of porn manga depicting children and real life occurrence of child abuse...

It's honestly all for the sake of preserving public moral. It's an easy target ; a niche media already quite stigmatized where not a lot of people will stand up for it. Well.. until now that is, basically.
It's hard to justify your wanting to have access to porn manga or drawings featuring underage-looking characters because of how actual child pornography is demonized (and rightfully so).

Then again, you can easily say "fiction is not reality" but the fear of public moral going down the shitter is so terrifying that most people can't allow it.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/yamiyaiba Mar 02 '19

Here's a real confounding one. Let's say there's an anime series, and it features high school girls. Let's say they're all 16. Someone makes a porn comic (doujinshi) of the series, but starts it with a blurb that it takes place 3 years after the end of the series. Does that violate content policy?

If yes, why? If no, why? They're explicitly 19 years old now, because the author of a fan work says so. In original canon, they're 16, sure. But in this story, they're older. Are fictional scenarios of fictional characters different somehow than official scenarios of fictional characters? If so, how?

  • What canon is canon then? Manga canon? Anime canon? Light novel canon? Stated fan work canon?
  • That's great for stories but does nothing for single images. Would a comment from the poster saying "she's 18 in this picture, mkay?" have the same effect?
  • Rules could be circumvented easily but stating "regardless of appearance, all characters in this work are over the age of 18" then

This gets worse when you consider series where the characters canonically age over the course of it, growing from a high school minor to an adult over the course of the series. Is lewd art of those characters acceptable or not? They canonically became adults, but their ages wouldn't necessarily be explicitly stated in fan media.

Long story short, the existing guidelines'aren't even functional, regardless of anyone's opinion as to whether they're even right or sensible. That's the argument here, at the moment at least.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/JustiniZHere Mar 02 '19 edited Mar 02 '19

While I'm extremely happy people are finally coming together to raise this issue I fully expect Reddit to just sweep this whole post under the rug and ignore it, them making a statement here would be suicide for them and I think they realize that.

If they are going force these changes anyways there needs to be some real consistency. Loli stuff has always been under the microscope however the equally as bad Shota content (which is roughly child looking boys) hardly ever gets banned or removed. As of right now the rules appear to be Loli = bad, Shota = ok and that is horse shit. Either ban both equally or (ideally) don't ban either.

Not only this but seeing people get their accounts banned for absolutely nothing, people who have had accounts for YEARS with no infractions, is just unacceptable.

I should also toss my hat in here, I'm a mod over on /r/granblue_en and it's been really hard keeping on top of posts that we need to remove due to reddits new policy changes because sometimes people get banned for stuff that is not even remotely applicable. So far there have been no cases where we have had to remove a post but it's impossible to know how far Reddit plans to take this for the future.

5

u/Uncreativity10 Mar 02 '19

I have no idea if they are enforcing either loli or shota bans more but they are removing shota since r/heykidwannaSS was banned.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Valariel_Dawn Mar 02 '19

Seriously. I get that they dont want underage content. Although I disagree with banning fictional characters I can accept it. What I cant accept is banning all images of adult women who happen to have smaller assets, and the banning of clearly non sexual content.

5

u/bacondev Mar 02 '19 edited Mar 03 '19

As you mentioned, age in anime means very little (if anything) since it doesn't necessarily match reality. So one must ask, “Is the depicted person of the age of consent?” But how would one know the answer to that? Off the top of my head, I can't think of an anime publisher that publishes the age of consent in their material. So what else is there to go by? And this brings us back to the topic of subjectivity. It's going to come down to whether or not the reviewer feels that advertisers would object to the content in question. Advertisers don't necessarily care about Reddit's ToS; they simply care that their brand isn't being associated with content to which they object.

I highly doubt that you're going to get a response from the admins about this. Assuming that they don't respond, I see two courses of action. You can try to predict what the reviewers will remove (which of course isn't feasible) and take action accordingly or you can move your community to a different platform. Neither of those options are good. But I simply don't see any other option.

Personally, anime in and of itself isn't a topic of interest of mine. But if it were and I were to care about keeping my reddit account, then I would stop participating in the anime subreddits. When a post such as the ones that you mentioned (especially the third one) yields an indefinite site-wide ban, why would I continue participating in that subreddit at all? I realize that this isn't a happy question to consider, but it's a very well-warranted question.

6

u/Knofbath Mar 02 '19

It's going to be really awkward if we have to go back to 4chan...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/happy_love_ Mar 02 '19

What about petite gone wild? I like flat chested girls. I am not attracted to Children. On n-hentai almost any flat chested girl is considered lolicon. There is a fucking huge difference between how "lolis" are portrayed in manga and doujins and how children are in real life.

You would have to be an idiot to think that liking flat chested girls means your a lolicon or a pedo.

→ More replies (13)

5

u/SJC-Caron Mar 02 '19 edited Mar 03 '19

Two points that I haven't seen come up in the discussion so far:

Artistic Irony: Is it on the artist / poster to provide direction on how a piece of art is to be interpreted by viewers, or can the artist / poster just post an artwork without explanation and leave it up to the viewer to decide how to interpret it? Regardless, some sexually lewd works involving minor-appearing characters may present a valid (in the eye of the beholder of course) artistic argument that the two themes (sexualization and minors) don't fit together comfortably. And society occasionally needs visual examples of why something is inappropriate / morally wrong. A less extreme example of Artistic Irony is the work of Paddy on FurAffinity.net (need to have an account to see the works I'm referring to), whose thing is drawing cute teddy bear-like characters engaging in adult BDSM and fetish activities.

Fetish Themes: While enjoyment of fetishes does not necessarily have to be sexual, some of the same or similar hormones, etc. as sexual activity tends to be involved, so they often get lumped together, so that any fetish content is automatically considered 18+ / NSFW under the sexualization category. But it is vital that some content (including drawn and photographic works), particularly discussions regarding consent and safety, gets decimated to the pubescent teens that are curious about particular fetish activities. For the minority of teens that are into fetishes I cannot emphasize enough the importance of well moderated places like r/TBDL. Getting back to anime / manga specific issues, fan-art is a common expression for certain fetish themes, the tight plug-suits / body-suits that are the uniform for many mech anime are the most obvious example. Given the form-fitting nature of these suits, they tend to emphasize the breasts, buts, and groins of the characters wearing them, and a common tendency in fan-art of characters in those uniforms is to exaggerate those features, so that while the fan-art is not pornographic it would not be a stretch to argue that the fan-art is sexualizing the characters, and since a large proportion of anime / manga involves elementary and high school aged kids, are those fan-arts child pornography? In regards to the various 'mon anime, a common trope in fan-art is one of the show's main characters getting stuck in rubber costume of one of the show's main monsters. While this fan-art can be all in good fun, its themes are not that far removed from the very adult BDSM themes of rubber gimps / drones / slaves / etc. Another point; because many anime / manga are aimed at kids and teens, and given how animation enable silly exaggeration, these works can cause some of the minors viewing / reading them to be curious about a fetish-like scene presented in them. So they eventually find a site like TUGStories.com, which in its all-ages fiction section has many stories that are only mild-exaggerations of bondage experiences that kids and teens have been know to engage in historically. While the all ages section is very much non-sexual, sometimes a story author will mention briefly how the victim character's groin is reacting to the situation as part of expressing the character's emotional confusion, only touching on it again (if at all) when it returns to a normal state. The area in question is always clothed, but would this type of line in a story posted on Reddit (or an art-work of that particular scene in the story) make it sexual, and hence child porn?

5

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '19 edited Mar 02 '19

Well i feel clarification is good, i still think this rule change is something that should be fought tooth an nail. It was already a slippery slope with banning Loli/Shota, but we all stood by and said 'ok we understand', and now its gotten to 'anyone under 18'. These rules, well already difficult to enforce when it was just lolis, is now virtually impossible to enforce and is not enforced to everyone equallly. It seems to be just aimed at anime.

But lets say for the sake of argument, that the stance so many people want to take is correct. That everyone who has ever watched or enjoyed loli/shota content is a pedo. (this is obviously not true, but will 'accept' it for the sake of the argument). Fine. Now the issue is- "are these people masturbating to child pornography"- The common stance in this thread is 'they look like children so its CP' fine.. Know what, ill accept that as well for the argument. But even if i agree with those 2 stances. Why is it wrong? If you want to reply with anything about it being gross or immoral, then that is not a valid stance, that stance can be applied to any topic, if i posted a picture of a steak, someone out there would prob go "thats disgusting". Personal opinion should have no place in laws or rules, because once they do, you are setting rules based on what you as an individual feel and not on any factual evidence. Here is the real issue- the reason ACTUAL child pornography is illegal isnt 'because its gross' or because some people feel sick thinking about it, or because it makes people uncomfortable, its wrong because actual- real- children are being harmed. That is why CP is wrong. Not because people 'find it gross'. Because of the real world harm it causes to innocent children. Now, can anyone argue that 'sexual pictures of drawn children hurt real children', these pictures are all of fake people, drawn by adults, for adults- no where in its production or distribution is a child used. If you say yes, is that because you think people will see a sexually drawn picture and go "its ok for me to do that in real life"?

If that is your stance then that stance has been shown, time and time again to not be true, and many who prob say 'drawn cp is the same as regular child porn, and is harmful to children" fight tooth and nail for Murder in games, Violence in comic books, Rape fantasy or incest fantasy in porn. People on reddit tend to fight to their dying breath that video games do not make people murderers, or that their rape/incest fantasy does not make them want to rape or have sex with their real family members. There have been many scientific studies to back these claims. The exact opposite has been researched saying that taking out your aggression in a game, makes people act less aggressive in real life- its an out for some anger. (source needed) So why does masturbating to questionable content suddenly make you a sexual deviant, or make you suddenly a danger to others? And why is this one particular version of porn, worse than others. The real thing you need to think about is not -do i personally find this wrong/questionable/gross- its "does this content cause any actual harm". The answer to that has been shown to be no. And some people even argue that true pedophiles- as a mental condition- people who are sexually attracted to children- not by choice and those who do not act on their desires meaning no harm to real people- find an out using loli hentai. I get it, no one wants to defend pedophiles or come off as accepting of them. Because the actual harm done to real children is reprehensible, and even thinking of standing against that viewpoint is sickening to the individual. Yet no one is harmed in these drawings. This is even something the supreme court ruled for- that these drawings are protected under free speech and expression. And once you draw a line in the sand banning one sort of art, where does it stop. Its like we are seeing here, it went from "pictures of obviously underage characters", to now "pictures of drawn characters under 18", to "pictures of anime characters who ARE over 18 (in age and mentality), but look younger (often simply because of a petite frame and not loli stuff. case in point New Game. The thing about anime, and fantasy is general is Age is simply difficult if not impossible to judge.

Reddit has taken the stance of "this makes me feel icky so it shouldnt be allowed", and the next question is- where and when does that stance end, and how long will people stand by accepting it, sure its easy to stand by and accept when it doesnt involve you, or is of a topic you also personally find distasteful (which is what i did when the ban for loli happened. I said 'well i dont agree but i accept'). But will you when reddit decides violent video games or certain legal porn is 'wrong'?

5

u/Kicken Mar 03 '19

This slippery slope has already involved to include banning users for posting screenshots of legally obtainable and marketed goods. It's a bit ridiculous to assert that CrunchyRoll is peddling materials that support and encourage pedophilia, isn't it?

→ More replies (4)

5

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '19

Just like to mention that there has been an admin replying on newer posts on this subreddit but still nothing here so tbh I think reddit is just giving us the finger and will be ignoring this although I’d happily be proven wrong.

6

u/grizzchan Mar 04 '19

Personally I think this is too major to just give a one-line comment and leave it at that. They're probably (hopefully) discussing this topic internally right now.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Tankanko Mar 02 '19

If a drawing of a non existent little girl pisses off some dick head advertisers, when will gaming/anime/movies be removed?

Gaming shows fake murder and fake murder is just as bad as fake non existent children. After that I think movies and anime should be banned because they show fake rape/murder sometimes. After that I think even talking about the subject should be taboo because it might hurt advertisers.

I quite like Loli stuff (and hate real life children but like petite girls irl) and I'd complain more but unfortunately a platform can choose to do whatever they want even if I disagree with it. Hope one day shit like this stops happening.

7

u/computeraddict Mar 02 '19

fake murder is just as bad as fake non existent children

I'd say fake murder is worse since murder is the worse crime. And heaven help us if a game lets you kill a kid. That's a double whammy.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Archensix Mar 03 '19

The west has grown up with a puritan culture that thinks violence is fine but sex is evil. Although we did have the phase of the media posting "call of duty creates mass murderers and terrorists, but games are a lot more popular than lolis and anime so that was laughed out of existence quickly. Games are probably fine but who knows, maybe the US will adopt Russia's stance of banning anime period.

8

u/EquivalentSelf Mar 02 '19

I don't have anything productive to comment here, but I want to express my support and do my small part in bringing more eyes to this issue. Great letter, and I hope the admins resolve this as fast as possible.

4

u/FuckNewHud Mar 02 '19

Really like the post and all the effort going into it from so many subreddits. Still think the admins are absolutely out of their minds and shouldn't be restricting loli/shota stuff in the first place, but we'll deal with that when they bother to actually discuss instead of demand.

4

u/LegoSpacenaut Mar 02 '19

Apparently I just need an alternative to reddit. >_>;

→ More replies (4)

4

u/xylont Mar 02 '19

u/spez get in on this yo

7

u/computeraddict Mar 02 '19

He's gotta database edit more posts of people trashing him, give him a minute.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/RampagingAardvark Mar 02 '19

If I remember correctly this is because investors are trying to force sexual puritanism on popular media platforms the same way they do with TV networks. Not to mention the fact that these major media platforms are also doing their best to court China, which has a particularly strong view against anything even vaguely resembling pedophilia.

That's at least what I heard in regards to Discord, but since all of these companies are constantly in communication behind closed doors about their general shared direction and values, I wouldn't be surprised if Reddit is just following suit.

4

u/JimmySullivan96 Mar 02 '19

We believe that communication with the moderators is key: they have the best knowledge of their content, their users, and what anime actually is.

Ask for the help of moderator teams and don’t rush into banning users based on the personal beliefs of the admin on duty.

Exactly, couldn't have said it better.

4

u/ChronoDeus Mar 02 '19

Other quirky scenarios that could cause issue with canonical age ruling include characters that age over time

I'm going to go ahead and say this isn't a quirky scenario, it's actually a fairly common one. The obvious examples being series with time skips.

Goku starts Dragonball as a little kid and Bulma as a teenager. Over the course of the series Goku grows up noticably while Bulma changes little for quite some time. Goku gets married and has a kid, and Bulma later has a kid then gets married. More time passes, Goku's son Gohan gets a girlfriend Videl in high school. More time passes and Gohan marries Videl and they have a kid.

Naruto starts with him and his contemporaries as 12 year olds. Vague amounts of time pass before we get a few years timeskip, then more vague amounts of time pass and Naruto is 17 at the end of the series before the final timeskip to the years later epilgoue, and his contemporaries are 16-17. There's a couple years skip to the movie that explains how he hooked up with his wife, and takes him and his contemporaries from 16-17 to 18-19. Then another dozen years give or take passes to the spin off/sequel featuring Naruto's son Boruto.

Fairy Tail starts with most of the characters in their late teens, with Lucy and many other girls being 17. Varying and sometimes vague amounts of time pass, and by the end of the second anime series one and a half to two years have passed.

Sword Art Online starts with Kirito and Asuna having just turned 14 and 15 respectively little more than a month before. Two years pass and they get together when they're 16 and 17 respectively at the end of the first arc. More time passes in subsequent arcs, until they're just a couple months short of being 18 and 19 when the third anime series begins.

Those are just a few prominent examples of series which have characters aging over time from "under 18" to "over 18". Few of them have notable physical changes when they cross from 17 to 18 beyond cosmetic examples of hairstyle and clothing.

More importantly, most of those age changes are poorly documented at best. Fairy Tail gives a calendar but not birthdates, and infrequently gives an update as to what the current date is. Dragonball is much the same, having a calendar but only a few specific birth days some of which have conflicting information available. Naruto lacks even a proper calendar, much less proper birth dates. Only SAO has both a proper calendar and proper birth dates. The result of this is that character ages are poorly documented. Do a quick attempt to look up a character's official age, and you'll frequently find only their age at the start of the series listed, only the year they were born listed, or only their age at the last official update listed. So you have characters who turn 18 and even become parents over the course of the series with limited visual indication of that change, and a quick attempt to rely on looking up their age is of no help as it either lists an outdated age which never receive some sort of official update, or it expects you to be familiar with the series in question to know their current age. And they're popular series where information is easy to look up.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/EkiAku Mar 02 '19

While I won’t miss the clear lewd loli art, I definitely agree there should be a clear defined line for edgecases. As it stands, it seems like I can’t even post gacha pulls from Love Live School Idol Festival or BanG Dream as there’s swimsuit sets in both of those games.

4

u/JustAVirus Mar 02 '19

I swear at this point it feels like if we want to be able to look at anything remotely scandalous we have to make an entire new bloody country.

4

u/quienchingados Mar 02 '19

I wonder in which category fits ariana grande.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '19

So the translation is that reddit has sold out to corporations l got ya.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '19

It’s because anime is the next target of the woke crowd

5

u/kingdomofdoom Mar 03 '19

Nah. I'm very left leaning and progressive (right wingers would probably classefy me as an "SJW"), and I'm not in support of anti-anime sentiment or the type of enforcement the admins seems to be doing here. Anime memes and culture is pretty integrated internet leftism anyway.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '19

ITT: a lot of paedophiles in denial

it’s fiction

Why are you into such sick shit

if you play GTA are you a murderer?

Looking at depictions of children being abused is not the same as playing a video game. For a start, nobody sees playing games as a problem. Looking at children being abused is wrong

what’s wrong with a little girl in a bikini? You see them at the beach

Most of us don’t fawn over pictures, dude. I barely notice children unless I know them or they’re being annoying

→ More replies (14)

4

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '19

Bit ironic this post having a sexualised underaged anime girl linked in it

4

u/Monkeybreath85 Mar 05 '19

Lolis aren’t real, sexual drawings of them have no victims. Just as playing GTA and murdering civilians doesn’t make me a murderer, liking lolis doesn’t make me a pedophile. 🙏

4

u/EddyBot Mar 08 '19

Reddit admins pulling a Tumblr

7

u/Hamlock1998 Mar 02 '19

This is the problem with banning a type of art. Since art is extremely subjective you can never judge it fairly, so there will always be cases where something goes wrong.

It's not like real people where you can know their age and judge based on facts.

We live in 2019 and so many websites have decided to ban a form of art, but people are okay with it because they think it would normalize pedophilia if it wasn't banned. Absolutely ridiculous.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '19

Art can only be judged at the level of the individual. No person, no matter how agreeable, no matter how similar their experiences to yours, not even your twin, could evaluate it in the same way. A drawing which offends no one does not exist.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/littlecolt Mar 02 '19

And yet we still have hate subs full of racists, white nationalists, and literal Nazis. They incite violence and pump out propaganda daily. No bans for them, I guess.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/Aoi_Meowamori Mar 01 '19

Everything about banning/moderating loli and shota content is completely asinine. They're not real children, they're cartoons, if you can't tell the difference between fantasy and reality than that's your problem.

Fact is, cultural censorship is never on the right side of history. It's just one group of people sticking their nose into other peoples business and finding shit to get in a huff about. The right and proper people of society all gather around to pat themselves on the back for being so normal, while smugly looking down on those they see as abnormal. Does this serve any useful purpose to the world? Fuck no it doesn't, it's all just masturbation.

You don't like it, don't look at it. Easy. I could spend hours listing all the sit I don't like, but I don't because it would be a massive waste of my time. Go pour your energy into something actually worthwhile, because censoring drawings on the internet sure ain't fucking it.

9

u/The_nickums Mar 01 '19

Everything about banning/moderating loli and shota content is completely asinine. They're not real children, they're cartoons, if you can't tell the difference between fantasy and reality than that's your problem.

Reminder that children develop the ability to tell the difference between reality and fiction around the age of 4. Page 79.

It should be seen as a basic skill and yet so many people seem to lack it entirely.

10

u/jaman4dbz Mar 02 '19

They don't lack it, they irrationally believe others lack it. They want a reason ppl do heinous crimes. As violence to video games, they blame loli for child porn. It's absurd. These ppl are just lazy of mind.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (45)

6

u/talonofdrangor Mar 02 '19

I've kind of been following this topic on and off since Holo got in trouble, but I'm curious about whether there were any problems with images of *male* characters. I know I've seen people throwing around "loli and shota" together under one umbrella, but I think of the focus so far has been with female characters. Please correct me if I'm wrong.

I mention this because, believe it or not, there is a lot of material out there that has fanservice of male characters, and the whole "check the canonical age" thing seems awfully problematic. For example, Shokugeki no Soma's cast is mostly high schoolers, and many of those characters get stripped of their clothing at some point in a sexual way-- both male and female characters alike. Would this be against reddit's standards? How about Free! which features male high schoolers in swimsuits / shirtless? What about yaoi (a very fetishized genre) involving high school characters?

4

u/Uncreativity10 Mar 02 '19

They do care about the male side since they banned r/heykidwannaSS which was primarily a SFW shota reddit.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/rexteram Mar 02 '19

I don't think gilding this post would be the best thing to do because that is just giving reddit money, so here is some gilding from Chika.

Also, this is a really well worded letter that (I feel) is able to convey what most of the anime community is thinking right now. I hope the admins see this and we are able to find a nice middle ground as I do not want this to head down the path of other social media platforms.

4

u/ZaneDaPayne Mar 02 '19

The only thing I wish was there, but at the same time understand why it can't be, is something about how these new guidelines classifying art as childporn are ridiculous.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '19

Except for the part where they throw a subdivision of the community under the bus and essentially say fuck you guys and change their rhetoric from fighting censorship to "getting clarification"?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Rin-Tohsaka-is-hot Mar 01 '19 edited Aug 07 '24

dazzling full chop deserted hobbies dime worthless bells enter engine

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (5)

3

u/zdemigod Mar 02 '19

This is sad, but we are powerless, im just gonna sit by and whatever happens, happens.

I like Lolis, i don't like Loli hentai but I'm fine with it existing. But whatever what I or you think is irrelevant. We have no say in the matter.

3

u/zacksato Mar 02 '19

This is youtube adpocalyps all over again. Maybe just maybe: Because of millions of content to filter by the admins they just ban randomly.

3

u/rzrmaster Mar 02 '19

Honestly, unless they HAD to reveal anything, i doubt they will.

Ultimately, it is all about money. It isnt the small anime communities, which havent even been 100% banned, that keeps the lights on. this isnt a greap thing to hear, but reality is reality.

it is a pity there arent good alternatives.

3

u/Heavyoak Mar 02 '19

as I stated before, on the thread celebrating Holofan4life being unbanned, the reddit mod team should be more concerned with the IRL porn that is questionable and should stop attacking anime.

frankly, it just seems at this point that they want to evidently ban all anime content, as even the most "family friendly" anime has a beach scene in it at some point.

but watch, somehow, they will blame all "explicit works" violations (and the "loss" of advert monies) on anime and completely ignore the real life "potentially underage" or "implied underage" IRL porn thats all over reddit.

3

u/castiel65 Mar 02 '19

Basically, some people got offended (nothing new today), and they want to censor art based on that...

I 'm not into these things at all, but I don't see why we should censor it. There's absolutely no harm to anyone. If someone can't distinguish reality from fiction then that's their problem.

Should we start censoring tv shows about murder? We all know murder is illegal and it might make some crazy people want to kill irl?

Instead of progressing, we're regressing in the time when censorship was widespread.

3

u/nonanec9h20 Mar 02 '19

I’m glad I live in a country where the law isn’t idiotic and doesn’t treat fictional character like real people. If depictions of underage characters in sexual situations isn’t ok, then why is anything else thats illegal by law?

3

u/Sychar Mar 02 '19

A buddy of mine got banned on twitter for posting a lewd of Jeanne D’arc from the fate universe, I thought that was pretty fucked.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/YouAreFools999 Mar 02 '19

Hai, admin-desu.

For reasons completely unrelated to this thread you are now relieved from your mod position.

3

u/cl3nly Mar 02 '19

So I'm a bit late here but I completely stand with you and the other subreddits. I'm currently the only active mode over at r/rule34_comics and r/fancomics and let me tell you this has been the most confused and frustrated I've ever been with a "policy update".

I can understand and completely agree with wanting to remove shota and Loli content but for the love of God or whatever you believe in give us guidelines to follow. Please admins, don't follow what Tumblr and Twitter are doing.

3

u/gives-out-hugs Mar 02 '19

As someone with no interest in lolis or other such material i would imagine the admins are going off of a "if it looks underaged and is doing something or wearing something inappropriate for a real child to be photographed in, remove it" the first 2 instances in this post i would 100% expect to see removed if it was a real underaged person, it is not the category of clothing that is the issue but rather how much of it is worn and the purpose of the image.

That being said, admins are never consistent in their administration, see rules on brigading, the clarity of them, as well as the rules on harassment

I would like to see the rules clarified as a whole and then enforced consistently. The majority of reddit enforcement seems to be by people who also do other jobs and at this point we should have dedicated admins whose only job is to enforce the rules and not also do other prohects, admins who need no knowledge of code or back end programming, just common sense and ability to administrate the rules properly.

I wish you luck in your quest for clarity, but i fear it will end with a blanket ban on loli or shota material no matter how clothed or unclothed they are

3

u/DRC-W Mar 02 '19

The rule literally gives a stipulation to the effect of “If you’re in doubt about whether a post is a minor being sexualized, this rule applies.”

The wording of the rule is valid as is and can be reasonably followed. This whole post comes off as rather ingenuine.

4

u/Kicken Mar 03 '19

The wording of the rule is valid as is and can be reasonably followed. This whole post comes off as rather ingenuine.

Did you look at the examples given? The examples that, by all means, should not reasonably cause doubt, and yet people were banned for it? u/Constipat8 was banned for posting a doujinshi containing fully mature women, large breasts and wide curves, except they were wearing high school uniforms. There is no argument to be made for the rule being clear or consistent, as is.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/FatMeowXD Mar 02 '19 edited Sep 07 '19

deleted 0.6367 What is ^^^this?

→ More replies (6)

3

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '19

In the end its slowly ever online place giving the finger to anime so that they can appeal to advertisers who have no understanding and no intent to understand the community and the culture of it.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '19

You guys really have no fucking life if this is what you spend your effort regulating

3

u/CriticalGoku Mar 07 '19

There is fundamental issue here that reddit, and global society have to reckon with once and for all.

No matter how distasteful, images of fictional characters are not real and do no harm. Even the most vile drawings would think of ultimately cause no one to come to harm and their creation. Any arguments about normalization and encourage are specious at best and inherently unprovable because they take place in the human mind and are impossible.

Under this framework, fictional minors are not real, and depictions of them do not cause harm in any way meaningful enough to justify restrictive measures. They should be in general allowed, both because it is right in any society that truly values free expression and because, from an administrative standpoint, it is far easier to just allow everything than try to fine-hair distinguish between what is intentionally sexualized and what is not.

And no, i'm not a lolicon, I like my fanservice fully developed and all that shit, but I think it should be allowed, and I think people who rage against this sort of thing have likely betrayed the free-minded teenagers they once were.

3

u/ILOVE_CODEGEASS Mar 17 '19

In other words: pedos pretend not to understand the rules that are clear as day so they can sexualize children. gotta love how these fucking spazzoids literally replied to every comment them calling them pedos. fucking loser idiots

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Wwlink55 Mar 19 '19

Just a heads up, they totally are giving users account suspensions for inappropriate comments from others on their posts. Im a moderator for an anime game community and we had a user get a temp suspension because someone else entirely posted NSFW comments on their post.

3

u/wafflepiezz Mar 19 '19

The founder of r/ChurchOfRikka was just perma-banned without any warnings.

He posted this thread on his alt account: https://www.reddit.com/r/ChurchOfRikka/comments/b2ogy9/state_of_this_subreddit/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app

Rikka is not even a loli.

But because she “looks” like one, power tripping Reddit admins thought it would be wise to permaban the founder of the sub without any warnings.

This is ridiculous.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/NarshaBannedWaifu Mar 02 '19

I'm a moderator on several of the subreddits above and I got suspended on my account /u/NarshaBestWaifu about a week ago. And I haven't got a reason to my suspension, their help page cites that they would PM you the details of your suspension but at the moment I can't access my account because it says 'Incorrect Password' despite me reseting it three times, which leds me to believe it's related to the suspension. And it shouldn't be like this since as it stands, I am suspended without any word as to why, which is totally unfair to go even without a word.

I have already contacted support twice, with both times receiving non-answers and inaction on the matter, and further replies to said support tickets go unanswered.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/The_Crimson_Fvcker Mar 02 '19

It feels like they're enforcing Sharia Law. If the characters aren't completely clothed from head to toe, you're immediately in trouble.

Also the whole "Bans without warning" thing.

Look I know you guys want to cozy up to TenCent (the company who helped build China's massive censorship wall on the internet, and also conveniently gave Reddit something like $300mil just around the time this unfair treatment of the anime community started?) I get it.

But why would a website which has always been paraded as a free place where you could join almost any community, like a less toxic and more structured (and more respected) version of 4chan, want to suddenly act like a communist dictatorship?

→ More replies (3)

5

u/ZeusPandaJuice Mar 02 '19

And this is why reddit will die. One loli and shota ARE NOT ILLEGAL. There is no lgocial reason to ban it, especially if you're not gonna ban all forms of fictional violence or even the literal beastiality hentai subs, it's just "stop liking what I don't like" to the 10000th degree. I mean hell some UN members have age of consent around 16-14, yet FICTIONAL images are the problem?! Not to mention the furry community who literally pretend to be animals for sexual reasons yet that's somehow fine and loli/shota isn't? This is the SAME group of people that say traps are transphobic despite traps literally NOT being trans. It's not about the "community" because these people were NEVER apart of the anime community, these are the same people that INVADED gaming, comics, even table top games like warhammer 40k, to push THEIR agenda. Since the dawn of anime, no one in the community has been anti loli or shota, at most they said "not for me" and moved on. It's NOT about "legal issues" because it's literally NOT ILLEGAL for the same reason it's not illegal to depict rape in porn, because it's FICTIONAL. It's just a bunch of people that have "power" trying to abuse it and tell others what they can and can't like

4

u/Kicken Mar 03 '19

This is the SAME group of people that say traps are transphobic despite traps literally NOT being trans.

Whew that is a fun rabbit hole.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (21)

5

u/doodledude9001 Mar 03 '19

Everyone who gave platinum/gold/silver please don't do it again. Reddit doesn't deserve a single dime until they admit their double-standards and clarify/revise their rules.

4

u/HotPjama Mar 03 '19

People got banned for those? Seriously?