r/anime • u/Goingbacktome • Aug 21 '21
Watch This! Here are 5 reasons why you would love Gintama and 5 reasons why you wouldn't.
As a 27 years old female with a normal social life, job and hobbies, one of my biggest "hobby" is watching anime since 2011, when I was astonished by Steins;Gate and Hunter x Hunter.
I went down into the rabbit hole and since I watched even classics like Legend of the Galactic Heroes or Ashita no Joe. I wrote this down to express that I'm not a weirdo who has a very different taste compared with the majority. I never thought I'll write long posts about a certain anime, until I recently watched Gintama with my husband (he saw even more anime than me and ended up loving this show even more than me).
This dumb masterpiece just stole my heart in every way possible. So I'll give you 5 reasons why Gintama should be your next watch and 5 other one why you wouldn't enjoy it.
You shouldn't watch it - 1
Its comedy is often crude and obnoxious. While Gintama has a wide arsenal in its pocket when it comes to comedy, you just won't see 5 episodes in a row without any joke related to dicks, poops, hemorrhoids, testacles or anything like these. Sometimes even the plot revolves around a thing like these examples, so I'm serious. If you're sensitive about this kind of humor, this show is not for you.
You should watch it - 1
If you're okay with this kind of humor (you like South Park for example) then I have good news for you: Gintama operates with these things in the most hilarious way possible, especially with context. The show perfectly knows that only the crudeness alone won't make a joke funny, so it menages to add subtle and smart punchlines alongside with it and the combination of all these nuances makes the comedy actually really funny.
You shouldn't watch it - 2
Some jokes heavily relies on the viewers knowledge about anime and japanese culture: you can find references based on western pop-culture like Star Wars, you can find even Ill Smith or Donald Zuramp (those aren't mistypes), but these are the minority. You'll mostly bump into things about japanese culture and various anime series or tropes. While its parody uses anime from EVERY GENRE, if you don't know nothing about one of the longer shounens, don't know why Luffy can strech his body, or don't know at least very basic things about Japan, some jokes will fly over your head, whether you read the explaination text above the jokes or not.
Edit: As I said, SOME JOKES. The majority of the comedy relies around its cast and their quirks.
You should watch it - 2
If you've seen a considerable amount of anime (which would be at least 20-30 from various genres, that already is more than enough), then you're in for a treat! We usually smile when we see a reference in anime, but Gintama doesn't stop there: it has complete, multi-episodes long arcs about certain shows, but at least always more than just a one-lined reference. When you hear that Gintama is the biggest parody in the medium, you can take that literally. Even the 4th wall breaking has a complete arc! It trolls you so hard like nothing else in anime and after you fell into its carefully prepared trap, all you can say that: Its genius.
You shouldn't watch it - 3
If you're expecting other than comedy. You've seen a dope fight from the show and want to start because of it? You'll be deeply disappointed. Roughly 70% of the show is comedy with slice of life feelings and while things get more serious towards the end, it'll remain true to its comedy/parody aspect even in its last seconds.
You should watch it - 3
If you want to start the show for the laughs and chills, or genre doesn't really matter if something is good, then you'll get much more than just a hilarious comedy. Gintama is just as funny and light-hearted as bloody and sad can be. The show is often praised by it's unique duality, because they go all-out with the comedy and all-out with the seriousness. It's a 2 in 1 package, your favorite moments will be from both sides. The real comedy/action mix.
Why you shouldn't watch it - 4
The animation is not the strongest aspect of Gintama. It improves over the time, it can be visually pleasing with its choreography and with its shots, but as a long-running series, the budget and the quality won't be at the same level per episode than for example Jujutsu Kaisen or Demon Slayer at all. You'll find many budget-friendly moments in it. While the fights have the improved animation quality, the only real modern "saguka" moment is in the Final Movie.
Why you should watch it - 4
The cast and the protagonist. They are quirky, lovable, deep and unique compared to the average. Gintoki stands out even from this memorable cast: his speeches, his actions and attitude, his ideal is just refreshing and highly entertaining. He is the older brother of every shounen protagonist. A mature goofy lazy asshole who is happen to be one of the best swordsman in the series, he doesn't want to save the world or anything like this. He loves the boring everyday life, that is his true peace. He is rarely serious, but when he does, he is the badassness itself, with a heartbreaking and unique past. The whole cast is similarly lovable, they are the heart of the show. The majority of comedy revolves around them and around the chemistry between them. If you're expecting boring or shallow characters, Gintama will surpass your expectations by far. Actually, this is one of the biggest reason why Gintama is loved by fans.
You shouldn't watch it - 5
If you expect greatness right from the start. The biggest, most frightening thing when someone wants to start Gintama, is it's early part. Who has the time to invest heavily into the show just because people say its great, especially in the "3 episodes rule" era? Absolutely valid. Then the other thing. We just cannot pinpoint out exactly when the viewer will start to love the show, because it's entirely subjective. Someone already likes at EP 10, for me, I started to really love it's comedy at EP 90!! (I'm not a fan of comedy, that is true aswell.) So it really depends on person and that isn't a big help for newcomers. We can skip the first two episodes, but thats all, really, because it has very few filler.
You should watch it - 5
If you're still interested in the show, it'll worth it. If these things didn't make you unsure enough about Gintama, I guarantee that you'll love it a lot and potentially, it can even be your favorite. The characters will grow on you heavily while seeing their everyday life, their funny arguments, their lovely moments, you'll see the infinite possibilities in its world and when things "get better and funnier", you already has an attachment towards them, it grips you steadily and doesn't let you go until the Final Movie. You'll be sad at the end, because this colorful, nothing like you've seen ride is over. Oh yeah, the show is highly rewatchable, some joke hits you even in the third or fourth time, same with the heavy drama or with the amazing fights.
-Lastly, I want to explain my view about the scores on MAL and Anilist.
There is a debate about why Gintama has so high scores and most people's opinion about it is:
-"Only people who already likes the show watched the later parts, the others dropped it at early."
It's true, but there is another thing. While it's a common fact that the show is not for everyone, that is common fact too, that many people who didn't like the show, but for some reason didn't drop it early on, ended up loving it. It's a mixed bag, because the first 15% of Gintama doesn't represent accurately the reason why the fans love the show.
I won't say that you'll love it anyway. I say that if you find somewhat decent the first two episodes (ep3-4), there is a pretty high chance you'll end up loving it and congratulations! You just liked more the beginning than I, who ended up writing a recommendation about Gintama, if this is reassuring for you in any way.
- This isn't my first post about Gintama, but I just love to write honest recommendations about it, it fills that "void" what I have since I finished the show. Sometimes, some fans can be a bit too pushy, or doesn't explain anything besides "best show, gets better", so I try to clarify things in a recommendation and post it. If there is 1 person who actually starts the show because of it, I'm happy and feel that its worth it.
As a side note: watch it piece by piece along with other shows. You won't feel that heavy commitment thing.
Thanks for reading.
46
u/bubudog1 Aug 21 '21
More people should do pros and cons when recommending stuff, this was pretty helpful.
17
u/Bay-Sea Aug 21 '21 edited Aug 21 '21
There is only 4 reasons for each, but as a fan, I agree with what you are saying about Gintama. Gintama is really a commitment as it is a character focused show. In order to enjoy the most of it, you have spend time with the cast rather than wait for the next serious arc.
7
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21
If any of you decided to watch Gintama, you might wanna read Gintama Anime/Manga FAQs from /r/Gintama. It pretty much explained everything you need to know about Gintama (what it's all about, watch order, anime vs manga comparison, etc.).
7
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21
How could you forget the single most important reason to watch it: Elizabeth
But yes. This is very accurate in describing it. Once you get past the first 50ish episodes it really takes off
8
u/horsing_around_town Aug 21 '21
I'm sorry, I only remember Ill Smith.
As for the considerable amount of anime that Gintama parodies, if you're familiar with the big WSJ titles to some extent, and a couple really big names like Spirited Away and Evangelion or Gundam, I'd say you're good to go.
Jojo, Naruto, Bleach, One piece, dragon Ball (and Z)- you just need to know the premise of these and how the main characters look. Maybe Bleach is parodied a bit heavier, still not more than 30 episodes deep. The rest is entry level- knowing that Hunter x Hunter has a term called 'nen' and that it's on hiatus all the time lmao.
11
u/neighmeansno Aug 21 '21
This post was really helpful in giving me the push to remove Gintama from my plan to watch list, thanks! I know that that probably wasn't your intention, but as someone who isn't into battle shonens at all, I'm worries both that a lot of the jokes would fly over my head and that I wouldn't be able to appreciate it when it does get serious.
3
u/aes110 https://myanimelist.net/profile/aes110 Aug 21 '21
Great post, I really liked this format! I definitely plan on reading/watching it when I'll be ready to start such a long show
3
u/SpaceMarine_CR Aug 21 '21
Best show, gets better
2
u/MeguminIsMyRival Aug 22 '21
Great post, it has the good and bad. I remember dropping Gintama a couple of times. I was new to anime and I felt it was too slow (especially compared to other Battle Shounens). Even the slice of life moments "felt" slow. For example, some slice of life anime I like now (or when I started) are Toradora, Kaguya, Oregairu, Shirobako, Hanasaku Ihora, etc... But I couldn't click with Gintama's slice of life moments. I think it's because those anime either had fan service, cute girls, a plot, or something for it. But in Gintama, there really wasn't much of that, especially early on. Hard to really pinpoint why.
A couple of years later, I watched it again and loved it from the first episode. No idea what changed, but I'm glad I tried it again.
3
u/Hackmanite_Ultra Aug 22 '21
Gintama is amazing. Probably peak fiction.
3
u/Sallad4ever Aug 22 '21
I agree with how the joke in Gintama sometimes relies heavily in Japanese pop culture. For example, the early episodes of Renho act totally confused me with who this Renho woman is, This disconnect made the reveal of the Renho less funnier imo
2
u/KikiFlowers https://anilist.co/user/AprilDruid Aug 22 '21
I remember reading Gintama's debut in US Jump, now it's one of more popular series.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment