r/anime • u/babydave371 :Ej:myanimelist.net/profile/babydave371 • Sep 17 '16
[WT!][Spoilers for lots of mecha shows] The big fat mecha-mmendation post.
-NOTE ON THE SPOILER TAG: I’ve tried to avoid spoilers in the text and in the links, the spoiler tag was just in case somebody cried spoiler about a show that I haven't seen or a scene I'd forgotten is slightly spoilery. I just wanted to be safe rather than sorry. However, I’m pretty sure that there are no real spoilers, so don't worry.
Hello and welcome to my big fat mecha-mendation guide! This is the sequel to my ‘Why you should take another stab at Mecha shows.’ from about a month back. Hopefully this will give those of you who have yet to really get into mecha shows a bit of help. Up first I’ll just list some must see shows and then afterwards I have a number of different sections for various different types of shows, with more detailed reviews of each show and why you should watch them.
The must see shows!
These are the shows that are important to mecha history and will give you a good starting point.
-Neon Genesis Evangelion
-Gunbuster
-Gundam 0079
-Do You Remember Love?
-Gundam 0080: War in the Pocket
-The Vision of Escaflowne
-Space Runaway IDEON
-Giant Robo: The Animation
-FLCL
-Patlabor: The Early Days
Here are the sections so you can search
Hype
Mature
Thriller
The Most Anime Anime that ever Animed
Eye porn
Weird
Fantasy
Comedy
Sports
Romance
Misc
Now then, let's begin:
I want something Hype, a bit silly, and full of heart
This is split into two series each are 6 episodes long. So we’ll begin with Gunbuster.
- Quick Hits: Space, 80s, emotional, super robot, hard sci fi, music, animation, short, important
- Plot: In Gunbuster we follow a young girl called Noriko as she trains to be a mecha pilot to fight in the war against the space monsters. The first half is mostly world building while the second half is hype and heart.
- Pros: Gunbuster is one of Anno’s earlier works and is also the spiritual predecessor of TTGL, that should give you some idea of what it is like. It features such silly things as mechas doing press ups but it also features super hype fights like this. Did I mention that this show is from the 80s? Because it is super 80s and it is fantastic. The show itself has great animation and sound, with the Gunbuster itself being an all-time mecha design. The show also has one of the best endings of all time, I cry every god damn time I watch it. Also, Coach is an absolute boss of a character. Noriko is the bomb by the way.
- Cons: It does have a few drawbacks though: if you don’t like the 80s then this show might be a little off putting and there is a certain male character who should have been introduced earlier in the show.
Now for Diebuster
- Quick Hits: Animation, music, insane, super robot, large, mecha designs, short
- Plot: In Diebuster we follow a young girl called Nono in her quest to go into space and become topless, the topless are a special group of individuals who pilot mechs and fight space monsters. From there shit gets insane, like TTGL insane.
- Pros: This thing looks amazing; it truly is one of those shows that takes advantage of the fact it is animated. It is unsurprising really when you realise that it was directed by the guy who did FLCL. Much like Gunbuster it has a fantastic soundtrack, though this is partly due to the fact that they share a lot of the same pieces. Additionally, this show has the most iconic use of the Gainax pose, which is pretty fun.
- Cons: It tries a little too hard to make you remember that it is in fact a sequel to Gunbuster. It just lacks that undefinable X factor that makes a truly great show great. Not really helpful I know. Also, the ending relies a tad too much on Gunbuster. I don’t want to bash it too hard because I do love it.
Conclusion – Watch Gunbuster/Diebuster if you want something with the madness of TTGL but with an emotional depth closer to Neon Genesis Evangelion.
You’ve all probably seen this but I I’ll try and convince you last holdouts.
- Quick Hits: Animation, music, insane, large, super robot, twists, coming of age, mid-length
- Plot: The show follows a young boy called Simon as he finds a little mecha called the Lagann while digging near his underground village. From there we follow his quest, with some buddies, to free the surface of the earth from the reign of the beast men. From there things get progressively bigger and more hype.
- Pros: TTGL is sheer madness basically. Simon gets quite a bit of character growth, which is done really well as they provide reasons for this growth. The show looks damn fine all round, except for episode 4, with a stunning ending. The show also has a very clear art design so everything works together well. On top of that, all the characters are likeable and make you want to shout ‘Row Row fight the Power!’.
- Cons: There is a weird middle section that is totally out of synch with the rest of the show and is a bit slow. Another problem is that the show does feel like it sometimes is being stretched out a tad to reach the 2 season quota of episodes, to me it seems like one of these shows that really needed to be 18-22 episodes long instead of 27. Also, episode 4 looks a bit odd because it has a different art style to the rest due to having a different director. Finally, it would have been nice to see the character of Yoko handled a tad better.
Conclusion - TTGL is a really strong overall package and is perfect for those times you just wanna whip out the popcorn and watch some awesome.
Mobile Fighter G Gundam – dub advised (it is the perfect amount of camp for the show)
- Quick Hits: Insane, dumb fun, full of heart, music, art direction, mecha designs, long
- Plot: You thought Gundam was all serious war dramas and space operas didn’t you? Well let me introduce you to a little show call G Gundam. G Gundam is set in a world where the nations of earth have all their own space colony, that looks appropriately stereotypical. To stop there being wars all the time there is a tournament every 4 years called the Gundam Fight where each nation sends a Gundam to earth for what is essentially a royal rumble. The show follows Domon Kasshu, the Neo-Japan fighter (btw every country is Neo-XXXX for some reason). He, however, is only piloting the Gundam to search for his brother and to free his father, who is in custody for creating a super powerful Gundam called the Dark/Devil Gundam. From this basic premise we get a twisting tale that leads up to a fantastic last episode that is so full of heart it hurts.
- Pros: In case it wasn’t obvious G Gundam is very silly. The pilots have snap-fitting latex suits, the gundams are based on national stereotypes, a horse pilots a horse shaped mecha at one point, and in general it is a lot of silly fun. This is great because the show knows it is silly, this self-awareness allows it to have proper emotional moments when the time is right. The art style is super strong, with some nice transitions from people to mechs. It has a great soundtrack that is surprisingly huge, it even has some Cantonese rap in there for good measure. G Gundam is a totally standalone show, as it is in its on universe, so you can watch it even if you’ve never tried a gundam before!
- Cons: It does have some structure issues unfortunately as the last arc feels tacked on despite the fact it is really important, they could have cut the penultimate arc by a couple of episode to rectify this. Also, the first set of episodes feel and are fight of the week episodes, but they do serve a purpose by introducing important characters for later. Unfortunately, this isn’t apparent when you are first watching them so they feel like filler. Finally, if you can’t handle silly then this isn’t the show for you, sorry.
Conclusion - G Gundam is just a fun and wild ride with a ton of style. By the end you’ll be shouting the burning finger speech with Domon every time he does it, that should really tell you all you need to know about the show.
- Quick Hits: Music, hair, weird, J rock, long
- Plot: The G Gundam of the Macross franchise. Like every Macross show it can be watched stand alone, however for maximum enjoyment you should watch the original SDF Macross or the Do You Remember Love film. In Macross 7 we follow a colony ship as it travels to find a new world. Along the way it is attacked by aliens and so we follow the conflict between the two sides. The hero of our story is a man by the name of Basara. He is the lead singer in a rock band called Fire Bomber and is also a pacifist. So when the aliens attack he hops in his mech, shoots speakers into the enemy, and then proceeds to sing at them. Yep, this show is nuts. As with all macross shows there is also a love triangle thrown in there for good measure, which provides some great moments.
- Pros: The show is so different from anything else you will ever see that it can be quite refreshing. It has a bloody great J rock OST, I think I am correct in saying that the real life Fire Bomber is the most successful musical act to have come out of Macross. It has so great mechanical designs with speakers and stuff, which is neat. Plus Basara plays his guitar in the cockpit Personally I love the characters in the show but I know Basara is very much a love or hate guy.
- Cons: It is a bit slow, it should never have been as long as it is, and there is quite a bit of reused footage, especially at the beginning. Quite a few people also find Basara to be insufferable, as I said I love him. Plus, you might get a tad tired of hearing ‘listen to my song’ over and over again.
Conclusion - All this makes Macross 7 a bit like marmite; either you love it or you hate it. So give it a go and see if it is your kind of thing.
- Quick Hits: The most insane thing you will ever see, part episodically, long, music
- Plot: Another super-robot show that is just bonkers. The setup is that aliens attack the earth, from underground, and then we fight them with a giant fucking mech. The show starts off as a monster of the week show but towards the end builds up to sheer madness.
- Pros: If you thought TTGL was insane then buckle up chaps and chappettes because you ain’t seen nothing. This show is possibly the most insane mecha show ever made, for example in the first episode alone we have a sentient mecha lion, a boy who grows wings, a cyborg, a freeze ray made of fridges, a microwave cannon made of countertop microwaves, rocket rollerblades, a cape, a mecha train, and a guy saying "The percentages mean nothing, a courageous heart can make anything possible!". It is just lunacy. Our main character is a cyborg chap called Guy and he is your typical man’s man protagonist, like Domon Kasshu from G Gundam, so expect lots of shouting and arse kicking. The show also has a rocking OST, with some excellent character themes, and great mechanical designs, which is to be expected with a sunrise show.
- Cons: the first half of the show is most of the week kinda stuff. It does serve to introduce you to the characters so that you care for them come the second half but it does get a bit tiresome. If you don’t like wacky combination mechs then you might not like the final form. Also, it might be a bit too insane for its own good, occasionally it was a bit of a sensory overload.
Conclusion – Insanity, pure insane fun. There is definitely a reason why GaoGaiGar is sometimes called the King of Super Robot shows, with all the pros and cons that entails.
I Want Something Mature
Macross Plus – Dub advised (Brian Cranston!)
- Quick Hits: Animation, music, mature, AI, relationships, short
- Plot: Macross plus is probably the most standalone entry into the macros franchise, which makes it a great entry point to macross. The basic story is that our MC is a bit of a reckless chap so he gets reassigned to a test facility so they can get him out the way and so that he can push the prototypes to the limit. At this test facility there are two prototypes for the next generation of Valkyrie (the mech/planes that the armed forces use in Macross). These two prototypes are in competition. Unfortunately, the test pilot for the other prototype is an old friend of out MC with whom he had a serious falling out with after a certain incident involving their other friend. As fate would have it this third friend is also in the area managing her AI pop idol (yeah Macross is weird). So the show boils down to the three of them trying to rectify their relationship.
- Pros: The show handles this damaged relationship in quite a mature manner, which is nice, and this is helped by them all being adults. It isn’t a stupid thing, like someone stealing the strawberry off someone else’s cake, that caused the rift, which makes it more realistic. The show itself is drop dead gorgeous in the way that only 90s OVAs with a ton of funding could be, just look at this shit! The soundtrack is great, Yoko Kanno was pretty much told to do whatever so we ended up with a trippy electronic OST. There are some also some trippy visuals to go along with the soundtrack at points. The show is really easy to get into because it is only 4 40 minute episodes long, so you can at least spare 40mins to try out ¼ of the show.
- Cons: There isn’t more! The only real gripe I have with it is that resolution of the rift could have been better. It is still pretty good but it could have been better. Also, there could have been some better explanation of the AI stuff, though a lot of it is inferred so you always know what is happening.
Conclusion – If Topgun with a love triangle and some AI, plus amazing visuals and audio, appeals to you then check it out.
Gundam 0080: War in the pocket – Dub advised (it is just a really solid dub with some great performances, shout out to the drunk woman on the phone!)
- Quick Hits: Mature, short, child protagonist, mecha designs, animation, sad
- Plot: Despite featuring probably the youngest protagonist of any of these show, 0080 is one of the more adult shows you’ll find. The show itself is a side story set during the same period as the original Gundam 0079, which makes it an excellent entry point into UC Gundam. The show itself follows a young boy called Alfred, who is 11. After a brief skirmish occurs in his space colony, which is neutral, he befriends a Zeon soldier. called Bernie, who is there on a secret mission. From there we follow Alfred as he experiences war first hand and it is soul crushing.
- Pros: The show is a 6 episode long ova so it has some amazing animation, long live the bottomless pit of gunpla funds! The action is top tier, though sparse, and super brutal. The show has some really cool mechanical designs too, like the Alex and the Kampfer. Despite the brief run time you feel like you really know all the major characters by the end, making it super powerful. The bonding scenes between Bernie and Alfred are especially cute. A lot of Gundam fans consider 0080 to be the high point of the franchise and, given how much great Gundam there is, that is quite the compliment. Oh and it is a set at Christmas, just in case that appeals to you.
- Cons: Honestly the only slight downside is the ost, which is that typical 80s synth. It doesn’t hurt the show much, but it certainly doesn’t benefit it. I hate to praise a show so much but 0080 is amazing.
Conclusion – If you want a near perfect war story that is also a great entry point to Gundam then 0080 is the show for. Also, hamburgers!
- Quick Hits: Art style, animation, mature, journalists, realistic, short
- Plot: So Flag is very very different from any other anime you’ll see. The story itself follows two freelance photographers/journalists (one male and one female) as they document the peace process, one as an imbedded reporter and one working with the rest of the media, in a war torn country. The show itself is clearly heavily influenced by the wars in Nepal, Iraq, and Afghanistan.
- Pros: The characters are all adults who behave as people would and the organisations in the story have clear and reasonable motives for their actions. The show also makes some very astute comments on the nature of modern conflict and reporting on it. You might also have noticed Flag’s unique art style. Almost the entire show is presented from the point of view of various in universe cameras and screens in a documentary style, the cuts between scenes are often done by the closing and opening up of new video files. This helps deal with the fact that they seem to have had a small budget, as it allows them to use a fuck ton of stills without it seeming odd, and lets the bits that are animated to be animated quite well. This is also helped by the fact that the show doesn’t really have that much action, it is far more realistic in having long moments of down time with short frantic bursts of action. I kind of feel like I’m gushing here but I finished the series yesterday (at the time of writing) and god damn that ending is fantastic.
- Cons: Unfortunately, the mechs aren’t the best cg out there but they aren’t worst thing in the world. If you are looking for lots of action, then this isn’t the show for you. It is a slow burner, which is perfect for the story it is telling. Outside of the two leads, you don’t really get to know the characters too well. You know their general personalities and a few quirks but there is still a distance. Mind you, seeing as the story is only set over a month that might have been deliberate. Finally, this is another one of those shows that just lacks that undefinable spark that separates the truly great shows.
Conclusion - Overall, Flag isn’t going to go down as an all-time great but it is a very solid and very adult show that everybody should give a shot. If nothing else, it is worth seeing for the visuals alone.
Blue submarine no-6 - Sub recommended (purely so you can understand what the fuck sharkman actually says)
- Quick Hits: Environmentalism, animation, art style
- Plot: We start off at the end of the world and a very watery end at that. Sea levels have risen and sentient beastmen from the sea are attacking humans. In all this an old vet is called back into service aboard the titular submarine in order for them to carry out a last ditch plan. From here we learn about both sides in the conflict and how might not be what they first appear to be.
- Pros: Grey morality everywhere! This show gives everyone a good reason for why they fight, making things nice and complicated. Sharkman is great, saying more would be spoilers. It has a really cool art style, the beastmen look really cool. The animation is really good for the most part.
- Cons: I didn’t find any of the human characters hugely interesting outside of our MC. There is some super wonky CGI, this shit is dire sadly. The OST is a mixed bag for me personally. The tracks are pretty much all good in their own right but I personally feel that the jazzier tracks don’t quite fit right. Though that could just be me.
Conclusion – A short series with an interesting story and art design but some wonky cg and some ill-fitting songs.
I want a thriller
Gundam 00 – Yes I know it may not fit precisely in as a thriller but I thought it the best fit.
- Quick Hits: Terrorism, animation, realistic future, long
- Plot: In the future, different nations have united to form 3 different nations, all three of which have access to solar technology. However, those countries that were once reliant on fossil fuels are now in poverty. These countries are engaged in years of warfare and internal strife over the control of solar energy. In the midst of this, a paramilitary group called Celestial Beings vow to use their supremely technologically advanced mobile suits called Gundams, in order to end war (pretty ironic eh?). The story follows Celestial Being and their attempts to do so.
- Pros: It feels like a very relevant commentary on a modern socio-political world which was very heavily influenced by the events of 9/11. Great action scenes. Feels more rooted in realism compared to other entries in the Gundam Franchise. Gundam Meisters feel very fleshed out (your liking of them will vary though). 1st Season- feels more terrorism based, 2nd Season- God based, Movie- Human nature based. Animation is really good and the mobile suit designs are really awesome. It also has some interesting themes with religion, terrorism and environmentalism being discussed.
- Cons: A lot of focus on Setsuna (the MC) and his mobile suit (his suit gets massive upgrades compared to everyone else) and not enough on his comrades. Series can feel incredibly inconsistent. The movie is pretty terrible honestly. Antagonists can be quite boring. Can be a bit too melodramatic at times. Saji and Louise are boring and their exclusion from the series would not hurt.
Conclusion – 00 is a modern version of Wing that is better in almost every way. It does have some problems but is really worth a watch if that style of show is your thing. Plus, it actually has something to say!
Thanks to /u/Hyoizaburo
- Quick Hits: Dirty, action packed, the 80s, revenge, outside the mecha, short
- Plot: A standalone spinoff of the VOTOMS series. The show is a revenge action-thriller as the MC takes down the people who got his squad mates killed. The show is interesting as the MC doesn’t pilot a Mecha, instead he fights mechs on foot.
- Pros: The show is fairly unique in its setup as I can only think of one other show that features our protagonist fighting mechs on foot but even he eventually gets in a mech. The show has a really grimy and earthy aesthetic that suits the story to a T. Our main character is a bit of a badass, unsurprisingly, and seeing what clever plan he’ll come up with this time is always fun. Mellowlink is animated at an above average rate, with no CG. It won’t blow your mind but it is certainly a step up from the average series. The show is a short and simple revenge tale that really works, and is a good intro to the enormous VOTOMS franchise.
- Cons: The art style and the music are very of their time, which may put off some people (for reasons I still fail to understand. The somewhat episodically nature of the show can also be a turn off as I know episodic shows are not everyone’s cup of tea. Finally, the villains can be a bit too much ‘we are the evil dudes mwuhahaha’. Though there are some quite interesting ones.
Conclusion – Mellowlink is a simple revenge tale that gets the job done. It is gritty, dirty and totally badass. Basically Rambo fighting mechs with a huge gun.
- Quick Hits: College aged, mecha design, terrorism, small mechs
- Plot: The world was controlled by an evil government but they were overthrown by a rebel group that has now replaced them. In Japan the new University year is about to begin and our MC, Rin, is about to start. She is an ex-ballet dancer that was forced to quite due to injury and is missing it in a major way. While at Uni she discovers the RideBack club. RideBacks are a motorbike-mecha hybrid that have yet to gain any real popularity among civilians. She tries one out and loves it. It helps that her ballet training helps her to become a good rider. From here a lot of stuff happens with the government and rebel elements in Japan. This is another one that isn’t really a thriller but this is the section it best fits in.
- Pros: It has a university aged student hooray! That makes like 4 shows ever? Jokes aside, it is nice to having characters from such an under represented age group. It also means that you don’t have that voice in the back of your mid asking ‘where the hell are these children’s parents?’. Rin herself is a pretty good character with some interesting moments. The side characters are basic but solid. The mechanical design of the Rideback is really cool as there is nothing else like it and with some minor adjustments one could see these things existing, figuring out how the arms would be controlled is the issue.
- Cons: Some things in the show are left unexplained, most importantly the details of a major incident are never really revealed. On top of that is a bit of a stretch for things to escalate as they do in the show, you have to just go with it. Rideback really wants you to care about a character called [Suzuri]9 http://imgur.com/AHxTZSw) and I’ll be honest I found her insufferable. Finally, some people might have issue with the CG used for the RideBacks. I got used to it but I have to admit it isn’t wonderful.
Conclusion – RideBack is very different from other mecha shows with its mech and characters. It is a fun little show but it is lacking is a couple of places that really hold it back from being something special.
- Quick Hits: Sad, mid length, character drama, OP
- Plot: 15 kids on holiday find a guy who is developing a robot game and he wants them to test it. Needless to say things are not what they seem to be. Really the robot could be just about anything, it is just a plot device to tell this bleak tale.
- Pros: The characters really are the high point of this show, this show could also be considered as just a character drama, each has their own voice and story to tell. The Op is also worth noting as it is pretty damn good.
- Cons: The visuals are solid but nothing to write home about, not that it matters much for this kinda show. Very depressing, which is turn-off for some. It could be argued that the characters maybe act a little too old for their age, but this is anime so you should be used to it.
Thanks to: /u/condoriano_ismyname
I Want the Most Anime Anime that ever Animed
Full Metal Panic – Dub advised (It is just great, apart from that one glasses girl, and is especially good for the fumoffu season.)
- Quick Hits: Everything under the sun, long, funny, animation
- Plot: Full Metal Panic might just be the most anime of all anime. The setup of the show is that a child soldier is assigned to protect a high school girl from being kidnapped by the baddies because she has supernatural knowledge of future tech. From here the show alternates from being a fish out of water high school show to being a serious military action show with a romance.
- Pros: The show has almost every single damn trope in the book. It has mecha, high school, tsundere, child soldiers, hot springs, beaches, blue haired girls, an evil guy who just won’t die, super natural stuff, and more! Some might think this a bad this a bad thing but it really isn’t as almost every single one of these tropes is pulled off to perfection and the combination of them al gives it a fresh feeling. The two different sides of the show, serious mecha and high school comedy, should cause some serious tonal whiplash but, in my opinion, this doesn’t happen because the main character is this serious child soldier the whole time, hence the fish out of water stuff. He is the connecting thread that confirms the seriousness of half the show and the comedy of the other half, it is kind of genius really. Speaking of the main character, I love him to bits. He is just so lovable! The main gal is pretty great too, my kind of tsundere. The show itself is very pretty to look at, especially the second and third seasons. One important note to make is that the entire second season is a comedy show, basically it takes the high school bits and runs rampant with them. This is not a bad thing though as ‘Full Metal panic? Fumoffu’ is bloody hilarious and is certainly up there as one of the best anime comedies of all time.
- Cons: Sadly, the music is mostly average outside of a few tunes. Another negative that must be noted is that the show sadly doesn’t end, in fact it leaves on a big ass cliff hanger. However, we are getting a new Full Metal Panic series in the near future so hopefully they continue where the original left off or cover the whole thing from the beginning. If you don’t like anime that is very well…anime then this is not the show for you.
Conclusion - So if you want a show stuffed with all the tropes that is somehow pretty great hit up Full Metal Panic!
- Quick Hits: Terrorism, supernatural, mind games, off the rails, Ops, twists
- Plot: Code Geass is yet another show with all the tropes that somehow works. The show follows one Lelouch as he attempts to free Japan, from the iron grip of the Britannian Empire, with his magical hypnotic eyes. It does get a bit more complicated than that, especially in the second series but this is still the basic plot.
- Pros: The show has some great mecha action, with a large variety of different weapons and abilities, and it has some great Gundam shout outs, in the form of Kallen ‘Kasshu’ Stadtfeld and the Char kick. The story is a great thrill ride with some clever twists in the first season and dumb but fun ones in the second season. Most of the characters are fun a loveable, especially one Orange, and I personally love their character designs, though I can see why the noodle nature of the designs might put people off. The mechanical designs are pretty great, as per usual for Sunrise, and of course they are animated fantastically. The series has a fairly strong ost, not the best in the world but there are some really memorable tracks, and some great OP songs. Additionally, most people agree that the show has a fantastic ending, though I personally fall in the opposite camp of thinking it is a bit silly and stupid (Sorry!).
- Cons: A big issue with the show is the entire second season. The second season was clearly being written as they went along, and I believe that interviews confirm this though I may be wrong, so it has a lot of really stupid twists and stuff in it. That is not to say the show isn’t fun, as it remains entertaining throughout its run. However, if you are a person with a low acceptance of bullshit then Cods Geass may not be for you.
Conclusion - Code Geass is a great thrill ride that is fairly clever in the first half and is fun but dumb in the second half. As long as you can just go with the second half’s absurdity then you’ll be golden.
I Want an Epic Space opera
Gundam 0079 + Universal Century Gundam main story
- Quick Hits: Long, war is hell, supernatural, great villain, a goofy side, coming of age, music, important, Tomino, mecha design
- Plot: We start with the big daddy of mecha shows: Gundam. The original mobile suit gundam is a fantastic show that follows Amuro and the crew of the White Base as the fight the Zeon during the One Year War. 0079 is very much a ‘war is hell’ type story, with various characters breaking down or running away.
- Pros: Depite having mechs 0079 is in many ways one of the more realistic war anime out there. On the whole the individual soldiers on each side are good people fighting for their freedoms and their perceived good, while it is the leaders who are the bad people with ideological motives. This combined with the war is hell aspect actually gives the show a great deal of grounding. 0079 is also noted for its fantastic characters. You get great characters like Bright Noa, Amuro Ray, Sayla Mass, Ramba Ral, and of course the one and only Char Aznable. All these characters have complex motivations and influences that make them interesting. On the visual side 0079 has its ups and downs. The character designs are fantastic, with each character having a distinct facial design and body, and a lot of the visual directing is fantastic, especially the newtype sequences. It has some fantastic mechanical designs, such as the Zaku and the titular Gundam, though there are some terrible ones as well, more on that later. Another area of strength is the sound design of the show with an ost filled with classics and some great sfx.
- Cons: Unfortunately, some of the mechanical designs look a bit pants, looking at you Zakrello. In addition, a lot of the non-mecha mechanical designs are very much of their time, especially the zeon fighter planes. As an admitted Gundam fanboy I enjoy the silliness of some the mechanical designs, as the Gundam franchise has always had a bit of a silly side, but I can certainly see why some people would be put off. Also, some of the animation is a bit wonky to say the least, though it does feature some fantastic animation at times especially in the movies. The whole newtype stuff could put people off as it strays away from the more real robot side of gundam.
Conclusion – 0079 is one of the most influential anime of all time and it isn’t hard to see why. The show has a fantastic plot and some excellent characters. It also laid down the foundation of the real robot genre. You can watch 0079 in two different ways: the series or the movie trilogy. The series provides better character work and feels grand because it is a long show but it does feature some wonky animation, a bit of a rushed ending, and a middle that I felt was slow. The movie trilogy fixes pretty much all of these problems and is generally accepted as an equally good way of viewing the story, even if the pacing in the first film is a bit off. So go watch 0079, it is great!
Once you have finished 0079 you can move onto Zeta, ZZ, and Char’s Counterattack. I won’t go into detail here but these series/film are also great, though ZZ can be a bit hit or miss for people.
SDF Macross + Do You Remember Love?
- Quick Hits: Love triangle, mecha/planes, transforming, idols, OP, important, animation, long, mecha design
- Plot: Aliens attacking, pop idol singing, and a mech pilot stuck in a love triangle. This is pretty much all you need to know about Macross, but don’t worry I will explain more. The SDF Macross is a space ship that humanity repairs and as it makes its maiden voyage aliens attack. The Macross then warps to escape and ends up at the other side of the solar system. From here we follow it as it makes its way back to earth and as it tries to stop the alien threat. However, this is not all! Alongside this military plot we have the plot of an idol who becomes a huge celebrity on the Macross and her romance with a pilot. Yep, Macross is a weird franchise, but that is why we love it.
- Pros: The mechanical designs, though, are great. The transformable Valkyrie is a classic of mech design, with it being a humanoid shape one moment and a fighter jet the next. The OST is also pretty fab, with the op being one of the best things ever. It has some really enjoyable characters, such as the genius pilot Max, that keep you invested. It has unique twist, with its themes around culture that provide for interesting viewing.
- Cons: Unfortunately, the show has not aged well visually. It looks really bad at times, eyeless people are not uncommon, and the animation is quite stiff. This does mean there are some really well animated fight sequences but I don’t really think it was worth it. The show also suffers from the first arc having a bit of a lull in the middle and a poor second arc that didn’t really need to be there. Luckily, all the problems with the series are fixed by the movie version, ‘Do You Remember Love’. The film just looks amazing and it sound amazing too. It has so many iconic shots in it that it hurts! The film also changes the story quite a bit, keeping it fresh for viewers of the series. Sadly, for the sake of brevity, the show cuts out a lot of character moments, especially with Max.
Conclusion - Overall, both the series and the film are great, but weird, space operas. The film is most definitely the better of the two but really should be seen after the series to get the most out of it.
Continued in the comments
16
u/babydave371 :Ej:myanimelist.net/profile/babydave371 Sep 17 '16 edited Sep 17 '16
Macross Frontier
Thanks to /u/Hyoizaburo
Gundam SEED – Note I have only seen about half the series, so take what I say with a pinch of salt.
Conclusion – A slightly worse 0079 with more modern visuals. So if you really can’t hack how 0079 looks for some reason give SEED a go, as it is still pretty good. I personally don’t like the character designs. They are that mid-2000s pretty boy type where they basically all look the same except for hair and clothes.
Space runaway IDEON
Conclusion – Ideon is a Tomino classic full of great characters and interesting plot points. The show is certainly not happy but this is done with a purpose. If you can get over those early episodes then Ideon is a great show to watch, especially considering how important it is to anime history. Be sure to watch the series till episode 38 then watch ‘Be Invoked’ instead of episode 39.
I want some Eye Porn
Break Blade – Sub recommended (The dub voices all feel a tad too young, I guess the voice actors are so used to voicing teenagers that it can be hard to switch. Plus, the sub cast is pretty stellar.)
Conclusion – Break Blade is a really solid show that is spectacular to look at. It nails all of the fundamentals, but sadly stops at that. It is still a great series though and well worth watching, just be sure to watch the film series and not the TV re-edit.
8
u/Are_you_daft Sep 17 '16 edited Sep 17 '16
I was praying this would be written by somebody who knew what they were talking about and it seems like you do! This write up represents a lot of time and effort and is quite thorough in its scope (
although I'm a little miffed you mention two Takahashi works and neither were VOTOMS!).Oops, looks like I caught the post before you finished posting the comments!Excellent work!
Addendum: I think a lot of 0080's impact comes from the contrast it poses against the backdrop of violence in the rest of UC Gundam. I'm not sure it would be as critically acclaimed if taken out of that context and watched by itself.
Edit: Now that I'm seeing all of the comments, I have to say it would have been a better idea to post this in bite sized pieces than all at once. Only somebody extremely invested in delving into Mecha would take the time to go through so much information all at once, and I don't think that's the intended target audience for your post.
8
u/Fluffyyqtasdf :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Fluffyyqt Sep 17 '16
PTW INTENSIFIES
I was actually looking for a mech show to watch, so i guess i have a few choices.
18
u/Taiboss :Fj::Fl:x7https://anilist.co/user/Taiboss Sep 17 '16
Just telling you that this is making me wanna not read your WT. Just so you know. A WT should be without spoilers, unless they are First-episode spoilers.
4
u/Autolycan Sep 17 '16
I saw RideBack recently based on a previous thread concerning mecha and I have to say I really liked it. The MC was great and I really wanted to know more about her and her growth with the RideBacks. I hated that RideBack. But her excitement, her design, and her story were fascinating. Would recommend that one.
3
u/PSninja Sep 17 '16 edited Sep 17 '16
If you are going to use multiple comments, at least put them all under the same comments family. It gets harder to follow everything like the way it is now.
2
u/schglobbs Sep 17 '16
A WT! with a spoiler tag? wut. But I applaud your effort on the detailed writeup, I've saved the thread for future reference! Also cheers for mentioning Nadesico!
Re: the cons you have listed for it, I thinks stuff like music is too subjective to be listed as a con unless it's awful, and Nadesico's totally is not.
It seems like most of the ost is taken off youtube otherwise I'd have linked to a few of them which I consider exceptional.
2
u/lilvon Sep 18 '16 edited Sep 18 '16
Holy shit you did a REALLY great job! As a huge Anno fan i loved & agreed with just about everything you had to say, especially Gunbuster. You remind me a lot of my best friend who is also a HUGE Gundam fanboy. But i need to get something off my chest
I AM NOT A GUNDAM FAN
Or maybe its more accurate to say Im not a Tomino fan. I think new types are stupid & 9 times out of 10 detract from the series when they show up. I also hate the forced drama, deaths from stupid misunderstandings, & they way Tomino slaughters women left & right(my friend tells me this is because his wife cheated on him or something, idk)
00
I think 00 is enjoyable but very lacking even tho it is VERY relevant. (And yes that movie is TERRIBAD i downloaded it to watch with my Gundam loving best friend & he admittedly fell alseep. It was long & boring) Again the plot is super relevent & the Gundams are super cool even if a bit OP at 1st. Setsuna almost killed the show for me. Friend forced me to watch the english dub. Eventually Setsunas antics became laughable I also enjoyed Saji & watching his GF develop. Tho I do feel at times they only showed up simply to remind us that they existed, overall i enjoyed what they brought to the show. Also the Princess is the most Japanese looking middle eastern lady ever. Also the second half is weaker because of "New-Type-Bullshit"(a running joke phrase between me & my friend now) and other plot reasons that are spoilers.
War in the Pocket
The 1st Gundam series I've watched as an adult. I hadn't seen any Gundam since I was a kid watching Toonami & since my best friend owns damn near 20 different series We set out to rectify that. Watching this 1st was a mistake & almost made me swear off Gundam forever. The plot is kinda dumb, characters are either dumb, annoying or both(especially the kid) commits the standard Gundam sin of accidental/misunderstanding deaths. only saving grace is that theirs no New-Type-Bullshit. One of the things people like about it is that it does the whole casualties of war/war is hell thing but presents it through a childs eyes so that's interesting but not enough to redeem its myriad of short comings. Oh and the holographic DVD case is nice.
Star Dust memories
Gonna make this quick does a lot of the same stupid shit War in the pocket does with shitty characters that don't make sense. Friend had lost the DVD set so i never got to watch the last 2 episodes but by this point i didnt care to watch the rest. Only redeeming factors are the cool suits & Gato. I don't remember if their was any New-Type-Bullshit but it really doesn't matter it's a shit show either way. :P
Iron Blooded Orphans
BEST GUNDAM! The Opening credits are great. The closing credits are PHENOMENAL! The Barbados(yes I know it's Barbatos idc) is one of the more unique looking "main" Gundams. Characters are all super likeable & their commander takes a real hands-on approach compared to past series. Character motivations all make sense making for a relatable realistic cast unlike a lot of Gundam series. The theme of family is also really strong here & just was an overall enjoyable watch. Theirs no New-Type-Bullshit either! Hopefully they don't fuck it up with season 2!
Mobile Suit Gundam
I'm sorry for saying this but the series is just to old looking for me to watch. I can handle 80's 90's anime just fine but that 70's animation is just to much for me. From what my friend tells me i probably wouldn't like it anyway. As it seems to have everything I hate about Gundam.
Char Mobile Suit Origins 1-3
The origins of Char, you get a lot more out of this if you watch OG Gundam, Zeta, Double Zeta, & Char's Counter attack 1st but it isn't necessary. The film shows you the origins of Casval(Char) & his sister Artesia(Sayla) Chafr is an amazing strategist, even if he is a douchbag. These movies are great fan service & i think the last one is right around the corner.
Char's Counterattack
Great Movie that wraps up the UC timeline. You'll be kinda lost if you haven't watched OG Gundam or the Zeta series. Still enjoyable even with its New-Type-Bullshit & misunderstanding deaths.
Overall Gundam isn't for everyone. I've already stated the things I don't like about it but it just depends on the series. you get different writing with different series so It's always worth it to check out whenever a new one drops. As far as UC goes I've caught large chunks of the Zeta series & plan to watch Victory once I finish up XX.
4
u/palparepa Sep 17 '16
Big GaoGaiGar fan here.
What I like the most about it, is that the main robot is weak. By that I mean that it's no invincible powerhouse; it certainly looks like that the bad guys have chances to win. Compare to, say, Mazinkaiser, who through the course of its whole series and movie never received a scratch.
That, and the rest of the robot cast is actually useful. GaoGaiGar himself may be necessary for the final blow most of the time, but the other super robots can fend off by themselves.
4
u/CardBack :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kung-Fu-Rwanda Sep 17 '16
Why isn't valvrave a must watch, I'm mad, and upset
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '16
I thought I'd add some thoughts on GaoGaiGar. First off, it definitely needs a seizure warning. GGG was made in a time before anime had to take seizures into consideration so there is lots of rapidly flashing lights and stuff like that in every single episode. I'm not even exaggerating.
Secondly is that I've heard a lot of people call it the holy grail of super robots and frankly I just plain disagree. Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed both series (gave GGG a 7 and Final an 8) but in no way was it close to any of the Gainax mechas.
1
u/anguishCAKE :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/anguishCAKE Sep 17 '16
Nice list and this should make my life much easier or much harder in chosing what my next anime to watch is(going through a mech craze of sorts at the moment). But I'm curious as to what you think of the last two AU gundam series'(00 & IB-O) and as someone who has only seen Delta and Frontier why DYRL is on the must watch list rather than those. I'm writing this as I'm going to bed, so I'll apollogize if you actually wrote an anwser for it there.
But I think at the very least 00 should be mentioned and that you could write your mind on IB-O as a refference for those getting into the genera though that serie, even if the writingcough cough Okada cough cough. got questionable and lazyMobile Suit Gundam Ironblooded-Orphans Character Death Spoiler Honestly I think Cross Ange was honestly more consistent and that it didn't have so painfully telegraphed deathflags that it basically drained the impact out of it.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '16
No Martian Successor Nadiseco? It's pretty much 90s version of Gurren Lagan.
1
u/Nippon_ninja :K:https://kitsu.io/users/Nippon_ninja Sep 17 '16
Good write up, though clearly a single reddit post does not do this list justice. I understand you have character limits, but this was pretty hard to read through. A tumblr post or a separate WT! thread for each section would be much easier to navigate.
1
u/Hyoizaburo https://myanimelist.net/profile/ElectroDeculture Sep 17 '16
Hey man,
I was excited to see this recommendation list come out. I remember when I wrote up some of the stuff that you said it was going to be around two weeks from then for to write it up haha. I can definitely see why it took so long to put up.
Fantastic effort on your part man although when I get through all of it, my PTW list is going to be inflated as hell.
2
u/Ledakan43 Sep 18 '16
emm, I see you guys are missing Zegapain in this list. Granted it's not exactly one of the most standout of series,since it was the early days of 3D mecha anime, but it's story is really good and it's getting a movie called Zegapain ADP in October.
1
u/Delta_Assault Sep 18 '16
I'm going through Blue Gender and it's pretty good if you're into really bleak, hopeless settings along the lines of The Walking Dead/The Road.
1
u/fgsfds11234 Sep 18 '16
Im not that into mechas but escaflowne was amazing. Seemed easy to get drawn into the world